The " Swarm of Ants vs. Herd of Elephants" Debated Revisited: Performance Measurements of PVM-Overflow Across a Wide Spectrum of Architectures
The Gorden Bell Prizes given out at Supercomputing every year includes at least two catergories: performance (highest GFLOP count) and price-performance (GFLOP/million $$) for real applications. In the past five years, the winners of the price-performance categories all came from networks of work-stations. This reflects three important facts: 1. supercomputers are still too expensive for the masses; 2. achieving high performance for real applications takes real work; and, most importantly; 3. it is possible to obtain acceptable performance for certain real applications on network of work stations. With the continued advance of network technology as well as increased performance of "desktop" workstation, the "Swarm of Ants vs. Herd of Elephants" debate, which began with vector multiprocessors (VPPs) against SIMD type multiprocessors (e.g. CM2), is now recast as VPPs against Symetric Multiprocessors (SMPs, e.g. SGI PowerChallenge). This paper reports on performance studies we performed solving a large scale (2-million grid pt.s) CFD problem involving a Boeing 747 based on a parallel version of OVERFLOW that utilizes message passing on PVM. A performance monitoring tool developed under NASA HPCC, called AIMS, was used to instrument and analyze the the performance data thus obtained. We plan to compare its performance data obtained across a wide spectrum of architectures including: the Cray C90, IBM/SP2, SGI/Power Challenge Cluster, to a group of workstations connected over a simple network. The metrics of comparison includes speed-up, price-performance, throughput, and turn-around time. We also plan to present a plan of attack for various issues that will make the execution of Grand Challenge Applications across the Global Information Infrastructure a reality.