SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Surface Feature”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

SourceResearch connectionFrom yearThrough year

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 217 records · Page 12

All sources NASA NTRS DOE OSTI

DOE OSTI2020

Induction heating cells with controllable thermal expansion of bladders and methods of using thereof

Disclosed herein are induction heating cells and methods of using these cells for processing. An induction heating cell may be used for processing (e.g., consolidating and/or curing a composite layup having a non-planar portion. The induction heating cell comprises a caul, configured to position over and conform to this non-planar portion. Furthermore, the cell comprises a mandrel, configured to position over the caul and force the caul again the surface of the feature. The CTE of the caul may be closer to the CTE of the composite layup than to the CTE of the mandrel. As such, the caul isolates the composite layup from the dimensional changes of the mandrel, driven by temperature fluctuations. At the same time, the caul may conform to the surface of the mandrel, which can be used to define the shape and transfer pressure to the non-planar portion.

42 ENGINEERING↗

DOE OSTI2021

Induction heating cells with cauls over mandrels methods of using thereof

Matsen, Marc R.↗

DOE OSTI2024

Plasticity-mediated deformation instabilities in thin film-compliant substrate systems: direct three-dimensional simulations

Abstract Surface wrinkles driven by mechanical instability commonly form in thin-film structures attached to a compliant substrate. In this study, a recently developed computational approach is employed to simulate the formation and transformation of wrinkles involving plastic yielding of the thin film. The three-dimensional (3D) finite element models contain an embedded imperfection at the film-substrate interface, serving to trigger the bifurcation modes. Successful application of this technique to allow for film plasticity is demonstrated, including the evolution of 3D surface patterns and their correlation with the overall load–displacement response. The simulations reveal that plastic yielding transforms the surface instability patterns into more localized forms. Under uniaxial loading, the sinusoidal elastic wrinkles undergo the wrinkle-to-fold transition. With equi-biaxial loading, the initial square-checkerboard array turns into continuous tall ridges along the 45° directions. In both loading modes, the plasticity-induced instability patterns are only partially relieved upon unloading, leaving permanent features on the surface.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

Relationships between summertime surface albedo and melt pond fraction in the central Arctic Ocean: The aggregate scale of albedo obtained on the MOSAiC floe

As part of the Multidisciplinary drifting Observatory for the Study of Arctic Climate (MOSAiC), the HELiX uncrewed aircraft system (UAS) was deployed over the sea ice in the central Arctic Ocean during summer 2020. Albedo measurements were obtained with stabilized pyranometers, and melt pond fraction was calculated from orthomosaic imagery from a surface-imaging multispectral camera. This study analyzed HELiX flight data to provide insights on the temporal and spatial evolution of albedo and melt pond fraction of the MOSAiC floe during the melt season as it drifted south through Fram Strait. The surface albedo distributions showed peak values changing from high albedo (0.55–0.6) to lower values (0.3) as the season advanced. Inspired by methods developed for satellite data, an algorithm was established to retrieve melt pond fraction from the orthomosaic images. We demonstrate that the near-surface observations of melt pond fraction were highly dependent on sample area, offering insight into the influence of subgrid scale features and spatial heterogeneity in satellite observations. Vertical observations conducted with the HELiX were used to quantify the influence of melt pond scales on observed surface albedo as a function of sensor footprint. These scaling results were used to link surface-based measurements collected during MOSAiC to broader-scale satellite data to investigate the influence of surface features on observed albedo. Albedo values blend underlying features within the sensor footprint, as determined by the melt pond size and concentration. This study framed the downscaling (upscaling) problem related to the airborne (surface) observations of surface albedo across a variety of spatial scales.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

DOE OSTI2024

Investigation of the cesium activation of Ga⁢N photocathodes by low-energy electron microscopy

Low-energy electron microscopy (LEEM) was performed on p-Ga⁢N samples during in situ cesium deposition. LEEM images of electron reflectivity recorded as a function of the incident electron energy at different Cs coverages allowed to spatially resolve the evolution of the local work function (WF) during the activation process. While the average WF drops by more than 3 eV, the local WF remains quite uniform across the surface throughout the activation process. Maximum fluctuations of less than 0.2 eV were observed in the WF maps for Cs coverage of a fraction of a monolayer. These fluctuations are mainly related to the surface topography, in particular, to the atomic steps’ structure, which replicates the substrate miscut. Apart from these weak spatial fluctuations, no Cs clusters that would induce strong local WF contrast were observed at the scale of the 20-nm resolution of the measurements. These observations agree with the simple model of semiconductor activation to negative electron affinity that describes the formation of a dipole layer as responsible for the lowering of the WF. Additionally, at complete Cs coverage, the WF becomes fully homogeneous over the surface, smoothing out features originating from defects and topography.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

DOE OSTI2020

Editors’ Choice—Flooded by Success: On the Role of Electrode Wettability in CO 2 Electrolyzers that Generate Liquid Products

Economic operation of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) electrolyzers generating liquid products will likely require high reactant conversions and product concentrations, conditions anticipated to challenge existing gas diffusion electrodes (GDEs). Notably, electrode wettability will increase as lower surface tension products (e.g., formic acid, alcohols) are introduced into electrolyte streams, potentially leading to flooding. To understand the hydraulically stable operating envelopes in mixed aqueous-organic liquid domains, we connect intrinsic electrode wettability descriptors to operating parameters such as electrolyte flow rate and current. We first measure contact angles of water-organic product dilutions on polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) and graphite surfaces as planar analogues for GDE components. We then use material balances around the reactive gas-liquid-solid interface to calculate product mass fractions as functions of water sweep rate and current. Product composition maps visualize the extent to which changes in cell performance influence capillary pressure, a determinant of GDE saturation. Analyses suggest that formic acid mixtures pose little risk for GDE flooding across a wide range of conditions, but effluents containing <30% alcohol by mass may cause flooding. This study reveals opportunities to integrate microstructural features and oleophobic surface treatments into GDEs to repel aqueous-organic mixtures and expand the window of stable operating conditions.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

DOE OSTI2024

Precision Structure Engineering of High-Entropy Oxides under Ambient Conditions

High-entropy oxides (HEOs) have unveiled a unique frontier in the realm of heterogeneous catalysis, taking advantage of the entropic effect and increased complexities to deliver ultrahigh stability and large tuning capability. However, current HEO synthesis mainly relies on high-temperature annealing approaches affording HEOs possessing no or low surface area, inferior active site exposure efficiency, and low controllability over the structure tuning. The grand challenge lies in producing high-quality HEO catalysts with high active site utilization efficiency, which relies on precision structure engineering, preferably under mild conditions. In this work, an in situ lattice engineering approach was developed to afford a supported HEO catalyst under ambient conditions. The HEO compositions (CuCoFeNiMnO x ) were uniformly integrated into the lattice of CeO 2 driven by cavitation-induced nucleation being generated via ultrasonication. The as-afforded catalysts were featured by high surface area, atomically dispersed HEO compositions, active redox properties, abundant oxygen vacancies (O V ), antiagglomeration, and high phase stability under harsh conditions. Compared with the ex situ introduction of HEO on the surface, the in situ method provides dual benefits to maintain the dispersity of HEO via entropic and lattice confinement effects. Engineering the complex HEO within the lattice of fluorite-structured CeO 2 also yields abundant defects (e.g., O V ) and active metal sites with strong reducing properties (e.g., Ce 3+ and Cu + ), which greatly improves the activity of the lattice oxygen and tunability of the adsorption behavior of the guest molecules, especially in the presence of impurities (e.g., water and propane). The catalytic performance of the supported HEO catalyst in oxidative procedures surpasses the pure dense phase HEO as well as the ex situ-generated catalysts. Further, the synthesis approach being developed in this work, together with the fundamental understanding in structure evolution and reaction mechanism, showcases a facile pathway under ambient conditions to generate stable catalysts capable of maintaining structural robustness in high-temperature conditions while delivering enhanced catalytic performance.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

DOE OSTI2020

Quantitatively accounting for the effects of surface topography on the oxidation kinetics of additive manufactured Hastelloy X processed by electron beam melting

In this work, the effects of surface roughness on the high-temperature corrosion of nickel-based superalloy X produced through electron-beam melting (EBM) additive manufacturing were studied. Surface area of samples in the rough, as-fabricated condition was measured using a 2D cross-section image analysis technique and a 3D image analysis technique. To verify the accuracy of surface area measurements, oxidation testing of samples in the as-fabricated and polished conditions was performed; polished sample oxidation curves were then compared to the as-fabricated sample oxidation curves before and after being adjusted using obtained surface area measurements. It was found that the 2D technique accurately measured surface area and accounted for the overlapping features present on EBM sample surfaces, whereas the 3D technique did not. Further, it was also observed that oxidation kinetics were moderately faster on the alloy X samples in the as-fabricated condition than for the polished condition.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2020

Laser-interference pulse number dependence of surface chemistry and sub-surface microstructure of AA2024-T3 alloy

The laser-based treatment of a metal surface is an intrinsically non-chemical technique that can alter both the topology and chemistry of surfaces. A laser-based treatment for coating and joining applications can offer alternative surface preparations to the chemically-based surface preparation techniques, which are subject to severe environmental protection and hazardous-waste management considerations. In this study, the surface chemistry and sub-surface microstructural changes are investigated for a novel surface processing method using laser interferometry produced by two beams of a pulsed Nd:YAG laser. The two-beam laser-interference allowed the structuring of the surface at length scales much less than that of the laser beam spot. Surface chemistry changes in the oxide layer of AA 2024-T3 aluminum alloy rolled sheet due to laser processing were investigated using x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). Near surface microstructural changes have been investigated with scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (SEM/EDS), and scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) as a function of number of interfering laser shots. SEM microstructure pictures of the top surface shows the minimization of surface defects, as all of the sharp features from a rolled sheet surface were smoothed by laser-structuring. STEM images indicate that the laser-interference processing reduced the formation of CuMn-rich precipitates over a 500–800 nm depth from the top surface. XPS data indicated that the Al oxide layer is modified compared to that of the baseline specimen and that the oxide thickness increases with the number of shots per spot. Finally, the additional thicker oxide on Al alloys is expected to increase the corrosion resistance of the coated Al 2024.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2024

Fatigue Testing and Characterization of Pre-hydrided Zircaloy-4 Cladding Tubes

The solubility of hydrogen in Zircaloy-4 (Zry-4) at the cladding operating temperature is near 100 wt. ppm. Above this solubility limit, excess hydrogen precipitates as δ-hydride platelets in the cladding material. Because of the effect of the thermal gradient across the cladding thickness on the migration and precipitation of hydrogen, hydride rims are often observed at the cladding outer surface; under excessive corrosion conditions hydride blisters are possible. It is well known that the fatigue of metal alloys, especially high cycle fatigue, is sensitive to the status of surface including the microstructure, roughness, and residual stress. Thus, the question considered herein, is whether excessive hydrogen pickup modifies the microstructure such that it has a degradation effect on the fatigue performance of cladding during operation. This report describes the evaluation of fatigue performance of a pre-hydrided Zry-4 cladding. A commercial Zry-4 was polished and pre-hydrided to 800 ppm and 1300 ppm H contents. The fatigue testing was conducted under strain control at 5 Hz with fully-reversed bending by using a cyclic integrated reversible bending fatigue tester (CIRFT). Six specimens with 1300 ppm and one specimen with 800 ppm were tested. Significant variation in test results were observed. While two of the 1300 ppm specimens failed with less than 1 ×10 5 cycles (at 0.32% and 0.41%), the four other samples did not fail over the strain amplitude range of 0.25% to 0.38%. Interestingly, the fracture initiation site of the failed samples was on the outside diameter (OD) surface rather than on the inside diameter (ID) surface as is typical for the as-polished cladding. This suggested a degrading effect of the hydriding process. Subsequently, three of the unfailed specimens were then further tested at ~0.43% to observe where failure initiation occurred. Significant variation was also observed in these three specimens. One specimen failed at ~9000 cycles while the two others failed at 43000 and 1.06 ×10 5 cycles. The performance here correlated to the location of failure initiation; failure initiated on the OD in the sample that failed after 9000 cycles while it initiated on the ID in the sample that failed after 43000 and 1.06 ×10 5 cycles. Flat features at the OD initiation sites suggest a brittle hydride feature on the surface of those samples was the cause of the degradation in fatigue performance, though the overall hydrogen levels in all samples was similar. A summary of all the observations is provided below: • The un-failed specimens with 1300 ppm H were cycled to failure with a higher amplitude near 0.43%. In addition, the fatigue-treated specimen tended to have a longer fatigue at the same induced amplitude. • Fractography revealed a mixed failure mode for the pre-hydrided specimen. Particularly, the specimen with fracture initiation site (FIS) located on the outer diameter surface of tube tended to have a shorter fatigue life than that of FIS on the inner diameter surface. • Etched cross section was shown to have hydride platelets aligned with tube longitudinal axis as expected, and the density of hydrides is at the similar level as in literature data. Meanwhile, a LECO procedure was applied for hydrogen concentration measurement, which showed the measured hydrogen contents are close to the nominal value. • With the polished cladding tube as baseline, O’Donnell-Lager (O-L) analysis showed that a decrease of about 50% in reduction-of-area (RA) would be needed for the O-L fitting to the fatigue data of 1300 ppm cladding. The suggestion for the next steps is provided.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

DOE OSTI2020

A machine learning approach to emulation and biophysical parameter estimation with the Community Land Model, version 5

Abstract. Land models are essential tools for understanding and predicting terrestrial processes and climate–carbon feedbacks in the Earth system, but uncertainties in their future projections are poorly understood. Improvements in physical process realism and the representation of human influence arguably make models more comparable to reality but also increase the degrees of freedom in model configuration, leading to increased parametric uncertainty in projections. In this work we design and implement a machine learning approach to globally calibrate a subset of the parameters of the Community Land Model, version 5 (CLM5) to observations of carbon and water fluxes. We focus on parameters controlling biophysical features such as surface energy balance, hydrology, and carbon uptake. We first use parameter sensitivity simulations and a combination of objective metrics including ranked global mean sensitivity to multiple output variables and non-overlapping spatial pattern responses between parameters to narrow the parameter space and determine a subset of important CLM5 biophysical parameters for further analysis. Using a perturbed parameter ensemble, we then train a series of artificial feed-forward neural networks to emulate CLM5 output given parameter values as input. We use annual mean globally aggregated spatial variability in carbon and water fluxes as our emulation and calibration targets. Validation and out-of-sample tests are used to assess the predictive skill of the networks, and we utilize permutation feature importance and partial dependence methods to better interpret the results. The trained networks are then used to estimate global optimal parameter values with greater computational efficiency than achieved by hand tuning efforts and increased spatial scale relative to previous studies optimizing at a single site. By developing this methodology, our framework can help quantify the contribution of parameter uncertainty to overall uncertainty in land model projections.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

DOE OSTI2024

Engineered MXene quantum dots for micro-supercapacitors with excellent capacitive behaviors

Micro-supercapacitors (MSCs) have drawn tremendous attention as promising candidates to power miniaturized portable/wearable electronics, but they still suffer from unsatisfactory electrochemical performance (e.g., insufficient energy density, mediocre rate capability), thus impeding their widespread applications. Here, a synergistic surface and structure engineering strategy achieved by downsizing to quantum dot scale, doping of heteroatoms, and introducing defects and functional groups is proposed to regulate the physicochemical properties of Ti 3 C 2 T x MXene. Encouragingly, the resulting MSCs based on defect-rich nitrogen-doped Ti 3 C 2 T x quantum dots (QDs) possess excellent electrochemical performance as demonstrated by large operating voltage (3.0 V in ionic liquid and 1.0 V in aqueous electrolyte), perfect rectangular CV shape even at 1000 V·s -1 , high volumetric capacitance of 33.1 F·cm -3 , and superior cycling stability after 10000 cycles. By employing experimental characterizations and density functional theory calculations, the remarkable performance of the MSCs is mainly due to the special chemical states as well as the unique surface and structural features of Ti 3 C 2 T x QDs, which offer abundant active sites, shorten ion diffusion pathways, promote ion/electron transports, and provide enhanced capacitance. Finally, this work provides a new strategy for the design of high-performance MSCs and a reference for the applications of MXene QDs in other energy-related fields.

42 ENGINEERING↗

DOE OSTI2025

Investigating the impact of preparation routes on the properties of copper-decorated silicon particles as anode materials for lithium-ion batteries

In recent years, the calendar life of Si has been recognized as a significant issue that must be addressed prior to technology deployment: The carbon conductive additive is a potential source of parasitic side reactions. However, carbon remains essential due to the low electronic conductivity of Si. In this study, we investigate the use of Cu as a conductive additive and potential alternative to carbon. Some Cu-decorated silicon particles (Si Cu ) were prepared using physical vapor deposition (PVD) via sputtering and high-energy milling. Other Si Cu particles were prepared by using a solution method and examined briefly. The milling method caused Cu to appear as island-like features on the Si surface, whereas the PVD method initially produced similar island-like features that gradually developed into a continuous coating around the Si as sputtering time increased. Electrodes fabricated from Si Cu exhibited lower overall resistivity, demonstrating the beneficial effect of Cu in improving electronic percolation through the electrode. Electrochemical tests showed that the milled SiCu exhibited higher capacity retention, improved rate capability, and lower overpotential. Furthermore, Si Cu coupled with an NMC811 cathode exhibited lower leakage currents compared with the baseline silicon, indicating that incorporating Cu provided an additional advantage of minimizing parasitic currents in the cells.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

DOE OSTI2025

The glass-ceiling convective regime and the origin and diversity of coronae on Venus

Venus and Earth are rocky planets of roughly the same size and bulk density, yet their surface volcanic and tectonic features appear substantially different. On Venus, the coexistence of large volcanic highlands—interpreted as the surface expression of long-lived mantle plumes—alongside coronae, smaller features thought to be caused by transient thermal diapirs, remains enigmatic. Using two-dimensional numerical models of mantle convection with sharp and broad mineral phase transitions for pyrolite, we show that both scales of upwellings can be generated in a stagnant lid planet with an interior temperature 250 to 400 K warmer than Earth’s. The smaller plumes originate from a ~600 km deep internal layer that exists as a consequence of the different sequence of mineral phase transitions that occur in warmer mantles less processed and differentiated by partial melting and volcanism. Future models that include melting will provide further tests of our hypothesis.

Science & Technology - Other Topics↗

DOE OSTI2024

Interaction-enhanced nesting in spin-fermion and Fermi-Hubbard models

The spin-fermion (SF) model postulates that the dominant coupling between low-energy fermions in near critical metals is mediated by collective spin fluctuations (paramagnons) peaked at the Néel wave vector, Q N , connecting hot spots on opposite sides of the Fermi surface. It has been argued that strong correlations at hot spots lead to a Fermi surface deformation (FSD) featuring flat regions and increased nesting. This conjecture was confirmed in the perturbative self-consistent calculations when the paramagnon propagator dependence on momentum deviation from Q N is given by χ − 1 ∝ | Δ q | . Using diagrammatic Monte Carlo (diagMC) technique we show that such a dependence holds only at temperatures orders of magnitude smaller than any other energy scale in the problem, indicating that a different mechanism may be at play. Instead, we find that a χ − 1 ∝ | Δ q | 2 dependence yields a robust finite- T scenario for achieving FSD. To link phenomenological and microscopic descriptions, we applied the connected determinant diagMC method to the ( t − t ′ ) Hubbard model and found that at large U / t > 5.5 before the formation of electron and hole pockets (i) the FSD defined as a maximum of the spectral function is not very pronounced; instead, it is the lines of zeros of the renormalized dispersion relation that deforms toward nesting, and (ii) the static spin susceptibility is well described by χ − 1 ∝ | Δ q | 2 . Flat FS regions yield a nontrivial scenario for realizing a non-Fermi liquid state. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

DOE OSTI2023

High-Order Mesh Morphing for Boundary and Interface Fitting to Implicit Geometries

Here, we propose a method that morphs high-order meshes such that their boundaries and interfaces coincide/align with implicitly defined geometries. Our focus is particularly on the case when the target surface is prescribed as the zero isocontour of a smooth discrete function. Common examples of this scenario include using level set functions to represent material interfaces in multimaterial configurations, and evolving geometries in shape and topology optimization. The proposed method formulates the mesh optimization problem as a variational minimization of the sum of a chosen mesh-quality metric using the Target-Matrix Optimization Paradigm (TMOP) and a penalty term that weakly forces the selected faces of the mesh to align with the target surface. The distinct features of the method are use of a source mesh to represent the level set function with sufficient accuracy, and adaptive strategies for setting the penalization weight and selecting the faces of the mesh to be fit to the target isocontour of the level set field. We demonstrate that the proposed method is robust for generating boundary- and interface-fitted meshes for curvilinear domains using different element types in 2D and 3D.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

DOE OSTI2023

Structural and Biophysical Properties of a [4Fe-4S] Ferredoxin-Like Protein from Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 with a Unique Two Domain Structure

Electron carrier proteins (ECPs), binding iron-sulfur clusters, are vital components within the intricate network of metabolic and photosynthetic reactions. They play a crucial role in the distribution of reducing equivalents. In Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803, the ECP network includes at least nine ferredoxins. Previous research, including global expression analyses and protein binding studies, has offered initial insights into the functional roles of individual ferredoxins within this network. This study primarily focuses on Ferredoxin 9 (slr2059). Through sequence analysis and computational modeling, Ferredoxin 9 emerges as a unique ECP with a distinctive two-domain architecture. It consists of a C-terminal iron-sulfur binding domain and an N-terminal domain with homology to Nil-domain proteins, connected by a structurally rigid 4-amino acid linker. Notably, in contrast to canonical [2Fe-2S] ferredoxins exemplified by PetF (ssl0020), which feature highly acidic surfaces facilitating electron transfer with photosystem I reaction centers, models of Ferredoxin 9 reveal a more neutral to basic protein surface. Using a combination of electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy and square-wave voltammetry on heterologously produced Ferredoxin 9, this study demonstrates that the protein coordinates 2x[4Fe-4S]2+/1+ redox-active and magnetically interacting clusters, with measured redox potentials of -420 +/- 9 mV and -516 +/- 10 mV vs SHE. A more in-depth analysis of Fdx9's unique structure and protein sequence suggests that this type of Nil-2[4Fe-4S] multi-domain ferredoxin is well conserved in cyanobacteria, bearing structural similarities to proteins involved in homocysteine synthesis in methanogens.

cyanobacteria↗

DOE OSTI2025

Impact of post-irradiation annealing on mechanical performance of irradiated 718 alloy

Here, the effect of post-irradiation annealing on solution-annealed 718 alloy was investigated using advanced mechanical testing, fractography, scanning electron microscopy, and transmission electron microscopy. Specimens were extracted from a proton beam window operated at the Spallation Neutron Source, irradiated with 940 MeV protons to a maximum dose of approximately 9.7 displacements per atom (dpa) at a calculated temperature not exceeding 110 °C while in service. Helium and hydrogen concentrations reached about 1700 and 6900 atomic parts per million (appm), respectively. Despite irradiation and high tensile strength (yield stress over 1 GPa), the material exhibited significant ductility. Annealing at 500 °C, 700 °C, and 900 °C for 30 min resulted in an appreciable decrease in yield strength and an increase in ductility for annealing treatments at 500 °C and 900 °C relative to the strength and ductility of the as-irradiated material. The presence of helium and hydrogen led to cavity formation and cleavage-like brittle features on fractured surfaces; however, high-magnification imaging revealed the presence of small-scale ductile dimples, indicating that the fracture mechanism remained mixed. The annealed specimens retained total elongation levels of 14–33 %, and there was no sudden drop in ductility after heat treatments. The ductility level in the irradiated and annealed material is notable despite the presence of helium and hydrogen.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗