Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

White, Daniel A.

Publications and source records attributed to White, Daniel A..

Explosively driven Richtmyer–Meshkov instability jet suppression and enhancement via coupling machine learning and additive manufacturing

The ability to control the behavior of fluid instabilities at material interfaces, such as the shock-driven Richtmyer–Meshkov instability, is a grand technological challenge with a broad number of applications ranging from inertial confinement fusion experiments to explosively driven shaped charges. In this work, we use a linear-geometry shaped charge as a means of studying methods for controlling material jetting that results from the Richtmyer–Meshkov instability. A shaped charge produces a high-velocity jet by focusing the energy from the detonation of high explosives. The interaction of the resulting detonation wave with a hollowed cavity lined with a thin metal layer produces the unstable jetting effect. By modifying the characteristics of the detonation wave prior to striking the lined cavity, the kinetic energy of the jet can be enhanced or reduced. Modifying the geometry of the liner material can also be used to alter jetting properties. We apply optimization methods to investigate several design parameterizations for both enhancing or suppressing the shaped-charge jet. This is accomplished using 2D and 3D hydrodynamic simulations to investigate the design space that we consider. We also apply new additive manufacturing methods for producing the shaped-charge assemblies, which allow for the experimental testing of complicated design geometries obtained through computational optimization. We present a direct comparison of our optimized designs with experimental results carried out at the High Explosives Application Facility at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Linear shaped-charge jet optimization using machine learning methods

Linear shaped charges are used to focus energy into rapidly creating a deep linear incision. The general design of a shaped charge involves detonating a confined mass of high explosive (HE) with a metal-lined concave cavity on one side to produce a high velocity jet for the purpose of striking and penetrating a given material target. This jetting effect occurs due to the interaction of the detonation wave with the cavity geometry, which produces an unstable fluid phenomenon known as the Richtmyer–Meshkov instability and results in the rapid growth of a long narrow jet. We apply machine learning and optimization methods to hydrodynamics simulations of linear shaped charges to improve the simulated jet characteristics. The designs that we propose and investigate in this work generally involve modifying the behavior of the detonation waves prior to interaction with the liner material. These designs include the placement of multiple detonators and the use of metal inclusions within the HE. In conclusion, we are able to produce a linear shaped-charge design with a higher penetration depth than the baseline case that we consider and accomplish this using the same amount of or less HE.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Design optimization for Richtmyer–Meshkov instability suppression at shock-compressed material interfaces

We report the Richtmyer–Meshkov instability (RMI) is a phenomenon that occurs at the interface of two substances of different densities due to an impulsive acceleration, such as a shock wave passing through this interface. Under these conditions, the instability can be seen as interface perturbations begin to grow into narrow jets or spikes of one substance that propagate into the other. In some cases, this interface may involve an elastic–plastic material, which can play a significant role in the development and behavior of the RMI. The ability to effectively control RMI jetting and spike growth is one major limiting factor in technological challenges, such as inertial confinement fusion, that involve using high-pressure shock waves to implode a fuel target. The propagation of RMI growth can lead to increased asymmetry in this implosion process and significantly reduce the obtained energy yield. We use hydrodynamics simulations of impactor shock-compression experiments and methods based in design optimization to suppress RMI spike growth by altering the geometry and other properties of a shock-compressed elastic–plastic material target that shares an interface with atmospheric air. These hydrodynamics simulations use an arbitrary Lagrangian–Eulerian method with a high-order finite element approach. Our results demonstrate that RMI suppression can be achieved by intentionally creating a separate upstream interface instability to counteract the growth of long narrow RMI spikes at an interface with initial perturbations.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Topology Optimization of Manufacturable Photonic Crystals With Complete Bandgaps [Dissertation]

Periodic structures consisting of dielectric material, i.e. photonic crystals, are capable of prohibiting electromagnetic waves within frequency ranges referred to as bandgaps. This principle was first demonstrated with alternating slabs of material and later demonstrated with three-dimensional (3D) structures capable of reflecting waves from any incident angle. A number of potential applications for photonic bandgap structures exist, including loss-less sharp corner waveguides, fiber optics, and radome design. Further, many optical devices could benefit from the perfect-mirror behavior of photonic crystals.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Manufacturing and stiffness constraints for topology optimized periodic structures

Topology optimization (TO) is commonly applied to design the unit cells of periodic structures. For example, metamaterials, lattice structures, phononic crystals (PhC), and photonic crystals (PC) have all been previously designed via TO. Unfortunately, the optimal structures for certain design objectives, e.g., bandgaps, are often impossible to manufacture as they have disconnected regions or “islands” of solid material (ISM) that are not self-supporting. Additionally, designs with enclosed void space (EVS) are problematic for additive manufacturing (AM) since support material or pre-sintered powder cannot be removed after manufacturing. We present a series of constraints that may be incorporated into any TO framework to ensure structures are self-supporting without enclosed voids. Additionally, we employ homogenization-based constraints that allow the designer to tune the elastic stiffness and isotropy of the optimized design. The proposed constraints are evaluated on example microstructures and utilized in a simple optimization test problem to highlight their abilities and limitations so that guidelines for appropriate combinations of constraints may be proposed. Effective constraint combinations are demonstrated on the design of 3D photonic crystals for maximum bandgap subject to manufacturing and stiffness constraints.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Topology optimization of 3D photonic crystals with complete bandgaps

The design of photonic crystals with complete bandgaps has recently received considerable research focus for numerous reasons. This work leverages well-known nonlinear programming techniques to alleviate the non-smoothness caused by degenerate eigenvalues such that topology optimization problems can be solved with the open-source IPOPT software. A fully-vectorial plane wave expansion technique is used with an iterative eigensolver to efficiently predict dispersion properties of candidate structures. Nonlinear programming is employed to solve the inverse problem of designing three-dimensional periodic structures that exhibit complete two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) photonic bandgaps. Mesh refinement is performed to alleviate the large computational burden of designing and analyzing photonic crystals, and a periodic density filter is implemented to impose a minimum feature size for manufacturability considerations.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Simultaneous material, shape and topology optimization

Using three design fields we develop an optimization environment that can simultaneously optimize material, shape and topology. We use the implicit representation of the boundaries with level-set functions that define the shape and topology. Differentiable R-functions allow us to combine these shapes and topology descriptions with Boolean operations. Additionally, we incorporate design dependent-stiffness materials with another design field. Notably, this framework accommodates design dependent loads, has the ability to introduce holes, and ensures the satisfaction of optimality criteria. It builds upon the fictitious domain, ersatz material, material interpolation and level-set methods. Additionally, it also borrows from parameterized density-based topology optimization methods. Since analytical sensitivities can be computed, we use efficient nonlinear programming algorithms to update the design instead of the Hamilton–Jacobi’s scheme of level-set methods. We illustrate the features of our framework by designing a cantilever beam with octet truss microlattice, a dam with design-dependent loads, and a composite clevis plate.

42 ENGINEERING↗

A dual mesh method with adaptivity for stress-constrained topology optimization

This paper is concerned with the topological optimization of elastic structures, with the goal of minimizing the compliance and/or mass of the structure, subject to a stress constraint. It is well known that depending upon the geometry and the loading conditions, the stress field can exhibit singularities, if these singularities are not adequately resolved, the topological optimization process will be ineffective. For computational efficiency, adaptive mesh refinement is required to adequately resolve the stress field. This poses a challenge for the traditional Solid Isotropic Material with Penalization (SIMP) method that employs a one-to-one correspondence between the finite element mesh and the optimization design variables because as the mesh is refined, the optimization process must somehow be re-started with a new set of design variables. The proposed solution here is a dual mesh approach, one finite element mesh defines the material distribution, a second finite element mesh is used for the computation of the displacement and stress fields. This allows for stress-based adaptive mesh refinement without modifying the definition of the optimization design variables. A second benefit of this dual mesh approach is that there is no need to apply a filter to the design variables to enforce a length scale, instead the length scale is determined by the design mesh. This reduces the number of design variables and allows the designer to apply spatially varying length scale if desired. The efficacy of this dual mesh approach is established via several stress-constrained topology optimization problems.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Simple, accurate surrogate models of the elastic response of three-dimensional open truss micro-architectures with applications to multiscale topology design

Elastic meta-materials are those whose unique properties come from their micro-architecture, rather than, e.g., from their chemistry. The introduction of such architecture, which is increasingly able to be fabricated due to advances in additive manufacturing, expands the design domain and enables improved design, from the most complex multi-physics design problems to the simple compliance design problem that is our focus. Unfortunately, concurrent design of both the micro-scale and the macroscale is computationally very expensive when the former can vary spatially, particularly in three dimensions. Instead, we provide simple, accurate surrogate models of the homogenized linear elastic response of the isotruss, the octet truss, and the ORC truss based on high-fidelity continuum finite element analyses. These surrogate models are relatively accurate over the full range of relative densities, in contrast to analytical models in the literature, which we show lose accuracy as relative density increases. The surrogate models are also simple to implement, which we demonstrate by modifying Sigmund’s 99-line code to solve a three-dimensional, multiscale compliance design problem with spatially varying relative density. Here, we use this code to generate examples in both two and three dimensions that illustrate the advantage of elastic meta-materials over structures with a single length scale, i.e., those without micro-architectures.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Multiscale topology optimization using neural network surrogate models

In this study, we are concerned with optimization of macroscale elastic structures that are designed utilizing spatially varying microscale metamaterials. The macroscale optimization is accomplished using gradient-based nonlinear topological optimization. But instead of using density as the optimization decision variable, the decision variables are the multiple parameters that define the local microscale metamaterial. This is accomplished using single layer feedforward Gaussian basis function networks as a surrogate models of the elastic response of the microscale metamaterial. The surrogate models are trained using highly resolved continuum finite element simulations of the microscale metamaterials and hence are significantly more accurate than analytical models e.g. classical beam theory. Because the derivative of the surrogate model is important for sensitivity analysis of the macroscale topology optimization, a neural network training procedure based on the Sobolev norm is described. Since the SIMP method is not appropriate for spatially varying lattices, an alternative method is developed to enable creation of void regions. Lastly, the efficacy of this approach is demonstrated via several examples in which the optimal graded metamaterial outperforms a traditional solid structure.

42 ENGINEERING↗

A computational study of symmetry and well-posedness of structural topology optimization

We report on computational topological optimization of elastic structures, in particular minimization of compliance subject to a constraint on the mass. Through computational experiments, it is discovered that even very simple optimization problems can exhibit complex behavior such as critical points and bifurcation. In the vicinity of significant points, structural topology optimization problems are not well-posed since infinitesimally small perturbations lead to distinct topologies.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Toplogical optimization of structures using Fourier representations

The minimization of compliance subject to a mass constraint is the topology optimization design problem of interest. The goal is to determine the optimal configuration of material within an allowed volume. Our approach builds upon the well-known density method in which the decision variable is the material density in every cell in a mesh. In it’s most basic form the density method consists of three steps: 1) the problem is convexified by replacing the integer material indicator function with a volume fraction, 2) the problem is regularized by filtering the volume fraction field to impose a minimum length scale; 3) the filtered volume fraction is penalized to steer the material distribution toward binary designs. The filtering step is used to yield a mesh-independent solution and to eliminate checkerboard instabilities. In image processing terms this is a low-pass filter, and a consequence is that the decision variables are not independent and a change of basis could significantly reduce the dimension of the nonlinear programming problem. Based on this observation, we represent the volume fraction field with a truncated Fourier representation. Furthermore, this imposes a minimal length scale on the problem, eliminates checkerboard instabilities, and also reduces the number of decision variables by over 100 × (two dimensions) or 1000 × (three dimensions).

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Automatic Complexity Reduction

This is the final report for LDRD project 12-ERD-038 titled Automatic Complexity Reduction. The original budget request was for $\$1.1$M for three years, the project was instead funded at $\$420$K for three years. The team consisted the PI Daniel White, post-doctoral researcher Kyle Lange, and staff member Mark Stowell. This work largely builds upon the research of Matt Stephanson, who was a summer scholar at LLNL. This report will provide a high level overview of the problem and the solution approach, as well as results, and future research directions.

42 ENGINEERING↗