Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Phase transformations”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,801 records · Page 100
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

On-chip pulse shaping of entangled photons

The miniaturization of optical systems via integrated photonics is critical to the ultimate scalability and performance of photonic quantum processors, yet many longstanding optical signal processing capabilities—such as Fourier-transform pulse shaping—remain unrealized on chip. In this work, we demonstrate on-chip spectral shaping of entangled photons using a multichannel microring-resonator-based silicon photonic pulse shaper. Achieving line-by-line phase control on a 3 GHz grid for two frequency-bin-entangled qudits, the pulse shaper's fine spectral resolution enables control of nanosecond-scale temporal features, which are observed by direct coincidence detection of biphoton correlation functions that show excellent agreement with theory. This work marks a demonstration of biphoton pulse shaping using an integrated spectral shaper and holds significant promise for applications in photonic quantum information processing.

Entanglement manipulation↗
DOE OSTI2020

Implementing Admittance Relaying for Microgrid Protection

An earlier study evaluated issues with microgrid protection. This highlighted the difficulties with microgrid protection, which include: 1. lack of fault current from inverter-interfaced generation, 2. varying fault current between grid-connected and islanded modes, 3. potential for normally-meshed operation and 4. unbalanced operation due to single-phase loads. It is worth noting that not all microgrid designs will include all these challenges. For example, microgrids could choose to omit meshed operation. Previous work identified differential protection based on the discrete S-transform for line protection and admittance protection for load protection as possible solutions . However, some severe limitations were identified. This included the potential for blinding of the discrete S-transform protection when fault contribution on either end of the line is similar, and loss of protection selectivity for admittance protection in the case of upstream line-ground faults. This report investigates admittance protection as a solution for line and load protection in greater detail by comparing analytical and simulated results. Section 2 describes the protection schemes analyzed and the behavior of inverter-interfaced microgrids under faults in more detail. Section 3 derives sequence networks for the fault cases considered. Section 4 presents a transient model constructed to validate the impedances calculated from the sequence networks. Section 5 compares the results from the sequence networks and transient model. Last, Section 6 presents the conclusions of this study in terms of the suitability of admittance relaying for protection of inverter-interfaced microgrids.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗
DOE OSTI2022

Non-Powered Dam Retrofit Exemplary Design for Hydropower Applications

Non-powered dams (NPDs) represent complex systems, situated at the intersection of natural stream environments and the built environment. The presence and operations of NPDs affect stream constituents (e.g., fish, recreational craft, sediment, water) and serve one or more engineered purposes (e.g., recreation, flood control, water supply, irrigation, tailings and debris control, navigation). By definition, NPDs do not provide hydropower generation. However, every NPD contains some untapped hydropower resource potential, represented by the pre-existing hydraulic head created by the dam and presence of flowing water. Adding power generation to an NPD requires retrofitting the NPD, which could involve the addition of any new component or function beyond that currently installed. Because this research is funded by the US Department of Energy Water Power Technologies Office, adding hydropower to NPDs is among the primary objectives for research investment. However, NPD retrofitting extends beyond the purview of hydropower additions. This report provides background information regarding NPD development in the United States, including an overview of the US NPD population, development potential, and recent development. It also summarizes challenges and opportunities facing NPD retrofit development, highlights the importance of maintaining or improving stream and dam functionality, notes key NPD characteristics, describes NPD retrofit methods, and identifies innovation areas for spurring future NPD retrofit development. Section 4 describes retrofit exemplary design principles and concepts that could apply to a wide range of NPD projects. These principles and concepts inform an NPD Retrofit Exemplary Design Specification (REDS), as included in Appendix A. The NPD REDS is heavily influenced by prior work under the standard modular hydropower technology acceleration research initiative, especially the work documented in the Exemplary Design Envelope Specification for Standard Modular Hydropower Technology (Witt et al., 2017). Whereas this prior work focuses on a particular technology class that applies most intentionally for new stream-reach development (i.e., greenfield sites), the NPD REDS contained herein applies more broadly to the NPD resource class and is technology-agnostic (i.e., the specific technologies intended to be described are not explicitly prescribed). This report serves as a part of early-phase research on NPD retrofit development, aimed toward spurring additional, follow-on efforts to specifically address development challenges, capitalize on development opportunities, and inspire innovation. As documented in the landmark “Hydropower Vision” report (DOE 2016), “transformative technical innovations able to meet the co-objectives of environmental sustainability and low-carbon energy will be critical to enabling additional hydropower growth.” This report serves as an important step in steering transformation of US non-powered dam infrastructure.

13 HYDRO ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2022

Aqueous spray-drying synthesis of alluaudite Na 2+2x Fe 2–x (SO 4 ) 3 sodium insertion material: studies of electrochemical activity, thermodynamic stability, and humidity-induced phase transition

In pursuit of high-energy density sodium insertion materials, polyanionic frameworks can be designed with tuneable high-voltage operation stemming from inductive effect. Alluaudite Na 2 Fe 2 (SO 4 ) 3 polysulfate forms one such earth-abundant compound registering the highest Fe 3+ /Fe 2+ redox potential (ca. 3.8 V vs. Na/Na + ). While this SO 4 -based system exhibits high voltage operation, it is prone to thermal decomposition and moisture attack leading to hydrated derivatives, making its synthesis cumbersome. Also, the Na–Fe–S–O quaternary system is rich with (anhydrous to hydrated) phase transitions. Herein, we demonstrate scalable aqueous-based spray drying synthesis of alluaudite Na 2+2x Fe 2–x (SO 4 ) 3 sodium insertion material involving the formation of bloedite Na 2 Fe(SO 4 ) 2 ·4H 2 O as an intermediate phase. Moreover, a reversible phase transition from alluaudite to bloedite under controlled conditions of temperature and relative humidity is reported for the first time. Thermochemistry measurements revealed the enthalpies of formation (ΔH° f ) of alluaudite and bloedite are exothermic. Hydrated bloedite (ΔH° f = –117.16 ± 1.10 kJ/mol) was found to be significantly more energetically stable than anhydrous alluaudite (ΔH° f = –11.76 ± 1.25 kJ/mol). The calorimetric data support the observed synthesis and transformation (hydration-dehydration) pathways. Spray drying route led to spherical morphology delivering capacity ~80 mAh/g. Spray drying can be extended for rapid economic synthesis of sulfate class of battery materials.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Bulk Glassy GeTe 2 : A Missing Member of the Tetrahedral GeX 2 Family and a Precursor for the Next Generation of Phase-Change Materials

Vitreous germanium disulfide GeS 2 and diselenide GeSe 2 belong to canonical chalcogenide glasses extensively studied over the past half century. Their high-temperature orthorhombic polymorphs are congruently melting compounds, and the tetrahedral crystal and glass structure is largely preserved in the melt. In contrast, the ditelluride counterpart is absent in the Ge-Te phase diagram, which shows only a single compound, monotelluride GeTe. Phase-change materials based on GeTe have become a technologically important class of solids, and their structure and properties are also widely studied. Surprisingly, very scarce information is available for alloys having GeTe 2 stoichiometry. Using a fast quenching procedure in silica capillaries, high-energy X-ray diffraction, and Raman spectroscopy supported by first-principles simulations, we show that bulk glassy GeTe 2 differs substantially from the lighter GeX 2 members, revealing 46% of trigonal germanium, 31% of three-fold coordinated tellurium, and only 20% of edge-sharing tetrahedra or pyramids. The fraction of homopolar Ge-Ge bonds is low; however, the population of dominant Te-Te dimers and Te n oligomers, n <= 10, appears to be significant. The complex structural and chemical topology of g-GeTe 2 is directly related to the thermodynamic metastability of germanium ditelluride, schematically represented by the following reaction: GeTe 2 $\rightleftarrows$ GeTe + Te. Disproportionation is complete above liquidus in the temperature range of semiconductor-metal transition, and the dense metallic GeTe 2 liquid, mostly consisting of five-fold coordinated Ge species, exhibits high fluidity, strong fragility (m = 99 ± 5), and presumably a fast structural transformation rate combined with low atomic mobility in the vicinity of the glass transition temperature, favorable for reliable long-term data retention in nonvolatile memories. The observed and predicted characteristic features make GeTe 2 a promising precursor for the next generation of phase-change materials, especially coupled with additional metal doping, depolymerizing the tetrahedral interconnected glass network and accelerating (sub)nanosecond crystallization.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Multiple freezing–melting pathways of high-density ice through ice XXI phase at room temperature

Various metastable ice phases and their complicated transition pathways have been found by pressurization at low temperatures at which slow kinetics and high metastability are easily achieved. By contrast, such diversity is less expected at room or elevated temperatures. Here, using a combination of a dynamic diamond anvil cell and X-ray free electron laser techniques, we demonstrate that supercompressed water transforms into ice VI through multiple freezing–melting pathways at room temperature, hidden within the pressure region of ice VI. These multiple transition pathways occur via a metastable ice (more specifically, ice XXI with body-centred tetragonal structure ($I\bar{4}2d$)) discovered in this study and a metastable ice VII that exists within the pressure range of ice VI. We find that supercompressed water structurally evolves from high-density water to very-high-density water, causing multiple transition pathways. These findings provide an insight to find more metastable ice phases and their transition pathways at elevated temperatures.

Lee, Yun-Hee [Korea Research Institute of Standard↗
DOE OSTI2022

Metal Site Substitution and Role of the Dimer on Symmetry Breaking in FePS 3 and CrPS 4 under Pressure

We combine infrared absorption, Raman scattering, and diamond anvil cell techniques to explore the properties of FePS 3 and CrPS 4 under pressure, comparing our findings with a symmetry analysis, lattice dynamics calculations, and an examination of the energy landscape. Although these complex chalcogenides are considered to be members of the same family of materials, they display remarkably different phase progressions on account of the metal center orbital filling, character of the P–P linkage, layer corrugation, and differing size of the van der Waals gap. Here, we discuss the space group progressions, structure–property relations, and development of pressure-induced metallicity in terms of the competition between local and long-range symmetry transformations and structural distortion pathways. These findings place the properties of FePS 3 and CrPS 4 on a firm foundation for work under strain control and in the single layer limit.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Generative Physics-Informed Neural Network Solving Multi-Scale and Multi-Phase Plasma Chemical Flow Field

Low-temperature plasmas (LTPs) are non-equilibrium systems with near-room-temperature gas and highly energetic electrons. This makes them ideal for delicate applications in biomedicine and semiconductor manufacturing, enabling processes like wound healing, sterilization, etching, and plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition without thermal damage. However, LTPs involve complex chemistries, with hundreds of species and thousands of reactions, complicating their diagnosis, prediction, and control. Conventional diagnostics, such as Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), laser-induced fluorescence (LIF), and optical emission spectroscopy (OES), offer limited species detection, while mass spectrometry (MS) struggles with low-sensitivity species. Additionally, LTP simulations face multi-scale challenges, as macroscopic fluid dynamics and microscopic particle collisions operate on vastly different timescales. To address these issues, we developed an artificial intelligence (AI) based diagnostic system: a generative physics-informed neural network (PINN-Gen) that can predict spatially resolved species concentrations and temperatures in LTPs by integrating experimental data from planar LIF with microscopic plasma chemical kinetics and macroscopic fluid mechanics, including plasma-liquid interactions at the interface between two phases. PINN-Gen solves no equations but checks the errors of physical laws by substituting the output from neural network, and the comparison with the experimental results. Thus, it naturally avoids the multi-scale difficulty of numerical simulations and predicts the results of conventionally unsolvable multi-scale and multi-phase problems. The real-time prediction will be robust due to the physical information used in the training of such a neural network, and only very limited input of condition required due to its generative feature.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗
DOE OSTI2020

Design, Synthesis, and Characterization of Polymer Precursors to Li x PON and Li x SiPON Glasses: Materials That Enable All-Solid-State Batteries (ASBs)

LiPON-like glasses that form lithium dendrite impenetrable interfaces between lithium battery components are enabling materials that may replace liquid electrolytes permitting production of all-solid-state batteries (ASBs). Unfortunately, to date, such materials are introduced only via gas-phase deposition. Furthermore, we demonstrate the design and synthesis of easily scaled, lowtemperature, low-cost, solution-processable inorganic polymers containing LiPON/LiSiPON elements. OPCl 3 and hexachlorophosphazene [Cl 2 P=N] 3 provide starting points for elaboration using MNH 2 (M = Li/Na) or (Me 3 Si)NH followed by reaction with controlled amounts of LiNH 2 to produce oligomers/polymers with molecular weights (MWs) ≈1–2 kDa characterized by multinuclear NMR, gel permeation chromatography (GPC), thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR), X-ray powder diffraction (XRD), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ ionization (MALDI)-time-of-flight (ToF) offering stabilities to 150–200 °C and ceramic yields (800 °C) of 50–60%. 7 Li NMR suggests that precursor-bound Li + dissociates easily, beneficial for electrochemical applications. XPS shows higher N/P ratios (1–3) than via gas-phase methods (<1) correlating N/P ratios, 7 Li shifts, and Li + conductivities. Li 2 SiPHN offers the highest ambient conductivity of 3 × 10 –1 mS cm –1 at 400 °C/2 h/N 2 .

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Vapor-phase grafting of a model aminosilane compound to Al 2 O 3 , ZnO, and TiO 2 surfaces prepared by atomic layer deposition

Atomic layer deposition (ALD) is a highly versatile surface functionalization technique that can conformally coat both planar and porous substrates. Here we use ALD metal oxide layers to establish a well-defined starting surface for vapor-phase surface organic modification. Vapor-phase (3-aminopropyl)triethoxysilane (APTES) surface silanization of ALD Al 2 O 3 , ZnO and TiO 2 surfaces were studied at 100 °C, 150 °C and 200 °C. In situ quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) and Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy measurements, and ex situ atomic force microscopy (AFM) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) measurements showed uniform monolayer silane formation through self-limiting APTES reaction. We observed a higher surface density of grafted APTES species following silanization at 100 °C compared to 200 °C, and we attribute this to the temperature-dependent reactivity of the surface hydroxyls and changes in the mode of APTES reaction. The FTIR and XPS measurements revealed that APTES reacts with Al 2 O 3 and ZnO exclusively through metal siloxy bond formation. However, APTES reacts with TiO 2 through both siloxy bond formation and ammonium salt formation via the amine group.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Exploring structural transitions at grain boundaries in Nb using a generalized embedded atom interatomic potential

The advancement in experimental techniques, like the atom probe tomography and high resolution electron microscopy, is fueling interest in studying structural transformations of grain boundaries in metal and alloys to uncover correlations between mechanical properties and solute or impurity segregation to grain boundaries. Atomistic modeling is an important tool that can pinpoint the intricate dynamics of grain boundary phase transitions, but the lack of accurate interatomic potentials needed to simulate the complex dynamics of grain boundary structural transitions and identify different metastable phases has been the bottleneck. To this end, we use niobium as a model body centered cubic (BCC) metal and develop an interatomic potential to study grain boundary phase transitions. The potential for Nb is based on a generalization of the embedded atomic method potential and has sufficient flexibility to learn complex energy landscapes using a small set of training structures. We systematically test and validate the using data from ab initio density functional theory calculations and experiments. Using this potential, we calculate energies of multiple symmetric-tilt grain boundaries spanning a wide range of misorientation angles. Additionally, we explore different metastable structures of the Σ 27(552) [$1\overline{1}0$] grain boundary and use molecular dynamic simulations to study the coexistence of metastable phases and grain boundary transitions at finite temperature.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Capturing Ring Opening in Photoexcited Enolic Acetylacetone upon Hydrogen Bond Dissociation by Ultrafast Electron Diffraction

Photoinduced biological and chemical reactions are often based on key structural transformations of a molecule driven across multiple electronic states. Acetylacetone (AcAc) is a prototypical system for complex chemical pathways involving several conical intersections (CI) and singlet–triplet intersystem crossings (ISC) characterized by distinct geometries. In the gas phase, AcAc is predominantly in a planar ring-like enolic form stabilized by a strong intramolecular O–H···O hydrogen bond. Following excitation into the S 2 (ππ*) state at 266 nm, acetylacetone undergoes rapid internal conversion followed by intersystem crossing. Such relaxation pathways are associated with structural changes including ring opening, deplanarization, and bond elongation. In this work, ultrafast electron diffraction (UED) at the SLAC MeV-UED setup is employed as a direct structural probe with a time resolution of 160 fs. Together with trajectory surface hopping simulations, analysis of the UED data provides a new perspective on the early time nuclear dynamics in acetylacetone. Specifically, AcAc is observed to undergo ring opening, deplanarization, and bond elongation all within the first 700 fs after photoexcitation. The monitored dynamics is associated mainly with the nuclear motion on the S 1 potential energy surface, formed after very rapid transfer from S 2 to S 1 , allowing AcAc to reach the conical intersection to intersystem crossing. Such time scales of nuclear motion are contrasted with the time scales of electronic transitions in AcAc that were previously characterized with spectroscopic methods, specifically internal conversion (<100 fs) and intersystem crossing (∼1.5 ps).

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Time-resolved Brownian tomography of single nanocrystals in liquid during oxidative etching

Colloidal nanocrystals inherently undergo structural changes during chemical reactions. The robust structure-property relationships, originating from their nanoscale dimensions, underscore the significance of comprehending the dynamic structural behavior of nanocrystals in reactive chemical media. Moreover, the complexity and heterogeneity inherent in their atomic structures require tracking of structural transitions in individual nanocrystals at three-dimensional (3D) atomic resolution. In this study, we introduce the method of time-resolved Brownian tomography to investigate the temporal evolution of the 3D atomic structures of individual nanocrystals in solution. The methodology is applied to examine the atomic-level structural transformations of Pt nanocrystals during oxidative etching. The time-resolved 3D atomic maps reveal the structural evolution of dissolving Pt nanocrystals, transitioning from a crystalline to a disordered structure. Our study demonstrates the emergence of a phase at the nanometer length scale that has received less attention in bulk thermodynamics.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Prediction of an alternative high-pressure route to polymeric carbon dioxide as a metastable energetic material

The use of pressure to obtain new materials that can be recovered under ambient conditions is a central problem in high-pressure physics. Despite decades of research, this goal has only been achieved in the laboratory for a few notable examples, such as diamond and cubic boron nitride. An area of significant interest is the transformation under compression of light-element molecular compounds to extended covalent-bonded (polymeric) solids. Among them, CO 2 has been extensively studied because of its status as a prototypical simple molecular system with a rich phase diagram and due to its fundamental role in Earth’s physics and chemistry. One of its polymeric crystalline phases, accessible at extreme pressures and temperatures, has been recently quenched to ambient pressure, but below room temperature. Here we report ab initio calculations predicting that isothermal compression of a carbon monoxide and oxygen mixture (CO+O 2 ), rather than the compound CO 2 , lowers the onset of C-polymerization at room temperature from ~ 118 GPa to ~ 7 GPa (complete by ~ 23 GPa). Moreover, it leads to the formation of an intrinsically different polymer with enhanced metastability. We predict that this dense phase is an energetic material which can potentially be recovered to ambient pressure and temperature.

Paul, Reetam [Lawrence Livermore National Laborato↗
DOE OSTI2023

Measurement of 2D density profiles using a second-harmonic, dispersion interferometer

A second-harmonic, dispersion interferometer is used to image large-area (≃5 cm 2 ) plasma-jet and gas-jet density profiles. Achromatic telescopes magnify the diameters of the primary-laser beam (1064 nm) and its second-harmonic (532 nm) before probing the sample and de-magnify the beam diameters after the sample, where the primary beam transfers its phase change to a second, second-harmonic beam, allowing the sample’s dispersive-phase change to be measured between two, orthogonally polarized second harmonic beams. The telescopes produce an azimuthally symmetric, dispersive-phase shift in the sample + background phase-change image and in the background phase-change image, which is removed by digital subtraction. The interferometer’s performance was verified using standard-optical components as dispersive elements (BK7 lenses and wedge plates), resolving a minimum, phase-change sensitivity of ΔΦ min ≳ 15 mrad and spatial resolution of Δx res ≃ 100 μm. The phase change produced by unknown-density objects (a pulsed-plasma-jet and a pulsed-gas-jet) was measured, and their data were used to recover the original, 2D density profiles using an inverse Abel transform: peak-number density, N gas ≃ 6 × 10 20 cm –3 and N e ≃ 5 × 10 16 cm –3 ; line-integrated density, ∫N gas dl ~ 2 × 10 19 cm –2 and ∫N e dl ~ 1 × 10 16 cm –2 . The techniques and methods developed here are scalable to even larger probe-beam diameters and frame-capture rates, leading to a diagnostic capability that is well-suited for applications involving the real-time measurement of density.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2020

Dynamic Observation of Dendritic Quasicrystal Growth upon Laser-Induced Solid-State Transformation

In this paper, we report the laser-induced solid-state transformation between a periodic “approximant” and quasicrystal in the Al-Cr system during rapid quenching. Dynamic transmission electron microscopy allows us to capture in situ the dendritic growth of the metastable quasicrystals. The formation of dendrites during solid-state transformation is a rare phenomenon, which we attribute to the structural similarity between the two intermetallics. Through ab initio molecular dynamics simulations, we identify the dominant structural motif to be a 13-atom icosahedral cluster transcending the phases of matter.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Unusual Quasiparticles and Tunneling Conductance in Quantum Point Contacts in 𝜈 = 2/3 Fractional Quantum Hall Systems

Understanding topological matter in the fractional quantum Hall (FQH) effect requires identifying the nature of edge state quasiparticles. FQH edge state at the filling factor 𝜈 = 2/3 in the spin-polarized and unpolarized phases is represented by the two modes of composite fermions (CF) with the parallel or opposite spins described by the chiral Luttinger liquids. Tunneling through a quantum point contact (QPC) between different or similar spin phases is solved exactly. With the increase of the applied voltage, the QPC conductance grows from zero and saturates at 𝑒 2 /2⁢ℎ while a weak electron tunneling between the edge modes with the same spin transforms into a backscattering carried by the charge 𝑞 = 𝑒/2 quasiparticles. These unusual quasiparticles and conductance plateau emerge when one or two CF spin-polarized modes in the QPC tunnel into a single mode. Here, we propose experiments on the applied voltage and temperature dependence of the QPC conductance and noise that can shed light on the nature of edge states and FQH transport.

Anyons↗
DOE OSTI2025

On two nucleons near unitarity with perturbative pions

We explore the impact of perturbative pions on the Unitarity Expansion in the two-nucleon S-waves of Chiral Effective Field Theory at next-to-next-to leading order (N 2 LO). Pion exchange explicitly breaks the nontrivial fixed point’s universality, i.e. invariance of S waves under both conformal and Wigner’s combined SU(4) spin–isospin transformations. On the other hand, Unitarity explicitly breaks chiral symmetry. The two seem incompatible in their respective exact-symmetry limits. χEFT with Perturbative Pions in the Unitarity Expansion resolves the apparent conflict in the Unitarity Window (phase shifts 45° ≲ δ(k) ≲ 135°), i.e. around momenta most relevant for low-energy nuclear systems. Its only LO scale is the scattering momentum; NLO adds only scattering length, effective range and non-iterated one-pion exchange (OPE); and N 2 LO only once-iterated OPE. Agreement in the 1 S 0 channel is very good.

Chiral symmetry↗

Refine your search to explore more results.