Engineering PapersSearch

Engineering topics

Rubin, S.

Publications and source records attributed to Rubin, S..

An increase of early rains in southern Israel following land-use change?

Rains at the onset of the October-April rainy season in southern Israel have steeply increased in the last 25 years relative to the previous 20 years, and are accompanied by an appreciable general increase of rainy-season rainfall. This increase in precipitation is specifically attributable to an intensification of the convection and advection processes due to afforestation and increased cultivation-induced enhancement of the daytime sensible heat flux from the generally dry surface; the enhancement proceeds from both the reduced surface albedo and the reduced soil heat flux in October, when insolation is strong. Greater daytime convection can lead to penetration of inversions capping the planetary boundary layer, while strengthened advection can furnish moist air from the Mediterranean.

Otterman, J.

Stiffnesses of a solid-rocket motor from an ambient vibration survey

Experience with many spacecraft configurations boosted by a variety of launch vehicles indicates that the maximum loads experienced throughout most of the structure are inertial in origin. These loads arise from the dynamic elastic response of the flight vehicle to the transient disturbances of launch and flight, and are highly dependent on the dynamic characteristics of both the spacecraft and the launch vehicle. It has proved to be most advantageous, in the analysis of this critical dependency of loads upon vehicle dynamic properties, to establish a mathematical model in terms of normal mode characteristics. In this way, the vibration behavior of an elastomechanical structure (or substructure) can be described by means of the so-called modal or natural degrees of freedom. The conduct of a mode survey test and the use of a suitably test-verified model in loads analyses is essential to the flight worthiness certification process of space systems. The desirability of such tests is confirmed by the fact that, almost invariably, significant deficiencies in the analytical models are revealed by the results. Therefore, this experimental program was undertaken to determine those properties of a solid-propellant rocket motor (SRM) which are required to characterize a dynamic model. Random ambient-excited accelerations were measured at a series of stations along the motor for the purpose of identifying the motor beam-like stiffnesses in bending, shear, and torsion. From a system identification point of view, it is significant that stiffness properties of a subsystem (the motor) are determined from modes of the full system (motor/stand configuration) using mode shape data of the subsystem only. This contrasts with traditional system identification approaches which rely upon complete system mode shapes.

Rubin, S.

Space shuttle pogo studies

Topics covered include: (1) pogo suppression for main propulsion subsystem operation; (2) application of quarter-scale low pressure oxidizer turbopump transfer functions; (3) pogo stability during orbital maneuvering subsystem operation; and (4) errors in frequency response measurements.

Coppolino, R. N.

Analysis of pogo on the space shuttle: Accumulator design guidelines and planar multiengine model development

The design guidelines were generated to support the selection of the baseline accumulator configuration for the space shuttle. They were based upon the elimination of the instabilities that had been predicted for the shuttle system (in the absence of accumulators) using the single-engine model. The multiengine pitch plane stability model was subsequently developed to enable a more refined analysis of the pogo problem. The results obtained with this refined model, in the absence of accumulators, indicated a generally stable system. However, it was found that reasonable adjustment of the axial motion of the feedline aft support on the external tank could induce instability of the system. This instability was eliminated by the addition of high-pressure oxidizer turbopump inlet accumulators to the system. The results obtained with the refined model did not suggest a need to alter the design guidelines that had been obtained previously. The analyses with the multiengine model also treated the question of the use of a phase margin in the system stability requirements.

Lock, M. H.

Active Suppression of Pogo on the Space Shuttle

The use of active pogo suppressors on the space shuttle was qualitatively investigated. Suppressor design concepts and the effectiveness of these designs in maintaining the stability of the shuttle vehicle were the primary concerns. Suppressor design concepts were developed by means of a series of parametric stability analyses. These two designs together with two designs provided by NASA were evaluated in detail for control effectiveness, performance relative to a passive suppression device, sensitivity of performance to feedback error, suppressor volume flow requirements, and suppressor development requirements. An active device at the high pressure oxidizer pump inlet was shown to provide a simple and effective design that is insensitive to error in the feedback signal. The sizing of an active suppressor was demonstrated to be dependent upon knowledge of the dynamic characteristics of the system.

Lock, M. H.

Passive suppression of pogo on the space shuttle

A qualitative assessment of the tendency for pogo instability of the shuttle vehicle in the absence of suppression devices, and the effectiveness of two passive suppressors (the compliant accumulator and the resistive accumulator) in counteracting any tendency toward instability is provided. In addition, the relative effectiveness of three suppressor locations (the low pressure pump (LWOP) inlet and discharge and the high pressure pump (HPOP) inlet) is also evaluated. The primary conclusion of the study is that effective pogo suppression, with passive devices, can be accomplished at the HPOP inlet location but not at the LPOP locations. Other conclusions are drawn regarding the relative effectiveness of the two accumulator types and with respect to tentative accumulator design requirements. Finally, a number of recommendations are made regarding future studies.

Lock, M. H.

Pogo suppression on space shuttle - early studies

Preliminary studies for pogo prevention on the shuttle vehicle are reported. The importance of the effect of oscillatory outflow from a hydroelastic tank is displayed in terms of excitation of normal modes for a structure containing that tank assuming its outlet is closed. Evaluation of an approximate propulsion frequency response at undamped feedline resonance reveals the conditions for which the contribution of tank outflow is destabilizing and also provides a criterion for identifying those structural modes which are of potential significance for system stability. Various finite-element and normal-mode models for hydraulic feedlines are evaluated relative to accuracy of admittances of a long line. A procedure is recommended for modeling a feed system to minimize the required number of second-order equations. Specific recommendations are made for the analytical estimation of pump cavitation compliance and a first estimate for the shuttle pumps is given. Weakness in past practices of pump testing are identified and a new three-phase program is proposed. Finally results of numerical studies on the early vehicle configuration are presented. It is concluded that an accumulator between the boost and main pump offers promise of higher effectiveness than one at the engine inlet.

Rubin, S.

New considerations for pogo prevention on space shuttle

Recommendations for improving the methodology of pogo suppression for the space shuttle include: Consideration of inter-pump location for accumulator or active device, inclusion of tank outflow effects in dynamic structural analysis, the use of simplified transfer functions in systems studies, three phase dynamic testing program for turbopump with development of dynamic flowmeters, and the use of a linearized mathematical model for engine physics studies.

Rubin, S.

Empirical evaluation of pump inlet compliance

Cavitation compliance was determined experimentally from pulsing tests on a number of rocket turbopumps. The primary test data used for this study are those for the Rocketdyne H-1, F-1, and J-2 oxidizer and fuel pumps employed on Saturn vehicles. The study shows that these data can be correlated by a particular form of nondimensionalization, the key feature of which is to divide the operating cavitation number or suction specific speed by its value at head breakdown. An expression is obtained for a best-fit curve for these data. Another set of test data for the Aerojet LR87 and 91 pumps can be correlated by a somewhat different nondimensional pump performance parameter, specifically by relating the cavitation number to its position between the head breakdown point and the point of zero slope of the head coefficient versus cavitation number. Recommendations are given for the estimation of the cavitation compliance for new designs in the Rocketdyne family of pumps.

Ghahremani, F. G.