Engineering PapersSearch

Engineering topics

Kyle A Pascioni

Publications and source records attributed to Kyle A Pascioni.

UAM Source Noise Hemisphere Flight Test Measurement Protocol

The overall goal of the NASA Urban Air Mobility Noise Working Group (UNWG) Ground and Flight Test Subgroup (SG2) is to develop a research measurement protocol, or set of guidelines, which can be used to adequately quantify the Urban Air Mobility (UAM) community noise impact via the creation of acoustic profiles that describe the vehicle source emission characteristics. This document lays out a measurement protocol for acquiring data suitable for the development of compact noise hemispheres that characterize the source acoustic emissions from full-scale UAM or Advanced Air Mobility (AAM) vehicles in outdoor flight. It also provides a narrative describing the numerous aspects of outdoor flight test design and execution that will hopefully prove useful to flight test engineers and practitioners.

Acoustics

Computational Study of Vortex-Induced Separation for a 5-Bladed Rotor

This work computationally investigated the rotor blade vortex-induced separation recently observed during an aerodynamic rotor test campaign in the NASA Langley Research Center 14- by 22-Foot Subsonic Tunnel. Two separate approaches (i.e., airfoil modification and blade tip modification) were studied to mitigate the vortex-induced separation. Low-fidelity tools based on blade element momentum theory were shown to mispredict the rotor inflow and were also shown to not capture the vortex-induced separation caused by perpendicular blade-vortex interaction. This misprediction was exploited to isolate the aerodynamic thrust deficit caused by the vortex-induced separation (i.e., 20%) from the thrust deficit due to inflow variation (i.e., 31%). High-fidelity tools were shown to reasonably predict aerodynamic forces within 13% and flow separation when compared to experimental results. The modified airfoil variant of the baseline rotor effectively mitigated the vortex-induced separation while the blade tip modified variant still showed separation, though the size and strength of the vortex was reduced. Acoustic predictions were underpredicted by 10 dB from preliminary measurements taken in the untreated wind tunnel. Broadband noise contributions from different rotor blade sections showed that self-noise due to flow separation and other turbulent boundary layer mechanisms was the dominant noise source for all three rotor cases, followed by blade-wake interaction noise caused by perpendicular blade-vortex interactions.

aerodynamics

Urban Air Mobility Noise: Current Practice, Gaps, and Recommendations

In 2018, NASA formed an Urban Air Mobility Noise Working Group to assemble noise experts from industry, universities and government agencies to identify, discuss, and address urban air mobility (UAM) noise issues. This paper presents a set of high-level goals intended to address barriers associated with UAM noise that may hamper their entry into service. It summarizes the current practice, identifies gaps in the current practice, and makes recommendations to address the gaps to achieve the high-level goals in four areas of interest: Tools and Technologies, Ground and Flight Testing, Human Response and Metrics, and Regulation and Policy.

urban air mobility

Tonal Noise Control Using Rotor Phase Synchronization

The purpose of this study is to determine if phase synchronization can be used to reduce the net radiated sound power from two rotors. Phase synchronization implies that the rotors have the same rotational speed with a fixed relative azimuthal blade position, or phase. The concept is evaluated both experimentally and numerically. Measurements of source directivity and thrust are initially compared with predictions to confirm that the model accurately captures the relevant trends. The model is then used to explore the design space and identify relevant parameters. Both experimental and numerical results show that the radiated sound power at the blade passage frequency can be reduced by appropriately controlling the relative azimuthal phase of the rotors. Vehicle level predictions are also provided for a notional octocopter, comparing two different modes of operation. Predictions show that phase synchronization can be used to achieve a 4-5 dB reduction of the sound pressure level at the blade passage frequency nearly everywhere on the ground plane beneath the vehicle.

Noah H Schiller

Noise Reduction Potential of Phase Control for Distributed Propulsion Vehicles

Phase control is a noise reduction technique leveraging destructive interference of the coherent acoustic source field between a system of propellers rotating at equivalent rates. Carefully selecting the relative azimuthal blade positions (phase), the overall directivity of the blade passage frequency noise can be modified, potentially steering these tonal components away from sensitive areas. A modeling technique is described and validated using measurements of a dual-rotor system. The sensitivity of noise reduction through phase control is studied in a typical parameter space, i.e., dependence on rotation rate, number of propellers, spacing and layout, and rotation direction. Additionally, estimates of how realistic conditions, e.g., error in the phase controller, degrade potential benefits are described based on the generalized coherence of the system. From this, it is observed that the deviation from the nominal rotation rate should not exceed approximately 0.5% to achieve a 6 dB decrease at the blade passage frequency.

Kyle A Pascioni

Slat Noise Control Using a Slat Gap Filler

The leading edge slat of a high-lift system is one of the main noise contributors on many commercial aircraft during approach. This paper continues our previous studies on the gap filler for passive noise control on the 30P30N high-lift airfoil. An improved implementation of the gap filler was applied to minimize the effects of flow leakage encountered in the previous work, which resulted in spurious noise content in the far-field acoustic spectra. To evaluate the effect of passive flow control on the acoustics generated by the unsteady flow field, anechoic wind tunnel experiments are conducted on the two-dimensional, three-element high-lift airfoil with a gap filler mounted to the slat. The slat geometry modification associated with the gap filler alters the flow field in the cove region that dominates the generation of the acoustic field. A single angle of attack (훼푘=8◦) and three flow speeds corresponding to Reynolds numbersof푅푒푐=1.2푒6,1.5푒6, and1.71푒6are selected as the test conditions. Steady surface pressure measurements are conducted to assess the effect of the treatments on the overall lift. Acoustic array measurements are used to evaluate the influence of the gap filler on the radiated noise. Delay and Sum beamforming is applied to locate the noise sources on the model and to provide the integrated spectra. The gap filler is found to eliminate the narrowband peaks in the acoustic spectra and, also, to yield a 10 dB reduction in the broadband noise in comparison with the baseline case. Time-resolved Particle Image Velocimetry results show that the flow features are significantly altered with the presence of the gap filler, which leads to a more stable slat cove shear layer and, thus, to weaker pressure and velocity fluctuations.

Yang Zhang

Medium-Sized Helicopter Noise Abatement Flight Test

An extensive flight test campaign was recently completed which aims to reduce the noise generated by helicopters in an effort to improve community acceptance. Using a ground-based microphone array, acoustic measurements were acquired on helicopters in the medium-size vehicle weight class over a number of flight conditions including steady level flight, steady descents, and approaches. While data were collected across four helicopters, the Leonardo AW139 and Sikorsky S-76D will be the focus of this paper. The extent of measured ground noise con- tours was limited due to the site constraints. Thus, the Noise Informed Community Environment Operations Planning System (NICEOPS) in conjunction with the flight test data was used to estimate how changes in the operating procedures impact noise exposure over a wider area during approaches. It was found that even small longitudinal accelerations can have a substantial influence on the noise generation processes during approach and must be modeled appropriately to develop new flight procedures which minimize the acoustic impact on the ground.

Flight Testing

Investigation of the 30P30N Slat Flow Field with Passive Control Devices Using Particle Image Velocimetry

The leading-edge slat of a high-lift wing is one of the main noise contributors during approach and landing. This paper describes an experimental investigation of the velocity field associated with multiple passive noise treatments, including slat-cusp extensions, a cove filler, and a gap filler, on a two-dimensional multi-element high-lift 30P30N airfoil. Previous work documented comparisons of both surface and far field pressure fluctuations in the presence of these devices with those for a baseline case at different flow conditions. However, important information related to the velocity fields was missing from the previous measurements, hindering our ability to elucidate the changes in the flow physics associated with the noise treatments. Therefore, two-component Particle Image Velocity has been used to investigate the influence of passive noise treatments on the flow fields. All measurements are taken at an effective, free-air angle of attack of 5.5 degrees and a stowed-chord-based Reynolds number of 1.71 × 10e6. The measurements show that the slat extensions shorten the slat-cove shear layer trajectory, resulting in reduced growth of disturbances within the slat-cove shear layer. This leads to a shift of tonal peaks to higher frequencies and a reduction in the tonal amplitudes. The gap filler blocks the flow path through the gap, causing the reattachment location to shift to the main wing leading edge lower surface. Consequently, the feedback loop associated with the flow-acoustic interaction in the baseline case is eliminated, and the turbulent kinetic energy in the slat-cove shear layer is significantly reduced. However, extensive flow separation is observed on the suction side of the gap filler, which does not eliminate the noise reduction benefit due to the gap filler, but does degrade the aerodynamic performance of the high-lift configuration. Finally, the overall flow field in the presence of the cove filler is similar to that in the baseline case at the design angle of attack, but the slat-cove shear layer is eliminated leading to a suppression of the cavity tones associated with the shear layer. This change accounts for the reduction in slat noise as measured in previous work.

Aeroacoustics

Machine Learning Methods for Estimating Propeller Source Noise Spheres

In this work, several neural network function approximations are compared for inter- polating, storing, and sampling acoustic source spheres with applications to propeller noise estimation. These methods are compared using an acoustic model of the three bladed GL-10 propeller at different flight conditions, with training data generated using NASA’s ANOPP-PAS module. The source spheres used to train the networks capture the tonal propeller noise due to both the blade thickness and loading. This tonal noise prediction method allows the vehicle noise to be estimated for auralization and acoustic control. Three radial basis function neural network architectures are compared in this work. The first two networks directly estimate the parameters of the source sphere at different flight conditions but differ in the number of layers used. The third network estimates the parameters of the source sphere using a weighted combination of spherical basis functions. These networks are trained on numerically generated source spheres, with operating points given in terms of the propeller rotation rate, freestream speed, and propeller angle of attack. The performance of the neural network is determined using a validation dataset of withheld data points. This performance is quantified in terms of the approximation error, training time, and sample time. The third network, which estimates the weights of the spherical basis functions, performs the best in both average and maximum approximation errors in all cases. This network’s worst case performance is 5.6 % relative dif- ference of a model parameter associated with acoustic pressure. The direct estimation network with a single layer has the worst approximation error in all cases. Additionally, the spherically defined network has the slowest sample time at 0.05 seconds per thousand points. Both direct estimation methods produce a thousand sample points in approximately 0.001 seconds.

Acoustics

Effects of Porous Gap Fillers on 30P30N Leading-Edge SlatNoise. Part I: Surface Pressure and Acoustics

The leading edge slat of a high-lift system is one of the main contributors to airframe noise during approach. In a previous experimental study, we assessed the performance of an impermeable slat gap filler as a passive flow control device to reduce the slat noise associated with a two-dimensional, three-element high-lift airfoil. The present paper, the first of two parts,represents a follow-on investigation to assess the relative efficacy of permeable gap fillers thatallow successively higher amounts of flow to pass through the gap. To evaluate the influence of this passive flow control device on the acoustics generated by the unsteady flow near the slat, experiments are conducted in an anechoic wind tunnel by mounting a gap filler to the slat element of the two-dimensional 30P30N high-lift configuration. Measurements are performed at a single geometric angle of attack (𝛼𝑘=8◦) and three different flow speeds that correspond to Reynolds numbers of𝑅𝑒𝑐=1.2𝑒6,1.5𝑒6, and1.71𝑒6, respectively. Steady surface pressure measurements are used to gauge the influence of the permeable gap filler treatments on the overall lift. The effect of each treatment on the radiated noise is analyzed via acoustic array measurements, followed by delay-and-sum beamforming to locate the slat noise sources and to provide the integrated acoustic spectra. The porous gap fillers are found to eliminate the narrowband peaks in the acoustic spectra and, also, to yield a 10 dB reduction in the broadband noise in comparison with the baseline case with no gap filler. The porous gap filler with thelowest permeability acts similar to the impermeable gap filler examined previously. However, the aerodynamics and noise reduction both degrade with increasing permeability. An accompanying abstract describes the particle image velocimetry measurements of the flowfield within the slat cove and on either side of the permeable gap f

slat noise

Effects of Porous Gap Fillers on Leading-Edge Slat Noise of 30P30N. Part II: PIV Measurements

The leading edge slat of a high-lift system is one of the main contributors to the airframe noise during approach conditions. This paper, the second of two parts, continues our previous studies on the slat gap filler as a passive noise control device on the two-dimensional, 30P30N multielement airfoil. Whereas the earlier study was focused on the effects of an impermeable gap filler that completely blocks the flow through the gap, this follow-on assessment is devoted to permeable slat gap fillers that allow limited amounts of flow to pass through the gap. Part I of this two-part abstract described the aerodynamic and acoustic effects of the permeable gap fillers, as inferred from both the measurements of static and unsteady surface pressures and the microphone array data for the radiated noise. To understand the physical mechanism responsible for the noise reduction documented in Part I, as well as for the accompanying aerodynamic penalty due to the porous gap fillers, Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) is used in this paper to measure the flow details in the slat-cove region of the 30P30N model. A single angle of attack (𝛼 = 5.5◦) and a chord based Reynolds number of 1.71𝑒6 are selected as the test conditions. The PIV results show that the slat flow features are significantly altered with the presence of the porous gap filler, resulting in a more stable slat-cove shear layer and, thus, reduced velocity fluctuations with a successive decrease in the permeability. The porous gap filler with the lowest permeability acts similar to the solid gap filler. However, flow separation is observed on the upper side of the porous interface, which leads to an aerodynamic performance penalty via a reduction in lift on the main wing.

slat noise

Acoustic Flight Test of the Joby Aviation Advanced Air Mobility Prototype Vehicle

An extensive acoustic flight test was performed on the Joby Aviation pre-production all-electric vertical takeoff and landing prototype. With the design intent of carrying a pilot and four passengers a maximum range of 150 miles, this vehicle utilizes distributed propulsion and vectored thrust via six tilting propellers. As part of the Advanced Air Mobility (AAM) National Campaign, this is the first full-scale AAM aircraft tested by NASA over representative conditions for all phases of a typical mission profile. A 58- channel distributed microphone array was used to acquire acoustic measurements on more than 100 test points (31 unique conditions). The measurements were postprocessed with synchronously sampled vehicle position and state data to form ground noise contours of departures and approaches at various flight path angles and accelerations. Comparing ground areas of 75 dBA isolines, approaches consistently exhibit higher noise levels rela- tive to departures. Directivity maps were generated for constant airspeed level flyovers. Examples comparing the differences in a semi-thrust borne and full wing-borne mode are given, with full wing-borne mode representing the quietest phase of the flight envelope tested. Measurements for hover in and out of ground effect are given and found to have 2 to 5 dB variation over a single run, and more significant variation between back-to-back runs. Finally, initial analysis of acoustic symmetry about the longitudinal vehicle axis and repeatability over several test days are presented.

Acoustics

An Artificial Neural Network Approach to Predict Rotor-Airframe Acoustic Waveforms

A surrogate artificial neural network/machine learning model was developed to predict the acoustic interaction for a fixed-pitch rotor in proximity to a downstream cylindrical airframe typical of small Unmanned Aerial System (sUAS) platforms. The model was trained to predict the acoustic waveform under representative hover conditions as a function of rotational speed, airframe proximity, and observer angle. Training data were acquired in an anechoic chamber on both isolated rotors and rotor-airframe configurations. Acoustic amplitude and phase of the revolution-averaged interaction were predicted, which required up to 25 harmonics to capture the impulse event caused by the blade’s approach and departure from the airframe. Prediction performance showed, on average, that the models could estimate the acoustic amplitude and phase over the relevant harmonics for unseen conditions with 86% and 75% accuracy, respectively, enabling a time domain reconstruction of the waveform for the range of geometric and flow parameters tested.

acoustics

Acoustic Characterization of the NASA Langley 14- by 22-Foot Subsonic Tunnel using a Phased Array

A characterization test was conducted in the NASA Langley Research Center 14- by 22-Foot Subsonic Tunnel to assess recent acoustic modifications in the facility. Test section reflectivity, background noise and shear layer effects were evaluated by taking measurements of known noise sources. Both conventional speakers and a high-pressure air source were employed as noise generation mechanisms. These were mounted to a pole or fairing at a consistent location in the test section. The source waveforms were used to represent the expected frequency content of scaled Urban Air Mobility vehicles. Acoustic measurements were taken using two unique microphone arrays placed outside the core flow, one of which was a 54-element streamwise-traversing phased array. The other was an 11-element linear tower array. The applicability of phased array acoustic beamforming techniques to mitigate shear layer effects and reject background noise is presented. Additionally, beamforming results are compared to results from single-microphone processing techniques. Flow speeds investigated ranged from Mach 0.00 (static) to Mach 0.12. The tunnel has been partially acoustically treated but still exhibits flow noise, reducing the signal-to-noise ratio of the source under investigation. Conventional beamforming was able to capture high frequency content passing through the shear layer better than single microphone measurements. CLEAN deconvolution improves source mapping at low frequencies.

phased array

Reflectivity characterization of in-flow acoustic floor treatment for the NASA Langley 14- by 22-Foot Subsonic Tunnel

An experimental campaign was performed to assess acoustic modifications to the NASA Langley Research Center 14- by 22-Foot Subsonic Tunnel. Recent acoustic test campaigns in this facility have emphasized the reduction of aerodynamic noise due to flow scrubbing across acoustically treated floor baskets. However, the measures implemented to address this noise contaminant have resulted in the installation of floor basket coverings of high acoustic reflectivity. Therefore, a controlled test campaign was performed to identify a suitable acoustic basket configuration in terms of both acoustic absorptivity and reduced flow scrubbing noise. This test campaign was conducted in two phases: the first in an anechoic chamber facility on a single acoustic basket panel to identify a notional configuration of acceptable absorptivity, and the second in a complete floor basket installation checkout test in the NASA Langley 14- by 22-Foot Subsonic Tunnel. Results show that the newly implemented floor treatment exhibits suitable performance in both desired categories of acoustic absorptivity and reduced flow scrubbing noise. This campaign has also validated the effectiveness and usefulness of the anechoic chamber test configuration as a means of assessing acoustic reflections at oblique angles of incidence.

Nikolas S Zawodny