Comparison of abrasion model differences in heavy ion fragmentation - Optical versus geometric models
Two different abrasion formalisms, one based on an energy-independent geometric model and the other based on a quantum-mechanical optical model, are shown to yield comparable fragmentation cross section predictions when used as input to an abrasion-ablation frictional-spectator interaction fragmentation calculation which includes electromagnetic dissociation contributions. The results suggest that any dependence upon the incident ion's kinetic energy above 200 MeV/nucleon is weak. It is also noted that the larger surface diffusiveness of the optical model densities only affects nuclear cross sections for near-projectile-mass fragments, while for heavier nuclei, the sizable cross-section contributions from electromagnetic dissociation negate these differences.