Engineering topics

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.

Publications and source records attributed to Mcsween, H. Y., Jr..

At least 19 records

NASA NTRS1994

Formation of thin sulfide rinds on the CM parent body

Many of the textures that are observed in CM chondrites have been alternately assigned nebular, parent-body, or combined nebular-parent body origins. Since it is very difficult to substantiate the production of complex textures in the nebula, an alternate approach to this problem is to rigorously determine which of the observable textures could have been produced by reasonable aqueous alteration processes on the CM parent body. Potential parent body reactions involving S deserve special attention because S-bearing phase define many important CM textures, such as rims. We have examined the possibility that the thin (about 5 microns) rinds of sulfides observed around some partially dissolved olivines within the chondrules and matrixes of CM chondrites were formed by the preferential precipitation of sulfides at or near dissolving olivine boundaries during parent-body alteration. Our model defines two infinite and parallel planes of olivine that are separated by pure water. Average separation distances between olivine grains in CM chondrites at the time of accretion (about 100-200 microns) were estimated by assuming a closed system fluid/rock ratio of 45% and varying the bimodal grain-size distribution. We restrict our calculations to the case of an isochemical system with sufficient bisulfide in solution to account for precipitation of pyrrhotite at STP. Our model examines the possibility that dissolving olivines with compositions between Fo(sub 0.9) and Fo(sub 0.4) can produce a strong gradient of Fe(2+) at pHs from 7 to 12 such that the precipitation of pyrrhotite will be initiated at the olivine-fluid boundary. Since CM phase equilibria is consistent with highly reducing conditions, Fe released by olivines would largely remain in solution as Fe(2+) until the solubility product of a Fe(2+) bearing phase was exceeded. Our calculations indicate that all examined combinations of olivine composition and pH yield a strong Fe(2+) gradient at the time the pyrrhotite solubility is exceeded near the olivine-fluid boundary. This favors the initiation of sulfide precipitation around dissolving olivines. However, sulfide rinds are not observed around all partially dissolved olivine grains in CM chondrites, which suggests that the availability of aqueous sulfide species limits the production of the thin sulfide rinds.

Browning, L. B.↗

NASA NTRS1994

Petrologic evolution of CM chondrites: The difficulty of discriminating between nebular and parent-body effects

We wish to draw attention to a major controversy that has arisen in the area of CM-chondrite petrology. The problem is important because its resolution will have profound implications for ideas concerning nebular dynamics, gas-solid interactions in the nebula, and accretionary processes in the nebula, among other issues. On the one hand, cogent arguments have been presented that 'accretionary dust mantles,' were formed in the solar nebula prior to accretion of the CM parent asteroid(s). On the other hand, no-less-powerful arguments have been advanced that a significant fraction of the CM lithology is secondary, produced by aqueous alteration in the near-surface regions of an asteroid-sized object. Because most, if not all, CM chondrites are breccias, these two views could coexist harmoniously, were it not for the fact that some of the coarse-grained lithologies surrounded by 'accretion dust mantles' are themselves of apparently secondary origin. Such an observation must clearly force a reassessment of one or both of the present schools of thought. Our objective here is to stimulate such a reassessment. Four possible resolutions of this conflict may be postulated. First, perhaps nature found a way of permitting such secondary alteration to take place in the nebula. Second, maybe dust mantles could form in a regolith, rather than a nebular, environment. Third, it is possible that dust mantles around secondary lithologies are different from those around primary lithologies. Finally, perhaps formation of CM chondrites involved a more complex sequence of events than visualized so far, so that some apparently 'primary' processes postdated certain 'secondary' processes.

Kerridge, J. F.↗

NASA NTRS1993

Heliocentric zoning of the asteroid belt by aluminum-26 heating

Variations in petrology among meteorites attest to a strong heating event early in solar system history, but the heat source has remained unresolved. Aluminum-26 has been considered the most likely high-energy, short-lived radionuclide (half-life 0.72 million years) since the discovery of its decay product - excess Mg-26 - in Allende CAI's. Furthermore, observation of relict Mg-26 in an achondritic clast and in feldspars within ordinary chondrites (3,4) provided strong evidence for live Al-26 in meteorite parent bodies and not just in refractory nebular condensates. The inferred amount of Al-26 is consistent with constraints on the thermal evolution of both ordinary and carbonaceous chondrite parent objects up to a few hundred kilometers in diameter. Meteorites can constrain the early thermal evolution of their parent body locations, provided that a link can be established between asteroid spectrophotometric signature and meteorite class. Asteroid compositions are heliocentrically distributed: objects thought to have experienced high metamorphic or even melting temperatures are located closer to the sun, whereas apparently unaltered or mildly heated asteroids are located farther away. Heliocentric zoning could be the result of Al-26 heating if the initial amount of the radionuclide incorporated into planetesimals was controlled by accretion time, which in turn varies with semimajor axis. Analytic expressions for planetary accretion may be integrated to given the time, tau, required for a planetesimal to grow to a specified radius: tau varies as a(sup n), where n = 1.5 to 3 depending on the assumptions about variations in the surface density of the planetesimal swarm. Numerical simulations of planetesimal accretion at fixed semimajor axis demonstrate that variations in accretion time among small planetesimals can be strongly nonlinear depending on the initial conditions and model assumptions. The general relationship with semimajor axis remains valid because it depends only on the initial orbit properties and distribution of the planesimal swarm. In order to demonstrate the basic dependence of thermal evolution on semimajor axis, we parameterized accretion time across the asteroid belt according to tau varies as a(sup n) and calculated the subsequent thermal history. Objects at a specified semimajor axis were assumed to have the same accretion time, regardless of size. We set the initial Al-26/Al-27 ratio = 6 x 10(exp -5) and treated n and tau(sub 0) at a(sub 0) = 3 AU as adjustable parameters. The thermal model included temperature-dependent properties of ice and rock (CM chondrite analog) and the thermodynamic effects of phase transitions.

Grimm, R. E.↗

NASA NTRS1993

Pyroxene equilibration temperatures in metamorphosed ordinary chondrites

Ordinary chondrites are divided into petrographic types based on observed mineralogical and textural properties consistent with progressive thermal metamorphism from low grade (type 3) to high (type 7). Regardless of the exact cause of the metamorphism, higher-type chondrites should retain information concerning peak temperatures reached and for what duration. Using the two-pyroxene geothermometer of Lindsley, we have calculated the equilibration temperatures for 26H, L and LL type 5 and 6 ordinary chondrites, to investigate the relative peak temperatures and equilibration-states reached by these various meteorite classes. The Lindsley thermometer relies on a detailed accounting of non-quadrilateral components in pyroxenes, whose recalculated compositions are then plotted onto an empirically-derived polythermal diagram from which temperatures can be interpolated. The reported uncertainty of this method is plus or minus 50 C; in addition, close spacing of isotherms on the graph (particularly for orthopyroxene compositions) increase this uncertainty. We have parameterized the Lindsley polythermal quadrilateral for 1 atm pressure (less than 2 bar), and interpreted recalculated coordinates directly in terms of 25 C temperature intervals. Meteorites selected for this study include both relatively shocked and unshoked specimens; heavily weathered or visibly brecciated specimens were avoided. Temperatures were calculated from orthopyroxene (opx) and clinopyroxene (cpx) analyses within one relative percent of ideal sums and stoichiometry. Histograms summarizing the calculated temperatures for type 5 and 6 ordinary chondrites are shown.

Harvey, R. P.↗

NASA NTRS1993

Wet inside and out? Constraints on water in the Martian mantle and on outgassed water, based on melt inclusions in SNC meteorites

Constraints on the volatile inventory and outgassing history of Mars are critical to understanding the origin of ancient valley systems and paleoclimates. Planetary accretion models for Mars allow either a volatile-rich or volatile-poor mantle, depending on whether the accreted materials were fully oxidized or whether accretion was homogeneous so that water was lost through reaction with metallic iron. The amount of water that has been outgassed from the interior is likewise a contentious subject, and estimates of globally distributed water based on various geochemical and geological measurements vary from a few meters to more than a thousand meters. New data on SNC meteorites, which are thought to be Martian igneous rocks, provide constraints on both mantle and outgassed water.

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.↗

NASA NTRS1986

Structural deformation of the Leoville chondrite

A petrofabric study of the Leoville chondrite was performed in order to gain an understanding of its deformation process. Strain values were determined from the chondrules' axial ratios or by the all-object-separation method, and the compaction required to deform Leoville chondrules was calculated from the decrease of radius in the circle-to-ellipse transformation. Structural and strain studies indicate the following order of events experienced by Leoville: (1) formation as an accretionary breccia, (2) compaction and development of foliation, (3) fracturing, possibly due to impact on earth, and (4) terrestrial weathering. Similarities between the axial ratios of chondrules (1.9-2.0) and of the whole meteorite (2.0) indicate either that Leoville deformed homogeneously or that it deformed as a framework of touching chondrules. This amount of strain corresponds to approximately 33 percent uniaxial shortening, assuming constant volume, and is likely to have been caused by compaction due to overburden from progressive accretion on the chondrite body. Diffusional flow is believed to be the mechanism by which olivines in these chondrules deformed.

Cain, P. M.↗

NASA NTRS1985

SNC meteorites - Clues to Martian petrologic evolution?

Shergottites, nakhlites and the Chassigny meteorites (SNC group) may have originated on Mars. The shergottites are medium-grained basalts, the nakhlites are pyroxenites and the Chassigny is a dunite. The SNC group is petrologically diverse but differs from all other known achondrites in terms of mineral chemistry, the redox state, the oxygen isotopic composition and the radiometric ages. The SNC stones are mafic and ultramafic cumulate rocks with mineralogies that indicate rapid cooling and crystallization from tholeiitic magmas which contained water and experienced a high degree of oxidation. The characteristics suggest formation from a large parent body, i.e., a planet, but not earth. The estimated ages for the rocks match the estimated ages for several mapped Martian volcanoes in the Tharsis region. Additionally, the elemental and isotopic abundances of atmospheric gases embedded in melts in the SNC stones match Viking Lander data for the Martian atmosphere. However, reasons are cited for discounting the possibility that a large meteorite(s) collided with Mars about 180 myr ago and served as the mechanism for ejecting the SNC stones to earth.

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.↗

NASA NTRS1985

Constraints on chondrule origin from petrology of isotopically characterized chondrules in the Allende meteorite

The petrologic and chemical properties of the ferromagnesian chondrules in the Allende carbonaceous chondrite were examined in terms of the isotopic composition and the correlations between isotopic patterns. Areas of thin sections were studied with a SEM and bulk chemical fractions of 12 constituents were quantified to calculate correlations with petrologic features. A possible correlation between (CaO + Al2O2)/MgO and oxygen isotopes imply the formation of oxygen isotopic compositions in the chondrules by exchanges between isotopically heavy nebular gases and O-16 enriched solids. Different rates of gaseous exchange occurred with the various types of chondrules. Factors which may have controlled the exchanges are discussed.

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.↗

NASA NTRS1985

What we know about Mars (but otherwise wouldn't) if it is the shergottite parent body

The evidence that some meteorites may actually be samples of fairly large solar system bodies, specifically the moon and the planet Mars was presented. The proposed martian meteorites, called shergottites are igneous rocks that crystallized from molten magmas. Their crystallization ages are much too young to have formed by internal melting within small asteroids, and the unusual chemical composition of gases trapped when these rocks were severely shocked matches that of the martin atmosphere measured by Viking. The implications of these samples for martian evolution was discussed and suggested, that if Mars is the shergottite parent body, the martian interior is much more like that of the earth than has been previously thought. Shergottites explain presence of small magnetic field indicate that volatileement concentratins in Mars should be similar to the Earth, and explain the great lengths of volcanic flows on the martian surface.

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.↗

NASA NTRS1984

Strain analysis of the Leoville chondrite and conditions in asteroidal interiors

Deformed chondrules in the Leoville carbonaceous chondrite define a preferred orientation, also recognized previously in other CV3 chondrites. Identifying the strain mechanism is necessary for understanding the conditions which caused this compressional shortening. Luckly, the major mineralogical constituent of CV3 meteorites is olivine, for which experimental data on strain mechanisms exist. The conditions that caused strain in the olivine were obviously applicable to the whole meteorite. Possible mechanisms of olivine deformation are cataclasis, low temperature plasticity, power low creep, and diffusional flow, each of which occurs under different combinations of temperature and deviatoric stress. Cataclasis can be ruled out on the basis of its high deviatoric stress requirements; some fractures occur in chondrule olivines, but these may have formed during excavation or impact. Low temperature plasticity and power low creep occur by means of various types of lattice dislocations. However, methods of thermal decoration and chemical etching of dislocations failed to indicate evidence for either mechanism. Thus, the inference is that diffusional flow, characteristic of low to moderately high temperatures and low deviatoric stress, was the major deformation mechanism.

Cain, P. M.↗

NASA NTRS1983

Petrogenesis of the Elephant Moraine A79001 meteorite Multiple magma pulses on the shergottite parent body

The EETA 79001 achondrite consists of two distinct igneous lithologies joined along a planar, non-brecciated contact. Both are basaltic rocks composed primarily of pigeonite, augite, and maskelynite, but one contains zoned megacrysts of olivine, orthopyroxene, and chromite that represent disaggregated xenoliths of harzburzite. Both lithologies probably formed from successive volcanic flows or multiple injections of magma into a small, shallow chamber. Many similarities between the two virtually synchronous magmas suggest that they are related. Possible mechanisms to explain their differences involve varying degrees of assimilation, fractionation from similar parental magmas, or partial melting of a similar source peridotite; of these, assimilation of the observed megacryst assemblage seems most plausible. However, some isotopic contamination may be required in any of these petrogenetic models. The meteorite has suffered extensive shock metamorphism and localized melting during a large impact event that probably excavated and liberated it from its parent body.

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.↗

NASA NTRS1983

Chemical characteristics and origin of H chondrite regolith breccias

Petrologic data and contents of Ag, Bi, Cd, Co, Cs, Ga, In, Rb, Se, Te, Tl and Zn-trace elements spanning the volatility/mobility range-in light and dark portions of H chondrite regolith breccias and L chondrite fragmental breccias are reported. The chemical/petrologic characteristics of H chondrite regolith breccias differ from those of nonbrecciated chondrites or fragmental breccias. Petrologic characteristics and at least some trace element contents of H chondrite regolith breccias reflect primary processes; contents of the most volatile/mobile elements may reflect either primary or secondary processing, possibly within layered H chondrite parent object(s). Chemical/petrologic differences existed in different regions of the parent(s). Regoligh formation and gardening and meteoroid compaction were not so severe as to alter compositions markedly.

Lipschutz, M. E.↗

NASA NTRS1983

Ferromagnesian chondrules in carbonaceous chondrites

Carbonaceous chondrites (groups CO and CV) contain three types of ferromagnesian chondrules that can be distinguished on the basis of mineralogy and texture. Statistical analysis of the bulk chemical compositions of these chondrule types suggest that two of the three types are genetically related. The chondrules in carbonaceous chondrites can thus be separated into two populations. These populations are also apparently distinct in terms of redox state and oxygen isotopic composition. The more abundant population (I) is clearly different from chondrules in unequilibrated ordinary chondrites, but the minor population (II) is similar to them in many respects. These chondrule populations may have formed by melting of solid, locally homogeneous precursor materials in different regions of the nebula, and were mixed after solidification was complete.

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.↗

NASA NTRS1982

Petrogenesis of light and dark portions of the Leighton gas-rich chondritic breccia

Individual dark fractions of the Leighton chondritic breccia are all enriched in volatile/mobile trace elements. Concentrations of the most highly volatile/mobile elements correlate with degree of equilibration, as expressed by compositional variability for silicates. Individual light clasts in the same meteorite are equilibrated and generally volatile-poor, except for enrichments in Rb and Cs. These alkali elements may have been redistributed by feldspar formation during metamorphism. Enrichments of other trace elements in dark portions may have been caused by mobilization during metamorphism in the parent body interior and deposition in the cooler surface layers. An alternative model involves accretional mixing of a diverse compositional population of primitive H group materials to form dark materials. Subsequent integration of light and dark materials was accomplished by impacts into a regolith.

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.↗

NASA NTRS1982

Numerical simulation of crystal fractionation in shergottite meteorites

Cumulus clinopyroxenes in the Shergotty and Zagami meteorites suggest crystal fractionation occurred, possibly by gravitative settling. Numerical models of this process in a nonconvecting environment argue that the small phenocrysts can segregate only under extreme conditions of cooling time or gravitational field strength. Since textures indicate that cooling time was not excessive, a large (planetary) g is required by these models, in agreement with other suggestions that the shergottite parent body may be Mars. Other calculations indicate that it is extremely difficult to produce the observed textures in a convecting environment, unless crystal setting occurred in a quiescent zone at the bottom of the magma chamber.

Grimm, R. E.↗

NASA NTRS1980

A note on the Allan Hills A77278 unequilibrated ordinary chondrite

Petrographic measures of disequilibrium in the ALHA 77278 chondrite indicate that this meteorite is more equilibrated than its exceptionally high volatile element contents suggest. Based on its metal compositions, this meteorite should be classified as an LL3 rather than an L3 chondrite.

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.↗

NASA NTRS1980

Origin of volatile-rich H chondrites with light/dark structures

The light and dark fractions of four gas-rich, brecciated H chondrites are studied in terms of petrography and volatile element chemistry in an investigation of the origin of light/dark chondrites. Petrographic constraints on the nature of the light and dark fractions of the meteorites are presented. Light clasts within the brecciated H chondrites are more highly metamorphosed than dark host material, and olivine, pyroxene and metal compositions suggest that dark fractions consist of mixtures of unequilibrated material and pulverized equilibrated H chondrite similar to the light clasts. Volatile element concentrations in the dark fractions are similar to those in the least equilibrated H3 chondrites, and no petrographic evidence for admixture of significant amounts of carbonaceous chondrite was noted. It is concluded that volatile-rich H chondrite breccias may not have incorporated carbonaceous chondrite dust as the volatile element carrier.

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.↗

NASA NTRS1979

Alteration in CM carbonaceous chondrites inferred from modal and chemical variations in matrix

The modal abundance of matrix in CM chondrites appears to vary from 57-85 vol%. The concentrations of volatile elements that should occur in matrix remain approximately constant despite differences in the proportions of matrix, suggesting that the differing matrix contents may not be real primary variations but are optical effects due to aqueous alteration processes that make other petrologic components unrecognizable. Apparent matrix content can be used as a qualitative measure of the degree of alteration experienced by each CM chondrite. Fe/Si ratios in matrices decrease progressively with increasing alteration due to the formation of new phyllosilicate phases with higher Mg/Fe ratios and optically recognizable opaque minerals that are not counted as matrix. The aqueous alteration process in CM chondrites appears to have been largely isochemical if the bulk meteorites are considered as the reacting systems, although depletion patterns and isotopic anomalies indicate open-system behavior for a few highly mobile components.

Mcsween, H. Y., Jr.↗