Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “multiple time stepping”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 217 records · Page 12

Ignition dynamics of a laminar diffusion flame in the field of a vortex embedded in a shear flow

The role of streamwise-spanwise vorticity interactions that occur in turbulent shear flows on flame/vortex interactions is examined by means of asymptotic analysis and numerical simulation in the limit of small Mach number. An idealized model is employed to describe the interaction process. The model consists of a one-step, irreversible Arrhenius reaction between initially unmixed species occupying adjacent half-planes which are then allowed to mix and react in the presence of a streamwise vortex embedded in a shear flow. It is found that the interaction of the streamwise vortex with shear gives rise to small-scale velocity oscillations which increase in magnitude with shear strength. These oscillations give rise to regions of strong temperature gradients via viscous heating, which can lead to multiple ignition points and substantially decrease ignition times. The evolution in time of the temperature and mass-fraction fields is followed, and emphasis is placed on the ignition time and structure as a function of vortex and shear strength.

Macaraeg, Michele G.↗

Consolidation of Braided Carbon Fiber/ Thermoplastic Tubes by Induction Heating

Thermoplastic composites have experienced renewed enthusiasm within the U.S. aerospace industry, due in part to opportunities for rapidly manufacturing large structures. Unlike the lengthy cure cycles required by thermosets, the thermoplastic matrix prepreg requires only heat and pressure to consolidate consecutive layers of material; with sufficient inter-ply contact time to develop a strong interface. The manufacturing requirements for thermoplastics provide manufacturing flexibility and of particular interest are in-situ consolidation processes; i.e consolidation during layup on a tool. In-situ consolidation removes the time-consuming and costly secondary processing step of autoclave or press consolidation. Process variables which contribute to laminate quality include temperature, heat transfer, inter-ply contact time, and consolidation pressure. Most of the work to date related to in-situ consolidation has been in conjunction with automated fiber placement (AFP), where prepreg tows are consolidated when placed on the tool. Considering this process for a braided structure adds complexity relative to AFP due to the rapid lay-down rate of the braider and simultaneous placement of a multiple prepreg tows. Processes considered for consolidation during AFP could not be applied to a braided part. Alternatively, a fully braided preform could be consolidated on the tool using well established thermoplastic welding techniques. The goal of this effort was to evaluate the effectiveness of induction welding to consolidate braided carbon fiber/thermoplastic composite tubes up to eight plies in thickness. The manufacturing process, thermal characterization, and initial mechanical property data of the consolidated tubes are reported.

In-situ consolidation, induction heating/welding, ↗

Data, Meet Compute: NASA's Cumulus Ingest Architecture

NASA's Earth Observing System Data and Information System (EOSDIS) houses nearly 30PBs of critical Earth Science data and with upcoming missions is expected to balloon to between 200PBs-300PBs over the next seven years. In addition to the massive increase in data collected, researchers and application developers want more and faster access - enabling complex visualizations, long time-series analysis, and cross dataset research without needing to copy and manage massive amounts of data locally. NASA has looked to the cloud to address these needs, building its Cumulus system to manage the ingest of diverse data in a wide variety of formats into the cloud. In this talk, we look at what Cumulus is from a high level and then take a deep dive into how it manages complexity and versioning associated with multiple AWS Lambda and ECS microservices communicating through AWS Step Functions across several disparate installations

EOSDIS↗

Embedded mesh solutions of the Euler equation using a multiple-grid method

New developments make it now possible to obtain solutions to Euler equations for many problems on the basis of acceptable computing times. The possibility of an extension of these methods to more difficult flows and increasingly complex geometries can depend on obtaining suitable grid structures. Thus, an attractive approach to complex geometries involves the recasting of the problem into the framework of a multiple-grid structure. The discrete equations represented on the grid are solved as a simultaneous system. In the present investigation, this is accomplished with the aid of Ni's multiple-grid algorithm. The multiple-grid structure provided in this study represents the first step towards a completely general modular approach to the solution of the complete compressible flow problem. In the presented cases, a fine mesh resolution is obtained within the embedded mesh regions, while preserving the global coarse mesh convergence rates.

Usab, W. J., Jr.↗

Use of Semi-Autonomous Tools for ISS Commanding and Monitoring

As the International Space Station (ISS) has moved into a utilization phase, operations have shifted to become more ground-based with fewer mission control personnel monitoring and commanding multiple ISS systems. This shift to fewer people monitoring more systems has prompted use of semi-autonomous console tools in the ISS Mission Control Center (MCC) to help flight controllers command and monitor the ISS. These console tools perform routine operational procedures while keeping the human operator "in the loop" to monitor and intervene when off-nominal events arise. Two such tools, the Pre-positioned Load (PPL) Loader and Automatic Operators Recorder Manager (AutoORM), are used by the ISS Communications RF Onboard Networks Utilization Specialist (CRONUS) flight control position. CRONUS is responsible for simultaneously commanding and monitoring the ISS Command & Data Handling (C&DH) and Communications and Tracking (C&T) systems. PPL Loader is used to uplink small pieces of frequently changed software data tables, called PPLs, to ISS computers to support different ISS operations. In order to uplink a PPL, a data load command must be built that contains multiple user-input fields. Next, a multiple step commanding and verification procedure must be performed to enable an onboard computer for software uplink, uplink the PPL, verify the PPL has incorporated correctly, and disable the computer for software uplink. PPL Loader provides different levels of automation in both building and uplinking these commands. In its manual mode, PPL Loader automatically builds the PPL data load commands but allows the flight controller to verify and save the commands for future uplink. In its auto mode, PPL Loader automatically builds the PPL data load commands for flight controller verification, but automatically performs the PPL uplink procedure by sending commands and performing verification checks while notifying CRONUS of procedure step completion. If an off-nominal condition occurs during procedure execution, PPL Loader notifies CRONUS through popup messages, allowing CRONUS to examine the situation and choose an option of how PPL loader should proceed with the procedure. The use of PPL Loader to perform frequent, routine PPL uplinks offloads CRONUS to better monitor two ISS systems. It also reduces procedure performance time and decreases risk of command errors. AutoORM identifies ISS communication outage periods and builds commands to lock, playback, and unlock ISS Operations Recorder files. Operation Recorder files are circular buffer files of continually recorded ISS telemetry data. Sections of these files can be locked from further writing, be played back to capture telemetry data that occurred during an ISS loss of signal (LOS) period, and then be unlocked for future recording use. Downlinked Operation Recorder files are used by mission support teams for data analysis, especially if failures occur during LOS. The commands to lock, playback, and unlock Operations Recorder files are encompassed in three different operational procedures and contain multiple user-input fields. AutoORM provides different levels of automation for building and uplinking the commands to lock, playback, and unlock Operations Recorder files. In its automatic mode, AutoORM automatically detects ISS LOS periods, then generates and uplinks the commands to lock, playback, and unlock Operations Recorder files when MCC regains signal with ISS. AutoORM also features semi-autonomous and manual modes which integrate CRONUS more into the command verification and uplink process. AutoORMs ability to automatically detect ISS LOS periods and build the necessary commands to preserve, playback, and release recorded telemetry data greatly offloads CRONUS to perform more high-level cognitive tasks, such as mission planning and anomaly troubleshooting. Additionally, since Operations Recorder commands contain numerical time input fields which are tedious for a human to manually build, AutoORM's ability to automatically build commands reduces operational command errors. PPL Loader and AutoORM demonstrate principles of semi-autonomous operational tools that will benefit future space mission operations. Both tools employ different levels of automation to perform simple and routine procedures, thereby offloading human operators to perform higher-level cognitive tasks. Because both tools provide procedure execution status and highlight off-nominal indications, the flight controller is able to intervene during procedure execution if needed. Semi-autonomous tools and systems that can perform routine procedures, yet keep human operators informed of execution, will be essential in future long-duration missions where the onboard crew will be solely responsible for spacecraft monitoring and control.

Brzezinski, Amy S.↗

Kepler Planet Detection Metrics: Per-Target Flux-Level Transit Injection Tests of TPS for Data Release 25

Quantifying the ability of a transiting planet survey to recover transit signals has commonly been accomplished through Monte-Carlo injection of transit signals into the observed data and subsequent running of the signal search algorithm (Gilliland et al., 2000; Weldrake et al., 2005; Burke et al., 2006). In order to characterize the performance of the Kepler pipeline (Twicken et al., 2016; Jenkins et al., 2017) on a sample of over 200,000 stars, two complementary injection and recovery tests are utilized:1. Injection of a single transit signal per target into the image or pixel-level data, hereafter referred to as pixel-level transit injection (PLTI), with subsequent processing through the Photometric Analysis (PA), Presearch Data Conditioning (PDC), Transiting Planet Search (TPS), and Data Validation (DV) modules of the Kepler pipeline. The PLTI quantification of the Kepler pipeline's completeness has been described previously by Christiansen et al. (2015, 2016); the completeness of the final SOC 9.3 Kepler pipeline acting on the Data Release 25 (DR25) light curves is described by Christiansen (2017).2. Injection of multiple transit signals per target into the normalized flux time series data with a subsequent transit search using a stream-lined version of the Transiting Planet Search (TPS) module. This test, hereafter referred to as flux-level transit injection (FLTI), is the subject of this document. By running a heavily modified version of TPS, FLTI is able to perform many injections on selected targets and determine in some detail which injected signals are recoverable. Significant numerical efficiency gains are enabled by precomputing the data conditioning steps at the onset of TPS and limiting the search parameter space (i.e., orbital period, transit duration, and ephemeris zero-point) to a small region around each injected transit signal.The PLTI test has the advantage that it follows transit signals through all processing steps of the Kepler pipeline, and the recovered signals can be further classified as planet candidates or false positives in the exact same manner as detections from the nominal (i.e., observed) pipeline run (Twicken et al., 2016, Thompson et al., in preparation). To date, the PLTI test has been the standard means of measuring pipeline completeness averaged over large samples of targets (Christiansen et al., 2015, 2016; Christiansen, 2017). However, since the PLTI test uses only one injection per target, it does not elucidate individual-target variations in pipeline completeness due to differences in stellar properties or astrophysical variability. Thus, we developed the FLTI test to provide a numerically efficient way to fully map individual targets and explore the performance of the pipeline in greater detail. The FLTI tests thereby allow a thorough validation of the pipeline completeness models (such as window function (Burke and Catanzarite, 2017a), detection efficiency (Burke Catanzarite, 2017b), etc.) across the spectrum of Kepler targets (i.e., various astrophysical phenomena and differences in instrumental noise). Tests during development of the FLTI capability revealed that there are significant target-to-target variations in the detection efficiency.

DR25↗

Continuous-Time Bilinear System Identification

The objective of this paper is to describe a new method for identification of a continuous-time multi-input and multi-output bilinear system. The approach is to make judicious use of the linear-model properties of the bilinear system when subjected to a constant input. Two steps are required in the identification process. The first step is to use a set of pulse responses resulting from a constant input of one sample period to identify the state matrix, the output matrix, and the direct transmission matrix. The second step is to use another set of pulse responses with the same constant input over multiple sample periods to identify the input matrix and the coefficient matrices associated with the coupling terms between the state and the inputs. Numerical examples are given to illustrate the concept and the computational algorithm for the identification method.

Juang, Jer-Nan↗

Algebraic turbulence modeling for unstructured and adaptive meshes

An algebraic turbulence model based on the Baldwin-Lomax model, has been implemented for use on unstructured grids. The implementation is based on the use of local background structured turbulence meshes. At each time-step, flow variables are interpolated from the unstructured mesh onto the background structured meshes, the turbulence model is executed on these meshes, and the resulting eddy viscosity values are interpolated back to the unstructured mesh. Modifications to the algebraic model were required to enable the treatment of more complicated flows, such as confluent boundary layers and wakes. The model is used in conjuction with an efficient unstructured multigrid finite-element Navier-Stokes solver in order to compute compressible turbulent flows on fully unstructured meshes. Solutions about single and multiple element airfoils are obtained and compared with experimental data.

Mavriplis, Dimitri J.↗

"The Design of a Compact, Wide Spurious-Suppression Bandwidth Bandpass Filter Using Stepped Impedance Resonators"

We propose an analytical design for a microstrip broadband spurious-suppression filter. The proposed design uses every section of the transmission lines as both a coupling and a spurious suppression element, which creates a very compact, planar filter. While a traditional filter length is greater than the multiple of the quarter wavelength at the center passband frequency (lambda(sub g)/4), the proposed filter length is less than (order n(Ssup th) + l)center dot lambda(sub g)/8. The filter s spurious response and physical dimension are controlled by the step impedance ratio (R) between two transmission line sections as a lambda(sub g)/4 resonator. The experimental result shows that, with R of 0.2, the out-of-band attenuation is greater than 40 dB; and the first spurious mode is shifted to more than 5 times the fundamental frequency. Moreover, it is the most compact planar filter design to date. The results also indicate a low in-band insertion loss.

U-Yen, Kongpop↗

Parallelized Quadrupole Simulations of Thermographic Responses of Composites

Thermography has been shown to be a viable technique for inspection of composites. Model inversion of the thermography data requires a fast method for performing the forward problem. Viable numerical methods for the thermal response forward problem are finite element, finite difference and the quadrupole method. Normally both the finite element and finite difference methods solve for the thermal response in the time domain which limits one’s ability to increase the speed of the simulation by parallelization. In contrast, the quadrupole method solves for the Laplace transform of the thermal response. One of the features of the Laplace transform methodology is the solution at any discrete time is independent of the solution at all other times. Therefore, it is easy to separate into a set of independent calculations with each of the times of interest being performed in parallel. Additionally, the numeric inversion of the Laplace transform typically involves numerically solving for the Laplace transform at multiple Laplace frequencies. Each of those solutions are also independent of solutions at other frequencies and can be calculated in parallel. By parallelization of this method, it is possible to perform the simulations of three-dimensional configurations in seconds. When the input stimulus for thermal response is a delta function heat flux (a reasonable approximation for flash heating), the thermal response is smooth. For this case, it is possible to accurately estimate the thermal response at any time within a given time interval from a set of simulations separated by exponentially increasing time steps. From these simulations, it is possible to accurately interpolate to find the response at intermediate times by a spline interpolation of the logarithm of time versus logarithm of temperature. The thermal response with exponential time stepping is shown to produce values for the thermal response which are within 1% of values within the time interval. The simulations are compared to finite element simulations of the same inspection configurations. The simulations are also compared to the thermographic measurements on composites where shape and depth of the delaminations are obtained from other inspection methods.

Thermography↗

Parallelized Quadrupole Simulations of Thermographic Responses of Composites

Thermography has been shown to be a viable technique for inspection of composites. Model inversion of the thermography data requires a fast method for performing the forward problem. Viable numerical methods for the thermal response forward problem are finite element, finite difference and the quadrupole method. Normally both the finite element and finite difference methods solve for the thermal response in the time domain which limits one’s ability to increase the speed of the simulation by parallelization. In contrast, the quadrupole method solves for the Laplace transform of the thermal response. One of the features of the Laplace transform methodology is the solution at any discrete time is independent of the solution at all other times. Therefore, it is easy to separate into a set of independent calculations with each of the times of interest being performed in parallel. Additionally, the numeric inversion of the Laplace transform typically involves numerically solving for the Laplace transform at multiple Laplace frequencies. Each of those solutions are also independent of solutions at other frequencies and can be calculated in parallel. By parallelization of this method, it is possible to perform the simulations of three-dimensional configurations in seconds. When the input stimulus for thermal response is a delta function heat flux (a reasonable approximation for flash heating), the thermal response is smooth. For this case, it is possible to accurately estimate the thermal response at any time within a given time interval from a set of simulations separated by exponentially increasing time steps. From these simulations, it is possible to accurately interpolate to find the response at intermediate times by a spline interpolation of the logarithm of time versus logarithm of temperature. The thermal response with exponential time stepping is shown to produce values for the thermal response which are within 1% of values within the time interval. The simulations are compared to finite element simulations of the same inspection configurations. The simulations are also compared to the thermographic measurements on composites where shape and depth of the delaminations are obtained from other inspection methods.

Thermography↗

Short Circuiting the Controller – Missteps in Maintenance and Inspection of Process and Wiring in STS-93

The primary objective of the Space Transportation System mission 93 (STS-93) was to deploy the Chandra X-Ray Observatory. Chandra, the world's most powerful X-Ray telescope, allowed scientists from around the world to study some of the most distant and dynamic objects in the universe. Stripped of nearly 7,000 pounds of its own gear to make room for the payload, the orbiter assigned to this mission was Space Shuttle Columbia. Prior to STS-93, Columbia had flown 25 flights and was NASA's oldest and heaviest orbiter. On July 23, 1999, after two prior launch scrubs, Eileen Collins and her crew of four launched from Kennedy Space Center. About five seconds after launch, Mission Control at Johnson Space Center detected a voltage drop on one of Columbia's electrical buses. As a result of this power fluctuation, a primary and back-up Main Engine controller dropped offline. Given design redundancy, the two remaining controllers supported all three engines. If there had been any other AC bus issues, one engine of the three on the Orbiter would have shut down. The redundant set of digital computer units in each engine controller saved Columbia and her crew from a very risky contingency abort. Post-flight inspection revealed soot on a screw head and a hole in an adjacent Kapton insulated wire. The single strand of polyimide wire was located nearly half-way down the payload bay. The Shuttle Independent Assessment Team (SIAT) reported that the wire had rubbed and chaffed against a burred screw head. The burr was later determined to be the result of overtightening of the screw by a technician during a maintenance refurbishment. Alone, the burr may not have been problematic, but later, during another ground processing event, possibly years after, someone inadvertently stepped on the wiring harness. With the pressure and motion of unintended contact, some of the Kapton insulation rubbed off against the burred screw head. The SIAT suspected the wire damage was pre-existing and was caused 4 or 5 years prior to the flight. Finally, the intense vibrations during the launch sequence allowed contact between the exposed conductor and exposed metal area on the burred screw head, resulting in the arcing and shorting of the wire. Due to the quick turnaround times of Space Shuttle Orbiters, wiring issues caused from multiple maintenance events were often overlooked. Additionally, failing to incorporate thorough and early inclusion of human systems integration (HSI) applications as a crucial part of the decision process can result in these types of misshaps. In order to reduce human error associated with integrated manufacturing, maintenance, refurbishment and flight preparations, wire inspection criteria should be refined and standardized, visual inspection processes should be quantified, and technicians should be certified by specially trained instructors. This case, among many others, unveils why human error management and development of safety metrics is a vital piece in the development of complex systems, and why it should be supported aggressively and implemented program wide.

Human Systems Integration↗

Unsteady transonic Navier-Stokes computations for an oscillating wing using single and multiple zones

Modern jet transports and maneuvering tactical fighters operating in the transonic regime often give rise to time-dependent fluid physics that interact with flexible structural components, e.g., vortical flow, shocks, and separation. Efficient computational fluid dynamic (CFD) methods are required to study such computationally intensive problems. In this work a numerical method is presented to address this problem. Time-dependent, compressible, Navier-Stokes equations are used to simulate unsteady transonic flow about a three-dimensional rigid wing undergoing a forced periodic motion in angle of attack. An efficient, implicit, diagonal algorithm is utilized because of its low operation count per time step compared to other methods that solve systems of block matrix equations. The formal time accuracy is addressed theoretically and demonstrated numerically by comparison of computational results with experimental data. A zonal grid approach, capable of treating complex geometries, is presented and its time accuracy is demonstrated by comparing a zonal computation with a single grid computation and experimental data.

Chaderjian, Neal M.↗

Developing a Cas9-Based Tool to Engineer Native Plasmids in Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803

The oxygenic photosynthetic bacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 (S6803) is a model cyanobacterium widely used for fundamental research and biotechnology applications. Due to its polyploidy, existing methods for genome engineering of S6803 require multiple rounds of selection to modify all genome copies, which is time consuming and inefficient. In this study, we engineered the Cas9 tool for onestep, segregationfree genome engineering. We further used our Cas9 tool to delete three of seven S6803 native plasmids. Our results show that all three smallsize native plasmids, but not the largesize native plasmids, can be deleted with this tool. To further facilitate heterologous gene expression in S6803, a shuttle vector based on the native plasmid pCC5.2 was created. The shuttle vector can be introduced into Cas9containing S6803 in one step without requiring segregation and can be stably maintained without antibiotic pressure for at least 30 days. Moreover, genes encoded on the shuttle vector remain functional after 30 days of continuous cultivation without selective pressure. Thus, this study provides a set of new tools for rapid modification of the S6803 genome and for stable expression of heterologous genes, potentially facilitating both fundamental research and biotechnology applications using S6803.

biotechnology↗

Full Scale Flat Floor Testing of a 500-M2-Class Solar Sail Deployer

Solar sailing missions rely on deployable systemsfor large area to mass ratios once in space, whilestill being small enough for launcher envelopes inthe stowed configuration. Many of thesedeployable systems feature booms that areflattened and subsequently coiled onto aspool/hub. As part of a collaborative deployablespace structures research effort of NASA and DLR,a boom deployment mechanism for a future 500 m²solar sail has been developed since 2017. To achieve the respective solar sail size goal, 16.5m long booms produced by NASA were integratedinto a DLR-designed deployer mechanism. Thisconsiderable size, as well as the lightweightconstruction of the booms and respectivedeployable systems makes ground testing asignificant challenge. Some systems for gravitycompensation and boom alignment will bepresented in the paper. However, the main focus isthe functional flat floor testing of the integratedboom-deployment mechanism system, as well asits challenges. The testing performed includes full deployment aswell as stowage of the booms. Both have beenperformed multiple times. The latter is one of thekey parameters determining packaging efficiency,which in turn confirms design assumptions. Duringsystem development, small scale tests and modelshave been used in preparation of flat floor testingof the 33 m span cross of the full-scale booms anddeployment mechanism. Hence a small chapter isalso devoted to analysing the differences inbehaviour between small- and full-scaledeployment systems. More parameters that are vital to design decisionshave been determined this way, such as drivingbelt force or hub brake torque. This paper alsofocuses on development goals and needs forfuture steps to achieve higher levels of technologyreadiness, such as the balancing of driving motorforce, synchronisation of its transmission and thecountering hub brake torque

Deployment mechanism↗

Efficient eigenvalue assignment for large space structures

A novel and efficient approach for the eigenvalue assignment of large first-order time-invariant systems is developed using full-state feedback and output feedback. First, a Schur decomposition is applied to triangularize the state matrix. Second, a series of coordinate rotations (Givens rotations) are used to move the eigenvalue to be reassigned to the end of the diagonal of its Schur form. Third, the eigenvalue is moved to the desired location by a full-state feedback, without affecting the remaining eigenvalues. The second and third step can be repeated until all the assignable eigenvalues are moved to the desired locations. Given the freedom of multiple inputs, the feedback gain matrix is calculated to minimize an objective function composed of a gain matrix norm and/or a robustness index of the closed-loop system. Numerical examples are given to demonstrate the feasibility of the proposed approach.

Maghami, Peiman G.↗

Optical Processing of Speckle Images with Bacteriorhodopsin for Pattern Recognition

Logarithmic processing of images with multiplicative noise characteristics can be utilized to transform the image into one with an additive noise distribution. This simplifies subsequent image processing steps for applications such as image restoration or correlation for pattern recognition. One particularly common form of multiplicative noise is speckle, for which the logarithmic operation not only produces additive noise, but also makes it of constant variance (signal-independent). We examine the optical transmission properties of some bacteriorhodopsin films here and find them well suited to implement such a pointwise logarithmic transformation optically in a parallel fashion. We present experimental results of the optical conversion of speckle images into transformed images with additive, signal-independent noise statistics using the real-time photochromic properties of bacteriorhodopsin. We provide an example of improved correlation performance in terms of correlation peak signal-to-noise for such a transformed speckle image.

Downie, John D.↗

Methods for Estimating Environmental Effects and Constraints on NexGen: High Density Case Study

This document provides a summary of the current methods developed by Metron Aviation for the estimate of environmental effects and constraints on the Next Generation Air Transportation System (NextGen). This body of work incorporates many of the key elements necessary to achieve such an estimate. Each section contains the background and motivation for the technical elements of the work, a description of the methods used, and possible next steps. The current methods described in this document were selected in an attempt to provide a good balance between accuracy and fairly rapid turn around times to best advance Joint Planning and Development Office (JPDO) System Modeling and Analysis Division (SMAD) objectives while also supporting the needs of the JPDO Environmental Working Group (EWG). In particular this document describes methods applied to support the High Density (HD) Case Study performed during the spring of 2008. A reference day (in 2006) is modeled to describe current system capabilities while the future demand is applied to multiple alternatives to analyze system performance. The major variables in the alternatives are operational/procedural capabilities for airport, terminal, and en route airspace along with projected improvements to airframe, engine and navigational equipment.

Augustine, S.↗