Appendix N: Peer Review Response Tracking
A sample peer review tracking document, identifying action items, relevant reviewer comments, action owners, and progress to date.
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
A sample peer review tracking document, identifying action items, relevant reviewer comments, action owners, and progress to date.
A peer review sample summary rating sheet, from the September 2002 The Peer Review Process Handbook, an Implementation Manual based on the Superconductivity Program Experience.
This peer review nondisclosure agreement should be signed by each reviewer prior to the program sending review materials if sensitive or proprietary information will be provided reviewers or discussed during the review, and to everyone attending a review.
This is a sample PEER Review Evaluation Form to be completed by reviewers after presentations and before leaving the review site.
The Baseline Case projection used to evaluate the impact of the EERE portfolio was benchmarked to the Energy Information Administration’s (EIA) 2003 Annual Energy Outlook (AEO) for the period between 2000 and 2025. To the extent possible, the same input data and assumptions were used in MARKAL (market allocation model) as were used to generate the AEO reference case. For example, the macroeconomic projections for gross domestic product (GDP), housing stock, commercial square footage, industrial output, and vehicle miles traveled (VMTs) were taken from the AEO. At the sector level, both supply-side and demand-side technologies were characterized to reflect the AEO assumptions, in cases where the representation of technologies is similar between MARKAL and the National Energy Modeling System (NEMS). The resulting projections track closely with the AEO at the aggregate level, although they do not match exactly at the end-use level. For the period after 2025, various sources were drawn upon to compile a set of economic and technical assumptions. The primary economic drivers of GDP and population were based on the real GDP growth rate from the Congressional Budget Office’s Long-Term Budget Outlook and population growth rates from the Social Security Administration’s 2002 Annual Report to the Board of Trustees.
The GPRA FY04 published documentation for Building Technologies and the Weatherization and Intergovernmental Program can be found at this link: http://www.pnl.gov/main/publications/external/technical_reports/PNNL-14231.pdf The Federal Energy Management Program (FEMP) metrics are estimated via a top-down approach, which are driven by forecasts of future energy consumption and prices. Federal metrics for regular buildings are aggregated from metrics developed for the Department of Defense (DOD), Department of Energy (DOE), General Services Administration (GSA), United States Postal Service (USPS), Veterans Affairs (VA), and all other agencies grouped together. Federal metrics for buildings housing energy intensive operations are estimated separately, but as a single group for the entire federal government. Metrics are not developed for exempt buildings, by definition.
Because the time horizon of the Annual Energy Outlook 2003 Reference Case (AEO-3 case) version of the National Energy Modeling System (NEMS) is 2025, and the goals of Distributed Energy (DE) programs are relatively short-term, the approach taken in this GPRA cycle is that most of the outputs are captured before that date. However, DE programs are part of a wider effort to transform the power system from its current highly centralized form to a more robust decentralized paradigm, a transformation with a longer time horizon than NEMS-GPRA provides. Distributed generation (DG) appears in multiple modules (roughly corresponding to subsectors of the full energy sector, i.e. utility, commercial, etc.), which hinders the DE program’s use of NEMS-GPRA. Further, only a limited number of technology slots are typically available to represent a broad array of equipment types, sizes, and configurations. For example, the reciprocating engines in the commercial sector all have combined heat and power (CHP) heating (but not cooling) capability, while those in the utility sector do not—in some instances, engines without CHP might be attractive in the commercial sector and vice-versa. Proper representation of DE program goals includes an accurate representation of DE’s technology-advancement targets, as well as an accounting for the limitations in the structure of NEMS, which can hinder estimation of the benefits that can be realized from DG technologies. Therefore, in addition to changing input assumptions relative to the AEO-3 version of NEMS, other fixes to perceived limitations or omissions are also appropriate in both the base and program cases.
The primary goal of the Geothermal Technologies Program is to reduce the cost of geothermal generation technologies, including both conventional and enhanced geothermal systems (EGS). Estimating the GPRA benefits involves projecting the market share for these technologies based on their economic and environmental characteristics.
The information provided in this report is based on the Industrial Technologies Program (ITP) report of the GPRA05 process, “GPRA05 Quality Metrics – Methodology and Results,” Energetics, Inc., March 11, 2004. The report includes additional methodological details and the actual off-line energy savings results submitted to the Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE).
Several changes from the Annual Energy Outlook 2003 (AEO2003) Reference Case were incorporated into the GPRA05 Baseline, in consultation with the Solar Energy Technologies Program.
Light-vehicle (LV) attributes were based on the FreedomCAR and Vehicle Technologies (FCVT) program goals, discussions with FCVT program managers, and technical analysis by contractors (Ref. 1). They were also based on a review of past GPRA characterizations (e.g., attributes included in the 2003 GPRA transportation methodology report that can be found on the EERE Web site (Ref. 2). Because the two models (NEMS-GPRA05 and MARKAL-GPRA05) that generate GPRA results require different levels of detail, the technical characterizations were provided in two parts: one for input to NEMS-GPRA05 and one for input to MARKALGPRA05. The discussion of the LV characterization is, thus, divided into two parts below.
The State Energy Program provides financial assistance to States, enabling State governments to target their own high priority energy needs and expand clean energy choices for their residents and businesses. With these funds and the resources leveraged by them, the State and Territory Energy Offices develop and manage a variety of programs geared to increase energy efficiency, reduce energy use and costs, develop alternative energy and renewable energy sources, promote environmentally conscious economic development, and reduce reliance on oil produced outside of the United States.
The wind energy component of the Wind and Hydropower Technologies Program seeks to reduce the cost and improve the performance of wind technology, and to reduce barriers to its use. The GPRA benefits are based primarily on model projections of the market share for wind technologies, based on their economic characteristics. This document describes the assumptions that are used by the models to calculate those benefits.
The Green Power Market Model (GPMM or the model) identifies and analyzes the potential electric-generating capacity additions that will result from “green power” programs, which are not captured in the “least-cost” analyses performed by the National Energy Modeling System (NEMS). The model projects green power-capacity additions through both green power marketing programs in deregulated markets, and utility green pricing programs in regulated markets.
The Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE) programs use integrated energy models to analyze the benefits expected from successful implementation of individual programs and the EERE portfolio as a whole. The use of integrated models provides a consistent economic framework and incorporates the interactive effects among the various programs. Feedback and interactive effects result from (1) changes in energy prices resulting from lower energy consumption, (2) the interaction between supply programs affecting the mix of generation sources and the end-use sector programs affecting the demand for electricity, and (3) additional savings from reduced energy production and delivery.
This document summarizes the results of the benefits analysis of EERE’s programs, as described in the FY 2007 Budget Request.
This document summarizes the results of the benefits analysis of EERE’s programs, as described in the FY 2007 Budget Request.