Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Rapid Process Design”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 235 records · Page 13

Electrochemical Dilatometry of Si-Bearing Electrodes: Dimensional Changes and Experiment Design

The severe volumetric changes in Si particles during the Li (de)alloying process cause expansion and contraction of the electrodes, which along with excessive electrolyte reduction and solid electrolyte interphase formation brings about rapid decay in cell capacity. In this work, we use operando electrochemical dilatometry to quantify the (de)lithiation-induced expansion/contraction of Si-based and graphite-rich electrodes during electrochemical cycling. We evaluate the relationship between electrode capacity and dilation and observe that by increasing the Si contribution to the electrode capacity, the swelling is aggravated upon lithiation. For silicon-rich anodes, the electrode dilation can be higher than 300%, and the expansion profile consists of a combination of slow swelling at low lithiation followed by an accelerated increase at higher lithium contents. We investigate how electrode properties, such as porosity, affect the dilation profile and quantify the irreversible expansion of the electrodes. Finally, we discuss some of the challenges associated with the dilatometry technique and suggest experimental approaches for obtaining consistent and reliable data.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

High-speed Synchrotron X-ray Imaging of Laser Powder Bed Fusion Process

In additive manufacturing (AM) processes, materials are selectively added in layer-wise fashion to build three-dimensional objects. This approach provides several advantages over conventional manufacturing, including the ability to manufacture complex parts, design flexibility, shorter lead times, reduced inventory of spares, and on-demand manufacturing [1]. With these advantages, applications of AM are increasing rapidly in the medical, aerospace, automobile, and defense industries [2, 3]. Currently, laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) is the most extensively used AM technique for manufacturing metal parts. In a typical LPBF process, a high-power laser beam is scanned across a thin layer of powder, melting and subsequently fusing it to the previous layer. Highly transient interactions between the laser, powder particles, and the bottom layer lead to defects in the AM materials. These defects include porosity, residual stresses, surface roughness, and undesirable microstructures [1, 4]. Additionally, several in situ techniques have been developed to capture these interactions in real time, including high-speed visible light and infra-red imaging [5]. However these techniques are limited to surface observations. Most of the important phenomena that govern the quality of the AM parts, such as dynamics of the vapor depression and melt pool, occur sub-surface and hence cannot be captured using traditional optical techniques. Recently, a synchrotron-based high-speed X-ray imaging technique has been developed to record the sub-surface dynamics of metallic materials during the LPBF process. The unprecedented spatial and temporal resolutions afforded by the synchrotron sources allow direct observation of many important phenomena in AM for the first time [6–9]. Further, high-speed X-ray diffraction and optical imaging techniques are also being applied to capture the crystallographic and thermal information of the material, respectively, as they undergo melting, solidification, and cooling [6, 9]. In this contribution, we introduce the recent developments at the Advanced Photon Source (APS) for in situ and operando study of LPBF processes.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

A Study on Peripheral Grain Structure Evolution of an AA7050 Aluminum Alloy with a Laboratory-Scale Extrusion Setup

A laboratory-scale hot extrusion setup was designed to investigate recrystallization and grain growth behavior of an AA7050 alloy during extrusion and subsequent heat treatments. Compared with industrial extrusion, the laboratory-scale process enabled rapid water quenching of extrudate with less delay so that the dynamic grain structure development was captured. After extrusion, static microstructure evolution in the extrudates was studied using salt bath annealing for 5 and 15 s at 490 °C and solutionization treatment for 1 h at 490 °C. The salt bath annealing was a simulation of the delay of press quenching in typical industrial extrusion practices. In the as-quenched extrudates, the peripheral region mainly exhibited continuous dynamic recrystallization and geometric dynamic recrystallization, whereas in the core region discontinuous dynamic recrystallization dominated. A <100> and <111> double fiber texture was identified in extrudates, and recrystallization behavior was found to be orientation dependent. The <100> oriented grains contained more sub-grain boundaries and better-defined sub-grains and had a higher tendency to fragment via continuous recrystallization, while the <111> oriented grains produced less sub-grain boundaries and did not recrystallize. Subsequent heat treatments resulted in static recrystallization and abnormal growth of the continuously recrystallized grains. Additionally, the effects of extrusion temperature (440, 480 and 520 °C) and punch speed (0.7, 1.4 and 2.1 mm/s) on grain structure were discussed. A revised grain structure evolution mechanism based on the observation of 7050 extrusion was proposed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Influence of Diffuse and Ground-Reflected Irradiance on the Spectral Modeling of Solar Reference Cells

Thermal Energy Storage (TES) is a key component for solar thermal applications to bridge the gap between the demand for thermal energy and the supply of solar energy, whose availability depends on the time of day and season. Thus, cost-effective packed-bed thermal containers filled with a solid storage medium have been proposed for high-temperature sensible heat storage as materials are abundant and relatively cheap. Thus, it is necessary to investigate their performance and temperature profiles during the charge-discharge cycle. Several models are available for this purpose. Typically, the more detailed a model, the greater the computational effort required to solve it, and hence a time-efficient model is needed to prevent excessively long computation times for long-term analysis. At the more basic level, the common Hughes E-NTU model and the less realistic simplified Infinite-NTU model are very important for their less time and computational effort. In this paper, the appropriateness of employing the Infinite-NTU model was evaluated to investigate the performance of a typical and scalable rock-bed TES as a case study. The results presented provide a methodology to quickly test the validity of the model and predict the temperature profile for the case under study. Accordingly, such simple charge-discharge cycle thermal performance predictions are important to plan, design, and rapidly deploy a reliable and economical solar thermal system for the supply of valuable heat to high-temperature demanding applications of power generation and industrial processes as part of a rapid shift towards non-polluting renewable energy. Keywords: Solar Thermal, TES, Packed-bed, NTU model, Temperature profile

PV modeling↗

Computational Modeling To Adapt Neutralizing Antibody

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) is the leading therapy for viral infections because it provides immediate protection and can be administered at higher levels than in a natural immune response. Finding mAbs that neutralize a broad spectrum of viral targets has proven difficult because many species and strains exist and blanket targeting is a slow and laborious process to experimentally screen 108 variants. A new method is needed to rapidly redesign mAbs for homologous targets. This project speeds up redesign using structure-based computational design to reduce the mAbs search space to a manageable level and screen mutants at a much higher rate than in experiments. Computation will also provide critical knowledge about the fundamental interactions. The project will adapt S230, a human antibody that neutralizes SARS-CoV, to neutralize SARS-COV-2.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

CMB-S4: Forecasting Constraints on Primordial Gravitational Waves

CMB-S4—the next-generation ground-based cosmic microwave background (CMB) experiment—is set to significantly advance the sensitivity of CMB measurements and enhance our understanding of the origin and evolution of the universe. Among the science cases pursued with CMB-S4, the quest for detecting primordial gravitational waves is a central driver of the experimental design. This work details the development of a forecasting framework that includes a power-spectrum-based semianalytic projection tool, targeted explicitly toward optimizing constraints on the tensor-to-scalar ratio, r, in the presence of Galactic foregrounds and gravitational lensing of the CMB. This framework is unique in its direct use of information from the achieved performance of current Stage 2–3 CMB experiments to robustly forecast the science reach of upcoming CMB-polarization endeavors. The methodology allows for rapid iteration over experimental configurations and offers a flexible way to optimize the design of future experiments, given a desired scientific goal. To form a closed-loop process, we couple this semianalytic tool with map-based validation studies, which allow for the injection of additional complexity and verification of our forecasts with several independent analysis methods. We document multiple rounds of forecasts for CMB-S4 using this process and the resulting establishment of the current reference design of the primordial gravitational-wave component of the Stage-4 experiment, optimized to achieve our science goals of detecting primordial gravitational waves for r > 0.003 at greater than 5σ, or in the absence of a detection, of reaching an upper limit of r < 0.001 at 95% CL.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

LaueMatching: an approach for rapid and robust indexing of Laue diffraction patterns

Traditional Laue diffraction pattern indexing often struggles with noisy data, weak signals, peak overlap and missing reflections, particularly from complex or deformed microstructures. Here, we introduce LaueMatching, a high-throughput indexing algorithm designed to overcome these limitations. LaueMatching utilizes a fundamentally different approach based on direct pattern correlation: experimentally pre-processed images are compared against a comprehensive pre-computed library of simulated diffraction patterns corresponding to a dense grid of possible orientations. This approach bypasses the need for explicit peak identification and fitting, steps that are often a failure point for traditional methods. The algorithm rapidly and robustly indexes multiple crystallographic orientations and crystal systems simultaneously, even from challenging patterns. LaueMatching's effectiveness and accuracy have been rigorously tested and validated on diverse experimental (Ni, Al, EuAl 2 O 4 ) and simulated diffraction patterns, demonstrating high-fidelity orientation refinement. Code to implement this approach on both CPU and GPU resources can be downloaded from https://github.com/AdvancedPhotonSource/LaueMatching.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Design and scale-up of a semi-industrial downer-reactor for the rounding of irregular polymer particles

The recent development of rapid prototyping technologies towards additive manufacturing reveals some major drawbacks of processes such as laser beam melting (LBM). This contribution focuses on the lack of suitable polymer material with a fine particle size and good flowability. Polymer particles obtained by a wet grinding process 1 are treated in a heated downer reactor. This treatment changes the particles’ morphology from a chiselled state towards a spherical form by surface tension forces in a molten state 2 and leads to an improved flowability. To reach the required amount of rounded polymer powder, a downer reactor in semi-industrial scale has been established and will be characterized in this article. For the purpose of particle rounding it is necessary to avoid contact of molten particles with each other and with the hot reactor walls. Furthermore, the heat distribution has been investigated as one of the key parameters of the process. Finally, a proof of concept by rounding wet grinded PBT material was successfully conducted. The product was examined to obtain data about a change in particle size and flowability.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Fuel Fabrication and Single Stage Aqueous Process Modeling

The Material Protection, Accounting, and Control Technologies program utilizes modeling and simulation to assess Material Control and Accountability (MC&A) concerns for a variety of nuclear facilities. Single analyst tools allow for rapid design and evaluation of advanced approaches for new and existing nuclear facilities. A low enriched uranium (LEU) fuel conversion and fabrication facility simulator is developed to assist with MC&A for existing facilities. Measurements are added to the model (consistent with current best practices). Material balance calculations and statistical tests are also added to the model. In addition, scoping work is performed for developing a single stage aqueous reprocessing model. Preliminary results are presented and discussed, and next steps outlined.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

ADVANCED HIGH SPEED PROGRAMMABLE PREFORMING

Polymer-matrix composites offer greater stiffness and strength per unit weight than conventional materials resulting in new opportunities for lightweighting of automotive and heavy vehicles. Other benefits include design flexibility, less corrosion susceptibility, and the ability to tailor properties to specific load requirements. However, widespread implementation of structural composites requires lower-cost manufacturing processes than those that are currently available. Advanced, directed-fiber preforming processes have demonstrated exceptional value for rapid preforming of large, glass-reinforced, automotive composite structures. This is due to process flexibility and inherently low material scrap rate. Hence directed fiber performing processes offer a low cost manufacturing methodology for producing preforms for a variety of structural automotive components. This paper describes work conducted at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), focused on the development and demonstration of a high speed chopper gun to enhance throughput capabilities. ORNL and the Automotive Composites Consortium (ACC) revised the design of a standard chopper gun to expand the operational envelope, enabling delivery of up to 20kg/min. A prototype unit was fabricated and used to demonstrate continuous chopping of multiple roving at high output over extended periods. In addition fiber handling system modifications were completed to sustain the high output the modified chopper affords. These hardware upgrades are documented along with results of process characterization and capabilities assessment.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Rapid Analysis of Microalgal Triacylglycerols with Direct-Infusion Mass Spectrometry

Cultivation of microalgae has the potential to provide lipid-derived feedstocks for conversion to liquid transportation fuels. Lipid extracts from microalgae are significantly more complex than those of traditional seed oils, and their composition changes significantly throughout the microalgal growth period. With three acyl side chains per molecule, triglycerides (TAGs) are an important fuel precursor, and the distribution of acyl chain composition for TAGs has a significant impact on fuel properties and processing. Therefore, determination of the distribution of microalgal TAG production is needed to assess the value of algal extracts designed for fuel production and to optimize strain, cultivation, and harvesting practices. Methods utilized for TAG speciation commonly involve complicated and time-consuming chromatographic techniques. Here we present a method for TAG speciation and quantification based on direct-infusion mass spectrometry, which provides rapid characterization of TAG profiles without chromatographic separation. Specifically, we utilize Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS) to provide a reference library of TAGs for the microalgae Nannochloropsis sp. that provides the basis for high-throughput TAG quantitation by time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOF MS). In conclusion, we demonstrate the application of this novel approach for lipid characterization with respect to TAG compound distribution, which informs both immediate and future strain and process optimization strategies.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Energy Efficient Thermoplastic Composite Manufacturing

The objective of the project was to establish an effective and affordable method to lay-up and consolidate/join large thermoplastic composite aerospace structure with cycle times measured in minutes rather than hours. Composite airplane designs have proven efficient and effective however future potential product production rates are challenging what the current systems can efficiently produce due to material lay-down constraints and extended thermal cycle times. The ability to lay-up then rapidly heat, consolidate, and cool large complex composite structures plus very accurately tool them (i.e. matching CTE of composite materials) along with very precise thermal control is a difficult challenge. Current systems such as autoclave processing of thermoset materials require long cycle times due to method of heating and the large associated thermal masses. These extended cycle times inhibit the ability to meet higher rate production scenarios due to the need for multiple sets of equipment and tools. Thermoplastic composite materials were used to facilitate more rapid cycle times via the elimination of a need for a cure dwell at temperature. Also, utilized induction heating along with smart susceptors to enable the quick cycle times needed while providing precise intrinsic thermal control. The intrinsic control of the induction heating process via the smart susceptors along with the use of laser assisted fiber placement were the key innovations areas developed. The ability to rapidly heat and then precisely control the temperature of the consolidation component was paramount to the success of this project. It is this unique processing attribute coupled with the thermoplastic material characteristics along with rapid lay-up methods that are novel and advantageous. While many requirements and influencing factors decide the materials and processes utilized for future airplane construction, the forecast of accelerated production rates and the recent performance successes of composites in airplane construction provide an opportunity for this processing technology to have significant influence. During the course of this project a number of key accomplishments were completed. They are as follows: The needed laser assisted fiber placement capabilities have been developed and validated on a component of meaningful scale and complexity. Subsequently, a thermoplastic preform of the part scale-up part design was laser assisted fiber placed and made availalbe for consolidation. An induction consolidation system was sized, designed, and fabricated resulting in the full capability to consolidate the scale-up component. The tool for induction consolidating of the scale-up component was designed and fabricated. An aluminum pressure bladder was welded and formed for use as the pressurization membrane to perform the needed application of pressure on the part at temperature to achieve consolidation. The induction consolidation system consisting of the restraint, induction power supply, induction tool with integrated induction coils and smart susceptor liners, along with the aluminum bladder were successfully used to consolidate a large thermoplastic skin. The capability of accomplishing rapid heat-up rates and cool down rates for consolidation of large thermoplastic skins with precise thermal control and even pressure application at the consolidation temperature was validated. The general conclusion is that the use of induction consolidation with smart susceptors is an effective method to rapidly and efficiently consolidate large thermoplastic composite components and enable affordable high rate manufacturing of composites. More specific conclusions generated by this project are as follows: A restraint type induction consolidation system provides an affordable option over the standard press when using the induction consolidation processing method. Aluminum bladders can be formed to the complex shapes needed and supply uniform pressure for consolidation and co-consolidation of thermoplastic composite materials. Straightforward modifications can be made to existing fiber placement robotic systems to enable their use for thermoplastic lay-up applications.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Dry Printing Pure Copper with High Conductivity and Adhesion for Flexible Electronics

Additive manufacturing of functional devices on various rigid and flexible substrates is rising rapidly due to their design flexibility, rapid manufacturing, and lower cost. Current printing technologies are ink-based and focused on printing silver (Ag) as conductive lines due to its matured ink formulation process, low sintering temperature, ease of printing, and low oxidation rate. However, Ag is the 68th most abundant element on Earth, while copper (Cu) is the 25th, making it much cheaper (>100×) while having a comparable conductivity to Ag. Therefore, printing Cu has become technologically and economically more attractive than Ag. Nevertheless, Cu printing is still a significant challenge in ink-based printing methods due to the higher sintering temperature relative to the glass-transition temperature of most flexible substrates, the higher oxidation rate, the challenging ink formulation process, and ink stability concerns. Here, we demonstrate printing highly conductive Cu on flexible polyimide substrates using a dry printing technique. Cu nanoparticles (~3–30 nm) are generated by on-demand laser ablation of a solid Cu target inside the printer head and under argon background gas. These Cu nanoparticles are then transported through a nozzle and onto the substrate, where they are laser-sintered in real time. The argon gas plays three critical roles in laser plume condensation for nanoparticle generation, transport, and sheath gas to avoid oxidation during sintering. The sintered nanoparticles thus show high electrical conductivity and mechanical stability under static and cyclic tests. Our dry printing technique can potentially revolutionize how electronic devices and sensors are additively manufactured for earth and space applications.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

A micro-jet array for economic intensification of gas transfer in bioreactors

Bioreactors are of interest for gas-to-liquid conversion of stranded or waste industrial gases, such as CO, CH 4 , or syngas. Process economics requires reduction of bioreactor cost and size while maintaining intense production via rapid delivery of gases to the liquid phase (i.e., high k L a). Here, we show a novel bioreactor design that outperforms all known technology in terms of gas transfer energy efficiency (k L a per power density) while operating at high k L a (i.e., near 0.8 s -1 ). The reactor design uses a micro-jet array to break feedstock gas into a downward microbubble flow. Hydrodynamic and surfactant measurements show the reactor's advanced performance arises from its bubble breakage mechanism, which limits fluid shear to a thin plane located at an optimal location for bubble breakage. Power dissipation and k L are shown to scale with micro-jet diameter rather than reactor diameter, and the micro-jet array achieves improved performance compared to classical impinging-jets, ejector, or U-loop reactors. Additionally, the hydrodynamic mechanism by which the micro-jets break bubbles apart is shown to be shearing the bubbles into filaments then fragmentation by surface tension rather than “cutting in half” of bubbles. Guided by these hydrodynamic insights, strategies for industrial design are given.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Review of in situ process monitoring for metal hybrid directed energy deposition

Hybrid manufacturing, or the combination of additive and subtractive manufacturing within a single build volume is transforming the way products are being fabricated. Additive manufacturing confers unprecedented freedom of design and reduced material usage while enabling serial customization. Subtractive manufacturing provides superior surface finish and improved dimensional accuracies. Interwoven, these two digital manufacturing paradigms are enabling the rapid manufacturing of complex, highly accurate, and customized geometries in a diversity of high-performance alloys. In situ monitoring, heavily relied upon in either additive or subtractive, becomes even more crucial with the interplay of the two processes in a single combined build sequence. Moreover, challenges that do not exist in either process alone can now have a dramatic impact on final part quality: (1) a large amount of heat is generated during additive manufacturing deposition, which is primarily dissipated into the machine tooling and impacts accuracy by deforming the material and causing misaligned machining; (2) microstructure, mechanical properties, and residual stresses are the result of the complex thermal histories generated by additive manufacturing and can impact subsequent cutting performance. This comprehensive review considers previous research in monitoring and providing closed-loop control in both additive and subtractive manufacturing separately and then considers the implications of the effectiveness of these monitoring techniques when additive and subtractive processes are integrated together.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Computational Design of Alloys for Energy Technologies

Advanced materials that maintain their mechanical performance under elevated temperatures, corrosive environments, and a range of static and evolving stresses are needed to improve the efficiency and reduce the environmental impact of a wide spectrum of energy technologies. For instance, cost-efficient alloys that can withstand high temperatures (e.g., 700 °C) have a critical role in improving the efficiency and economics of power generation to support decarbonization of the energy sector; such is true of both the nuclear and fossil energy sectors. Considering both the threats of the energy crisis, namely soaring costs of greenhouse gas emission-producing energy and climate change, it is essential to increase the pace of material discovery and enable rapid paths for material qualification to advance clean energy technologies. Conventionally, alloy development has followed a slow Edisonian process that uses repeated cycles of making, characterizing, and modifying to arrive at optimum composition and processing conditions to achieve the desired component performance. This optimization is followed by the necessary stepwise materials qualification. Furthermore, the increasing adoption of sound data management and physics-informed machine learning represents the next step in the acceleration of materials design and development. In the integrated computational materials engineering (ICME) approach, computational modeling and simulation data from different length and time scales can be combined with complex microstructural details from multimodal experimental characterization and selective property testing to close the design loop for rapid alloy development.

Computational Design Of Materials↗

Integrated Computational Materials and Mechanical Modeling for Additive Manufacturing of Alloys with Graded Structure Used in Fossil Fuel Power Plants

Wire-arc additive manufacturing (WAAM) has demonstrated its unique capability of producing large-size alloy components with a significantly reduced fabrication time and enhanced geometry design freedom. In this project, the team has developed an ICME (Integrated Computational Materials Engineering) modeling framework, which supports the WAAM of the AUSC (Advanced Ultra-Supercritical) power plant components. The manufacturing design has been applied to Inconel 740H, steel P91, as well as the dissimilar alloy components between steel P91 and Inconel 740H. The ICME model framework is developed by considering two types of modeling. First, mechanistic modeling has been applied to control the printing quality and understand the sequence of the dissimilar printing of the wall structure. The following models have been included in the developed ICME framework: finite element thermal model, grain structure model, residual stress simulation, crystal plasticity model, CALPHAD-based precipitation kinetic model, phase stability prediction, thermal expansion predictive model, and heuristic creep model. Secondary, a physics-based machine learning model has also been developed based on the ICME model structure. The machine learning model development is based on the ICME model prediction with calibration of the experiments. In addition, the WAAM has been utilized as a high-throughput experimental tool rapidly generating a gradient of alloy composition to facilitate experimental database generation for process-structure-property relationships. Such a database directly supported the ICME-enhanced machine learning, which further assisted in intermediate composition block design between P91 and 740H. A high-throughput screening study of the oxidation resistance has been performed based on such high-throughput experimentation. Based on the computational design, several dissimilar alloy manufacturing with post-heat treatment have been performed with a comprehensive evaluation of mechanical performance, including hardness mapping, yield strength, creep resistance. In this project, the single component of P91 and 740H processed by WAAM after heat treatment designed by ICME has demonstrated higher performance in yield strength and creep resistance than the wrought materials. The P91 sample prepared by WAAM with ICME-designed heat treatment performs better than P92 in creep resistance. The designed graded alloy printing with intermediate block shows a promising performance that exceeds the traditional welding. Moreover, the current research indicates the high need for location-specific design analysis with uncertainty quantification, an important topic that deserves more dedicated research. The achievement of this project demonstrated the promising future of WAAM in structural alloy manufacturing for energy power plant development. Successful printing requires synergetic efforts made by manufacturing, mechanical, and materials sciences.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Powder satellite-reduction apparatus and method for gas atomization process

The broad applicability of at least certain aspects of the present invention derives from the ability to determine the critical location where secondary satellite formation occurs for any atomization system or design and allows for the rapid assessment of the effectiveness of various satellite reduction strategies, including but not limited to several embodiments detailed herein. Aspects of this invention can be utilized during initial atomization system design in order to evaluate effective chamber geometries and enabling strategies which reduce/eliminate satelliting, or can be retrofit to existing systems and allows for economic evaluation of effectiveness based off of initial capital expenditures versus increased operating requirements/expenses.

Anderson, Iver E.↗