Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Thomas, Sara

Publications and source records attributed to Thomas, Sara.

Method for Real-Time Salt Aerosol Concentration and Size Measurements for Molten Salt Reactor Safety Assessments

Licensing a new nuclear reactor involves evaluating credible accident scenarios by developing models that simulate accident progression to predict possible outcomes and their impact on safety. The formation of radionuclide-bearing aerosols in the respirable size range can significantly affect dose consequence and threaten human health and is therefore a focus of nuclear reactor safety assessments. Recent reviews of the literature identified a lack of existing experimental data describing the mechanisms of formation and properties (size, concentration, and composition) of radionuclide-bearing aerosols that may be produced from molten salt reactor (MSR) facilities during postulated accident scenarios. Experiments on aerosol formation from molten salt systems are a high priority need that will support MSR licensing by indicating the radiological consequences of aerosol formation and providing the data required for model development and validation. The evolving conditions that occur during a MSR accident, such as a spill of molten fuel salt, may affect aerosol formation mechanisms and aerosol properties over time. There is a need to conduct experiments that simulate credible MSR accidents in a laboratory to generate aerosols with realistic characteristics and behaviors and a need to measure these aerosols in real time under accident-relevant conditions. This report describes the development of a method that can be used to quantify the size and concentration of salt aerosol particles that form from molten salt systems in real time. This method will be employed in future integral effects tests that are conducted at an engineering scale to simulate realistic MSR accidents and in future separate effects tests that will provide mechanistic insight into aerosol formation and properties to support process model development.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Thermochemical Modeling of Radionuclide Vapor-Liquid Equilibria in Sodium Pools for SFR Mechanistic Source Term Analysis

Mechanistic source term (MST) analysis of sodium fast reactors (SFR) requires understanding of various radionuclide (RN) transport phenomena influencing potential releases from the fuel to the environment. One such phenomenon includes the retention or release of RNs from the sodium coolant pool, representing the step after possible fuel failures and influencing transport to the cover gas region. Thermodynamic vapor-liquid equilibria (VLE) calculations were performed on systems representing SFR sodium pools containing oxygen impurities and radionuclide (RN) inventories. First, an assessment and recreation of a previously developed thermodynamic database was completed, including updates to thermodynamic parameters. The RN inventories used in VLE calculations represented hypothetical source terms that might be released to the pool during previously analyzed fuel failure scenarios. The calculations were performed for all possible combinations of sodium pool size (i.e., total oxygen) and number of failed fuel pins (i.e., total RNs). In this way, multiple ratios of the RN relative to the oxygen impurity (RN:O) were compared for their impact on RN volatility, which is discussed in terms of the vapor fraction (VF), defined as the fraction of the RN that is calculated to exist in the vapor phase at equilibrium above condensed phases of that element. Similar trends in VLE behavior are seen in the equilibrium calculation results for elements of similar chemistry, and for some element types, it was found that the RN:O ratio can be important due to oxide formation, which typically exist in the condensed phase.

Shahbazi, Shayan↗

Integrated Process Testing of MSR Salt Spill Accidents

Part of the licensing process for new nuclear reactors requires vendors to assess the potential consequences of identified accident scenarios using accident progression modeling. The accident scenario that will likely be evaluated by all molten salt reactor (MSR) developers is a spill of radionuclide-bearing fuel salt onto the reactor containment floor (i.e., a salt spill accident). The development of accident progression models requires experimental data to inform which processes to incorporate, to enable the calculation of parameters to model these processes, and to validate the model predictions. The data should quantify the sensitivities of key processes (e.g., molten salt spreading, heat transfer, containment structure corrosion, radionuclide vaporization, and aerosol generation) towards the initial conditions of the spill, the ambient environment, and the features of the containment. In addition, results from integrated process tests that quantify coupled processes are required to validate systems-level models. This report documents results from integrated process tests conducted on simulated molten salt spill accidents. The generated experimental data simultaneously quantify the heat transfer behavior of the spilled salt, compositional changes to the bulk salt, and the release of surrogate fission products from the spilled salt as aerosol particles. All tests that were conducted used FLiNaK doped with surrogate fission products, and the variables that were evaluated included the initial salt temperature and the concentration of surrogate fission products present in the salt. The major accomplishments of this work include identifying surrogate fuel salt compositions that provide insight into the dispersal behavior of radionuclides of potential significance to the source term, employing previously developed methods and measurement techniques to simultaneously measure key processes, generating data on the coupled processes of molten salt heat transfer and surrogate fission product release as aerosol particles, demonstrating new test methods for real-time monitoring of the flow rate of the spill and aerosol size quantification in an argon atmosphere, and developing a mass transfer model for cesium and iodine release from molten FLiNaK to provide insight into aerosol formation by vapor condensation. The same methodology applied herein can be employed to study different salt compositions of interest to MSR developers, different environmental conditions, and other variables that are relevant to postulated accident scenarios. The insights gained from these integrated process tests conducted at a laboratory scale will be incorporated into future integral effects tests conducted at an engineering scale.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Progress on Long-Term Objectives for the Development of Advanced Reactor Mechanistic Source Term Modeling and Simulation Tools

To assist both the advanced reactor industry and U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) in the pursuit of reactor design and licensing, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Nuclear Energy Advanced Modeling and Simulation (NEAMS) program has established a mechanistic source term (MST) research project under the auspices of the Multiphysics Applications technical area. MST analysis is central to the reactor licensing process and a focus of the NRC regarding their mission to provide reasonable assurance of adequate protection of public health and safety and environment. The MST research project is a collaboration between Argonne National Laboratory (Argonne) and Sandia National Laboratories (SNL) with a high-level objective to coordinate the development of comprehensive advanced reactor MST mod/sim capabilities to support risk-informed design and licensing decisions. As part of this effort, an MST mod/sim development pathway was developed in FY21, which outlines the high-level objectives and near-term tasks necessary to achieve the project objectives. Since publication of the development pathway, Argonne and SNL have focused initial efforts on addressing the “near-term tasks” outlined in the report, and the current work provides a status update of the progress achieved in FY22. This report is a progress update on 6 tasks supporting molten salt reactor (MSR) and sodium fast reactor (SFR) MST analyses which were initiated in FY22 as recommended high priority near-term tasks. These tasks were continued into FY23 as they also support previously recommended long-term development objectives to advance MST analyses for these advanced reactors.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Conceptual Design of Engineering-Scale Molten Salt Spill Tests to Support Molten Salt Reactor Licensing

Nuclear accident progression analysis codes for reactor licensing must be validated using experimental data that was generated at a large enough scale so that the results are representative of full-scale accidents. This report describes a conceptual design of engineering-scale molten salt spill tests that will provide the necessary datasets to support molten salt reactor (MSR) licensing. Design considerations, salt compositions, test variables, processes to be quantified, and suitable measurement techniques are presented and discussed. Aspects of the conceptual engineering-scale molten salt spill test design presented in this report were made using insights from recent laboratory-scale molten salt spill tests conducted at Argonne. Additional input from model developers, MSR vendors, and technical experts will benefit the design of the proposed engineering-scale molten salt spill tests.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Modeling Radionuclide Vaporization from Sodium Pools for SFR Mechanistic Source Term Analysis

To assist both the advanced reactor industry and U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) in the pursuit of reactor design and licensing, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Nuclear Energy Advanced Modeling and Simulation (NEAMS) program has established a mechanistic source term (MST) research project under the Multiphysics Applications technical area. As part of this effort, an MST mod/sim development pathway was developed in FY21 under the NEAMS program, which outlines the high-level objectives and near-term tasks necessary to achieve the project objectives. One such recommended task was the assessment of a previously developed thermodynamic database to model radionuclide vaporization from liquid sodium pools (specifically in the context of MST analyses), which is the focus of this topic report. As such, a thermodynamic database was created in FactSage for liquid sodium pools containing oxygen and relevant elements which represent radionuclides pertinent to MST analyses. The database was demonstrated in calculating vapor fraction curves for each element in the system at concentrations relevant to SFR MST.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

MSR Salt Spill Accident Testing Using Eutectic NaCl-UCl 3

Assessing the potential consequences of identified accident scenarios is an essential part of the licensing process for a new nuclear reactor and is achieved by using accident progression models. A likely accident scenario that will be evaluated by developers of molten salt reactors (MSRs) is a spill of radionuclide-bearing fuel salt onto the reactor containment floor (i.e., a salt spill accident). Models to determine the consequences of a molten salt spill accident need to be parameterized and validated using experimental data, but little experimental effort has been dedicated to fill these data gaps to date. Specifically, data is needed to enable model development for individual processes (e.g., spreading, heat transfer, corrosion, radionuclide vaporization, and aerosol generation) that quantifies the sensitivities towards the initial conditions of the spill, the ambient environment, and the features of the containment. In addition, integrated experiments that simulate salt spill accidents will need to be conducted to provide insight into coupled processes and data for model validation, but these experiments will require the use of proven methods to quantify the processes under evaluation.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

State of Knowledge on Aerosols and Bubble Transport for Mechanistic Source Term Analysis of Molten Salt Reactors

A comprehensive review of the current state of knowledge surrounding molten salt aerosol behavior and bubble transport in molten salt systems relevant to mechanistic source term (MST) analyses of molten salt reactors (MSR) and fluoride high temperature reactors (FHR) was provided. Although relatively little experimental work has been carried out on investigating these phenomena in molten salts compared to that for other nuclear fluids of interest (e.g., aqueous, sodium), the amount of work that has been reported still provides a baseline understanding to inform and design future experimental campaigns on these topics. The bulk of this data is derived from the Molten Salt Reactor Program (MSRP) which was carried out at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) nearly 50 years ago, leading to the successful operation of the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE). Many other related research efforts are also highlighted in this review, such as recent efforts under the DOE:NE Advanced Reactor Technology (ART) MSR Campaign. The goal of this report is to provide a foundation for modelers to base assumptions on, as well as to make recommendations to experimentalists attempting to close information gaps. As such, Section 4 contains recommendations for future experimental work that may be needed to close current information gaps related to MST modeling of MSRs. Additionally, given the flowing fuel nature of MSRs, the relevance of aerosol and bubble transport behavior in molten salts goes beyond just MST modeling, evidenced by experiences with the pump bowl and off-gas system of the MSRE.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Progress on Near-Term Tasks for the Development of Advanced Reactor Mechanistic Source Term Modeling and Simulation Tools

To assist both the advanced reactor industry and U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) in the pursuit of reactor design and licensing, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Nuclear Energy Advanced Modeling and Simulation (NEAMS) program has established a mechanistic source term (MST) research project under the auspices of the Multiphysics Applications technical area. MST analysis is central to the reactor licensing process and a focus of the NRC regarding their mission to provide reasonable assurance of adequate protection of public health and safety and environment. The MST research project is a collaboration between Argonne National Laboratory (Argonne) and Sandia National Laboratories (SNL) with a high-level objective to coordinate the development of comprehensive advanced reactor MST mod/sim capabilities to support risk-informed design and licensing decisions.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Electrochemical Corrosion of SIMFUEL: Effects of dissolved H2 and noble metal particles

This report describes the results from electrochemical corrosion tests that were conducted using simulated spent fuel (SIMFUEL) materials comprised of UO2 and surrogate fission products. Two SIMFUEL compositions were tested to quantify the effect of noble metal inclusions and dissolved H2 on the UO2 dissolution rate. One material consisted of UO2 with added lanthanide oxides (UO2 N) and the other consisted of UO2 with added lanthanide oxides and noble metals (UO2-H) at concentrations to simulate high burnup fuel. The electrochemical corrosion tests on the SIMFUEL materials were conducted in aqueous electrolyte solutions (pH 10) that were either saturated with air or purged with a H2/Ar gas mixture to maintain a constant dissolved H2 concentration. The results from electrochemical corrosion tests on SIMFUEL can be applied to qualitatively understand and also quantify the separate effects of water chemistry and fuel composition on the degradation behavior of the UO2 matrix. Open circuit potential (OCP) measurements on a SIMFUEL material of known composition (i.e., known fraction of NMPs at the fuel surface) immersed in a known solution chemistry (i.e., pH, Eh, [O2], [H2]) at known temperature provide qualitative insight into the degradation behavior of the UO2 matrix. If the OCP is above the threshold potential at which the oxidative dissolution of U(IV) to U(VI) occurs, the SNF is expected to degrade by oxidative processes under the experimental conditions. The net currents that are measured during potentiostatic tests, during which the surface potential of the SIMFUEL material is fixed by a potentiostat, can be used to quantify the UO2 degradation rate and optimize the rate constant values used in the Fuel Matrix Degradation Model (FMDM) for half reactions that occur on the SNF surface. Specifically, electrochemical measurements enable the estimation of the total anodic current at ECORR–which is the surface potential at which the total anodic and total cathodic currents are equal–so that the rate constant values for key reactions can be calculated. The open circuit potential measurements, potentiostatic tests, surface property measurements (scanning electron microscopy images and electrochemical impedence spectroscopy plots), and solution elemental composition analyses are being performed to update and optimize the FMDM. A case study is presented herein to show how electrochemical corrosion test results and accompanying characterization results for the UO2 N material in air-saturated solution can be used to validate the SNF surface reaction module of the FMDM. Future electrochemical tests will be conducted to provide quantitative information on the effects of NM content (burnup), H2 concentration, water chemistry, temperature, and galvanic couples with cladding and EBS alloys on UO2 degradation that can be used to improve the accuracy and functionality of the FMDM.

Thomas, Sara↗

Modeling Molten Salt Spreading and Heat Transfer using MELTSPREAD – Model Development Updates

This report summarizes spreading and heat transfer results calculated using MELTSPREAD for a scenario of molten FLiNaK spilling onto a flat stainless steel substrate that was inspired by the “maximum credible accident” scenario of the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE). MELTSPREAD was developed at Argonne to model the one-dimensional flowing and freezing of molten corium and was applied to model molten salts for the first time during FY21. The molten salt MELTSPREAD model that was developed during FY21 was updated as part of this work using a corrected heat of fusion value of FLiNaK and to accommodate a larger salt spill volume. The model was run with and without the inclusion of contributions from decay heat and a sensitivity analysis of initial spill conditions was performed to determine the importance of those factors on model outcome. The results provide insight into the expected spreading and heat transfer behavior of simulated and irradiated fuel salt that has been spilled and indicate aspects of the model to be revised in future versions of the MELTSPREAD model for applications to molten salt.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗