Issues on Reproducibility/Reliability of Magnetic NDE Methods
One of the critical elements related to the practicality of any NDE technique is its reproducibility under nominally the same inspection conditions. The results of certain test methodologies, however, are not always repeatable and understanding the origin of the irreproducibility is often as critical as obtaining reproducible results. One example is the characterization of residual stress in structural ferromagnets using the magnetoacoustic (MAC) method. Although it has not been widely publicized, the test results of this method are known to be time-dependent. Two distinct types of time dependencies have been observed during testing. The first type has a clearly definable relaxation time, while no such trend has been observed for the second. The purpose of the present study is to systematically investigate the time dependence of the second type, to find out the range and, if possible, the origin of the variation in the test results. For this, MAC curves were obtained under various stress levels and the tests were repeated over time. Particular attention was given to whether noise in the measuring device or a change in the laboratory environment could have been a contributing factor. The steel samples used for the study were cut from C- and U-class railroad wheels. The MAC behavior of these samples was reported previously. Each steel sample was first machined to be a cylindrical rod of 3.175 cm (1.25 in) in diameter and 26.67 cm (10.5 in) in length. The center portion of the samples were further machined to form a pair of flat and parallel surfaces for the launch and reflection of the ultrasonic pulses. Data acquisition involved two major elements; magnetic and acoustic measurements. Throughout the experiment the net magnetic induction, B, was measured by integrating the induction pickup coil output using an integrating fluxmeter. The acoustic measurements employed the phase-locked technique which will be described in the following.