IPPW Short Course Introduction to Aerocapture, Entry, Descent, and Landing: Low Enthalpy Testing
Overview of ground test techniques used for aerodynamic characterization from supersonic to subsonic speeds.
wind tunnel↗
Engineering topics
Mark Schoenenberger
Publications and source records attributed to Mark Schoenenberger.
An Investigation of Bluff Body Corrections Using the NASA/ODU 6-inch MSBS
Spheres of different diameters were tested in the NASA/ODU 6-inch Magnetic Suspension Balance System (MSBS). The objective is to develop an improved understanding of blockage corrections to be made to other bluff-body geometries. Drag coefficients are shown with classical corrections applied, along with wall pressure signatures and base pressure measurements. Anomalous behavior was observed with the largest diameter, thought to be some form of flow breakdown, hence uncorrectable interference.
magnetic suspension↗
Comparison of Dynamic Stability Testing Techniques with Magnetic Suspension Wind Tunnel
Dynamic stability testing techniques currently utilized at NASA Langley Research Center (LaRC) are conducted in multiple facilities and consists of free flight, forced oscillation, and free-to-oscillate tests. The MIT/NASA/ODU Magnetic Suspension and Balance System (MSBS) has been recommissioned to explore its utility as an additional facility to expand the dynamic stability test capabilities currently available at NASA LaRC. Simulations were created to replicate each current test facility and method as closely as possible. Data collected from the simulated environments was corrupted with replicated noise sources of the different testing environments and then compared to real data collected during tests when such data was available. The corrupted data was then passed through data reduction and System Identification (SID) to estimate the accuracy of the results with the known aerodynamic model that was utilized within the simulation to generate the original data. Magnitudes of noise were varied utilizing Monte Carlo analysis to perform sensitivity analysis of each noise source on the extracted dynamic stability coefficients. Some preliminary results will be presented.
Otoniel Ramirez↗
Comparison of Dynamic Stability Testing Techniques with Magnetic Suspension Wind Tunnel
Dynamic stability testing techniques currently utilized at NASA Langley Research Center (LaRC) are conducted in multiple facilities and consists of free flight, forced oscillation, and free-to-oscillate tests. The MIT/NASA/ODU Magnetic Suspension and Balance System (MSBS) has been recommissioned to explore its utility as an additional facility to expand the dynamic stability test capabilities currently available at NASA LaRC. Simulations were created to replicate each current test facility and method as closely as possible. Data collected from the simulated environments was corrupted with replicated noise sources of the different testing environments and then compared to real data collected during tests when such data was available. The corrupted data was then passed through data reduction and System Identification (SID) to estimate the accuracy of the results with the known aerodynamic model that was utilized within the simulation to generate the original data. Magnitudes of noise were varied utilizing Monte Carlo analysis to perform sensitivity analysis of each noise source on the extracted dynamic stability coefficients. Some preliminary results will be presented.
Otoniel Ramirez↗
Exploring the Accuracy of RANS Simulations for Mars Entry Vehicles
Accurate yet inexpensive predictions of aerodynamic coefficients for Mars entry vehicles have remained a consistent challenge over the past five decades. Below Mach 6, drag on the backshell becomes significant and must be accurately predicted. Steady Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) models are commonly used, despite their poor predictions of backshell pressure. While scale-resolving simulations have shown promise in the past decade, there is still a need for cheap, accurate RANS predictions for large aerodynamic databases. The Mars Science Laboratory (MSL) is used as a case study to examine predictive accuracy and known shortcomings for RANS predictions of Mars entry vehicles. Several different grid generation techniques are compared, including a comparison between prismatic boundary layer grids and fully unstructured, tetrahedral grids. Comparisons are made to experimental data for Mach 2.5, 3.5, and 4.5. The accuracy of predicted aerodynamic coefficients is examined. Overpredictions in axial force and drag are explained by a closer examination of the surface pressure. These findings document sensitivities and best practices for future RANS database development of Mars entry vehicles.
RANS↗
Exploring the Accuracy of RANS Simulations for Mars Entry Vehicles
Accurate yet inexpensive predictions of aerodynamic coefficients for Mars entry vehicles have remained a consistent challenge over the past five decades. Below Mach 6, drag on the backshell becomes significant and must be accurately predicted. Steady Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) models are commonly used, despite their poor predictions of backshell pressure. While scale-resolving simulations have shown promise in the past decade, there is still a need for cheap, accurate RANS predictions for large aerodynamic databases. The Mars Science Laboratory (MSL) is used as a case study to examine predictive accuracy and known shortcomings for RANS predictions of Mars entry vehicles. Several different grid generation techniques are compared, including a comparison between prismatic boundary layer grids and fully unstructured, tetrahedral grids. Comparisons are made to experimental data for Mach 2.5, 3.5, and 4.5. The accuracy of predicted aerodynamic coefficients is examined. Overpredictions in axial force and drag are explained by a closer examination of the surface pressure. These findings document sensitivities and best practices for future RANS database development of Mars entry vehicles.
CFD↗
Increasing the Dynamic Pressure Capability of the NASA Langley/ODU 6-inch MSBS
The 6-inch NASA/ODU Magnetic Suspension and Balance System (MSBS) has been configured for dynamic stability testing of blunt-body atmospheric entry capsules. Tests have been successfully accomplished in the low-speed, open-circuit wind tunnel, at speeds up to around 40 m/s. The wind tunnel is designed to reach around 150 m/s, resulting in dynamic pressures comparable to those projected to arise in a future supersonic MSBS facility. Extensive system upgrades are being undertaken to permit testing at higher speeds/dynamic pressures, including control system enhancements, revised position and attitude sensing, and activation of additional electromagnets in the existing array. This paper will review recent progress in all these areas.
Mark Schoenenberger↗
Using Motion-Tracking Camera System for Magnetic Suspension Wind Tunnel Tests For Re-entry Capsules
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Entry Systems Modeling↗
Increasing the Dynamic Pressure Capability of the NASA Langley/ODU 6-inch MSBS
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Mark Schoenenberger↗
The Feasibility of Motion Tracking Camera System for Magnetic Suspension Wind Tunnel Tests
The Entry Systems Modeling (ESM) Program at NASA has actively participated in the re-development of the Magnetic Suspension Balance System (MSBS) at the six-inch subsonic wind tunnel at NASA Langley Research Center. This initiative aims to enhance the MSBS system's capabilities, enabling the testing of stingless entry vehicle models at supersonic speeds. To achieve this, control algorithms are required to ensure magnetic levitation control and stability for models during free-oscillation dynamic responses. Currently, the system relies on electromagnetic position sensors to provide real-time 3 degrees of freedom in a rigid body. While this approach has proven successful for subsonic speeds, expanding testing under higher pressure conditions may necessitate the incorporation of real-time roll and pitch measurements to quantify the dynamic stability characteristics of the models in free-oscillation. In collaboration with Old Dominion University, the team at NASA Langley Research Center proposes the implementation of a motion-tracking camera system. This system will provide real-time five degrees of freedom output, which will be utilized within a closed feedback control system and a two-step system identification model to isolate aerodynamic forces from their corresponding magnetic forces. The motion-tracking cameras will offer precise and accurate control over the levitation system, facilitating precise and repeatable experiments within the wind tunnel. The real-time feedback provided by the cameras enables prompt adjustments to ensure the maintenance of stable levitation throughout the testing process.
Entry Systems Modeling↗
Uncertainty Modeling for Mars Ascent Vehicle’s Aerodatabase Development
The design of the Mars Ascent Vehicle - Mars Sample Return (MAV-MSR) trajectories requires an accurate assessment of flight performance. Typically, these trajectories are developed by flight mechanics analysis to meet complex mission requirements and then flight performance assessed through Monte Carlo simulations. Consequently, it is crucial to develop an aerodynamic aerodatabase as an input model for flight mechanics analysis to provide static and dynamic force and moment coefficients under specific flight conditions. The force and moment coefficients in the MAV aerodatabase are determined using the FUN3D computational fluid dynamics solver. Firstly, an overview of the aerodatabase is presented to demonstrate its applicability to trajectory-defined simulations. This effort is followed by an initial attempt to quantify uncertainties in the force and moment coefficients necessary for updating the current aerodatabase. The uncertainty model identifies uncertainty adders and multipliers for coefficient-based forces and moments through a direct comparison between FUN3D and wind tunnel test data from NASA Marshall Space Center's 14x14 inch Trisonic Wind Tunnel. These uncertainties aim to encompass various changes in Mach number, angle of attack, and aerodynamic roll angle.
Uncertainty analysis↗
The Feasibility of Motion Tracking Camera System for Magnetic Suspension Wind Tunnel Tests
The Entry Systems Modeling (ESM) Program at NASA has actively participated in the re-development of the Magnetic Suspension Balance System (MSBS) at the six-inch subsonic wind tunnel at NASA Langley Research Center. This initiative aims to enhance the MSBS system's capabilities, enabling the testing of stingless entry vehicle models at supersonic speeds. To achieve this, control algorithms are required to ensure magnetic levitation control and stability for models during free-oscillation dynamic responses. Currently, the system relies on electromagnetic position sensors to provide real-time 3 degrees of freedom in a rigid body. While this approach has proven successful for subsonic speeds, expanding testing under higher pressure conditions may necessitate the incorporation of real-time roll and pitch measurements to quantify the dynamic stability characteristics of the models in free-oscillation. In collaboration with Old Dominion University, the team at NASA Langley Research Center proposes the implementation of a motion-tracking camera system. This system will provide real-time five degrees of freedom output, which will be utilized within a closed feedback control system and a two-step system identification model to isolate aerodynamic forces from their corresponding magnetic forces. The motion-tracking cameras will offer precise and accurate control over the levitation system, facilitating precise and repeatable experiments within the wind tunnel. The real-time feedback provided by the cameras enables prompt adjustments to ensure the maintenance of stable levitation throughout the testing process.
Entry Systems Modeling↗
Uncertainty Modeling for Mars Ascent Vehicle’s Aerodynamic Database Development
The design of the Mars Ascent Vehicle - Mars Sample Return (MAV-MSR) trajectories requires an accurate assessment of flight performance. Typically, these trajectories are developed by flight mechanics analysis to meet complex mission requirements and then flight performance assessed through Monte Carlo simulations. Consequently, it is crucial to develop an aerodynamic aerodatabase as an input model for flight mechanics analysis to provide static and dynamic force and moment coefficients under specific flight conditions. The force and moment coefficients in the MAV aerodatabase are determined using the FUN3D computational fluid dynamics solver. Firstly, an overview of the aerodatabase is presented to demonstrate its applicability to trajectory-defined simulations. This effort is followed by an initial attempt to quantify uncertainties in the force and moment coefficients necessary for updating the current aerodatabase. The uncertainty model identifies uncertainty adders and multipliers for coefficient-based forces and moments through a direct comparison between FUN3D and wind tunnel test data from NASA Marshall Space Center's 14x14 inch Trisonic Wind Tunnel. These uncertainties aim to encompass various changes in Mach number, angle of attack, and aerodynamic roll angle.
Uncertainty analysis↗
Aerodynamic Stability Characterization of the Mars Sample Return (MSR) Earth Entry System (EES) in the Transonic Dynamics Tunnel
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Dynamic Stability↗
Mars Launch System MLS Aerodynamics
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Mark Schoenenberger↗
Development of Data Reduction Methods for Dynamic Stability Tests in a Magnetic Suspension and Balance System
The NASA/ODU 6-inch Magnetic Suspension and Balance System (MSBS) is operational in a “free-to-yaw” configuration in a subsonic wind tunnel. The MSBS hardware has been heavily modified over recent years to utilize a transverse magnetization scheme, with mixed electromagnetic and motion tracking camera position sensors and a relatively sophisticated control system. The project aims to provide a unique test capability for dynamic stability testing of planetary entry capsules, free from support interference. Aerodynamic tests are being conducted, with a focus of validation of the data reduction methods used to extract dynamic stability parameters. The unique complication is the existence of magnetic, aerodynamic, and mass centers, where magnetic, aerodynamic, and inertia forces respectively are resolved. The paper will report on tests of a family of EEV-like geometries, where the conical half-angle varied between 45 and 60 degrees in steps of 3.75 degrees. The paper will present experimental results from the parametric family of EEV-like geometries. Simulation results will also be presented, based on a two or three degree-of-freedom Simulink model. The model allows the exploration of the effects of non-coincident centers and the sensitivity of results arising from uncertainties in location.
Entry Systems Modeling↗
Mars Sample Return Earth Entry System Helicopter Drop Test Reconstruction
The Mars Sample Return campaign conducted four successful helicopter drop tests of the Earth Entry System at the Utah Test and Training Range on October, 2023. The tests acquired data for the 52.5 deg sphere cone geometry that can be used to develop models for the terminal descent aerodynamics and flight dynamics used to model ground impact conditions. The acquired test data included both sensor data outputs from an on-board inertial measurement unit, global positioning system, and video cameras as well as atmospheric measurements from weather balloons. This data was processed using a Kalman filter/smoother to reconstruct the capsule’s trajectory and aerodynamics. An equation-error method was used to reconcile the aerodynamics by solving for a set of dispersions in the aerodynamic database that form a best-fit to the reconstructed aerodynamics. The reconstructed trajectories were compared with flight simulations generated using Program to Optimize Simulated Trajectories II. The results indicate that the simulation underpredicted the vehicle oscillation amplitudes. The reconstruction exhibits a persistent low-amplitude oscillation that does not damp out as predicted.
Chris D Karlgaard↗
Mars Sample Return Earth Entry System Helicopter Drop Test Reconstruction
The Mars Sample Return campaign conducted four successful helicopter drop tests of the Earth Entry System at the Utah Test and Training Range on October, 2023. The tests acquired data for the 52.5 deg sphere cone geometry that can be used to develop models for the terminal descent aerodynamics and flight dynamics used to model ground impact conditions. The acquired test data included both sensor data outputs from an on-board inertial measurement unit, global positioning system, and video cameras as well as atmospheric measurements from weather balloons. This data was processed using a Kalman filter/smoother to reconstruct the capsule’s trajectory and aerodynamics. An equation-error method was used to reconcile the aerodynamics by solving for a set of dispersions in the aerodynamic database that form a best-fit to the reconstructed aerodynamics. The reconstructed trajectories were compared with flight simulations generated using Program to Optimize Simulated Trajectories II. The results indicate that the simulation underpredicted the vehicle oscillation amplitudes. The reconstruction exhibits a persistent low-amplitude oscillation that does not damp out as predicted.
Chris D Karlgaard↗