Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Soelberg, Nick

Publications and source records attributed to Soelberg, Nick.

At least 19 records

Technology Development Roadmap for Volatile Radionuclide Capture and Immobilization

An “Off-Gas and Waste Forms Strategy Workshop” was held in Washington, D.C. on January 31, and February 1, 2023, to review the current state of the art (baseline) technologies for capturing and immobilizing these volatile radionuclides in waste forms (WFs). The discussions in that workshop were used to develop a roadmap for future research and development to mature technologies that are presently not ready for use in a commercial reprocessing facility and develop and demonstrate technologies that provide more safety, more simplicity, or lower costs compared to the current baseline.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Iodine Sorption on AgZ-PAN

The Department of Energy (DOE) Nuclear Fuel Cycle and Supply Chain Program Material Recovery and Waste Form Development (MRWFD) Campaign Off-gas Sigma Team has performed research and development on iodine control and iodine waste forms for the past several years. This research and development has included iodine adsorption tests using a laboratory-scale test system containing multiple-segmented fixed beds of iodine adsorbents. Iodine capture performance has been tested using (a) non-radioactive synthetic gas mixtures blended from air, nitrogen, NO, NO 2 , water, to simulate dissolver off-gas (DOG) and vessel off-gas (VOG) streams from used nuclear fuel aqueous reprocessing, (b) inorganic and organic iodine species, and (c) different sorbents. An initial test of silver-functionalized mordenite in polyacrylonitrile matrix (AgZ-PAN) was conducted to assess if this sorbent, initially designed for selective sorption of Xe that evolves into used fuel reprocessing off-gas streams, could also be a candidate for iodine sorption. This test was conducted using the same deep-bed test system and methodologies used in many prior iodine sorption tests using other sorbents. Diatomic iodine (I2) was used as the target iodide in a gas stream containing air, NO, NO 2 , and moisture designed to simulate an aqueous reprocessing dissolver off-gas (DOG) stream.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Organic Iodine Capture from Vessel Off-gas

The Department of Energy (DOE) Nuclear Fuel Cycle and Supply Chain Program Material Recovery and Waste Form Development (MRWFD) Campaign Off-gas Sigma Team has performed research and development on iodine control and iodine waste forms for the past several years. This research and development has included iodine adsorption tests using a laboratory-scale test system containing multiple-segmented fixed beds of iodine adsorbents. Iodine capture performance has been tested using non-radioactive synthetic gas mixtures blended from air, nitrogen, NO, NO2, water, and the target iodine compounds diatomic iodine (I2), representing likely inorganic iodides, and methyl iodide (iodomethane, CH3I) and 1-iodobutane (butyl iodide) a surrogates for potential organic iodides, that could exist in dissolver off-gas (DOG) and vessel off-gas (VOG) streams from used nuclear fuel aqueous reprocessing.

12 - MGMT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE WASTE↗

Expression of Interest for off-gas system design build

Idaho National Laboratory (INL) and Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) are studying a used nuclear fuel reprocessing system that could be used to recycle used nuclear fuel by separating waste fission products from re-useable, valuable uranium that can be used in making new nuclear fuel. This process includes dissolving the mixture of uranium and fission products in a nitric and hydrofluoric acids, then using an organic extraction process to remove and recover the uranium. The waste fission products remain in the acidic aqueous “raffinate” stream.” The fission products in this raffinate waste stream are expected to require stabilization in a vitrified glass waste form for safe disposal. INL and PNNL plan to construct and operate a facility in which to test the performance of the electric melter process that would receive a non-radioactive but chemically similar simulant of this raffinate. This test system will be located at INL in or near Idaho Falls, ID. In the melter, which operates at a temperature of about 1,050 to 1,150oC, the water, nitric acid, and other volatile and semi-volatile materials evolve into an off-gas stream, while the fission products (in this case, non-radioactive simulants of fission products) are melted with glass forming chemicals into a molten glass. Upon cooling, the molten glass provides a durable waste form for long-term disposal. Expressions of interest are requested from companies who would like to receive a request for proposal to design and build this off-gas system. We expect to request proposals and desire to award a contract prior to the end of September 2019.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Iodobutane Deep Bed Adsorption Test Report

The Department of Energy (DOE) Nuclear Technology Research and Development (NTRD) Program Material Recovery and Waste Form Development (MRWFD) Campaign Off-gas Sigma Team has supported research and development on iodine control and iodine waste forms for the past several years. As a part of this on-going research, two deep-bed iodobutane adsorption tests have been performed with higher NO x levels. High (>1,000) iodine decontamination factors (DFs, the ratios of the inlet iodine concentrations divided by the outlet iodine concentrations, when the gas flowrate is constant) were achieved with both the silver aerogel and silver zeolite sorbents. The iodine adsorption mass transfer zone (the depth of the sorbent bed in which adsorption is occurring at any specific time) for these tests was estimated at 4 inches for both sorbents under the test conditions. Silver utilization for silver aerogel sorbent reached 41% (up to 12 g adsorbed iodine per 100 g silver aerogel sorbent), while silver utilization reached 43% (up to 6.8 g adsorbed iodine per 100 g silver zeolite sorbent). These values are generally consistent with results for prior methyl iodide adsorption tests. The results also indicate that, during iodine adsorption process, the organic iodide molecule decomposes so that the iodine can be adsorbed. Even when sorbent breakthrough is reached, the organic iodide molecule continues to decompose; and the unadsorbed iodine that passes through bed is no longer in the form of the original organic iodide; but in the form of iodine compounds that are soluble in NaOH solutions, such as HI or I 2 . This research and development has included iodine adsorption tests using a laboratory-scale test system containing segmented fixed beds of iodine adsorbents in series. Non-radioactive synthetic gas mixtures were blended from air, nitrogen, NO, NO 2 , water, and the target iodine compounds to represent dissolver off-gas (DOG) streams from used nuclear fuel aqueous reprocessing.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Milestone Report - Data Requirements and Test System Needs for Development of an Integrated Off-Gas Treatment System

In fiscal year 2016 an Engineering Evaluation of an integrated off-gas system was conducted. This study resulted in a report entitled Engineering Evaluation of an Integrated Off-Gas Treatment System for Used Nuclear Fuel Reprocessing Facilities (Jubin et al. 2016a), from here referred to as the “Engineering Evaluation.” This study focused on the capture and retention of the volatile radionuclides ( 3 H, 14 C, 85 Kr, and 129 I), selected semi-volatile radionuclides, specifically 106 Ru, and chemical species like NO and NO 2 generated during the dissolution of the used nuclear fuel. The study examined the design of the combined head-end off-gas streams and the vessel off-gas stream. The study drew upon the available literature to conduct the equipment sizing and sorbent usage. A number of assumptions were required to complete this analysis and major gaps in the available data were identified that, if resolved, could increase the fidelity of the engineering design.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

IODINE ADSORPTION IN FIXED BED ADSORBER TESTS

I-129 emissions control is needed for used fuel aqueous reprocessing. I-129 capture has been studied for 40 years; Two sorbents tested in recent years – Silver Zeolite (AgZ) and silver-functionalized Aerogel (AGAero). Results show needed iodine adsorption efficiencies are possible, DFs up to10,000. Mass transfer zone (MTZ) depths ~2 in. for I2 and 8 in. for CH3I, but increase over time; deeper sorbent beds needed for efficient CH3I capture. Ag utilization between 10-70% for most test durations; lower for higher NOx. Iodine sorption capacities: ~10 g/100 AgZ and ~20 g/100 g AgAero; lower for high NOx. Nearly all adsorbed I was physisorbed iodine for I2 and CH3I.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Milestone report - M4FT-16OR03010723 - Joint Test Plan to Identify the Gaseous By-Products of CH3I Loading on AgZ

The objective of this test plan is to describe research to determine the gaseous by-products of the adsorption of CH 3 I on hydrogen reduced silver exchanged mordenite (AgZ). An initial test plan was developed in FY 2012 to discern the chemical reactions that occur when organic iodides interact with the other components in a prototypical off-gas in the presence of silver-loaded zeolite, AgZ. CH 3 I is used as a surrogate for organic iodides that could be present in the gas streams, although follow-on tests include potentially using other organic iodides as well. This test plan was updated to reflect test results obtained during FY 2013 to FY 2015 and was further adjusted based on additional information from the relevant literature obtained since 2012. Four main questions are listed that need to be answered to verify earlier test results that indicate that CH 3 I and I 2 are present in the effluent from a column containing AgZ.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

IWTU TI-102 – Part 2 Sample Analyses

Samples from the Integrated Waste Treatment Unit (IWTU) were collected for analysis after TI-102 – Part 2 shutdown. The scope of analyses performed by Battelle Energy Alliance (BEA) included: • Scanning electron micrography (SEM) and energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) analysis for particle morphology, particle size, and elemental composition estimates • Loss on ignition (LOI) for determining the fraction that is coke and not bauxite • Proximate and ultimate analysis • Particle-size analysis using sieve trays • Bulk and particle density • Elemental analysis • Solubility • X-ray diffraction for mineralogy analysis • Thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA). This report provides the results of those analyses.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Performance Criteria for Capture and/or Immobilization Technologies - Milestone Report

The capture and subsequent immobilization of the four regulated volatile radionuclides ( 3 H, 14 C, 85 Kr, and 129 I) from the off-gas streams of a used nuclear fuel (UNF) reprocessing facility has been a topic of substantial research interest for the US Department of Energy and its international colleagues. Removal of some or all of these radionuclides (e.g., based upon fuel burnup, fuel type, cooling time) from the plant effluent streams prior to discharge to the environment is required to meet regulations set forth by the US Environmental Protection Agency. Upon removal, the radionuclide, as well as associated sorbents that cannot be cost-effectively regenerated, is destined for conversion to a waste form. Research in separation and capture methodologies has included a wide range of technologies, including liquid caustic scrubbing systems, solid adsorbents, and cryogenic distillation. The studies of waste forms have been correspondingly diverse. In considering the technologies available for future development and implementation of both sorbents and waste forms, it is necessary to identify benchmark measures of performance to evaluate objectively each sorbent system or waste form.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Milestone Report - M3FT-15OR03120213 - A Literature Survey to Identify Potentially Problematic Volatile Iodine-Bearing Species Present in Off-Gas Streams

Four radionuclides have been identified as being sufficiently volatile in the reprocessing of nuclear fuel that their gaseous release needs to be controlled to meet U.S. regulatory requirements (Jubin et al. 2011, 2012). These radionuclides are 3 H, 14 C, 85 Kr, and 129 I. Of these, 129 I has the longest half-life and potentially highest biological impact. Accordingly, control of the release of 129 I is most critical with respect to U.S. regulations for the release of radioactive material in stack emissions. Current U.S. Environmental Protection Agency regulation governing nuclear facilities (40 CFR 190) states that the total quantity of radioactive materials entering the general environment from the entire uranium fuel cycle, per gigawatt-year of electrical energy produced by the fuel cycle, must contain less than 5 mCi of 129 I. The study of inorganic iodide in off-gas systems has been almost exclusively limited to I 2 , and the focus of organic iodide studies has been CH 3 I.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Phase 2 Methyl Iodide Deep-Bed Adsorption Tests

Nuclear fission produces fission products (FPs) and activation products, including iodine-129, which could evolve into used fuel reprocessing facility off-gas systems, and could require off-gas control to limit air emissions to levels within acceptable emission limits. Research, demonstrations, and some reprocessing plant experience have indicated that diatomic iodine can be captured with efficiencies high enough to meet regulatory requirements. Research on the capture of organic iodides has also been performed, but to a lesser extent. Several questions remain open regarding the capture of iodine bound in organic compounds. Deep-bed methyl iodide adsorption testing has progressed according to a multi-laboratory methyl iodide adsorption test plan. This report summarizes the second phase of methyl iodide adsorption work performed according to this test plan using the deep-bed iodine adsorption test system at the Idaho National Laboratory (INL), performed during the second half of Fiscal Year (FY) 2014. Test results continue to show that methyl iodide adsorption using AgZ can achieve total iodine decontamination factors (DFs, ratios of uncontrolled and controlled total iodine levels) above 1,000, until breakthrough occurred. However, mass transfer zone depths are deeper for methyl iodide adsorption compared to diatomic iodine (I2) adsorption. Methyl iodide DFs for the Ag Aerogel test adsorption efficiencies were less than 1,000, and the methyl iodide mass transfer zone depth exceeded 8 inches. Additional deep-bed testing and analyses are recommended to (a) expand the data base for methyl iodide adsorption under various conditions specified in the methyl iodide test plan, and (b) provide more data for evaluating organic iodide reactions and reaction byproducts for different potential adsorption conditions.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Studies on the Mechanisms of Methyl Iodide Adsorption and Iodine Retention on Silver-Mordenite

Silver-containing mordenite (MOR) is a longstanding benchmark for radioiodine capture, reacting with molecular iodine (I 2 ) to form AgI. However the mechanisms for organoiodine capture are not well understood. Here we investigate the capture of methyl iodide from complex mixed gas streams by combining chemical analysis of the effluent gas stream with in depth characterization of the recovered sorbent.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Phase 1 Methyl Iodide Deep-Bed Adsorption Tests

Nuclear fission results in the production of fission products (FPs) and activation products including iodine-129, which could evolve into used fuel reprocessing facility off-gas systems, and could require off-gas control to limit air emissions to levels within acceptable emission limits. Research, demonstrations, and some reprocessing plant experience have indicated that diatomic iodine can be captured with efficiencies high enough to meet regulatory requirements. Research on the capture of organic iodides has also been performed, but to a lesser extent [Jubin 2012b]. Several questions remain open regarding the capture of iodine bound in organic compounds. Deep-bed methyl iodide adsorption testing has progressed according to a multi-laboratory methyl iodide adsorption test plan. This report summarizes the first phase of methyl iodide adsorption work performed according to this test plan using the deep-bed iodine adsorption test system at the Idaho National Laboratory (INL), performed during Fiscal Year (FY) 2013 and early FY-2014. Testing has been performed to address questions posed in the test plan, and followed the testing outline in the test plan. Tests established detection limits, developed procedures for sample analysis with minimal analytical interferences, and confirmed earlier results that show that the methyl iodide reacts when in contact with the AgZ sorbent, and not significantly in the gas flow upstream of the sorbent. The reaction(s) enable separation of the iodine from the organic moiety, so that the iodine can chemisorb onto the sorbent. The organic moiety can form other compounds, some of which are organic compounds that are detected and can be tentatively identified using GC-FID and GCMS. Test results also show that other gas constituents (NOx and/or H2O) can affect the methyl iodide reactions. With NOx and H2O present in the gas stream, the majority of uncaptured iodine exiting iodine-laden sorbent beds is in the form of I2 or HI, species that are soluble in NaOH scrubbing solution for iodine analysis. But when NOx and H2O are not present, then the majority of the uncaptured iodine exiting iodine-laden sorbent is in the form of methyl iodide. Methyl iodide adsorption efficiencies have been high enough so that initial DFs exceed 1,000 to 10,000. The methyl iodide mass transfer zone depths are estimated at 4-8 inches, possibly deeper than mass transfer zone depths estimated for I2 adsorption on AgZ. Additional deep-bed testing and analyses are recommended to (a) expand the data base for methyl iodide adsorption under various conditions specified in the methyl iodide test plan, and (b) provide more data for evaluating organic iodide reactions and reaction byproducts for different potential adsorption conditions.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗