Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Tonks, Michael R.

Publications and source records attributed to Tonks, Michael R..

At least 19 records

Impact of grain boundary and surface diffusion on predicted fission gas bubble behavior and release in UO 2 fuel

In this work, we quantify the impact of grain boundary (GB) and surface diffusion on fission gas bubble evolution and fission gas release in UO 2 nuclear fuel using simulations with a hybrid phase field/cluster dynamics model. Here, we begin with a comprehensive literature review of uranium vacancy and xenon atom diffusivity in UO 2 through the bulk, along GBs, and along surfaces. In our model we represent fast GB and surface diffusion using a heterogeneous diffusivity that is a function of the order parameters that represent bubbles and grains. We find that the GB diffusivity directly impacts the rate of gas release via GB transport, and that the GB diffusivity is likely below 104 times the lower value from Olander and van Uffelen. We also find that the surface diffusivity impacts bubble coalescence and mobility, and that the bubble surface diffusivity is likely below 10 -4 times the value from Zhou and Olander.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Anisotropic physics-regularized interpretable machine learning of microstructure evolution

Anisotropic Physics-Regularized Interpretable Machine Learning Microstructure Evolution (APRIMME) is a general-purpose machine learning solution for grain growth simulations. In prior work, PRIMME employed a deep neural network to predict site-specific migration as a function of its neighboring sites to model normal, isotropic, grain growth behavior. This work aims to extend this method by incorporating grain boundary misorientation-based grain growth behavior. APRIMME is trained on anisotropic simulations created using the Monte Carlo-Potts (MCP) model. Furthermore, the results of this work are compared statistically using grain radius, number of sides per grain, mean neighborhood misorientations, and the standard deviation of triple junction dihedral angles, and are found to match in most cases. The exceptions are small and seem to be related to two causes: (1) the deterministic model of APRIMME is learning from the stochastic simulations of MCP, which seems to accentuate triple junction behaviors; and, (2) a bias against very small grains is made evident in a quicker decrease in grains than expected at the beginning of an APRIMME simulation. APRIMME is also evaluated for its general ability to capture anisotropic grain growth behavior by first investigating different test case initial conditions, including a circle grain, three grain, and hexagonal grain microstructures.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

A triple junction energy study using an inclination-dependent anisotropic Monte Carlo Potts grain growth model

This work presents a Monte Carlo Potts grain growth model in which the grain boundary (GB) energies depend on the GB inclination. The inclination is calculated using a linear smoothing approach developed by the authors. In bicrystal simulations with a shrinking grain, the grain changes shape to prefer low energy GB inclinations. However, in polycrystal simulations the preferred inclinations depend on the approach used to assign the triple junction (TJ) energies. Approaches that produce unimodal TJ energy distributions result in the expected behavior of preferring low energy GB inclinations. However, approaches that produce bimodal TJ energy distributions result in medium energy or even high energy inclinations being preferred. Overall, this study underscores the importance of TJs in anisotropic grain growth.

Grain boundary inclination↗

A new efficient grain growth model using a random Gaussian-sampled mode filter

This paper presents the use of a Gaussian neighborhood mode filter for predicting grain growth in a manner similar to the solutions obtained by a Monte Carlo Potts model. This flexible grain growth model can quickly utilize modern, computationally optimized data science strategies on graphics processing units to simulate grain growth up to 100 times faster than the state-of-the-art, publicly available Monte Carlo Potts model. We show that, given the correct neighborhood, the mode filter can replicate normal grain growth in two or three dimensions. In addition, the paper briefly demonstrates the ability to model limited anisotropic in grain boundary energy and mobility. Anisotropic grain boundary energy is modeled by defining a weighted mode filter operation. Anisotropic grain boundary mobility is modeled by scaling and orienting the Gaussian neighborhood in a particular direction.

Anisotropy↗

The evolution of grain boundary energy in textured and untextured Ca–doped alumina during grain growth

The role of anisotropic grain boundary energy in grain growth is investigated using textured microstructures that contain a high proportion of special grain boundaries. Textured and untextured Ca–doped alumina was prepared by slip casting inside and outside a high magnetic field, respectively. At 1600°C, the textured microstructure exhibits faster growth than the untextured microstructure and its population of low–angle boundaries increases. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is employed to measure the geometry of thermal grooves to assess the relative grain boundary energy of these systems before and after growth. In the textured microstructure, the grain boundary energy distribution narrows and shifts to a lower average energy. Conversely, the energy distribution broadens for the untextured microstructure as it grows and exhibits abnormal grain growth. Further analysis of the boundary networks neighboring abnormal grains reveals an energy incentive that facilitates their growth. These results suggest that coarsening is not the only dominant grain growth mechanism and that the system can lower its energy effectively by replacing high energy boundaries with those of low energy. The faster growth of lower energy boundaries suggests that isotropic simulations do not adequately account for anisotropic grain growth mechanisms or anisotropic mobility.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

A comparative study of two numerical approaches for solving Kim–Kim–Suzuki phase-field models

Among the standard multi-phase multi-component phase-field (PF) methods, the Kim–Kim–Suzuki (KKS) method has the advantage of decoupling interfacial energy from bulk energy and solving concentration as the conserved variable. There are two approaches to numerically solving a KKS method: the global solution approach (GSA) solves all variables in a global system simultaneously, and the local solution approach (LSA) solves phase concentrations locally using a Newton solver. This work compares the performance of LSA and GSA for solving four KKS models of increasing complexity with the finite element method using the MOOSE framework. The solution accuracy, degrees of freedom (DOFs), memory usage, and computational efficiency are compared. We find that GSA and LSA generate similar solutions, with a maximum difference of only 0.34%. For each model, LSA has a lower number of DOFs, utilizes less memory, and less wall time. Additionally, the savings of memory and wall time in LSA increase with increasing mesh density of the same model and are more pronounced in models with higher dimensionality and more nodes. However, GSA is easier to implement in existing codes and can better solve highly nonlinear systems by utilizing sophisticated solvers.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Multiscale Development and Validation of the Stainless Steel Alloy Corrosion (SStAC) Tool for High Temperature Engine Materials

The goal of this project was to create a simulation tool to assist in part design, reducing costs by eliminating the need for conservative material selection, and enabling alloy optimization to improve corrosion resistance. Thus, it helps decrease costs for existing engines and assists in the material and engine design for the engines of the future. To meet our stated goal, we developed the Stainless-Steel Alloy Corrosion (SStAC) tool, which: (1) Models corrosion of engine valves fabricated from 21-2N valve steel in an engine environment at temperatures up to 800 °C. (2) Runs in 1D for a fast estimate of the corrosion rate, and in 2D or 3D for more detailed simulations that represent any part geometry and predict the precise location and rate of corrosion and its impact on the mechanical and thermal behavior. (3) Was implemented using the open-source Multiphysics Object Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE). (4) Couples the corrosion model with mechanics and thermal transport models. The SStAC tool can predict the corrosion rate of 21-2N engine valves with less than 10% error.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Automated, high-accuracy classification of textured microstructures using a convolutional neural network

Crystallographic texture is an important descriptor of material properties but requires time-intensive electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) for identifying grain orientations. While some metrics such as grain size or grain aspect ratio can distinguish textured microstructures from untextured microstructures after significant grain growth, such morphological differences are not always visually observable. This paper explores the use of deep learning to classify experimentally measured textured microstructures without knowledge of crystallographic orientation. A deep convolutional neural network is used to extract high-order morphological features from binary images to distinguish textured microstructures from untextured microstructures. The convolutional neural network results are compared with a statistical Kolmogorov–Smirnov tests with traditional morphological metrics for describing microstructures. Results show that the convolutional neural network achieves a significantly improved classification accuracy, particularly at early stages of grain growth, highlighting the capability of deep learning to identify the subtle morphological patterns resulting from texture. The results demonstrate the potential of a convolutional neural network as a tool for reliable and automated microstructure classification with minimal preprocessing.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

A phase-field study of stainless-steel oxidation from high-temperature carbon dioxide exposure

An electrochemical phase-field model has been developed to investigate the oxidation mechanisms of the 21-2N valve stainless steel alloy exposed to carbon dioxide at 973 K. Three oxide phases observed in oxidation experiments are included in the model: Mn 3 O 4 , Cr 2 O 3 , and MnCr 2 O 4 . Local charge neutrality and the conserved current condition are assumed to include the impact of the electric potential on oxidation, though it is found to be negligible when the system is electrically isolated. The sensitivity of the oxidation processes to the values of the diffusion mobilities is examined, and the oxidation rate is calibrated against experimental data by modifying the sensitive mobilities. We find that both inward oxygen and outward metal diffusion are important for oxidation. Furthermore, by investigating the impact of the order of the initial oxide layers, we find that Cr 2 O 3 serves as a barrier to outward Mn diffusion. Moreover, controlling the initial oxide layer order can be used to limit oxidation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

An electrochemical mesoscale tool for modeling the corrosion of structural alloys by molten salt

Understanding the impact of microstructure on corrosion rates can aid the development of corrosion-resistant alloys for molten salt reactors. Here in this work, we develop an electrochemical phase-field model for capturing the microstructure-dependent corrosion of structural alloys by molten salts. As a demonstration problem, we apply this model to capture the selective depletion of Cr from Ni-Cr grain boundaries during corrosion in molten FLiBe salt. We perform sensitivity analysis and model verification on 1D simulations to confirm that the model predicts diffusion-limited kinetics. The model is validated using 1D, 2D, and 3D simulations against experimental data for Ni-5Cr and Ni-20Cr corrosion in molten FLiBe. The 1D simulations predict the corrosion behavior with reasonable accuracy when using an effective diffusion coefficient that accurately represents the grain boundary diffusion. 2D simulations that represent the grain structure underpredict the corrosion. 3D simulations that represent the grain structure predict the corrosion with reasonable accuracy. The corrosion rate predicted by the 3D simulations is proportional to the average grain size at the alloy/salt interface.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Survey of Relevant Data from the MSRP to Guide Development of MSR Chemistry Modeling Benchmarks

The Multiphysics Applications technical area of the Nuclear Energy Advanced Modeling and Simulation (NEAMS) program is tasked with assessing, demonstrating, and applying NEAMS tools in solving multiphysics problems of nuclear reactors, such as liquid-fueled molten salt reactors (MSRs), which are the focus of this report. MSRs are actively being pursued as a potential candidate for power and heat generation by the nuclear industry. However, the inherent multiphysics nature of liquid-fueled MSRs, stemming from the strong interrelationship of neutronics, thermal fluids, and chemistry phenomena, provides unique challenges in modeling and simulation (mod/sim). Therefore, it will be important to develop mod/sim tools with varying types of multiphysics coupling that depend on the problem. The current work is focused on the initiation and development of MSR chemistry modeling benchmarks useful for validating current and potential future NEAMS tools. Development of such benchmarks include the following actions: 1) Summarize available chemistry data from the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) MSR Program (MSRP) including operation of the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE) and design studies for the Molten Salt Breeder Reactor (MSBR) concept; 2) Recommend simulation problems in MSR chemistry mod/sim based on (1); 3) Assess the current state of NEAMS tools that may support (2); 4) Demonstrate and validate the capabilities of the NEAMS tools in (3) while providing iterative feedback on future code development activities. The objective of this report is to initiate this effort by completing actions (1) and (2), which are discussed in Section 2. An overview of the relevant available MSRE experimental data is provided with examples of how this data may be useful in chemistry mod/sim problems, with the caveat that most of this data is over 50 years old, therefore some problem details as well as uncertainty estimates are often not provided. In Section 3, the current state of NEAMS tools is assessed for potential use in these mod/sim problems, with considerations for future code development activities, supporting action (3). Future work supporting this project under NEAMS may include a deeper dive into the specific phenomena discussed here including tasks such as the compilation of additional available data, updates in code development activities, and ultimately the demonstration and validation of these tools, supporting action (4).

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Engineering grain boundary anisotropy to elucidate grain growth behavior in alumina

Current grain growth models have evolved to account for the relationship between grain boundary energy/mobility anisotropy and the five degrees of grain boundary character. However, the role of grain boundary networks on overall growth kinetics remains poorly understood. To experimentally investigate this problem, a highly textured Al 2 O 3 was fabricated by colloidal casting in a strong magnetic field to engineer a unique spatial distribution of grain boundary character. Microstructural evolution was quantified and compared to an untextured sample. From this comparison, a prevalence of (0001)/(0001) terminated grain boundaries with anisotropic networks were identified in the textured sample. These boundaries and their networks were found to be driving grain growth at a faster rate than predicted by models. These findings will allow better modelling of grain growth in real systems by experimentally exploring the impact thereon of grain boundary plane anisotropy and relative energy/mobility differences between neighboring boundaries.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Calculating the grain boundary inclination of voxelated grain structures using a smoothing algorithm

We have developed a flexible method for calculating the grain boundary (GB) inclinations of voxelated grain structure data using smoothing algorithms. We compared the performance of four algorithms: the linear interpolation, Allen–Cahn, level-set, and vertex algorithms. We assessed their accuracy using 2D and 3D cases with known inclinations. The vertex algorithm provided the best balance between accuracy and efficiency for 2D structures while the linear interpolation algorithm provided the best balance for 3D structures. We compared the GB inclinations calculated using our smoothing method on a 3D high energy X-ray diffraction microscopy (HEDM) dataset to those determined by meshing the GBs. The two approaches determined similar GB plane distributions, though they varied significantly at triple junctions. In conclusion, the smoothing method was demonstrated for two sources of 3D voxelated grain structures: HEDM data and results from Monte Carlo Potts grain growth simulations.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

The effect of stress on the migration of He gas bubbles under a thermal gradient in Fe by phase-field modeling

Here a phase-field model is parameterized to study the effect of elastic stresses on the migration of He gas bubbles in Fe under a temperature gradient. Stresses caused by the gas bubble pressure and residual stress in the Fe matrix are considered. The dependence of He bubble migration velocity on the magnitude of the residual stress, average temperature, temperature gradient, and bubble size is measured. In agreement with a theoretical model based on surface diffusion, simulation results demonstrate that He bubbles move towards the high temperature region with velocities in Fe that are orders of magnitude faster than previously reported in UO 2 . It is found that local stresses in the matrix caused by the He bubble have negligible effect on the bubble migration process; however, residual stresses in the Fe matrix, potentially caused by processing or irradiation, can modestly modify bubble kinetics through pressure dependence of the He diffusion coefficients. Compressive residual stress decreases diffusion coefficients for bulk and surface diffusion mechanisms, thus reducing the migration velocity of the gas bubble. In contrast, tensile residual stress increases the diffusion coefficients, resulting in an increase in the gas bubble migration velocity. This pressure dependence is also consistent with a theoretical model. This phase field model lays the foundation for analysis of bubble coalescence-induced fracture in He bubble-containing steels.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Thermal Energy Transport in Oxide Nuclear Fuel

To efficiently capture the energy of the nuclear bond, advanced nuclear reactor concepts seek solid fuels that must withstand unprecedented temperature and radiation extremes. In these advanced fuels, thermal energy transport under irradiation is directly related to reactor performance as well as reactor safety. The science of thermal transport in nuclear fuel is a grand challenge as a result of both computational and experimental complexities. Here we provide a comprehensive review of thermal transport research on two actinide oxides: one currently in use in commercial nuclear reactors, uranium dioxide (UO 2 ), and one advanced fuel candidate material, thorium dioxide (ThO 2 ). In both materials, heat is carried by lattice waves or phonons. Crystalline defects caused by fission events effectively scatter phonons and lead to a degradation in fuel performance over time. Bolstered by new computational and experimental tools, researchers are now developing the foundational work necessary to accurately model and ultimately control thermal transport in advanced nuclear fuels. We begin by reviewing research aimed at understanding thermal transport in perfect single crystals. The absence of defects enables studies that focus on the fundamental aspects of phonon transport. Next, we review research that targets defect generation and evolution. Here the focus is on ion irradiation studies used as surrogates for damage caused by fission products. We end this review with a discussion of modeling and experimental efforts directed at predicting and validating mesoscale thermal transport in the presence of irradiation defects. While efforts in these research areas have been robust, challenging work remains in developing holistic tools to capture and predict thermal energy transport across widely varying environmental conditions.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Oxidation kinetics and microstructure evolution of high Mn stainless-steel alloy in CO 2 at 700 °C

Oxidation kinetics and scale formation were examined in 21–2N Stainless Steel alloys in a CO 2 environment at 700 °C. Several characterization techniques were used to identify the morphology, crystallographic structure, and chemical composition of the oxide scale formation during exposures up to 1925 h. High manganese content played an important role in homogenous oxide scale formation of Mn 3 O 4 and MnCr 2 O 4 at the scale/gas and scale/alloy interfaces and as an FCC stabilizer in the alloy. Depletion of Mn resulted in an FCC to BCC phase transformation at the scale/alloy interface. No carburization was observed, indicating that the oxide layer is preventing carbon uptake.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗