The Shergotites Are Young

Abstract

Recently, Bouvier et al. (2006), interpreting their Pb isotopic data, have inferred that the shergottite suite of the SNC (martian) meteorites have ancient ages of approximately 4-4.5 b.y. But conventional wisdom has it that the shergottites are much younger (approximately 500-150 m.y.) Are the shergottites young or are they ancient rocks whose ages have been reset by metamorphism or alteration?