Selection Effect in Dark Energy Survey Y1

Abstract

The discovery that the Universe expansion is accelerated poses one of the most profound mysteries in physics. Cosmic acceleration could be a sign of the fact that General Relativity breaks down on cosmological scales and has to be replaced, or it could arise from an unknown form of energy that currently dominates our Universe. That is what we call dark energy and in this case the problem moves to the discovery of its nature. Dark Energy Survey aims to study the nature of dark energy and to test General Relativity and cosmological models. The cluster analysis of the first run of DES leads to results which are incomparable with what other surveys have obtained. In particular it turns out that the matter density of the Universe is $Ω_m = 0.179^{+0.031}_{−0.038}$, very different from the 0.3 value expected. In this work we build a procedure that can be followed in order to understand whether the solution of DES Y1 problem could be a selection effect or not.