NASA NTRS1991
Development of finite dynamic elements can result in a significant reduction of computing time and cost for calculation of natural frequencies and mode shapes, which is an essential part of flutter prediction. Analysis with and without the dynamic terms is an alternative to constructing a new finite element mesh, to determine whether the mesh is sufficiently refined. Finite dynamic elements show spectacular improvement in convergence of higher modes with mesh refinement, but the improvement for lower modes is not so great. Cost reduction ratios greater than 20 have been observed for some modes. An average cost reduction ratio of 12 was achieved for the first six modes of a swept, tapered sandwich composite plate, at the 3 percent error level. Another set of calculations was made to determine the mesh density and cost parameters for which none of the first 12 frequencies was in error by more than 3 percent. It was found that the computing cost parameter for the dynamic element was about three times lower than the basic triangular element and 5.9 times lower than an eight-node isoparametric element.