Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Newman, Jennifer

Publications and source records attributed to Newman, Jennifer.

L-TERRA [SWR-15-34]

Lidar (light detection and ranging) instruments are often used in wind energy studies in place of meteorological towers, as they can collect measurements at higher heights than met towers and are more easily moved to different parts of a site. While lidars can accurately measure mean wind speeds, they frequently measure different values of turbulence intensity (TI) than would be measured by a cup anemometer on a tower. Discrepancies in TI values are caused by several factors, including instrument noise and volume averaging. The inability of lidars to accurately measure turbulence is a significant barrier to replacing met towers with lidars in the future. There is currently no accepted standard process for quantifying and removing these errors in lidar TI measurements. The Software is an error reduction algorithm for lidar-measured turbulence. The algorithm is trained using co-located lidar and meteorological tower data. Lidar-measured parameters, such as wind speed, shear, and TI, will be used to predict the difference between the lidar- and tower-measured TI. The algorithm will be disseminated as a set of computer code that can be used by lidar users and manufacturers to correct lidar TI data in real time or in post-processing.

Newman, Jennifer↗

Development of a Dynamic Lidar Uncertainty Framework

As wind turbine sizes increase and wind energy expands to more complex and remote sites, remote-sensing devices such as lidars are expected to play a key role in wind resource assessment and power performance testing. The switch to remote-sensing devices represents a paradigm shift in the way the wind industry typically obtains and interprets measurement data for wind energy. For example, the measurement techniques and sources of uncertainty for a remote-sensing device are vastly different from those associated with a cup anemometer on a meteorological tower. Current IEC standards for quantifying remote sensing device uncertainty for power performance testing consider uncertainty due to mounting, calibration, and classification of the remote sensing device, among other parameters. Values of the uncertainty are typically given as a function of the mean wind speed measured by a reference device and are generally fixed, leading to climatic uncertainty values that apply to the entire measurement campaign. However, real-world experience and a consideration of the fundamentals of the measurement process have shown that lidar performance is highly dependent on atmospheric conditions, such as wind shear, turbulence, and aerosol content. At present, these conditions are not directly incorporated into the estimated uncertainty of a lidar device. In this presentation, we describe the development of a new dynamic lidar uncertainty framework that adapts to current flow conditions and more accurately represents the actual uncertainty inherent in lidar measurements under different conditions. In this new framework, sources of uncertainty are identified for estimation of the line-of-sight wind speed and reconstruction of the three-dimensional wind field. These sources are then related to physical processes caused by the atmosphere and lidar operating conditions. The framework is applied to lidar data from a field measurement site to assess the ability of the framework to predict errors in lidar-measured wind speed. The results show how uncertainty varies over time and can be used to help select data with different levels of uncertainty for different applications, for example, low uncertainty data for power performance testing versus all data for plant performance monitoring.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

Wind Lidar Activities in the United States

IEA Wind Task 32 seeks to identify and mitigate the barriers to the adoption of lidar for wind energy applications. This work is partly achieved by sharing experience across researchers and practitioners in the United States and worldwide. This presentation is a short summary of some wind lidar-related activities taking place in the country, and was presented by Andrew Clifton at the Task 32 meeting in December 2016 in his role as the U.S. Department of Energy-nominated country representative to the task.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

Ground-Based Remote or In Situ Measurement of Vertical Profiles of Wind in the Lower Troposphere

Knowledge of winds in the lower troposphere is essential for a range of applications, including weather forecasting, transportation, natural hazards, and wind energy. This presentation focuses on the measurement of vertical profiles of wind in the lower troposphere for wind energy applications. This presentation introduces the information that wind energy site development and operations require, how it used, and the benefits and problems of current measurements from in-situ measurements and remote sensing. The development of commercial Doppler wind lidar systems over the last 10 years are shown, along with the lessons learned from this experience. Finally, potential developments in wind profiling aimed at reducing uncertainty and increasing data availability are introduced.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

An error reduction algorithm to improve lidar turbulence estimates for wind energy

Abstract. Remote-sensing devices such as lidars are currently being investigated as alternatives to cup anemometers on meteorological towers for the measurement of wind speed and direction. Although lidars can measure mean wind speeds at heights spanning an entire turbine rotor disk and can be easily moved from one location to another, they measure different values of turbulence than an instrument on a tower. Current methods for improving lidar turbulence estimates include the use of analytical turbulence models and expensive scanning lidars. While these methods provide accurate results in a research setting, they cannot be easily applied to smaller, vertically profiling lidars in locations where high-resolution sonic anemometer data are not available. Thus, there is clearly a need for a turbulence error reduction model that is simpler and more easily applicable to lidars that are used in the wind energy industry. In this work, a new turbulence error reduction algorithm for lidars is described. The Lidar Turbulence Error Reduction Algorithm, L-TERRA, can be applied using only data from a stand-alone vertically profiling lidar and requires minimal training with meteorological tower data. The basis of L-TERRA is a series of physics-based corrections that are applied to the lidar data to mitigate errors from instrument noise, volume averaging, and variance contamination. These corrections are applied in conjunction with a trained machine-learning model to improve turbulence estimates from a vertically profiling WINDCUBE v2 lidar. The lessons learned from creating the L-TERRA model for a WINDCUBE v2 lidar can also be applied to other lidar devices. L-TERRA was tested on data from two sites in the Southern Plains region of the United States. The physics-based corrections in L-TERRA brought regression line slopes much closer to 1 at both sites and significantly reduced the sensitivity of lidar turbulence errors to atmospheric stability. The accuracy of machine-learning methods in L-TERRA was highly dependent on the input variables and training dataset used, suggesting that machine learning may not be the best technique for reducing lidar turbulence intensity (TI) error. Future work will include the use of a lidar simulator to better understand how different factors affect lidar turbulence error and to determine how these errors can be reduced using information from a stand-alone lidar.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

Improving Lidar Turbulence Estimates for Wind Energy

Remote sensing devices (e.g., lidars) are quickly becoming a cost-effective and reliable alternative to meteorological towers for wind energy applications. Although lidars can measure mean wind speeds accurately, these devices measure different values of turbulence intensity (TI) than an instrument on a tower. In response to these issues, a lidar TI error reduction model was recently developed for commercially available lidars. The TI error model first applies physics-based corrections to the lidar measurements, then uses machine-learning techniques to further reduce errors in lidar TI estimates. The model was tested at two sites in the Southern Plains where vertically profiling lidars were collocated with meteorological towers. Results indicate that the model works well under stable conditions but cannot fully mitigate the effects of variance contamination under unstable conditions. To understand how variance contamination affects lidar TI estimates, a new set of equations was derived in previous work to characterize the actual variance measured by a lidar. Terms in these equations were quantified using a lidar simulator and modeled wind field, and the new equations were then implemented into the TI error model.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

The Role of Surface Energy Exchange for Simulating Wind Inflow: An Evaluation of Multiple Land Surface Models in WRF for the Southern Great Plains Site Field Campaign Report

The Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model is used to investigate choice of land surface model (LSM) on the near-surface wind profile, including heights reached by multi-megawatt wind turbines. Simulations of wind profiles and surface energy fluxes were made using five LSMs of varying degrees of sophistication in dealing with soil-plant-atmosphere feedbacks for the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Atmospheric Radiation Measurement (ARM) Climate Research Facility’s Southern Great Plains (SGP) Central Facility in Oklahoma. Surface-flux and wind-profile measurements were available for validation. The WRF model was run for three two-week periods during which varying canopy and meteorological conditions existed. The LSMs predicted a wide range of energy-flux and wind-shear magnitudes even during the cool autumn period when we expected less variability. Simulations of energy fluxes varied in accuracy by model sophistication, whereby LSMs with very simple or no soil-plant-atmosphere feedbacks were the least accurate; however, the most complex models did not consistently produce more accurate results. Errors in wind shear also were sensitive to LSM choice and were partially related to the accuracy of energy flux data. The variability of LSM performance was relatively high, suggesting that LSM representation of energy fluxes in the WRF model remains a significant source of uncertainty for simulating wind turbine inflow conditions.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

A New Approach for Reducing Uncertainty in Biospheric CO 2 Flux

In the 2010 Global Carbon Project Report it was estimated that the terrestrial biosphere sequesters 2.4 Pg of anthropogenic carbon emissions per year although the uncertainty on that value is undoubtedly high as no error bars were given. As man-made emissions of CO 2 continue to increase unabated in the atmosphere, quantifying the fate of these anthropogenic sources requires both knowing the magnitude and uncertainty of background, natural CO 2 fluxes. Thus, reducing uncertainty in biospheric CO 2 flux measurements will not only give us direct, accurate observations for future carbon accounting and climate treaties but also indirectly help us quantify anthropogenic emissions for the same purposes. In conjuncture with ecosystem models or remote-sensing techniques, these measurements also provide accurate constraints on global and continental terrestrial CO 2 budgets. With the motivation stated above, we designed and executed a three-year Laboratory Directed Research and Development (LDRD) project with the aim of reducing the uncertainty in eddy-covariance biospheric CO 2 flux. Reducing uncertainty was approached in two ways. The first utilized nontraditional eddy covariance instrumentation to identify and characterize atmospheric flows above and within the plant canopy. Here, atmospheric laser detection and ranging (lidar) instrumentation were used to capture unique flow features at night which may explain erroneous or anomalous carbon fluxes. The second approach utilized a multi-layer, 3rd order closure canopy-atmosphere model to simulate fluxes at each field site. Three sites were chosen for field instrument deployment and modeling. These included the Wind River AmeriFlux tower in Washington State and the Tonzi AmeriFlux and Diablo AmeriFlux towers in northern California. These sites represent some of the extremes in the biological and meteorological conditions over which eddy covariance techniques are used. Wind River is a multi-layered, 60-m tall seasonal rainforest, Diablo is a 1-m tall grassland with a very short growing season, and Tonzi is a 2- layered savannah canopy with complex ecohydrology. All three are surrounded by complex terrain in varying degrees. The towers provided very different test sites for validating the UC Davis Advanced Canopy Atmosphere Soil Algorithm (ACASA) model. Such validation gives promise that the model can be used to independently verify and gap-fill biospheric CO 2 measurements from the network of ~ 550 global flux towers for future greenhouse gas emissions monitoring and verification studies.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

2013-2014 Lidar Campaign: Measurements of Inflow at a Northern Oklahoma Wind Farm

In November 2013, LLNL deployed two vertically-profiling, Doppler Laser Detection and Ranging (lidar) instruments at Enel Green Power North America’s 235 MW wind farm in Northern Oklahoma to collect wind measurements. The lidars were used to measure wake-free observations of the free-stream wind flow (i.e., inflow) for purposes of quantifying rotor-disk wind characteristics under varying atmospheric conditions. The measurements included horizontal wind speed, vertical wind speed, wind direction, and turbulence intensity, taken at a ~1 Hz sampling rate and averaged over 10-minute intervals. From these measurements we also calculated wind shear across the turbine rotor disk and turbulence kinetic energy (TKE).

17 WIND ENERGY↗

2013 LIDAR Campaign at Buena Vista Wind Farm: An Examination of Hill "Speedup" Flows

In June 2013, two Laser and Detection Ranging (lidar) units (ZephIR 300, Natural Power, North Ledbury, England) were deployed at the Buena Vista Wind Farm in the Altamont Hills region of California until mid-August of that year. This was the third field campaign at Buena Vista for the 12-ERD-069 project, following a winter campaign in 2011-2012 and a summer campaign in 2012. The lidar data provided wind measurements at the base (“flatland” lidar) and along the slope (“hill” lidar) of a ridge to study the flow as it moved up and along the ridge towards turbine A08 under varying stability conditions. The lidars measured wind speed, direction and turbulence at ten measurement heights including ones equivalent to the turbine rotor-disk. Instrument placement is shown in Figures 1 and 2. The placement of the two lidars was based on wind direction measurements taken at the hill lidar location during summer of 2012. The predominant wind direction in 2013 was nearly identical to 2012 and the lidar locations proved optimal for capturing wind flow as it approached A08 from the southwest. SCADA data provided 10-minute nacelle wind speed and power data for the nearby turbines.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

Assessment of Land Surface Model Performance in WRF for Simulating Wind at Heights Relevant to the Wind Energy Community

The Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model was used to investigate the impact of land surface model (LSM) physics on the simulated surface energy balance and the near surface wind profile, including heights reached by a modern wind turbine. Simulations were made for a domain centered over the Department of Energy (DOE) Southern Great Plains (SGP) Atmospheric Radiation Measurement Program (ARM) Central Facility in northern Oklahoma. High-resolution measurements of surface fluxes and profiles of wind speed, direction and turbulence were available for model validation. We tested 10 common LSM configurations in WRF including Noah, Noah-MP, SSiB, Pleim-Xiu, RUC, and others to evaluate (1) the accuracy of simulated surface energy fluxes, (2) the accuracy of forecasted rotor-disk height wind speeds, and (3) the sensitivity of rotor disk wind speed to the choice of LSM. WRF was run for four, two-week periods covering different canopy, surface meteorology and soil moisture conditions. LSM performances varied by simulation period and errors were greatest during periods with high soil moisture and live crop cover, indicating highest LSM sensitivity when PBL behavior is most coupled to land-atmosphere exchange. Higher wind speed errors also occurred at night during the spring, possibly from the difficulty with simulating nocturnal low-level jets. We found that choice of land surface model led to a ~10% improvement in simulating hub-height wind speed. Errors in wind shear were also sensitive to the choice of LSM. Overall the best performing models were Noah and Noah-MP. The variability of LSM performance across different soil moisture and vegetation canopy conditions suggests LSM representation of surface energy exchange processes in WRF remains a large source of model uncertainty. Furthermore, our results indicate the choice of LSM impacts simulated wind fields in WRF at heights relevant to the wind industry, at least for the Southern Great Plains region.

17 WIND ENERGY↗