Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Safety Case”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 199 records · Page 11

LaserSnake2: An Innovative Approach to Nuclear Decommissioning - 17080

Nuclear decommissioning challenges exist the world over and require innovative approaches to ensure safe and cost effective dismantling of high hazard nuclear facilities. LaserSnake technology makes use of the flexibility and dexterity of snake arm robots to deploy high-powered laser cutting, lifting and manipulation tools. This paper describes the development and use of the system to achieve the successful size reduction and removal of a substantial stainless steel vessel within the First Generation Reprocessing Plant (FGRP) at Sellafield in the UK. Due to the environment, nuclear decommissioning is an extremely challenging activity. High ambient radiation levels often preclude entry to the areas involved, and as industry tries to minimise dose uptake, even moderate radiation levels now require remote solutions. 'In-situ' size reduction of process plant, including vessels and pipework, will allow the removal of the nuclear inventory from a building prior to further decontamination and demolition. The term 'in situ' is in this case used to mean work done on plant items within their existing cells as opposed to moving items from their original location to a dedicated size reduction facility. Traditional size reduction cutting methods, such as reciprocating saws or grinders, pose a significant challenge for remote deployment platforms. This includes the loss of haptic feedback and the length of time taken to perform the task, and difficulty dealing with the reaction forces. Although remote engineered solutions for these tools are possible, they are are typically complicated, unreliable and expensive. Robot deployed laser cutting is widely used in non-nuclear industrial sectors, and offers a simpler method for size reduction. LaserSnake2 is a UK collaborative project, co-funded by the Nuclear Decommissioning Authority, Innovate UK and the Department of Energy and Climate Change. The project combined the skills of robotic experts and laser and optic specialists, to develop a remote handling technology suited for deployment within active nuclear environments. As well as meeting strict safety case requirements, the system provides a safe and cost effective method for decommissioning of complex nuclear spaces. An overview of the system development and deployment is presented in this paper. In July 2016, a successful decommissioning campaign was conducted in the FGRP at Sellafield. The LaserSnake2 system was used to size reduce a double-skinned dissolver vessel within a radiologically active nuclear cell. Planning of the size reduction method and processes, as well as results of the campaign itself are described in this paper. The containment procedures and radiological considerations for the system are presented along with the effects of operations on the cell and ventilation systems. LaserSnake, developed as a modular arm system with up to 4.5 m of articulation, carries an integrated tool comprising a high power, decommissioning specific, laser cutting head, high definition cameras and high powered illumination LEDs. It is designed for precise dismantling work within confined and hazardous environments. The tool can be interchanged, allowing the snake-arm robot also to carry grippers, environmental mapping sensors and other tools which may prove advantageous during a decommissioning campaign. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Preliminary Safety Analysis of the Gorleben Site: Safety Concept and Application to Scenario Development Based on a Site-Specific Features, Events and Processes (FEP) Database - 13304

Based upon the German safety criteria, released in 2010 by the Federal Ministry of the Environment (BMU), a safety concept and a safety assessment concept for the disposal of heat-generating high-level waste have both been developed in the framework of the preliminary safety case for the Gorleben site (Project VSG). The main objective of the disposal is to contain the radioactive waste inside a defined rock zone, which is called containment-providing rock zone. The radionuclides shall remain essentially at the emplacement site, and at the most, a small defined quantity of material shall be able to leave this rock zone. This shall be accomplished by the geological barrier and a technical barrier system, which is required to seal the inevitable penetration of the geological barrier by the construction of the mine. The safe containment has to be demonstrated for probable and less probable evolutions of the site, while evolutions with very low probability (less than 1 % over the demonstration period of 1 million years) need not to be considered. Owing to the uncertainty in predicting the real evolution of the site, plausible scenarios have been derived in a systematic manner. Therefore, a comprehensive site-specific features, events and processes (FEP) data base for the Gorleben site has been developed. The safety concept was directly taken into account, e.g. by identification of FEP with direct influence on the barriers that provide the containment. No effort was spared to identify the interactions of the FEP, their probabilities of occurrence, and their characteristics (values). The information stored in the data base provided the basis for the development of scenarios. The scenario development methodology is based on FEP related to an impairment of the functionality of a subset of barriers, called initial barriers. By taking these FEP into account in their probable characteristics the reference scenario is derived. Thus, the reference scenario describes a comprehensive set of probable future evolutions of the repository site. By stepwise consideration of less probable FEP or less probable characteristics of FEP within this process, alternative scenarios are also developed, which are characterized by a lower probability of occurrence. An important methodological aspect is that some assumptions had to be made for the scenario development. They allow, on the one hand, to deal systematically with incomplete knowledge regarding the geological situation below ground owing to restricted site investigations, and, on the other hand, to structure the scenario development process. The consideration of alternative assumptions may result in additional alternative scenarios. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Comprehensive Forced Response Analysis of J2X Turbine Bladed-Discs with 360 Degree Variation in CFD Loading

The temporal frequency content of the dynamic pressure predicted by a 360 degree computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis of a turbine flow field provides indicators of forcing function excitation frequencies (e.g., multiples of blade pass frequency) for turbine components. For the Pratt and Whitney Rocketdyne J-2X engine turbopumps, Campbell diagrams generated using these forcing function frequencies and the results of NASTRAN modal analyses show a number of components with modes in the engine operating range. As a consequence, forced response and static analyses are required for the prediction of combined stress, high cycle fatigue safety factors (HCFSF). Cyclically symmetric structural models have been used to analyze turbine vane and blade rows, not only in modal analyses, but also in forced response and static analyses. Due to the tortuous flow pattern in the turbine, dynamic pressure loading is not cyclically symmetric. Furthermore, CFD analyses predict dynamic pressure waves caused by adjacent and non-adjacent blade/vane rows upstream and downstream of the row analyzed. A MATLAB script has been written to calculate displacements due to the complex cyclically asymmetric dynamic pressure components predicted by CFD analysis, for all grids in a blade/vane row, at a chosen turbopump running speed. The MATLAB displacements are then read into NASTRAN, and dynamic stresses are calculated, including an adjustment for possible mistuning. In a cyclically symmetric NASTRAN static analysis, static stresses due to centrifugal, thermal, and pressure loading at the mode running speed are calculated. MATLAB is used to generate the HCFSF at each grid in the blade/vane row. When compared to an approach assuming cyclic symmetry in the dynamic flow field, the current approach provides better assurance that the worst case safety factor has been identified. An extended example for a J-2X turbopump component is provided.

Elrod, David↗

Experiments and Simulation of a Borehole in Salt to Understand Heat, Brine, and Vapor Migration - 19192

Disposition of heat-generating nuclear waste (HGNW) remains a continuing technical and sociopolitical challenge. Numerous concepts for HGNW management have been proposed and examined internationally, including an extensive focus on geologic disposal. One proposed geologic material is salt because of its low permeability and viscoplastic deformation that causes self-repair of damage done to the salt by waste emplacement activities. Evaluating the safety and technical challenges of storing HGNW in a salt repository is an ongoing process involving experiments and supporting numerical simulation. Currently an experiment is underway at the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP) to explore how the presence of a heat generating source affects phenomena such as brine migration, vapor transport, and mechanical changes to the bedded salt. A sub-horizontal heated borehole test is in progress in the underground at the WIPP that includes a centrally located 10.2 cm diameter borehole with an adjustable heater surrounded with smaller diameter boreholes instrumented with thermocouples. The central borehole contains an inflatable packer, heating block, brine sampler, and constantly flowing nitrogen gas circulation system. Air-injection tests performed in the central borehole provide pressure measurements that are used to constrain permeability of the system. The steady-state temperatures, as well as the rise and fall of temperature when the heater is cycled on and off, have been measured for up to 60 days. In the borehole, dry nitrogen gas circulation evaporates water and outflows to a desiccant container where water mass is measured daily during the experiment to quantify vapor removal. Although this test is a 'shake-down' for a planned second round of fresh borehole testing, we have gathered a rich dataset. These data allow us to build simulations using the Finite Element Heat and Mass transfer code (FEHM) to evaluate the experimental results, determine field-scale parameters, and identify code improvements to reproduce important physical processes that may not be accounted for at present. A 3-D numerical mesh, built using LaGrit software (lagrit.lanl.gov; Miller et al., 2007), includes increasing resolution around the central borehole. Modeling of the experiment allows for determining the local thermal conductivity and permeability of any damaged bedded salt around the borehole, where damage from drilling may change the permeability, porosity and saturation conditions, by parameter testing and inverse methods. Additionally, assumptions about brine and vapor flow and transport are being tested by comparing measured and simulated results. The combination of experimental data and model results provide additional data to help support the safety case for safe and effective HGNW disposition in bedded salt formations. Initial results from this experiment show that water flow into the borehole is within previous experimental results. Further, we have found that the design of the heater block is restricting energy to flow into the rock salt. Thus, this test has proven useful in design of the next generation experiment where infrared heating may be used to bypass issues caused by air gaps located around the current stainless steel block heater. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Investigations of dual-purpose canister direct disposal feasibility - 15106

Direct disposal of commercial spent nuclear fuel (SNF) in dual-purpose canisters (DPCs) could avoid the cost and complexity of re-packaging spent fuel into smaller purpose-built containers, avoid disposing of the DPC hulls as low-level waste, and potentially decrease worker dose. Technical objectives for disposal are: 1) safety of workers and the public, 2) engineering feasibility; 3) thermal management; and 4) criticality control after permanent closure of a repository. The postclosure safety case for DPC direct disposal would resemble that for any repository-waste isolation would be enhanced by choosing host geology in which radionuclide transport is diffusion dominated, and for which transport properties and pathways are insensitive to the expected temperature history. Containment functions would be assigned to the disposal overpack, and published data show that suitable materials exist for most possible disposal environments. Earlier studies showed that DPC-based waste packages would be only slightly larger and heavier than those proposed for a repository in volcanic tuff. Engineered solutions are available for transporting and emplacing them underground, although some could be the largest of their kind. The cost of DPC direct disposal in various geologic settings has been compared to options involving a change to loading standardized multi-purpose canisters, or continuing to load DPCs and re-packaging all of them for disposal. In general DPC direct disposal would cost tens of billions of dollars less, in packaging and disposal costs. Calculations for emplacement in hard rock and sedimentary rock show that host rock peak temperature targets of 100 to 200 deg.C could be met by managing fuel age and burnup, with repository closure at up to 150 years from reactor discharge. For disposal in salt, DPC-based waste packages could be emplaced at only 50 to 100 years from discharge, depending on burnup. Sedimentary media such as shales pose special challenges especially if they have low thermal conductivity. If backfill is used around DPC-based packages its peak temperature could be 150 to 200 deg.C. Without flooding of waste packages with ground water, criticality can never occur. However, some small number of disposal overpacks could fail within the postclosure performance period due to corrosion or disruptive events. Once flooded, the aluminum-based neutron absorber materials used in most DPCs would readily degrade. Analysis has shown that even without neutron absorbers, virtually all DPCs could be subcritical if flooded with chloride brines such as would occur in a salt repository. The licensing basis for existing DPCs involves criticality analysis that may be conservative compared to fuel that is actually loaded, and the difference provides uncredited reactivity margin. Uncredited margin can offset increases in reactivity associated with flooding and basket degradation. For flooding with fresh water, with loss of neutron absorbers, many DPCs have been shown to be subcritical using uncredited margin. Significantly fewer are subcritical if the fuel basket also degrades. Thus, the materials of DPC basket construction (e.g., aluminum or carbon steel) could be deleterious if they fully corrode, along with the neutron absorbers, during the performance period. Logistical simulations are used to better understand the relationship between the needed DPC decay storage time for disposal, and the timing of future events such as the repository opening date, or a transition to loading multi-purpose (disposable) canisters at nuclear power plants. Results show that the maximum benefit from implementing a new canister design, with respect to shortening the cooling time for all SNF including that in DPCs, is associated with the earliest repository start date. As time passes more of the total SNF inventory will be in DPCs such that the value of a transition to multi-purpose canisters will decline, and the remaining options are DPC direct disposal and re-packaging in purpose-designed disposal canisters. Fuel age at emplacement is of interest to evaluate potential impacts from future changes in the fuel management system that could place fuel age limits on dry storage or transportation. The minimum fuel age at emplacement (best-case) is obtained by re-packaging all DPCs into smaller canisters for disposal, thus drastically decreasing the needed decay storage time for any geologic disposal setting. If the industry transitions to smaller, multi-purpose canisters, and without re-packaging, the fuel age at emplacement would be comparable to the best case if: 1) the emplacement power limit is high enough, or 2) both the transition and the repository start date occur early (e.g., 2036 was analyzed). Technical feasibility evaluation continues to show that direct disposal could be safe and cost effective, for some DPCs and in some geologic settings. Direct disposal of a substantial fraction of existing DPCs, limited mainly by thermal management, uncredited criticality margin, materials of DPC basket construction, and the salinity of ground water in the disposal environment, could be part of the overall waste management system. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Developing a new criticality methodology to support decommissioning of legacy plutonium facilities

To decommission a legacy plutonium finishing facility, a number of gloveboxes need to be disposed of. These gloveboxes have been in place since the 1960's and were operational until the 1980's. A period of initial clean out and decommissioning took place in the 1990's and the first gloveboxes were removed from the line in the early 2000's. Compliance with downstream waste handling facility requirements meant that the gloveboxes needed to be removed using intensive 'hands-on' methods in order to size reduce them to fit into 200 litre (55 gallon) drums. This is the standard approach for handling waste items known as Plutonium Contaminated Material (PCM) on the Sellafield site and was credited in the criticality safety case for the decommissioning of the gloveboxes as it allowed each waste drum to be individually assayed such that the fissile content of the waste could be known. Not only was this approach time-consuming and laborious but as it involved operators working with cutting tools in a highly contaminated area it was challenged as being overly restrictive to operations and potentially hazardous to the workers. In order to decommission the remaining nine gloveboxes in the facility, a new decommissioning approach and associated criticality methodology has been developed. Instead of intensive size reduction and waste drum assay, the gloveboxes will be removed with little or no size reduction and put into storage crates without assay. The criticality assessor will review the operational history of each glovebox, along with the decommissioning records and relevant plant data, to make an evidence-based judgement that the crated glovebox represents no greater a residual criticality risk than would have been realised from the equivalent number of PCM drums that the standard decommissioning approach would have generated. This method identifies, in conjunction with the plant personnel, a number of review points to ensure that before the glovebox is removed any bulk residue material has been recovered and no more than a safe amount of moderating material (fixative) has been added to fix any remaining fissile contamination. Finally, once these review points have been confirmed to be complete - through a stakeholder meeting with criticality safety, plant operators and project managers - the glovebox will be placed in a crate, and this crate will be declared a Low Criticality Risk crate. No formal assay will be required prior to exporting the crate to the downstream waste handling facility and no fissile mass value will be assigned to the contents of the crate. No further intrusive work will be required on the crate and it can be safely stored without any spacing requirements, pending final disposal. (author)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Determining Salinity Recharge Time for Deep Borehole Disposal - 17480

It is generally accepted that the borehole above the disposal zone of a deep borehole disposal must be sealed 'completely' and 'permanently'. By completely it is meant that the seal zone overall must not allow fluids to flow up through it more readily than they could through the surrounding geological barrier. By permanently it is meant that the seal(s) must maintain their function(s) for long enough to satisfy the safety case which could be in excess of 100,000 years. However, designing seals to meet these exacting requirements may be a case of over-engineering because the perturbations in the salinity gradients and density stratification of the groundwater created in and around the borehole during the drilling and operational phases of the borehole would be transient. Darcy flow of groundwater and diffusional flows will re-establish the salinity gradient which is one of the main barriers to the upward flow of fluid through the borehole and surrounding rock, restoring the natural barrier and making the engineered seals redundant. In this paper we address the question of the timescale over which this recharge can be expected to take place. Our methodology involves establishing a mathematical model whose solution gives the time taken for an initial pressure disturbance to reach a steady state and the migration rates of brines resulting from this pressure field. We discuss the model, its assumptions and the solutions, both analytical and numerical. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

An Improved Model For Determining Salinity Recharge Time for Deep Borehole Disposal - 20405

In a previous publication (K. P. Travis, D. Burley and F. G. F. Gibb, WM2017 Conference, Phoenix Arizona paper no. 17480) we introduced a numerical model to estimate the time it would take for a pressure perturbation to subside following its creation from the construction of a deep geological borehole in water-saturated rock. The model was based on the notion of a point source of momentum - a solution of the time-dependent pressure-diffusion equation. Using the model, we estimated that it would take on the order of 10 k years for physical equilibrium to become re-established following the sinking of a 5 km borehole in granite. The significance of such a model is that it places an upper bound on the lifetime required of a borehole sealing system - a necessary input to a borehole post-closure safety case assessment. No engineered sealing system has ever been devised which is capable of retaining its sealing properties for 10 half-lives of long-lived radioisotopes in spent fuel or high-level waste. One of the key advantages of disposing of nuclear waste via Deep Borehole Disposal (DBD) is the natural sealing provided by density stratified groundwater. Upon sinking of a borehole, and subsequent filling with fresh water, brine or drilling mud, this natural barrier may be temporarily damaged. Over time, fresh brine from the far-field will flow towards or away from the hole (driven by a pressure gradient) and will eventually re-establish the original salinity gradient. It follows that the engineered seals need last only as long as the time required for this salinity gradient to reset itself. One of the limitations of our previous model was the use of a static boundary condition on the borehole wall. The model used a boundary pressure which varied quadratically with depth (arising from differences between the pressure of a column of fresh water in the borehole and that of a column of brine in the host rock). However as brine replaces fresh water in the borehole (driven by a pressure gradient), the boundary function must change with time. We now introduce an improved model which takes this time dependent boundary condition into account. The model also takes into account the time taken for a mixture of brine and fresh water to re-establish chemical equilibrium through the process of diffusion. The paper contains the mathematical details of our new iterative model as well as results showing the time taken to reach steady state, and concentration profiles for the components of the brine-filled borehole as a function of time together with a discussion on the implications of the results for developing a post-closure safety assessment for DBD. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

An underground laboratory in the context of salt disposal research - 15549

Evaluating the basis of need for an underground research laboratory for salt science and engineering is imperative because of the significant commitment of time and money involved. Decades of salt repository studies, numerous experiments, and sophisticated modeling capabilities underpin the scientific database that supports safe disposal of nuclear waste in salt. The safety case for disposal of non-heat-generating waste such as transuranic waste interred at the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant is robust, with the only long-term releases to the environment projected to be by way of human intrusion. The scientific evidence also favors safe disposal of heat-generating waste. Technical evaluations for disposal of heat-generating waste in salt experienced a rather long hiatus in the United States subsequent to certification of the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant and issuance of the Nuclear Waste Policy Act Amendment that ended salt disposal research for the civilian program. Similar salt repository research in Germany was delayed by a ten-year moratorium that ended in 2010. In collaboration with German peers, the United States Department of Energy has reviewed and evaluated thermally driven processes in salt disposal and identified key technical areas in which to prioritize resources. The goal for disposal research in salt is to provide sufficient technical information to license a repository successfully. The necessity or utility of a salt underground laboratory is to be evaluated in the context of an overall research agenda that supports a license application. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Understanding the consequences of hypothetical post-closure transient criticality in a geological disposal facility - 14439

Radioactive Waste Management (RWM) is responsible for implementing geological disposal of the UK's higher-activity radioactive wastes. These wastes include significant quantities of fissile nuclides and, therefore, demonstration of criticality safety for the wastes under disposal conditions forms an important component of RWM's disposal system safety case. At the time of disposal all waste packages will be safely sub-critical. Containment provided by the engineered barrier system of a geological disposal facility (GDF) will ensure that criticality is not possible for some time after disposal. However, as waste packages degrade, fissile and other materials may be mobilised, which could affect the potential for criticality. Although the likelihood of a critical configuration developing is demonstrably low, it cannot be assumed to be zero over long post-closure timescales. The UK environment agencies' Guidance on Requirements for Authorisation for a GDF includes a specific requirement to consider the consequences of hypothetical 'what-if' post-closure criticality. RWM has undertaken a programme of research to model and understand the consequences of hypothetical post-closure criticality events. Initially focused on the scenario of fissile material relocation and accumulation following intermediate level waste (ILW) disposal, two bespoke computer models were developed. The quasi-steady-state (QSS) model considered critical systems maintained by accumulation of fissile materials where the temperature feedback remains negative throughout the transient. The rapid transient model (RTM) considered systems with positive temperature feedback. The QSS model development included a successful comparison with the Oklo natural reactors. With a requirement to consider post-closure criticality for a wider range of potential waste types under different illustrative disposal concepts, the initial transient criticality models had some limitations. For the QSS model this was the assumption of fixed geometry, while the complex functional inputs required in the RTM were not readily available for different materials. For the QSS model this paper describes the model development to allow changing volume; this has enabled its application to 'what-if' scenarios of flooding within a spent fuel waste package and the slumping of a stack of ILW packages. For rapid transient criticality this paper explains how the development of a simpler 'bounding approach' model to complement the RTM has enabled transient criticality analysis for a wider range of host materials. The role of this research in demonstrating post-closure criticality safety of a GDF in the UK is presented in a companion paper which also draws on the results of a parallel research project to demonstrate that the likelihood of post-closure criticality is low. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Radiation Mapping at JET and ITER using advanced computational acceleration techniques and tools - Paper 63

The Applied Radiation Physics group at the Culham Centre for Fusion Energy (CCFE) have developed and applied state-of-the-art radiation mapping methods and tools to enable complex shielding calculations in fusion devices during plasma operations, and associated maintenance in the device and surrounding areas. Here, we present the description and application of those tools to produce radiation maps both to support the JET safety case (the EU experimental tokamak device based at Culham) and the planned DT campaign in the next few years; and the ITER device. Radiation mapping of fusion facilities are essential for assessing radiation hardness of electronics during operations, and to define safe working dose limits to staff during routine maintenance. At CCFE the Monte Carlo radiation transport code MCNP6 is one of the codes used to perform radiation transport calculations. Due to the size and complexity of the JET and ITER devices, and their surrounding buildings, a suite of tools have been created at CCFE to reduce the computational requirements of the calculations. This paper describes three of these tools, which have been developed and applied to nuclear and radiological field mapping in fusion devices. The results presented in this paper highlight the application of three methods that have been used to improve the computational efficiency and capabilities for radiation mapping in fusion devices such as JET and ITER. These methods are Global Variance Reduction, the Surface Source Mesh routine and the Smeared Source routine. This paper demonstrates the three techniques used in combination, enabling a very computationally challenging fusion problem to become tractable (with acceptable computing effort), also enabling improved capability to allow the mapping of radiations fields during transport operations for activated materials. (authors)

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Optimising the Performance of the Low Level Waste Repository - 12144

The Low Level Waste Repository (LLWR) is the United Kingdom's principal facility for the disposal of low-level waste (LLW). The LLWR made a major submission to its environmental regulator (the Environment Agency) on 1 May 2011, the LLWR's 2011 Environmental Safety Case (ESC). One of the key regulatory requirements is that all aspects of the construction, operation and closure of the disposal facility should be optimised. An optimised Site Development Plan for the repository was developed and produced as part of the ESC. The Site Development Plan covers all aspects of the construction, operation and closure of the disposal facility. This includes the management of past and future disposals, emplacement strategies, design of the disposal vaults, and the closure engineering for the site. The Site Development Plan also covers the period of active institutional control, when disposals at the site have ceased, but it is still under active management, and plans for the long-term sustainable use of the site. We have a practical approach to optimisation based on recorded judgements and realistic assessments of practicable options framed within the demands of UK policy for LLW management and the characteristics the LLWR site and existing elements of the facility. The final performance assessments undertaken for the ESC were based on the Site Development Plan. The ESC will be used as a tool to inform future decision-making concerning the repository design, operation and the acceptance of wastes, as set out in the evolving Site Development Plan. Maintaining the ESC is thus essential to ensure that the Site Development Plan takes account of an up-to-date understanding and analysis of environmental performance, and that the Plan continues to be optimised. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Used fuel disposition research and development roadmap - FY10 status.

Since 1987 the U.S. has focused research and development activities relevant to the disposal of commercial used nuclear fuel and U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) owned spent nuclear fuel and high level waste on the proposed repository at Yucca Mountain, Nevada. At the same time, the U.S. successfully deployed a deep geologic disposal facility for defense-related transuranic waste in bedded salt at the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant. In 2009 the DOE established the Used Fuel Disposition Campaign (UFDC) within the Office of Nuclear Energy. The Mission of the UFDC is to identify alternatives and conduct scientific research and technology development to enable storage, transportation and disposal of used nuclear fuel and wastes generated by existing and future nuclear fuel cycles. The U.S. national laboratories have participated on these programs and has conducted research and development related to these issues to a limited extent. However, a comprehensive research and development (R&D) program investigating a variety of geologic media has not been a part of the U.S. waste management program since the mid 1980s. Such a comprehensive R&D program is being developed in the UFDC with a goal of meeting the UFDC Grand Challenge to provide a sound technical basis for absolute confidence in the safety and security of long-term storage, transportation, and disposal of used nuclear fuel and wastes from the nuclear energy enterprise. The DOE has decided to no longer pursue the development of a repository at Yucca Mountain, Nevada. Since a repository site will ultimately have to be selected, sited, characterized, designed, and licensed, other disposal options must now be considered. In addition to the unsaturated volcanic tuff evaluated at Yucca Mountain, several different geologic media are under investigation internationally and preliminary assessments indicate that disposal of used nuclear fuel and high level waste in these media is feasible. Considerable progress has been made in the U.S. and other nations in understanding disposal concepts in different geologic media, but gaps in knowledge still exist. A principal aspect of concern to the UFDC as it considers the broad issues of siting a repository in different geologic media are the marked differences in the regulatory bases for assessing suitability and safety of a repository between the U.S. and other nations. Because the probability based - risked informed nature of the current U.S. regulations for high-level radioactive waste and spent nuclear fuel is sufficiently different from other regulations, information gained in previous studies, while useful, likely need to be supplemented to enable more convincing communication with the public, better defense of the numerical models, and stronger safety cases. Thus, it was recognized when the UFDC was established that there were readily identified disposal-related R&D opportunities to address knowledge gaps. An effort to document these research opportunities was a key component of Fiscal Year (FY) 2010 engineered system, natural system, and system-level modeling activities for a range of disposal environments. A principal contribution to identifying these gaps was a workshop held to gather perspectives from experts both within and external to the UFDC regarding R&D opportunities. In the planning for FY2010 it was expected that these activities would culminate with a UFDC research and development roadmap that would identify the knowledge gaps, discuss the R&D needed to fill these gaps, and prioritize the proposed R&D over both the near- and long-term. A number of knowledge gaps and needed R&D were identified and are discussed in this report. However, these preliminary R&D topics have not been evaluated in detail nor have they been prioritized to support future planning efforts. This will be completed in FY11 and the final UFDC Research and Development Roadmap will be completed. This report discusses proposed R&D topics in three areas related to repository siting, design, and performance: natural systems, engineered systems, and overall disposal system. The intent of this report is to consolidate the proposed R&D topics to support subsequent discussions among UFDC and external expertise to identify additional R&D needs and to prioritize these needs, leading to the development for the UFDC Research and Development Roadmap.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

XRD Analysis of Cement Paste Samples Exposed to the Simulated Environment of a Deep Repository - 12239

Portland cement materials are widely used as engineered barriers in repositories for radioactive waste. The capacity of such barriers to avoid the disposed of radionuclides to entering the biosphere in the long-term depends on the service life of those materials. Thus, the performance assessment of structural materials under a series of environmental conditions prevailing at the environs of repositories is a matter of interest. The durability of cement paste foreseen as backfill in a deep borehole for disposal of disused sealed radioactive sources is investigated in the development of the repository concept. Results are intended to be part of the body of evidence in the safety case of the proposed disposal technology. This paper presents the results of X-Ray Diffraction (XRD) Analysis of cement paste exposed to varying temperatures and simulated groundwater after samples received the radiation dose that the cement paste will accumulate until complete decay of the radioactive sources. The XRD analysis of cement paste samples realized in this work allowed observing some differences in the results of cement paste specimens that were submitted to different treatments. The cluster analysis of results was able to group tested samples according to the applied treatments. Mineralogical differences, however, are tenuous and, apart from ettringite, are hardly observed. The absence of ettringite in all the seven specimens that were kept in dry storage at high temperature had hardly occurred by natural variations in the composition of hydrated cement paste because ettringite is observed in all tested except the seven specimens. Therefore this absence is certainly the result of the treatments and could be explained by the decomposition of ettringite. Although the temperature of decomposition is about 110-120 deg. C, it may be initially decomposed to meta-ettringite, an amorphous compound, above 50 deg. C in the absence of water. Influence of irradiation on the mineralogical composition was not observed when the treatment was analyzed individually or when analyzed under the possible synergic effect with other treatments. However, the radiation dose to which specimens were exposed is only a fraction of the accumulated dose in cement paste until complete decay of some sources. Therefore, in the short term, the conditions deemed to prevail in the repository environment may not influence the properties of cement paste at detectable levels. Under the conditions presented in this work, it is not possible to predict the long term evolution of these properties. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Improvements to neutron detection of Pu in solvent for an aqueous buffer tank, magnox reprocessing plant, Sellafield - 14216

The PP Active Feed Tank (PPAFT) is a buffer tank that is not safe by geometry and which is located between the Medium Active (MA) and Plutonium Purification (PP) cycles of the chemical separation process in the Magnox Reprocessing Plant. The PPAFT receives Pu nitrate in acid which has been conditioned ready for the extraction of Pu with TBP/OK (tri-butyl phosphate in kerosene) solvent in the PP Cycle. The criticality safety case for the PPAFT recognises that during both normal operations and potential maloperations solvent which is dissolved (TBP which is present in solution but can be released upon a change in acidity) and entrained (TBP/OK physically carried over but not in solution) will accumulate in the PPAFT. The only practicable route out for Pu in solvent in the PPAFT is the normal process route out from the base of the PPAFT to the PP cycle through intermediate vacuum lift and feed vessels. However, the dished end base of the PPAFT and the intermediate vacuum lift and feed vessels are of particularly challenging geometry. There are five neutron monitors placed around the PPAFT for the detection of Pu in solvent. The original design intent of the neutron detection system was that any single monitor should be able to reveal an accumulation of Pu in solvent before it would potentially be unsafe if fed downstream. However, over time there have been changes to the fuel feed and chemical process of the plant which have had the potential to affect the performance of the neutron monitoring system. The ability of the neutron monitoring system to function to its original intent was questioned. Work has recently been carried out to investigate the capabilities of the PPAFT neutron monitoring system for current plant conditions and to identify potential improvements while making best use of the existing neutron monitors. It was found that moving a neutron monitor from the side to the top of the PPAFT and adding alarms based on the ratio of signals from multiple neutron detectors would be effective in improving detection of Pu in solvent. This paper describes the challenges involved in detecting thin layers of Pu in solvent using neutron monitors, discusses the improvements made to the PPAFT neutron monitors and details the combination of real plant data and modelling with the shielding code MCBEND used to provide confidence in the enhanced neutron monitoring system. (author)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Salt Disposal Investigations to Study Thermally Hot Radioactive Waste In A Deep Geologic Repository in Bedded Rock Salt - 12488

A research program is proposed to investigate the behavior of salt when subjected to thermal loads like those that would be present in a high-level waste repository. This research would build upon results of decades of previous salt repository program efforts in the US and Germany and the successful licensing and operation of a repository in salt for disposal of defense transuranic waste. The proposal includes a combination of laboratory-scale investigations, numerical simulations conducted to develop validated models that could be used for future repository design and safety case development, and a thermal field test in an underground salt formation with a configuration that replicates a small portion of a conceptual repository design. Laboratory tests are proposed to measure salt and brine properties across and beyond the range of possible repository conditions. Coupled numerical models will seek to describe phenomenology (thermal, mechanical, and hydrological) observed in the laboratory tests. Finally, the field test will investigate many phenomena that have been variously cited as potential issues for disposal of thermally hot waste in salt, including buoyancy effects and migration of pre-existing trapped brine up the thermal gradient (including vapor phase migration). These studies are proposed to be coordinated and managed by the Carlsbad Field Office of DOE, which is also responsible for the operation of the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP) within the Office of Environmental Management. The field test portion of the proposed research would be conducted in experimental areas of the WIPP underground, far from disposal operations. It is believed that such tests may be accomplished using the existing infrastructure of the WIPP repository at a lower cost than if such research were conducted at a commercial salt mine at another location. The phased field test is proposed to be performed over almost a decade, including instrumentation development, several years of measurements during heating and then subsequent cooling periods, and the eventual forensic mining back of the test bed to determine the multi-year behavior of the simulated waste/rock environment. Funding possibilities are described, and prospects for near term start-up are discussed. Mining of the access drifts required to create the test area in the WIPP underground began in November 2011. Because this mining uses existing WIPP infrastructure and labor, it is estimated to take about two years to complete the access drifts. WIPP disposal operations and facility maintenance activities will take priority over the SDI field test area mining. Funding of the SDI proposal was still being considered by DOE's Offices of Environmental Management and Nuclear Energy at the time this paper was written, so no specific estimates of the progress in 2012 have been included. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Characterization of modeling and experimental data inconsistencies from burst testing for high-burnup commercial fuel rod applications

Fuel fragmentation, relocation, and dispersal are some of the largest issues remaining in the nuclear industry before rod-average burnup can be increased beyond 62 GWd/tU. The issue is primarily related to the potential for fuel to be dispersed into the reactor primary system, which may increase public risk. One way to prevent dispersal is to avoid cladding burst. The objective of this work is to support the high burnup safety case by evaluating cladding burst under high-burnup, full-length fuel rods and to identify uncertainties that could improve model predictions. The results of this analysis will evaluate realistic, prototypic loss-of-coolant accident (LOCA) conditions; support future cladding burst test designs; and inform the development of mechanistic material models. Realistic high-burnup operating conditions were implemented in the BISON fuel performance code to simulate steady-state and LOCA transient fuel rod evolution to the point at which cladding burst occurred. Parametric studies are performed to assess code response to changes in rod internal pressures and heating rates. Results were compared with simulated LOCA experiments to identify inconsistencies between commercial fuel rod analysis and experimental validation. The representative full-length fuel rod LOCA simulation results did not agree with cladding burst tests. Cladding burst tests indicated burst occurring well below (100–150 °C) those calculated in the full-length fuel rod LOCA analysis. Further investigation indicated that the cladding burst tests do not appear to be representative for full-length fuel rods. The inconsistency investigated in this work showed that the differences between the BISON simulation and the experiment's cladding burst conditions arise from an incomplete characterization of the cladding surface temperature, detailed rodlet characterization, lack of cladding strain measurements, and uncertainty in the cladding creep and failure models.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Radiation damage effects in chlorite investigated using microfocus synchrotron techniques

A detailed understanding of the mechanisms and effects of radiation damage in phyllosilicate minerals is a necessary component of the evaluation of the safety case for a deep geological disposal facility (GDF) for radioactive waste. Structural and chemical changes induced by a-particle damage will affect these mineral’s performance as a reactive barrier material (both in the near and far-field) over timescales relevant to GDF integrity. In this study, two examples of chlorite group minerals have been irradiated at a-particle doses comparable to those predicted to be experienced by the clay buffer material surrounding high level radioactive waste canisters. Crystallographic aberrations induced by the focused 4He2+ ion beam are revealed via high-resolution, microfocus X-ray diffraction mapping. Interlayer collapse by up to 0.5 Å is prevalent across both macro- and micro-crystalline samples, with the macro-crystalline specimen displaying a breakdown of the phyllosilicate structure into loosely-connected, multi-oriented crystallites displaying variable lattice parameters. The damaged lattice parameters suggest a localised breakdown and collapse of the OH- rich, ‘brucite-like’ interlayer. Microfocus Fe K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy illustrates this defect accumulation, manifest as a severe damping of the X-ray absorption edge. Subtle Fe2+/Fe3+ speciation changes are apparent across the damaged structures. A trend towards Fe reduction is evident at depth in the damaged structures at certain doses (8.76 x 1015 alpha particles/ cm2). Interestingly, this reductive trend does not increase with radiation dose, indeed at the maximum dose (1.26 x 1016 alpha particles/ cm2) administered in this study, there is evidence for a slight increase in Fe binding energy, suggesting the development of a depth-dependant redox gradient concurrent with light ion damage. At the doses examined here, these damaged structures are likely highly reactive, as sorption capacity will, to an extent, be largely enhanced by lattice disruption and an increase in available ‘edge’ sites.

Bower, William R.↗