Measurements of heat flux components due to charged and non-charged particles in DIII-D divertor near and under detachment
Not Available
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Engineering topics
Shafer, M. W.
Publications and source records attributed to Shafer, M. W..
Direct measurement of the electron turbulence-broadening edge transport barrier to facilitate core–edge integration in tokamak fusion plasmas
Abstract The integration of a high-performance core and a dissipative divertor, or the so-called ‘core–edge integration,’ has been widely identified as a critical gap in the design of future fusion reactors. In this letter, we report, for the first time, direct experimental evidence of electron turbulence at the DIII-D H-mode pedestal that correlates with the broadening of the pedestal and thus facilitates core–edge integration. In agreement with gyrokinetic simulations, this electron turbulence is enhanced by high η e ( η e = L n / L T e , where L n is the density scale length and L T e is the electron temperature scale length), which is due to a strong shift between the density and temperature pedestal profiles associated with a closed divertor. The modeled turbulence drives significant heat transport with a lower pressure gradient that may broaden the pedestal to a greater degree than the empirical and theoretically predicted pedestal width scalings. Such a wide pedestal, coupled with a closed divertor, enables us to achieve a good core–edge scenario that integrates a high-temperature low-collisionality pedestal (pedestal top temperature T e,ped > 0.8 keV and a pedestal top collisionality ν * ped < 1) under detached divertor conditions. This paves a new path toward solving the core–edge integration issue in future fusion reactors.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
13C surface characterization of midplane and crown collector probes on DIII-D
Not Available
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Study on divertor detachment and pedestal characteristics in the DIII-D upper closed divertor
Abstract Experiments performed in DIII-D demonstrate that higher plasma current and heating power combined with impurity seeding facilitate the achievement of divertor detachment with a higher pedestal pressure and higher plasma performance in H-mode plasmas with a baffled closed divertor compared with an open divertor. Dedicated experiments were carried out to study the impact of power, plasma current and impurity seeding on divertor detachment with ion B × ∇ B directed into the divertor favorable for the L–H transition. With a factor of three variation in heating power and with only D 2 puffing, no significant difference in the separatrix density at detachment onset was found. The higher heating power leads to higher impurity concentration and wider scrape-off layer (SOL) width, and reduces the detachment onset density to one similar to that in lower-power plasmas. Higher current requires higher pedestal and line-averaged densities to achieve divertor detachment; however, the increase in separatrix density at increasing plasma current is found to be less pronounced. Initial calculations found that both power scan and plasma current scan datasets are qualitatively consistent with theory after considering the change in impurity concentration and heat flux width. This also motivates the future extensive study of transport and divertor impurity behavior in order to have a quantitative comparison between experiment and theory. Compared with an open divertor, a closed divertor facilitates detachment onset at ∼40% lower line-averaged plasma density. Additional N 2 seeding facilitates the achievement of detachment at a lower separatrix density and thus a higher pedestal temperature, which is beneficial for advanced tokamak scenarios. Higher heating power requires a higher N 2 puffing rate to achieve the same degree of detachment, while a higher N 2 puffing rate leads to lower detachment onset line-averaged density, both of which agree with theory. In contrast to the narrower pedestal in an open divertor approaching detachment, the pedestal density width in a closed divertor increases with density. The density gradient increases with line-averaged density at higher plasma current, but remains nearly unchanged at lower plasma current. In particular, compared with discharges with low power, at high heating power the pedestal density gradient is much weaker, while the SOL density is significantly higher and wider. At the same plasma current, both pedestal pressure gradient and temperature gradient decrease linearly with the line-averaged density but remain similar across different heating powers. Even with different plasma current and heating power, the normalized pressure gradient remains identical. As a result, achievement of divertor detachment with a higher pedestal pressure and higher plasma performance is shown in a closed divertor, which is important for improving core–edge integration as one of the critical issues for future tokamak fusion reactors.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Influence of triangularity on the plasma response to resonant magnetic perturbations
The effect of the axisymmetric plasma shape on the non-axisymmetric plasma response to resonant magnetic perturbations is investigated in experiment and modeling for the DIII-D, EAST and ASDEX Upgrade tokamaks. Systematically modeling the effect of the triangularity, whilst keeping other equilibrium quantities largely unchanged, reveals that the plasma response is strongly suppressed at high triangularity compared to that at low triangularity. This is validated through targeted comparison with experiments at DIII-D, EAST, and ASDEX Upgrade. DIII-D and EAST magnetic measurements are used to validate simulations, while at ASDEX Upgrade the plasma edge displacement is measured. Both experiments and modeling find a reduced magnetic plasma response on the high-field side at high triangularity across devices. Multi-modal analysis of the simulation results extracts the mode structure and applied spectrum dependence of each mode. The amplitude of the dominant mode reveals similar trends with the edge resonance and radial displacement near the X-point, which suggests that the multi-mode plasma response provides another way to understand the edge localized mode (ELM) control physics. The plasma response is strongly reduced at high triangularity compared to that at low triangularity, which implies different ELM control effects as shaping is varied. Furthermore, these findings indicate that the plasma shape should be taken into consideration when designing an RMP-ELM control strategy in experiment, and that predictive plasma response calculations can be used to maximize access to RMP-ELM control in future devices by maximizing the coupling between coils and the plasma.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Achievements of actively controlled divertor detachment compatible with sustained high confinement core in DIII-D and EAST
The compatibility of efficient divertor detachment with high-performance core plasma is vital to the development of magnetically controlled fusion energy. The joint research on the EAST and DIII-D tokamaks demonstrates successful integration of divertor detachment with excellent core plasma confinement quality, a milestone towards solving the critical plasma–wall-interaction (PWI) issue and core-edge integration for ITER and future reactors. In EAST, actively controlled partial detachment with T et,div ~ 5 eV around the strike point and H 98 > 1 in different H-mode scenarios including the high β P H-mode scenario have been achieved with ITER-like tungsten divertor, by optimizing the detachment access condition and performing detailed experiments for core-edge integration. For active long-pulse detachment feedback control, a 30 s H-mode operation with detachment-control duration being 25 s has been successfully achieved in EAST. DIII-D has achieved actively controlled fully detached divertor with low plasma electron temperature (T et,div ≤ 5 eV across the entire divertor target) and low particle flux (degree of detachment, DoD > 3), simultaneously with very high core performance (β N ~3, β P > 2 and H 98 ~ 1.5) in the high βP scenario being developed for ITER and future reactors. The high-β P high confinement scenario is characterized by an internal transport barrier (ITB) at large radius and a weak edge transport barrier (ETB, or pedestal), which are synergistically self-organized. Both the high-β P scenario and impurity seeding facilitate divertor detachment. The detachment access leads to the reduction of ETB, which facilitates the development of an even stronger ITB at large radius in the high β P scenario. Thus, this strong large radius ITB enables the core confinement improvement during detachment. In conclusion, these significant joint DIII-D and EAST advances on the compatibility of high confinement core and detached divertor show a great potential for achieving a high-performance core plasma suitable for long-pulse operation of fusion reactors with controllable steady-state PWIs.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Numerical assessment of the new V-shape small-angle slot divertor on DIII-D
The small-angle slot (SAS) divertor of the DIII-D tokamak, and its upcoming upgrade, the V-shape small-angle slot (SAS-V) divertor, are numerically investigated using the SOLPS-ITER code package, including the effect of particle drifts, for a range of plasma density, heating power, strike point position in the slot, and for both magnetic field directions. The simulations show that the electron temperature near the strike point is reduced in SAS-V compared to SAS, for both magnetic field directions, such that SAS-V achieves divertor detachment at a lower value of the outboard mid-plane separatrix electron density. The detachment threshold is lower because the V-shape focuses recycling neutrals on the V-end, densifying and cooling the plasma in the slot. At sufficiently high density, the V-shape also reduces the radial gradient of the temperature profile at the target, which in turns reduces the radial electric field and the E x B drift velocities, further densifying and cooling the plasma in the slot and leading to detachment. The V-shape effect, however, is reduced for higher heating power. With more heating power, the detachment density increases, reducing the ionization mean free path of recycled neutrals, which therefore become less sensitive to target shape changes. Furthermore, this suggests that in a fusion reactor, where the heating power is high, optimization of the divertor target shape needs to be combined with other strategies to lower the detachment density, such as in-slot injection of low-Z impurities.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Observation of fully detached divertor integrated with improved core confinement for tokamak fusion plasmas
Integration of divertor detachment with a high-performance (β N ~ 3, β p > 2, H 98 ~ 1.5) core plasma has been demonstrated in DIII-D high-β p (poloidal beta) plasmas associated with a sustained core internal transport barrier (ITB) and an H-mode edge transport barrier (ETB). Such good core-edge integration has been achieved for both neon and nitrogen seeding, for both favorable and unfavorable B-field directions, independently from the impurity puffing locations, though these variations play important roles on divertor characteristics. Compared to the standard H-mode plasmas, the high-β p plasma exhibits a much wider window of detachment compatible with high confinement core. Fully detached divertor plasmas with low plasma temperature (Te < 5 eV), low particle flux, and low heat flux across the entire divertor target plate were obtained by using nitrogen seeding. This detached high-β p plasma is compatible with a newly developed detachment control system which can help optimize the nitrogen gas flow rate. Several features, i.e., the high edge safety factor in the high-β p scenario, impurity injection, closed divertor and reduced heating power requirement due to the high confinement, facilitate the achievement of full divertor detachment at lower density. Instead of degrading global performance, the divertor detachment facilitates the access to an even stronger ITB at large radius with a relatively weak ETB through self-organized synergy between ITB and ETB, leading to sustained high confinement. The strengthening of the large-radius ITB compensates for the ETB degradation associated with divertor detachment. In addition, a weak ETB naturally has smaller edge localized modes (ELMs). In particular, with neon injection, a long-period no-ELM H-mode phase has been achieved simultaneously with high-performance core and partially detached divertor plasmas. Furthermore, these results demonstrate the possibility of integrating excellent core plasma performance with an effective divertor solution, an essential step toward steady-state operation of reactor-grade plasmas.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Integration of full divertor detachment with improved core confinement for tokamak fusion plasmas
Divertor detachment offers a promising solution to the challenge of plasma-wall interactions for steady-state operation of fusion reactors. Here, we demonstrate the excellent compatibility of actively controlled full divertor detachment with a high-performance (β N ~ 3, H 98 ~ 1.5) core plasma, using high-β p (poloidal beta, β p > 2) scenario characterized by a sustained core internal transport barrier (ITB) and a modest edge transport barrier (ETB) in DIII-D tokamak. The high-β p high-confinement scenario facilitates divertor detachment which, in turn, promotes the development of an even stronger ITB at large radius with a weaker ETB. This self-organized synergy between ITB and ETB, leads to a net gain in energy confinement, in contrast to the net confinement loss caused by divertor detachment in standard H-modes. These results show the potential of integrating excellent core plasma performance with an efficient divertor solution, an essential step towards steady-state operation of reactor-grade plasmas.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Absolute calibration of the Lyman-α measurement apparatus at DIII-D
The LLAMA (Lyman-Alpha Measurement Apparatus) diagnostic was recently installed on the DIII-D tokamak [Rosenthal et al., Rev. Sci. Instrum. (submitted) (2020)]. LLAMA is a pinhole camera system with a narrow band Bragg mirror, a bandpass interference filter, and an absolute extreme ultraviolet photodiode detector array, which measures the Ly-α brightness in the toroidal direction on the inboard, high field side (HFS) and outboard, low field side (LFS). This contribution presents a setup and a procedure for an absolute calibration near the Ly-α line at 121.6 nm. The LLAMA in-vacuum components are designed as a compact, transferable setup that can be mounted in an ex situ vacuum enclosure that is equipped with an absolutely calibrated Ly-α source. The spectral purity and stability of the Ly-α source are characterized using a vacuum ultraviolet spectrometer, while the Ly-α source brightness is measured by a NIST-calibrated photodiode. The non-uniform nature of the Ly-α source emission was overcome by performing a calibration procedure that scans the Ly-α source position and employs a numerical optimization to determine the emission pattern. Nominal and measured calibration factors are determined and compared, showing agreement within their uncertainties. A first conversion of the measured signal obtained from DIII-D indicates that the Ly-α brightness on the HFS and LFS is on the order of 1020 Ph sr-1 m-2 s-1. The established calibration setup and procedure will be regularly used to re-calibrate the LLAMA during DIII-D vents to monitor possible degradation of optical components and detectors.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Observations of wall conditioning by means of boron powder injection in DIII-D H-mode plasmas
In this paper, we report observations from the DIII-D tokamak indicating that boron (B) powder injection in tokamak plasmas improves wall conditions similarly to glow discharge boronization (GDB). Isotopically enriched B powder (B 11 > 95%) was introduced gravitationally in a sequence of H-mode plasma discharges at rates up to ~160 mg s -1 for durations up to 3 s. Boron injection to cumulative amounts ≤0.1 g appeared to improve wall conditions similarly to boronization, with indications of reduced wall fueling, reduced recycling at the outer strike point and reduced impurity content at breakdown. Post-mortem analysis of graphite samples exposed to far scrape-off layer plasma fluxes during boron injection confirm the formation of a B-C layer, with average surface composition B:C ~ 1. The results suggest that injecting boron-rich powders in tokamak plasmas can effectively replenish boron films on carbon plasma facing components to improve wall conditions and extend the duration of the beneficial effects of GDB.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Improved core-edge compatibility using impurity seeding in the small angle slot (SAS) divertor at DIII-D
Impurity seeding studies in the slot divertor (SAS) at DIII-D have revealed a strong relationship between the detachment onset and pedestal characteristics with both target geometry and impurity species. N 2 seeding in the slot has led to the first simultaneous observation of detachment on the entire suite of boundary diagnostics viewing the SAS without degradation of core confinement. SOLPS-ITER simulations with D+C+N, full cross-field drifts and n-n collisions activated are performed for the first time in DIII-D to interpret the behavior. This illustrates a strong effect of divertor configuration and plasma drifts on the recycling source distribution with significant consequences on plasma flows. Flow reversal is found for both main ions and impurities affecting strongly the impurity transport and providing an explanation for the observed dependence on strike point location of the detachment onset and impurity leakage found in the experiments. Matched discharges with either nitrogen or neon injection show that while nitrogen does not significantly affect the pedestal, neon leads to increased pedestal pressure gradient and improved pedestal stability. Little nitrogen penetrates in the core, but a great amount of neon is found in the pedestal consistent with the different ionization potentials of the two impurities. This research demonstrates that neutral and impurity distributions in the divertor can be controlled through variations in strike point locations in a fixed baffle structure. Divertor geometry combined with impurity seeding enables mitigated divertor heat flux balancing core contamination and thus leading to enhanced divertor dissipation and improved core-edge compatibility which are essential for ITER and for future fusion reactors.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Separating divertor closure effects on divertor detachment and pedestal shape in DIII-D
Comparison between an open divertor and a more-closed divertor in DIII-D demonstrates detachment at an up to 40% lower pedestal density (n e,ped ) in the closed divertor, due to a combination of decreased fueling of the pedestal and increased dissipation in the scrape off layer (SOL) in the closed divertor, both resulting from increased neutral trapping in the divertor. Predicting whether the relationship between divertor closure and detachment will hold for an opaque SOL, in which the contribution of ionizing neutrals to fueling the pedestal is lessened, requires separating out the different mechanisms contributing to the density difference at detachment. A series of experiments on DIII-D characterizes matched discharges using various divertor configurations to isolate the effects of divertor closure. These experiments show detachment at up to 25% lower n e,sep in the closed divertor than the open, supported by simulations showing increased neutral trapping, and hence increased dissipation, in the closed divertor. A difference in n e,ped /n e,sep is also seen: for matched n e,sep , the closed divertor has up to 20% lower ne,ped, consistent with modeling showing a smaller ionization fraction inside the separatrix in this case. Understanding how these pieces fit together will help in develop of predictive models of pedestal density and detached divertors compatible with a high-performance core.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Predicting the rotation profile in ITER
Determining the toroidal rotation for future tokamaks like ITER is a challenging and important problem. By combining empirical scalings for the intrinsic rotation at the top of the pedestal with the expected neutral beam torque and modeling of momentum transport, the toroidal rotation profile for ITER is predicted with TGYRO using TGLF (SAT0 and SAT1). On axis rotation exceeds 20 krad s –1 and the E x B shear is significant enough to reduce turbulent transport and significantly increase confinement and fusion power when comparing to cases that ignore the effect of rotation. Here, the prediction of the rotation at the top of the pedestal is made with increased confidence due to experiments and modeling in DIII-D that have determined the importance of fast-ion and neutral particle transport effects on intrinsic rotation at this location. In particular, the effect of neutral particles on momentum transport in the pedestal region is found to be insignificant.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗