Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Young, Kevin

Publications and source records attributed to Young, Kevin.

At least 73 records · Page 4

Metrics and Benchmarks for Quantum Processors: State of Play

A compelling narrative has taken hold as quantum computing explodes into the commercial sector: Quantum computing in 2018 is like classical computing in 1965. In 1965 Gordon Moore wrote his famous paper about integrated circuits, saying: "At present, [minimum cost] is reached when 50 components are used per circuit. But... the complexity for minimum component costs has increased at a rate of roughly a factor of two per year... by 1975, the number of components per integrated circuit for minimum cost will be 65,000." This narrative is both appealing (we want to believe that quantum computing will follow the incredibly successful path of classical computing!) and plausible (2018 saw IBM, Intel, and Google announce 50-qubit integrated chips). But it is also deeply misleading. Here is an alternative: Quantum computing in 2018 is like classical computing in 1938. In 1938, John Atanasoff and Clifford Berry built the very first electronic digital computer. It had no program, and was not Turing-complete. Vacuum tubes — the standard "bit" for 20 years — were still 5 years in the future. ENIAC and the achievement of "computational supremacy" (over hand calculation) wouldn't arrive for 8 years, despite the accelerative effect of WWII. Integrated circuits and the information age were more than 20 years away. Neither of these analogies is perfect. Quantum computing technology is more like 1938, while the level of funding and excitement suggest 1965 (or later!). But the point of the cautionary analogy to 1938 is simple: Quantum computing in 2018 is a research field. It is far too early to establish metrics or benchmarks for performance. The best role for neutral organizations like IEEE is to encourage and shape research into metrics and benchmarks, so as to be ready when they become necessary. This white paper presents the evidence and reasoning for this claim. We explain what it means to say that quantum computing is a "research field", and why metrics and benchmarks for quantum processors also constitute a research field. We discuss the potential for harmful consequences of prematurely establishing standards or frameworks. We conclude by suggesting specific actions that IEEE or similar organizations can take to accelerate the development of good metrics and benchmarks for quantum computing.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Remote Robotic Equipment for Retrieval of High Level Waste to Support Environmental Closure - 18162

The Idaho Cleanup Project contractor, Fluor Idaho, LLC, is responsible for managing HLW calcine stored in the Calcined Solids Storage Facility at the Idaho Nuclear Technology and Engineering Center. The Idaho Nuclear Technology and Engineering Center is a DOE managed facility located at the INL Site in the remote portions of southeast Idaho. In 2016, DOE directed Fluor Idaho to develop and test a full-scale retrieval system to demonstrate the ability to safely retrieve HLW calcine from the Calcined Solids Storage Facility for future retrieval and processing. Removing HLW calcine from the State of Idaho is required by the 1995 Settlement Agreement, which mandates that DOE have HLW calcine ready to be moved out of Idaho by December 2035. Fluor Idaho is currently testing retrieval and transfer concepts to ensure that the Calcined Solids Storage Facility is placed in a final configuration that is protective of human health and the environment after HLW calcine has been removed to the maximum extent practical. This paper describes the full-scale prototype that will be used to prove retrieval and transfer system design capabilities, verify operating parameters, and establish a basis for calcine retrieval efficacy. Additionally, it describes the retrieval (bulk and residual) and visual monitoring systems that were designed and tested in 2017 and will continue to be tested with the full-scale prototype. Testing (i.e., full-scale mockup, bulk retrieval, residual clean-out, and visualization monitoring) performed by Fluor Idaho will demonstrate the maximum extent practical of HLW calcine removal that is achievable. This is critical to (1) establish criteria for ending calcine removal activities, (2) evaluate cost and benefits associated with performing additional removal, and (3) ensure clean up and closure standards under applicable requirements (e.g., statutes, orders, and agreements) are met. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗