Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Whalen, Scott A.

Publications and source records attributed to Whalen, Scott A..

Friction-based recycling: an evaluation of friction extrusion for fabricating Ti-6Al-4 V wire fabricated from machining chip feedstock

Abstract Titanium and its alloys are used in aviation and automobile industries due to their remarkable strength to weight ratio, but machining loss commonly is high with ~ 80 wt% of the material being converted to scrap. Recycling post-consumer Ti scrap directly into solid bulk products is a potential solution for repurposing valuable material. Further, eliminating fresh Ti sponge during recycling might lead to lower energy and greenhouse gas emissions. In this study, a solid-phase process known as friction extrusion was utilized to recycle Ti-6Al-4 V machining chips into solid wires which could be used as feedstock in additive manufacturing. The friction consolidation technique was first used to convert chips with varying degrees of oxygen content into solid billets for its use as feedstock material in subsequent friction extrusion. The extrudates were fabricated above the beta transition temperature, which was achieved by selecting the rotation rate and feed rate, to process the billets near 1000 °C using a tungsten-lanthana extrusion die. This work presents the first occurrence of friction extruded titanium alloy wires. The effect of friction extrusion on microstructural features, tensile properties, and texture are reported. Overall, the friction extrusion method is capable of directly recycling Ti-6Al-4 V scrap into extruded wire.

Friction Extrusion↗

Microstructural refinement of an Al-Ce-Mg alloy via Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion

Al-Ce alloys have attracted recent interest because of their high thermal stability due to the low solubility of Ce in the Al matrix. The Al 11 Ce 3 eutectic phase gives excellent strain hardening behavior and moderate high-temperature strength in the as-cast state. However, its strengthening effect is limited by its coarse as-cast structure. Therefore, alternative manufacturing methods such as additive manufacturing or equal channel angular pressing have been applied to refine the Al 11 Ce 3 phase to good effect. However, these techniques are both expensive and time-consuming. Therefore, this study aims to use Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion (ShAPE), an emerging solid phase processing technique that is more easily scalable than the previously mentioned methods. ShAPE can produce useful cross-sections of an Al-8Ce-4Mg alloy while refining the Al 11 Ce 3 phase to produce a higher strength material. It was found that a low temperature ShAPE process can improve the room temperature yield strength by ~60 % compared to a binary Al-4Mg alloy. Additionally, the high-temperature yield strength of the Al-Ce alloys increased by 20%, with a simultaneous 15% improvement in ductility compared to the binary Al-Mg alloy. Finally, these results highlight the potential for ShAPE as a processing technique for Al-Ce alloys.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Achieving high-ZT in Te/Se-based thermoelectric materials via volume-constrained shear-induced plastic deformation

This study investigated the correlation between severe plastic deformation and microstructural evolution, along with the corresponding response in the thermoelectric performance. Specifically, severe plastic deformation introduced into intrinsically brittle thermoelectric materials like Bi 2 Te 3 - x Se x leads to microstructural changes ranging from nano- to micro- scales, including phase transformation, phase segregation, and stacking faults. The resultant residual strain and lattice defects in the Bi 2 Te 3-x Se x materials led to engineering of electronic bands, which increases the effective mass of electrons while controlling their concentration, thereby enhancing the power factor.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Metal Scrap Upcycling with Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion (ShAPE)

The overarching objective of this project is to convert metal scraps, such as aluminum, titanium, and other alloys provided by the industry, into extruded tubing, wires, and rods. Upcycling of scrap will be accomplished using Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion (ShAPE). This approach is a new solution for recycling. The specific aims of this project are as follows: 1. Receive metal scrap under a Material Transfer Agreement (MTA), in the form of billets, from select industry partners that meet the following requirements: outer diameter of 1.245 inches (+/-0.003 inches), inner diameter drilled with a 0.404-inch drill bit, and a length of 4.0 inches (+/-0.01 inches). The billet must be cast or compacted to greater than 98% density. If the industry partner does not have the capabilities to prepare the billets, PNNL can make introductions to third-party entities as needed. Industry partners will also provide a composition analysis as weight percent. 2. Extrude metal scrap via the ShAPE process at PNNL. 3. Evaluate and benchmark the extrudate material properties per the ASTM B557-15 – Testing Tubulars Standard or similar wire and rod standards. 4. Characterize the extrudate microstructure for any of the following: grain size, second phase composition, and texture. Additional testing may include corrosion per the ASTM B117 standard and electro-potential. 5. Deliver specimens to industry partners under an MTA for additional third-party evaluations. Industry partners will, in return, provide a non-proprietary report on any testing, including testing per the ASTM B557-15, ASTM B117, and other industry standards. 6. PNNL will develop data and insights to support intellectual property capture, a published non-proprietary technical report, research collaborations, and commercialization opportunities.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Wrought Aluminum-Cerium Alloys by Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion

Al-Ce alloys have attracted recent interest because of their high thermal stability due to the very low solubility of Ce in the Al matrix. The Al 11 Ce 3 eutectic phase gives excellent strain hardening behavior and moderate high-temperature strength in the as-cast state. However, its strengthening effect is limited by its coarse as-cast structure. Therefore, alternative manufacturing methods such as additive manufacturing or equal channel angular pressing have been applied to refine the Al 11 Ce 3 phase to good effect. However, these techniques are both expensive and time-consuming. Therefore, this study aims to use Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion (ShAPE), an emerging solid phase processing technique that is more easily scalable than the previously mentioned methods. ShAPE can produce useful cross-sections of an Al-8Ce-4Mg alloy while refining the Al 11 Ce 3 phase to produce a higher strength material. It was found that a low temperature ShAPE process can improve the room temperature yield strength by ~60% compared to a binary Al-4Mg alloy. Additionally, the high-temperature yield strength of the Al-Ce alloys increased by 20%, with a simultaneous 15% improvement in ductility compared to the binary Al-Mg alloy. These results highlight the potential for ShAPE as a processing technique for Al-Ce alloys.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Recycling of Titanium Scrap by Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion (ShAPE)

Titanium and its alloys are used in the aviation and automobile industries due to their remarkable strength to weight ratio, but, commonly, machining loss is high with ~90 wt.% of the material being converted to scrap. Recycling post-consumer Ti scrap directly into solid bulk products is a potential solution for repurposing valuable material. Further, reducing or even eliminating fresh Ti sponge during recycling might lead to lower energy and greenhouse gas emissions. In this study, a solid-phase process known as friction extrusion was utilized to recycle Ti-6Al-4V machining chips into solid wires which could be used as feedstock in additive manufacturing. The friction consolidation technique was first used to convert chips with varying degrees of oxygen content into solid billets for its use as feedstock material in subsequent friction extrusion. The extrudates were fabricated above the beta transition temperature, which was achieved by selecting rotation rate and feed rate, to process the billets near 1000°C using a tungsten-lanthana extrusion die. This work presents the first occurrence of friction extruded titanium alloy wires. The effect of friction extrusion on microstructural features, tensile properties, and texture are reported. Overall, the friction extrusion method is capable of recycling Ti-6Al-4V scrap directly into extruded wire.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Upcycling of Mixed Aluminum Alloy Shredder Scrap using Shear Processing

Conservation of critical materials is an increasing area of focus in the Unites States. In 2023, aluminum was added to the US Department of Energy Final Critical Materials List which has spurred public and private research into sustainable management of these resources. Additionally, efficiency in manufacturing and conservation of natural resources are growing concerns with targets to lower global carbon emissions, as primary aluminum alloy production is energy intensive, requiring 14 MWh of electricity plus 0.4 tonnes of CO2 per tonne of Al. Due to these factors, is essential that more sustainable manufacturing methods for aluminum alloys are developed going forward. To this end, much research is ongoing on the topic of more efficient utilization and recovery. However, most of this research still requires primary aluminum in the production process. Here, it will be attempted to bypass the use of primary aluminum and produce useful material recycled from 100% post-consumer scrap. Even considering recent developments in recycling of Al scrap, there is still a large amount of post-consumer scrap that is underutilized due to high impurity content, and that amount will increase significantly as more and more aluminum alloys are utilized in vehicles. This “scrap wave” is expected to cover 80% of the demand for automotive aluminum alloys by 2050 . A challenge to be addressed before the coming scrap wave can be fully utilized is that the tolerance of manufacturing techniques to impurities or off-spec alloy compositions must be increased. Particularly, in 5000-and 6000-series alloys (the most common wrought alloys in durable products), excess iron, copper, and silicon create brittle intermetallics during casting that remain in the extruded microstructure which limit the formability, ductility, and corrosion resistance of the alloy. Concerningly, many of the highest-volume post-consumer aluminum scrap streams such as automotive shredder scrap contain a mix of alloys including both wrought and cast alloys. Their compositions can vary widely depending on geography and the time of year. Because they are mixed, they often contain high content of multiple alloying elements such as Si and Cu in higher concentrations than are found in typical wrought alloys. They may also be contaminated with non-Al alloys from fasteners that get mixed in and often have high content of unwanted elements such as Fe. As a method for utilizing these underused scrap streams that are high in tramp elements, an emerging extrusion technology is being developed at the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) that aims to upcycle 100% post-consumer aluminum scrap directly into extruded components without the addition of primary aluminum . This new technology, called Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion (ShAPE), is enabling a shift away from today’s recycling paradigm by reaching deeper into lower-value scrap streams, using shredder scrap as the extrusion billet material. Sometimes referred to as Twitch or Tweak, these scrap streams result from shredding and sorting of automobiles, building materials, appliances, and consumer goods. ShAPE combines the linear axis of conventional extrusion with a rotating extrusion die. This rotating die applies large strain to the material during extrusion, which breaks up large impurity-containing intermetallic particles, reducing their deleterious effects. This has been demonstrated for 6063 machining scrap spiked with excess Fe, and Twitch scrap high in Fe, Si and Cu where strength and ductility were retained for both feedstock compositions. Additionally, the extreme plastic deformation during ShAPE enables extrusion of billets with high Si that are too brittle for processing by conventional extrusion. By using 100% post-consumer shedder scrap as feedstock, ShAPE has the potential to slash embodied energy and carbon in extruded components by >80% compared to conventional extrusion of primary aluminum alloys.

Milligan, Brian K.↗

Impact of Backing Plate and Thermal Boundary Conditions for High-Speed Friction Stir Welding of 25-mm Thick Aluminum Alloy 7175-T79

Here this study demonstrates high-speed (150 mm/min) single pass friction stir butt joining of 25 mm thick aluminum alloy 7175-T79. To understand the impact of quenching and cooling rate on process responses, joint strength, and grain size distributions across the weld thickness, we performed a series of friction stir welding (FSW) trials in air and with a trailing water spray using steel and composite backing plates (BP). Welds made in air and trailing water spray exhibit significantly different hardness distributions across the nugget, heat affected zone (HAZ), and HAZ minimum hardness as evidenced by detailed microhardness mapping. The effect of trailing water spray (TWS) on joint efficiency overshadows the influence of BP composition due to the vastly different contribution to quenching. TWS also resulted in a multifaceted effect on FSW such as lowering processing temperature, increasing X and Z forces while lowering Y force, and narrow heat affecting zone. Finally, digital image correlation (DIC)-based fracture mode analysis and grain size measurements correlate with the hardness distribution.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Shear-assisted extrusion assemblies and methods

Shear-assisted extrusion assemblies are provided. The assemblies can include a billet containing assembly containing a billet comprising a billet outer material and a billet inner material in at least one cross-section; a tool operably engaged with the billet; an extrudate receiving channel configured to receive extrudate from the tool, wherein the extrudate comprises extruded outer material and extruded inner material in at least one cross-section, the extruded outer material being the same material as the billet outer material, and the extruded inner material being the same as the billet inner material. Methods for producing multi-material shear-assisted extrudate are also provided.

Komarasamy, Mageshwari↗

Process Intensification for Nanostructure Aluminum Extrusions

A new technology called Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion (ShAPE™), pioneered at the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), has the potential to revolutionize the US extrusion industry. Maturation of the ShAPE™ process would create a new cross cutting US manufacturing technology that advances three key the objectives within AMO; namely, nanomaterials processing, process intensification, and materials for extreme and harsh environments. PNNL and SCM Metals Products, Inc. (SCM), a division of Kymera International, will collaborate to mature the ShAPE™ extrusion process beyond TRL 3 to increase the likelihood of its adoption by industry. PNNL’s custom (one-of-a-kind in the world) ShAPE™ machine will be used to extrude round rods of high strength aluminum alloy feedstock powder provided by SCM. As proof-of-concept, PNNL has previously extruded 5 mm diameter rods with SCM aluminum alloy powder AL-12.4TM. This project aims to scale up the process to a diameter of 25 mm while retaining the excellent mechanical properties achieved for the 5 mm diameter rods. The degree of process intensification with ShAPE™ will also be estimated. The primary objectives of this project are as follows. 1) Fabricate 25 mm diameter nanostructured extrusions in bulk, directly from AL-12.4TM aluminum alloy powder without the need for canning, degassing, compaction, and other intermediate steps typical of powder metallurgy extrusion. 2) Achieve a microstructure with an ultrafine grained (UFG <1 µm) aluminum matrix having refined and homogenously distributed nanoscale second phases. 3) Show that the ram force can be significantly reduced compared to conventional powder metallurgy extrusion of the same material and estimate the extent of process intensification that may be possible with ShAPE™. 4) Demonstrate improved high-temperature mechanical properties compared to conventional extrusion of the same material. The following tasks will be undertaken to achieve these objectives. PNNL will develop the die set and process parameters necessary to fabricate Al-12.4TM extrusions with a 25 mm diameter. Microstructural analysis will be performed by PNNL while mechanical testing will be conducted by SCM. With information learned from the process development and characterization, PNNL will perform an estimate of the degree of process intensification that may be possible with ShAPE™.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Non-Rare Earth Magnesium Bumper Beams

Magna will team with the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) to develop Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion (ShAPE™) of rectangular and multi-zoned extrusion profiles using non-RE Mg. It is envisioned that the ShAPE™ process, developed during this project for non-circular profiles, will serve as the foundation for fabrication of full-scale bumper beams of the future where near net-shapes are extruded directly from castings in a single step, without the need for costly rare earth additives. In this project, the ShAPE™ process will be developed for a rectangular profile measuring 1” x 2” with a 0.06” wall thickness. Successful extrusion of rectangular cross sections is a critical step along the path toward profiles with multiple zones. With the process established for a rectangular profile, the project will then make advancements toward multi-zoned cross sections. A magnesium alloy bumper beam offers a 35% weight savings compared to aluminum alloys and 60% compared to high strength steels. The bumper beam was chosen as the first component to target because the geometry can have a fairly simple 0.6-0.12 inch wall/web thickness, generally compatible with PNNL’s knowledge base and equipment capability surrounding ShAPE™. The bumper component offers commercial value by providing mass reduction in the front of the vehicle along with ride and handling benefit. PNNL has demonstrated the ability to ShAPE™ process non-RE Mg tubing with high strength, ductility and energy absorption. It has been shown that ShAPE™ extruded ZK60 and Mg2Si tubing with 0.30 inch diameter and 0.03 inch wall thickness have similar energy absorption to AA6061-T6. This is due to significant grain refinement, breakdown and dispersion of second phases, and the ability to eliminate anisotropy in compressive/tensile strength by aligning texture 45 degrees to the extrusion axis. Scalability of the ShAPE™ process has been demonstrated in ZK60 by fabricating 2.0 inch diameter tubing with 0.06 and 0.12 inch wall thicknesses having concentricity as tight as 1.3%. These tubes exhibit an ultimate tensile strength of 260-300 MPa and room temperature ductility of >20% parallel, perpendicular and 45 degrees to the extrusion axis. Aluminum bumpers represent approximately 54% of the NA light vehicle market. If the research effort is successful, providing a 30% mass reduction at equal cost relative to aluminum bumpers, it is anticipated that 25% market penetration would be realized over the next 5 year and 50% market share by 2030. 100% of the aluminum automotive bumpers are sourced from the tier network, providing resourcing opportunity based on equal performance, reduced mass and cost equivalent lower than aluminum bumpers. Due to the relatively low vehicle content, magnesium components are currently shredded and 100% recycled with aluminum content in the US, presenting a positive life cycle impact.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Co-Extrusion of Dissimilar Aluminum Alloys via Shear-Assisted Processing and Extrusion

Bimetallic tubes are used when a component requires more than one performance requirement, for instance, strength/creep resistance and oxidation/corrosion resistance. Shear-assisted processing and extrusion (ShAPE) can be used to fabricate extrudates that are comparable or superior in performance relative to conventionally manufactured extrudates. For the first time, ShAPE has been successfully employed in producing bimetallic Al tubing consisting of 6061 and 7075 Al alloys. Both light and electron microscopy techniques were used to investigate the integrity of the tubes, especially the interface between the core and cladding of the bimetallic tubes. Void-free bimetallic tubes were produced using ShAPE. Quantification of tube integrity was carried out with tensile testing under as-extruded and post-aged conditions. All the bimetallic tubes in the as-extruded samples exhibited uniform elongation above 5% with good tensile strength. Key insights such as material flow during bimetallic tube extrusion were obtained from the characterization of remnant billet and simulation results from a smoothed particle hydrodynamics model.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Sensing and Control During Bulk SPP

In this work, we use the thermoelectricity to directly measure the temperature at different radial positions within instrumented Al1100 billets during friction extrusion. Site-specific and uninterrupted temperature measurements were possible by measuring the local voltages at several thermoelectric junctions consisting of aluminum-nickel pairs during extrusion. Measurements were conducted for a constant die rotation speed of 150 RPM and different extrusion feed rates of 2, 8, 32, and 80 mm.min-1. X-ray computed tomography was used to locate the positions of the thermoelectric junctions inside the processed billet, thus allowing for site-specific microstructural characterization at the precise measurement points. Smooth particle hydrodynamic modeling allowed to determine the thermal, strain, and strain rate fields developing during FE. The applicability and limitations of this temperature measurement approach are discussed as a function of the peak extrusion and torsion stresses relative to the matrix of extrusion feed rates.

42 ENGINEERING↗