Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Yamamoto, Akio

Publications and source records attributed to Yamamoto, Akio.

Development of nuclear data processing code FRENDY version 2

Nuclear data processing is an important interface between an evaluated nuclear data library and neutronics calculation codes. JAEA has been developed the new nuclear data processing code FRENDY from 2013. FRENDY version 1 generates the ACE files used for the continuous-energy Monte Carlo codes including PHITS, Solomon, Serpent,and MCNP and it was released as the open-source software under the 2-clause BSD license in 2019.After we released FRENDY version 1, many functions, e.g., the multi-group neutron cross-section library generation, the statistical uncertainty quantification of the probability tables for unresolved resonance cross-section, the 'perturbation' of the ACE file for uncertainty quantification, and the modification of the ENDF-6 formatted nuclear data file, have been developed. We released FRENDY version 2 including these functions. The present paper gives an overview of FRENDY and presents features of new functions implemented in FRENDY version 2. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Investigation of the impact of difference between FRENDY and NJOY2016 on neutronics calculations

A nuclear data library is used as a starting input for all subsequent neutronics calculations. NJOY has been used worldwide as a nuclear data processing code to create cross section libraries for a long time. For the verification of NJOY method and for providing an alternative nuclear data processing tool, JAEA has been developed the new nuclear library processing code FRENDY. In this paper, nuclear calculations were performed using the ACE files and the multigroup libraries created by both FRENDY and NJOY, and the impacts on the neutronics characteristics due to nuclear data processing were investigated using those libraries. MCNP was used to compare the ACE files by calculating many benchmark problems including ICSBEP and it was confirmed that the k-eff values generally agree with each other within the range of statistical errors. The multigroup cross sections are verified by the BWR design codes LANCR/AETNA through calculation of a commercial BWR5 equilibrium core loaded with 9*9 fuels. It was confirmed that fuel assembly and core characteristics are consistent with each other. From the above investigations, it was confirmed that FRENDY can provide comparable continuous/multi-group neutron cross sections with NJOY. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Neutron diffusion calculation in heterogeneous geometry based on local/global iteration using proper orthogonal decomposition

This study newly proposes a heterogeneous core calculation method based on local/global iteration using proper orthogonal decomposition (POD). By using the singular value decomposition (SVD) and the low-rank approximation, appropriate POD bases for expanding the neutron flux can be obtained from snapshot data of the neutron flux obtained by fine mesh calculations. By projection using the POD bases, the dimension of the target equation (e.g., discretized neutron diffusion equation) can be dramatically reduced. In the proposed method, POD is effectively applied to each single assembly calculation (local calculation). Furthermore, using the local/global iteration, the effective neutron multiplication factor and the neutron flux distribution in the whole core geometry can be obtained by combining the numerical results of the local calculation for each fuel assembly and the global calculation for the whole core. As a feasibility study, the proposed method is applied to a one-dimensional heterogeneous core analysis, and the accuracy is investigated by changing the total number of POD bases. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Uncertainty Quantification of Spatial Correction Factor for Sjoestrand Method due to Cross-section Data

Accelerator-driven System (ADS), which couples a subcritical core with a spallation neutron source, is proposed as a nuclear transmutation technology to reduce the radioactive half-life of high-level waste. To maintain a safe operation in ADS, the core should be kept in subcritical state. Thus, the subcritical state of the core must be quantified through measurement of subcriticality, which is a quantitative margin from critical state. The area ratio method, or the Sjoestrand method, is one of the subcriticality measurement techniques applicable to the ADS. In this method, the absolute value of subcriticality can be obtained by analyzing the temporal variation of neutron density in the core due to the periodic injection of neutron pulses. In practice, the value of subcriticality is measured by the temporal variation of neutron count rate detected by a detector in the core. Time integrals of count rates due to prompt and delayed neutrons A{sub p} and A{sub d}, are measured. Then, the ratio of A{sub p} to A{sub d}, which is called as the area ratio, yields negative reactivity -ρ, i.e. subcriticality, in dollar units: A{sub p}/A{sub d} ≅ -ρ/β{sub eff'} (1) where β{sub eff} is the effective delayed neutron fraction. Equation (1) represents the basic idea of the Sjoestrand method. Note, however, that Eq. (1) is approximately derived using the point kinetics model. In an actual subcritical system, the measured area ratio is not necessarily equal to the exact value of subcriticality in dollar units, due distortion by spatial higher-order modes. Hence, in the actual measurement, this spatial effect is corrected by a spatial correction factor such as the Bell and Glasstone correction factor (the Bell factor), or by extraction of the fundamental mode (so-called the extrapolated area ratio method). In addition, there is an effect due to the neutron detector materials (e.g. {sup 3}He(n,p) and {sup 235}U(n,f)). These effects must be considered in the correction of the measured area ratio. In this study, we focused on the uncertainty of Bell factor. The Bell factor f is defined by the ratio of the area ratio to the subcriticality as follows: f ≡ -[ρ/β{sub eff}]/[A{sub p}/A{sub d}] (2) The Bell factor f can be evaluated by a core analysis. By multiplying the measured area ratio by the Bell factor?, the spatial higher-order mode effect in the area ratio can be corrected. However, the uncertainty of the Bell factor due to uncertainties of cross-section data (covariance data) has not been quantitatively evaluated so far. In this study, we propose a method to quantify the uncertainty of the Bell factor in an actual core analysis. As a feasibility study, the uncertainty quantification is carried out in a simple one-dimensional subcritical core system. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Uncertainty Quantification of Activation Due to Cross Section Data in Neutron Shielding Calculation

Quantification of activation in structure materials around the nuclear reactor through calculation is necessary before start of decommissioning. Then a neutron shielding calculation is carried out to estimate activation of structural materials. Neutron shielding calculation is performed out for spatially large regions around a reactor through deep penetration calculation, calculation result would have significant uncertainty. In order to minimize total amount of structure materials treated as radioactive waste, quantitative estimation on uncertainty of structural activation and its reduction is important. The uncertainties due to calculation arises from that of input data and that of calculation method. Examples of uncertainty of input data is those for nuclear reaction cross section and atom density of the nuclide in the structure. In this study, we focus on the uncertainty of cross section, which would be one of the dominant uncertainties, and try to estimate uncertainty of activation due to cross section data in a neutron shielding calculation. The random sampling method (RS) is used as the uncertainty quantification method. With the RS method, uncertainty estimation can be carried out without modification of computer codes for a neutron shielding calculation. (authors)

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Prediction on Underestimation of Statistical Uncertainty in Monte Carlo Eigenvalue Calculation for Two-dimensional Heterogeneous Color Set Geometry

In a Monte Carlo calculation, statistical uncertainty is inevitably included in the result. The statistical uncertainty is commonly estimated by the central limit theorem without considering correlation among generations. The statistical uncertainty is usually expected to decrease at the inverse square root of the number of neutron histories. However, in a Monte Carlo eigenvalue calculation in a large geometry whose dominance ratio is close to unity, the central limit theorem would not be valid and thus the statistical uncertainty of fission source distribution can be significantly underestimated when inter-cycle correlation is not appropriately taken into account. The true statistical uncertainty can be calculated by statistical processing of the results obtained by multiple Monte Carlo runs using different initial random seeds, but this approach has a drawback of large calculation cost. Therefore, prediction of true statistical uncertainty by alternate approach is desirable. One of the solutions for this issue is an evaluation method of statistical uncertainty based on the eigenfunction expansion and the Autoregressive model (AR model). In this method, the true statistical uncertainty is theoretically derived by applying the AR model to behavior of expansion coefficients of eigenfunction in fission source distribution during cycles. Underestimation ratio of statistical uncertainty of fission source distribution can be predicted by this method. Note that the underestimation ratio of statistical uncertainty is defined by the ratio of estimated error by a Monte Carlo calculation to the true statistical error. In the previous study, the proposed method was verified in a simple condition such as one energy group, one dimensional homogeneous slab geometry. Contributions of this summary are as follows. Firstly, expression of the noise term that is appeared in the AR model is theoretically derived. Secondly, prediction on underestimation ratio of statistical uncertainty is carried out in a more general case, i.e., flux of each fuel cell in 2 x 2 heterogeneous assembly geometry taken from the C5G7 benchmark problem. Through the present study, applicability of the theoretical prediction for underestimation of statistical uncertainty in practical problems will be verified. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Application of Simplified Pn Approximation to Angular Distribution of Neutron Source in MOC Calculations

Concept of the simplified Pn approximation is applied to represent angular distribution of anisotropic scattering source in order to decrease number of angular flux moments stored during transport sweeps. In practical design calculations, anisotropic scattering is usually taken into account through transport correction. Though the transport correction yields a reasonable result for many cases, detail treatment of anisotropic scattering is desirable in high fidelity neutronics calculations, e.g., a direct heterogeneous transport calculation in three dimensional geometry. Direct treatment of anisotropic scattering has been established, which commonly utilizes the series expansion by the spherical harmonics functions. The expansion by the spherical harmonics functions requires (L + 1){sup 2} angular flux moments when up to L-th order anisotropy is taken into account. The previous studies suggested that consideration up to P3 anisotropic scattering yields converged results in many neutronics analysis for LWR. In this case, (3 + 1){sup 2} = 16 angular flux moments should be stored and retained in each flux region of each energy group. This storage requirement would be significant in a large scale calculation with many flux regions and energy groups. Chao et al. proposed an explicit angular flux representation based on the simplified Pn (SPn) method. Number of angular flux moments required in a SPn calculation is (L + 1) when L-th order angular distribution is considered. Since the SPn method adopts the physical picture of 'locally 1D system' along particular direction, required number of angular flux moments is much smaller than that based on the spherical harmonics functions. In the present study, concept of the SPn method is applied to describe angular distribution of anisotropic scattering source. By adopting the SPn approximation, as described above, number of angular flux moments can be significantly reduced. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Comparison of the Numerical Stability between CMFD and GCMR with Stabilization Techniques

The Coarse Mesh Finite Difference (CMFD) method and the Generalized Coarse Mesh Rebalance (GCMR) method have been applied to many reactor physics codes and these methods contribute for improvement of calculation speed. On the other hand, the numerical instability of these methods have been a crucial issue. In order to overcome this issue, some stabilization techniques such as damping factor and correction techniques of diffusion coefficient have been developed. The systematic comparison of the calculation stability and efficiency between GCMR and CMFD with various stabilization techniques has not been reported and these results are important for the improvement of nuclear reactor analysis. The present summary focuses on this point. Namely, calculation stability and efficiency of the CMFD and the GCMR are compared with investigation of the effect of stabilization techniques on these methods. We applied these methods and techniques to 2D geometries with and without voided regions. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Comparison of Fuel Loading Pattern Optimization Results using Exhaustive Search for Fresh Fuels and Local Search for Burned Fuels

Fuel loading pattern optimization is a combinatorial optimization problem from the mathematical point of view. However, exhaustive search is impractical because enormous computational cost is necessary due to huge search space. For this reason, various optimization methods have been developed so far, but no methods are able to guarantee to reach the optimum solution. In the present study, search space is divided into subspaces using key parameters that well represent characteristics of a loading pattern and then promising subspaces are extensively searched. In the present method, balance between division of a search space into subspaces and a search method used in a subspace is essential. For example, when the number of division is set to be one, it is equivalent to the exhaustive search thus is impractical. Similarly, when the division to subspaces is too coarse, an optimum (or near optimum) solution cannot be found through local search in each subspace since design space of a subspace is still too large. Contrary, if division to subspaces is too fine, number of subspaces becomes to large thus promising subspaces cannot be found. In the present study, search space is divided focusing on the location of fresh fuel assemblies with gadolinia since it has significant impact on core characteristics. Number of possible loading patterns of gadolinia bearing fresh fuel assemblies is not very large thus exhaustive search is possible. Local fine search is executed by considering location of burned fuels for each loading pattern of gadolinia bearing fresh fuel assembly. If the same solution is obtained by multiple local searches starting from different initial burnt fuel locations (but the same loading patterns for gadolinia bearing fresh fuel assemblies), the obtained solution is highly likely the optimum in the subspace. In more general, the present method is based on the 'divide and conquer' approach, which is familiar in the optimization field. Namely, after division of search space into subspaces and then promising subspace is searched. Once the promising subspace is found, the subspace is further subdivided into subspaces and repeat the above procedures. This method would be efficient when appropriate balance between search space division method and performance of local search is achieved. The previous works utilizes the similar approach. In reference [1], exhaustive search in small region in a core is carried out focusing on loading patterns of gadolinia bearing fresh fuel assemblies. In reference [2], rough exhaustive search based on the 'batch-wise' loading pattern is performed with the assist of the linear programming. By contrast, in the present study, exhaustive search is carried out for loading patterns of gadolinia bearing fresh fuel assemblies. The random Multi-start Local Search (MSLS) with the direct search or the exhaustive binary swap is used to find out optimal solutions in a subspace, which consists of loading patterns having the same arrangement of gadolinia bearing fresh fuel assemblies. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗