SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “cathode coating”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

SourceResearch connectionFrom yearThrough year

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 199 records · Page 11

All sources NASA NTRS DOE OSTI

DOE OSTI2020

Vanadium oxide coatings to self-regulate current sharing in high-temperature superconducting cables and magnets

High-temperature superconductors such as REBa 2 Cu 3 O 7-δ (REBCO, RE = rare earth) enable high-current cables and high-field magnets. By removing the turn-to-turn insulation in a magnet application, recent experiments demonstrated that REBCO magnets can self-protect against catastrophic damage during a superconducting-to-normal transition (quench), i.e., when the stored magnetic energy rapidly converts to heat. The current can bypass the hot spot during a quench, thereby reducing the localized heat dissipation. The removal of the insulation between turns, however, leads to excessive eddy currents during current ramping, thereby forcing a much-prolonged magnet charging time. To address this issue, we investigate vanadium oxide (VO x ) coatings as a temperature-dependent self-switching medium that automatically manages current sharing. VO x coatings (with 1.70 ≤ × ≤ to 2.07) were deposited by reactive cathodic arc deposition, initially on insulating glass to determine the electrical properties, and later on commercial REBCO tapes. The coatings are x-ray amorphous but with a short-range crystalline ordering according to Raman spectrometry. The resistivity of VO x decreased by at least three orders of magnitude when the temperature increased from 80 to 300 K. The coating process is compatible with commercial REBCO tapes as evidenced by the negligible change in the critical current caused by the coating process. Here, the results from current sharing experiments and circuit analysis suggest that the VO x coating can effectively self-regulate current sharing in REBCO magnets, suppress excessive eddy currents, and enable self-protection during quenches.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

DOE OSTI2022

Building interface bonding and shield for stable Li-rich Mn-based oxide cathode

Implementation of Li-rich Mn-based oxide cathode with high-energy-density has been restrained by capacity/voltage degradation that results from irreversible lattice oxygen loss and structure rearrangements. To resolve these challenges, in this work, Li 1.2 Mn 0.54 Ni 0.13 Co 0.13 O 2 encapsulated by amorphous Co x B (CB-LRM) is rationally designed via autocatalytic plating for highly reversible cationic/anionic hybrid cathode material. Band coherency is ingeniously evoked by interface-reconstruction between bulk structure and amorphous coating layer, which lower the energy of O $2p$ states. Furthermore, this is associated with strengthened orbital hybridization of O $2p$-Mn $3d$ and increased formation energy of oxygen vacancy, which mitigates the lattice oxygen loss considerably. Additionally, interface shielding effects that protect electrode against electrolyte corrosion and the reduction of surface oxygen are also present with fully coverage of amorphous Co x B coating layer. As a result, the as-designed CBLRM cathode exhibits excellent cycle stability after 100 loops with only 0.154% per cycle capacity fade and improved voltage degradation. Given this, this work provides a potential avenue for rational design of lattice oxygen-based electrode materials with high-energy-density.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

DOE OSTI2023

The effect of ink ball milling time on interparticle interactions and ink microstructure and their influence on crack formation in rod-coated catalyst layers

This work investigates the influence of ballmilling (sometimes also referred to as jar roller milling) time on cathode catalyst layer (CL) inks and electrode properties using formulations and coating methods relevant for industrial manufacturing. Four CL inks with the same composition were milled for 24, 48, 72, or 96 h. Rheological investigation of these inks showed a reduction of elastic moduli and steady-shear viscosity with continuous ink milling, which is correlated to a decrease in particle-particle interactions as well as formation of smaller agglomerates. Optical microscopy (OM) analysis of the fabricated electrodes revealed a trend in surface crack formation; formulations milled for 24 h contained the lowest average surface crack area percentages of 0.370% at heavy-duty loadings of ~0.300 mg Pt cm -2 , compared to 2.418% for the ink milled for 96 h. Further characterization of the CL through transmission electron microscopy (TEM) imaging showed a decrease in the mean agglomerate and pore size with milling time. Furthermore, these smaller electrode features were consistent with reduced fracture resistance and, hence, development of larger stresses during drying. Our results highlight the need to consider ink processing as an important component in defect-free CL manufacturing.

30 DIRECT ENERGY CONVERSION↗

DOE OSTI2021

Tuning Surface Stoichiometry of SOFC Electrodes at the Molecular and Nano-scale for Enhanced Performance and Durability

This project achieved the following objectives. Different cation segregation behaviors of different common SOFC cathodes, including La 0.6 Sr 0.4 Co0.2Fe 0.8 O 3-δ (LSCF), Sr 0.5 Sm 0.5 O 3-δ (SSC), and PrBa 0.5 Sr 0.5 Co 1.5 Fe 0.5 O5 +δ (PBSCF), were determined. We showed how oxygen partial pressure and gas impurities impact the stability of SOFC cathodes. We developed atomic layer deposition (ALD) coating techniques for electrodes and showed that by introducing different elements and different ALD oxidizers, electrode surface chemistry can be altered, resulting in enhanced oxygen reduction kinetics. In addition, we developed solution infiltration technique to enhance performance and durability of electrodes. Different infiltrates as well as different thermal treatment processes were screened to identify the optimal surface modification process that yields both low impedance and high durability. The modified cathode shows excellent stability and has a low area specific resistance (ASR) of only 0.2 Ωcm 2 at 600 °C after over 2000 hours of operation. Further, we developed ceramic anodes, SrFe(Co,Mo)O 3 (SFCM) and SrFe(Ni,Mo)O 3 (SFNM), and enhanced anode oxidation kinetics by solution infiltration or in situ catalyst exsolution from the ceramic anode surface. The modified anodes showed improved performance in full SOFCs, and the optimized anode modification shows high stability for over 400 hours at 550 °C. Moreover, the modified anode also demonstrates high durability in methane. This work provides fundamental understanding of electrode surface chemistry and demonstrates a simple, facile, cost-effective approach to enhance catalytic activity and durability of SOFC electrodes.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

NASA NTRS1961

Quantum Yield of Gold-Cathode Photomultipliers

Two gold-cathode EMI 6255G tubes have been investigated for their quantum yield between 3100 and 1900 A. The tubes had cathodes of different appearances. One of these, numbered 3012, had a slight bluish tinge and was very transparent to visible light; the other, numbered 3021, had a definite gold coloration. The relative quantum yield of each tube was determined with the aid of a Cary model 14 recording spectrophotometer used as a monochromator. The monochromator relative-energy output was determined from the current output of a sodium-salicylate-coated RCA 1P21 photomultiplier. Each gold-cathode tube was then operated at 3000 v, and the central 1.8 cm cube of the cathode was exposed to the monochromator output.

Childs, Charles B.↗

NASA NTRS1976

Long lifetime hollow cathodes for 30-cm mercury ion thrusters

An experimental investigation of hollow cathodes for 30-cm Hg bombardment thrusters was carried out. Both main and neutralizer cathode configurations were tested with both rolled foil inserts coated with low work function material and impregnated porous tungsten inserts. Temperature measurements of an impregnated insert at various positions in the cathode were made. These, along with the cathode thermal profile are presented. A theory for rolled foil and impregnated insert operation and lifetime in hollow cathodes is developed. Several endurance tests, as long as 18000 hours at emission currents of up to 12 amps were attained with no degradation in performance.

Mirtich, M. J.↗

NASA NTRS1976

Long lifetime hollow cathodes for 30-cm mercury ion thrusters

An experimental investigation of hollow cathodes for 30-cm Hg bombardment thrusters was carried out. Both main and neutralizer cathode configurations were tested with both rolled foil inserts coated with low work function material and impregnated porous tungsten inserts. Temperature measurements of an impregnated insert at various positions in the cathode were made. These, along with the cathode thermal profile are presented. A theory for rolled foil and impregnated insert operation and lifetime in hollow cathodes is developed. Several endurance tests, as long as 18,000 hours at emission currents of up to 12 amps were attained with no degradation in performance.

Mirtich, M. J.↗

DOE OSTI2025

Mitigating Transition Metal Dissolution from Mn-rich Cathodes: Influence of Processing and Testing Methods

Manganese-rich oxides continue to gain interest with respect to the development of Earth-abundant options for lithium-ion cathodes. Of the unique challenges that hinder the respective performance of various classes of such materials, manganese dissolution still stands as a common theme. The work herein explores Li 3 PO 4 as a robust surface protection layer on a prototypical, Co-free, manganese-rich cathode in the way of a lithium- and manganese-rich oxide. The study highlights the critical importance of synthesis and processing in realizing optimal performance of a given surface treatment by comparing sol-gel and atomic layer deposition methods. Furthermore, cycling protocols are emphasized as a critical factor in adequately gauging the efficacy of surface protection strategies to mitigate manganese dissolution and the subsequent electrochemical consequence. Optimized Li 3 PO 4 coatings coatings on lithium- and manganese-rich cathode particles are shown to greatly mitigate capacity fade, impedance rise, pore/void formation and mechanical damage during long-term cycling.

Mallick, Subhadip [Argonne National Laboratory (AN↗

NASA NTRS1977

Low-temperature thermionic emitter

An improved photodelineatable cathode material is disclosed comprising a combination of triple carbonate (TC) and a hydrocarbon polymeric photoresist PR. A mixture of TC powder and PR is applied to a cathode by spraying, spinning or dipping and is then subjected to activation at a temperature from about 800.degree. C up to the melting temperature. The cathodes can be activated at a temperature as low as 800.degree. C and still deliver a 0-field, temperature-limited current density of 750 milliamperes per sq. centimeter at 600.degree. C. If a pattern is desired, the coating is exposed through a suitable mask to actinic light to harden the photoresist in the desired areas. Following exposure, the exposed image areas are developed and the unexposed portions of the coating are removed with solvent. When dry, the cathode is ready for activation.

Remington, Richard W.↗

DOE OSTI2023

Rheo-electric measurements of carbon black suspensions containing polyvinylidene difluoride in N -methyl-2-pyrrolidone

Lithium-ion battery cathode slurries have a microstructure that depends sensitively on how they are processed due to carbon black's (CB) evolving structure when subjected coating flows. While polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF), one of the main components of the cathode slurry, plays an important role in modifying the structure and rheology of CB, a quantitative understanding is lacking. In this work, we explore the role of PVDF in determining the structural evolution of Super C65 CB in N-methyl-2-pyrrolidinone (NMP) with rheo-electric measurements. We find that PVDF enhances the viscosity of NMP resulting in a more extensive structural erosion of CB agglomerates with increasing polymer concentration and molecular weight. We also show that the relative viscosity of all suspensions can be collapsed by the fluid Mason number (Mnf), which compares the hydrodynamic forces imposed by the medium to cohesive forces holding CB agglomerates together. Using simultaneous rheo-electric measurements, we find at high Mnf, the dielectric strength (Δε) scales with Mnf, and the power-law scaling can be quantitatively predicted by considering the self-similar break up of CB agglomerates. The collapse of the relative viscosity and scaling of Δε both suggest that PVDF increases the hydrodynamic force of the suspending medium without directly changing the CB agglomerate structure. These findings are valuable for optimizing the rheology of lithium ion battery cathode slurries. We also anticipate that these findings can be extended to understand the microstructure of similar systems under flow.

Mechanics↗

DOE OSTI2023

Enhanced Electrochemical Performance of Disordered Rocksalt Cathodes Enabled by a Graphite Conductive Additive

Cobalt-free cation-disordered rocksalt (DRX) cathodes are a promising class of materials for next-generation Li-ion batteries. Although they have high theoretical specific capacities (>300 mA h/g) and moderate operating voltages (~3.5 V vs Li/Li + ), DRX cathodes typically require a high carbon content (up to 30 wt %) to fully utilize the active material which has a detrimental impact on cell-level energy density. To assess pathways to reduce the electrode’s carbon content, the present study investigates how the carbon’s microstructure and loading (10–20 wt %) influence the performance of DRX cathodes with the nominal composition Li 1.2 Mn 0.5 Ti 0.3 O 1.9 F 0.1 . While electrodes prepared with conventional disordered carbon additives (C65 and ketjenblack) exhibit rapid capacity fade due to an unstable cathode/electrolyte interface, DRX cathodes containing 10 wt % graphite show superior cycling performance (e.g., reversible capacities ~260 mA h/g with 85% capacity retention after 50 cycles) and rate capability (~135 mA h/g at 1000 mA/g). Furthermore, a suite of characterization tools was employed to evaluate the performance differences among these composite electrodes. Overall, these results indicate that the superior performance of the graphite-based cathodes is largely attributed to the: (i) formation of a uniform graphitic coating on DRX particles which protects the surface from parasitic reactions at high states of charge and (ii) homogeneous dispersion of the active material and carbon throughout the composite cathode which provides a robust electronically conductive network that can withstand repeated charge–discharge cycles. Overall, this study provides key scientific insights on how the carbon microstructure and electrode processing influence the performance of DRX cathodes. Based on these results, exploration of alternative routes to apply graphitic coatings is recommended to further optimize the material performance.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

DOE OSTI2025

Developing low-cost rechargeable batteries: beyond traditional layered oxide cathodes for Li-ion and beyond Li-ion batteries

Here, the rising demand for energy storage systems, driven by the rapid adoption of electric vehicles and the global shift toward renewable energy, necessitates continuous efforts to lower the cost of current lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) and enhance the sustainability of existing battery chemistries. This feature article examines the key challenges associated with Ni- and Co-containing LIB cathodes and compares advancements in cathode development for non-traditional Li-ion and beyond Li-ion chemistries. First, a review of earth-abundant element containing disordered rock-salt cathodes is presented, with a discussion of key strategies such as compositional tuning and carbon coating to improve their electrochemical performance. Hurdles in developing oxide-based cathodes for Na- and K-ion batteries are also highlighted, followed by an in-depth overview of polyanion and Prussian blue cathodes for Na- and K-ion systems. Overall, this article provides a systematic perspective on the design of earth-abundant, low-cost, and sustainable cathode materials for both LIB and beyond LIB technologies.

Lohani, Harshita [Lawrence Berkeley National Labor↗

DOE OSTI2021

Deciphering Interfacial Chemical and Electrochemical Reactions of Sulfide-Based All-Solid-State Batteries

Large interfacial resistance resulting from interfacial reactions is widely acknowledged as one of the main challenges in sulfide electrolytes (SEs)-based all-solid-state lithium batteries (ASSLBs). However, the root cause of the large interfacial resistance between the SEs and typical layered oxide cathodes is not fully understood yet. Here we deciphered that interfacial oxygen loss from single-crystal LiNi 0.5 Mn 0.3 Co 0.2 O 2 (SC-NMC532) chemically oxidizes Li 10 GeP 2 S 12 , generating oxygen-containing interfacial species. Meanwhile, the interfacial oxygen loss also induces a structural change of oxide cathodes (layered-to-rocksalt). Besides, the high operation voltage can electrochemically oxidize SEs to form non-oxygen species (e.g. polysulfides). These chemically and electrochemically oxidized species, together with the interfacial structural change, are responsible for the large interfacial resistance at the cathode interface. More importantly, the widely adopted interfacial coating strategy is effective in suppressing chemically oxidized oxygen-containing species and mitigating the coincident interfacial structural change but is unable to prevent electrochemically induced non-oxygen species. These findings provide a deeper insight into the large interfacial resistance between the typical SE and layered oxide cathodes, which may be of assistance for the rational interface design of SE-based ASSLBs in future.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

DOE OSTI2025

Selective concentration of multivalent cations via electrodialysis through tandem membranes

Selective electrodialysis is attractive for recovering and recycling valuable ions. However, most studies in this field focus on membranes that are selective for monovalent ions. Multivalent cations preferentially partition into cation-exchange membranes, but low mobilities and concentration polarization limit electrodialysis selectivities for these cations. This work employs electrodialysis through an “in-series” combination of a Nafion membrane and a multilayer polyelectrolyte film (MPF)-coated Nafion membrane to concentrate and isolate La 3+ or Mg 2+ from monovalent ions. The bare Nafion membrane gives a La 3+ /Na + selectivity up to 4 (depending on conditions), which enables concentration of La 3+ with a high current efficiency. The MPF-coated membrane allows selective passage of Na + while rejecting La 3+ to increase the purity of the concentrated multivalent cation. For example, the concentration of La 3+ in the accumulation solution can reach 9 times its original concentration in the feed solution with a purity of 93 mol% (99 wt%) when starting with equimolar mixtures of NaNO 3 and La(NO 3 ) 3 . This study examines how the separation varies with the type of polyelectrolyte, the applied voltage, and the composition of feed, accumulation, and cathode solutions. Here, a high nitric acid concentration (0.5 M) in the cathode compartment allows monovalent anions to pass through the MPF-coated Nafion membrane to maintain the electroneutrality of the accumulation solution. With a low acid concentration (0.04 M) in the cathode chamber, water splitting occurs at the MPF-coated membrane and La(OH) 3 precipitates.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

DOE OSTI2021

Synergy of Graphene Nanoribbons and Graphene Sheets for High-Rate Lithium-Sulfur Batteries

According to the increasing demands for shortening the battery charging time, high current rate (C-rate) performances become more significant in practical applications. With a higher theoretical capacity, lithium-sulfur batteries are treated as promising candidates for the next-generation batteries. In this work, the utilization of graphene nanoribbons (GNRs) exhibits the benefits in conductivity and other electrochemical performances, especially for high-rate applications. With air-controlled electrospray as the method, carbon encapsulated sulfur particles, poly(acrylic acid), reduced graphene oxide (rGO) sheets, and GNRs are mixed and directly deposited onto the carbon coated aluminum collector, to employ as the cathode. The scanning electron microscopy (SEM) imaging exhibits that the two-dimensional structure of GNRs helps construct inter-connected networks. This improved structure of cathode can increase the electroconductivity, confirmed by the electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS), and modify the porosity, indicated through pore size distribution profiles. In this way, the polysulfides can be more efficiently trapped and utilized, realizing the promising behavior with faster charge transfer. In terms of the cycling performance at 0.2 C, the batteries with GNRs can perform 18% higher in capacity than those without GNRs, without decreasing the charge retention. According to the rate-capability tests, systems with GNRs can achieve enhanced performance compared to batteries with precursor carbon nanotubes (CNTs), especially at high C-rates. At 2 C, with 80 wt % of graphene-based materials as GNRs, batteries can achieve an increase in capacity by 78% and 41% compared with systems without GNRs and those with CNTs, respectively. Accordingly, the results testify the synergy of GNRs and rGO sheets in Li-S batteries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

NASA NTRS1998

Cathodic Protection Deployment on Space Shuttle Solid Rocket Boosters

Corrosion protection of the space shuttle solid rocket boosters incorporates the use of cathodic protection(anodes) in concert with several coatings systems. The SRB design has large carbon/carbon composites(motor nozzle) electrically connected to an aluminum alloy structure. Early in the STS program, the aluminum structures incurred tremendous corrosive attack due primarily to the galvanic couple to the carbon/carbon nozzle at coating damage locations. Also contributing to the galvanic corrosion problem were stainless steel and titanium alloy components housed within the aluminum structures and electrically connected to the aluminum structures. This paper will highlight the evolution in the protection of the aluminum structures, providing historical information and summary data from the operation of the corrosion protection systems. Also, data and information will be included regarding the evaluation and deployment of inorganic zinc rich primers as anode area on the aluminum structures.

Zook, Lee M.↗

NASA NTRS2010

Physical and Electrical Characterization of Aluminum Polymer Capacitors

Conductive polymer aluminum capacitor (PA capacitor) is an evolution of traditional wet electrolyte aluminum capacitors by replacing liquid electrolyte with a solid, highly conductive polymer. On the other hand, the cathode construction in polymer aluminum capacitors with coating of carbon and silver epoxy for terminal connection is more like a combination of the technique that solid tantalum capacitor utilizes. This evolution and combination result in the development of several competing capacitor construction technologies in manufacturing polymer aluminum capacitors. The driving force of this research on characterization of polymer aluminum capacitors is the rapid progress in IC technology. With the microprocessor speeds exceeding a gigahertz and CPU current demands of 80 amps and more, the demand for capacitors with higher peak current and faster repetition rates bring conducting polymer capacitors to the center o( focus. This is because this type of capacitors has been known for its ultra-low ESR and high capacitance. Polymer aluminum capacitors from several manufacturers with various combinations of capacitance, rated voltage, and ESR values were obtained and tested. The construction analysis of the capacitors revealed three different constructions: conventional rolled foil, the multilayer stacking V-shape, and a dual-layer sandwich structure. The capacitor structure and its impact on the electrical characteristics has been revealed and evaluated. A destructive test with massive current over stress to fail the polymer aluminum capacitors reveals that all polymer aluminum capacitors failed in a benign mode without ignition, combustion, or any other catastrophic failures. The extraordinary low ESR (as low as 3 mOMEGA), superior frequency independence reported for polymer aluminum capacitors have been confirmed. For the applications of polymer aluminum capacitors in space programs, a thermal vacuum cycle test was performed. The results, as expected, show no impact on the electrical characteristics of the capacitors. The breakdown voltage of polymer capacitors has been evaluated using a steady step surge test. Initial results show the uniform distribution in the breakdown voltage for polymer aluminum capacitors. Polymer aluminum capacitors with a combination of very high capacitance, extraordinary low ESR, excellent frequency stability, and non-ignite benign failure mode make it a niche fit in space applications for both today and future. Polymer capacitors are apparently also the best substitutes of the currently used MnO2-based tantalum capacitors in the low voltage range. However, some critical aspects are still to be addressed in the next phase of the investigation for PA capacitors. These include the long term reliability test of 125 C dry life and 85 C/85%RH humidity, the failure mechanism and de-rating, the radiation tolerance, and the high temperature performance. All of the above requires the continuous NEPP funding and support.

Liu, David (Donghang)↗

DOE OSTI2024

Corrosion of Zinc Cold Spray Coatings in a Wet Sweet and Sour Gas Environment

Internal corrosion is a problem for steel pipelines transporting natural gas or CO 2 containing water and partial pressures of H 2 S higher than 0.3 kPa (0.05 psi). This work aims to mitigate internal corrosion in steel pipelines transporting natural gas containing H 2 S using cold spray coatings. Two types of the cold spray binary metallic coatings (zinc chromium [ZnCr]. zinc niobium [ZnNb]) were studied using electrochemical techniques: potentiodynamic polarization, linear polarization resistance, and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. The corrosion resistance of cold spray coatings (ZnCr, ZnNb) was evaluated in an environment containing 4 bar CO 2 pressure, simulating the partial pressures found in gas transmission lines over a solution of 3.5 wt% NaCl heated to 40°C. A concentration of 0.003 M Na 2 S 2 O 3 ·5H 2 O, corresponding to H 2 S partial pressures around 0.079 bar (1.146 psi), was used to simulate sour conditions. Postcorrosion surface characterization was performed using a scanning electron microscope (SEM) equipped with an energy-dispersive x-ray spectroscope (EDS) and x-ray diffraction analysis. The data showed that the presence of 0.003 M Na 2 S 2 O 3 ·5H 2 O shifted the corrosion potential to more anodic values and decreased the corrosion current density. Both coatings showed similar behavior after 1 h of exposure in the CO 2 /H 2 S environment, indicating that similar electrochemical reactions were occurring on ZnNb and ZnCr. SEM images and EDS surface analyses for specimens showed a significant change in the surface chemical composition of carbon steel coated with ZnNb and ZnCr after 24 h of immersion. In the presence of thiosulfate (under sour conditions), the formation of corrosion product layers (ZnCO 3 and ZnS) on top of ZnNb and ZnCr coatings increased their corrosion resistance, which helped to reduce their corrosion by a factor of 2. Under a sweet environment, the corrosion rates for steel coated with cold spray coatings after 14 d of exposure are lower than that for galvanized steel by a factor of 5 due to the ZnCO 3 layer formed on top of the coatings. The ZnCO 3 layer formed on the steel surface acts as a physical barrier against corrosion by blocking the diffusion of corrosive species to the surface. No localized attack was observed. ZnCr Cold spray coating with defect showed promising corrosion protection against CO 2 corrosion (sweet corrosion) after 14 d of exposure to a CO 2 environment. Here, the scratch on the coating simulated damage created in service, and it was deep enough to expose the substrate material (steel). The formation of zinc oxide (ZnO) and zinc carbonate (ZnCO 3 ) on the scratch confirmed the cathodic protection of the steel by ZnCr and ZnNb coatings.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗