Materials for Ultra‐Coherent, Mobile, Electron‐Spin Qubits

Abstract

This research project has had the goal of gaining a better understanding of the physics of electrons bound to the surface of superfluid helium from both experimental and theoretical perspectives. It has particularly been aimed at two areas which had not been well studied: the relaxation and decoherence of the spin of the electrons on the helium surface and how the properties of underlying metallic layers affect the behavior of the electrons when the helium covering the metal is thin. This work is motivated in part by interest in using the spin of these electrons as a quantum bit, or qubit. Low levels of decoherence are advantageous for qubits, and moving the electrons, as one might do in a quantum processor, will be easiest if thin helium films can be employed. It had been suggested that spin decoherence should be very weak for electrons bound to superfluid He, but before this work there have been no quantitative studies of spin relaxation and decoherence. It is especially important to know how moving the electrons across the helium surface would affect their spin coherence. Calculations performed as part of this project show that the Rashba effective magnetic field, the mechanism which limits the spin coherence of mobile electrons in silicon-based devices (an actively pursued qubit technology), is exceptionally weak for electrons bound to helium. This project has identified other decoherence mechanisms which are stronger, but still weak compared to analogous silicon-based structures. Calculated spin coherence times for mobile electrons approach one day, as compared to microseconds in silicon. With coherence times of this magnitude, the spin qubit errors on helium will be completely dominated by errors in the quantum gates. In related work, the possibility of using an artificial spin-orbit interaction (a gradient magnetic field) for quantum operations on the electrons spins was considered. The calculations show that a moderate gradient field, small enough to be generated by a narrow superconducting wire, will enable high-fidelity quantum operations on electrons held in lithographically-defined quantum dots by driving them with a microwave electric field. The spin and motional coherence of the electrons is sufficient to allow high-fidelity 2-qubit quantum operations between electrons in neighboring quantum dots. As an outgrowth of experiments aiming to measure electron spin coherence it was discovered that very high densities of electrons can be stably supported on thin helium films coating ultra-smooth amorphous metallic layers. The measured densities are high enough that the electron system has almost certainly transitioned from an ordered array of electrons, known as a Wigner crystal (ordered by the electrons’ mutual repulsion), to a quantum fluid known as a Fermi liquid. This transition has been a subject of intense interest for over 40 years, since the electron Wigner crystal was first observed with electrons bound to superfluid helium, but it has never been unambiguously observed. Experiments are still underway in these new structures to definitively determine whether true quantum melting of the Wigner crystal has been demonstrated. This work has also catalyzed the development of a new approach for measuring the transport of electrons across very thin helium films, as will be needed for some of the quantum computing applications. The high electron density experiments as well as experiments with electrons bound in quantum dots have led to new techniques which may enable spin coherence measurements.