Engineering topics
Knudson, M. D.
Publications and source records attributed to Knudson, M. D..
Review of pulsed power-driven high energy density physics research on Z at Sandia
Pulsed power accelerators compress electrical energy in space and time to provide versatile experimental platforms for high energy density and inertial confinement fusion science. The 80-TW “Z” pulsed power facility at Sandia National Laboratories is the largest pulsed power device in the world today. Z discharges up to 22 MJ of energy stored in its capacitor banks into a current pulse that rises in 100 ns and peaks at a current as high as 30 MA in low-inductance cylindrical targets. Considerable progress has been made over the past 15 years in the use of pulsed power as a precision scientific tool. This paper reviews developments at Sandia in inertial confinement fusion, dynamic materials science, x-ray radiation science, and pulsed power engineering, with an emphasis on progress since a previous review of research on Z in Physics of Plasmas in 2005.
Mechanical and optical response of polymethylpentene under dynamic compression
Polymethylpentene, commonly referred to by its trade name TPX (Mitsui Chemicals, Inc.), is a thermoplastic polymer that has the potential to be a useful window material for dynamic compression experiments. For such experiments, an optically transparent or a low x-ray absorptive window is often used to maintain stress within the sample during compression. TPX can be used as a low-impedance optical and x-ray window due to its good transmittance in most parts of the electromagnetic spectrum, very low density (0.83 g/cm 3 ), and low x-ray absorption. In dynamic compression experiments, interferometry can be used to determine the particle velocity at the interface between the sample and window. However, velocimetry measures the rate of change of the optical path length, commonly referred to as the apparent particle velocity. An experimentally determined window correction factor is needed to ascertain the actual particle velocity from the measured apparent velocity. Here, we present the results of a series of dynamic compression experiments from 1 to 31 GPa designed to characterize the mechanical and optical response of TPX, determine the range of stresses over which TPX is transparent, and determine the window correction factor. Finally, the index of refraction was found to be essentially linear in density, resulting in a simple constant correction factor. TPX was found to remain largely transparent over the entire stress range examined.
Evaluation of exchange-correlation functionals with multiple-shock conductivity measurements in hydrogen and deuterium at the molecular-to-atomic transition
The temperature ( T ) and density (ρ) conditions at which hydrogen undergoes a molecular-to-atomic (MA) transition is crucial to our understanding of the gas-giant planets such as Jupiter and Saturn. First-principles (FP) calculations suggest that this transition is coincident with metallization and acts as a catalyst for hydrogen-helium demixing, which has significant consequences for models of planetary interiors. Prediction of this transition boundary has proven to be difficult using FP methods. In particular, detailed comparisons of finite temperature density functional theory (FT-DFT) calculations of the MA transition in both the high- T , low-ρ regime, where the transition is largely T driven, and the low- T , high-ρ regime, where the transition is largely ρ driven, suggest that the transition is very sensitive to the exchange-correlation (xc) functional used in the calculation. Here we present a detailed comparison of previous multiple-shock electrical conductivity measurements with FT-DFT calculations employing various xc functionals to probe a regime where both T and ρ play an important role in the transition. The measurement results are found to be inconsistent with the semilocal xc functional PBE and are in much better agreement with the nonlocal xc functionals vdW-DF1 and vdW-DF2. Furthermore, we show that the inconsistency with PBE likely stems from pressure errors associated with the PBE xc functional, resulting in calculated pressures that are too low at these T and ρ conditions. Together with previous comparisons at high- T , low-ρ and low- T , high-ρ these results provide a consistent picture for the MA transition over a wide T and ρ range. Here, this picture may also provide insight into differences in experimental observations of the metallization of liquid hydrogen and deuterium in the low- T regime.
A Review of Equation-of-State Models for Inertial Confinement Fusion Materials
Material equation-of-state (EOS) models, generally providing the pressure and internal energy for a given density and temperature, are required to close the equations of hydrodynamics. As a result they are an essential piece of physics used to simulate inertial con nement fusion (ICF) implosions. Historically, EOS models based on different physical/chemical pictures of matter have been developed for ICF relevant materials such as the deuterium (D2) or deuterium-tritium (DT) fuel, as well as candidate ablator materials such as polystyrene (CH), glow-discharge polymer (GDP), Berylium (Be), Carbon (C), and boron carbide (B 4 C). The accuracy of these EOS models can directly affect the reliability of ICF target design and understanding, as shock timing and material compressibility are essentially determined by what EOS models are used in ICF simulations. Systematic comparisons of current EOS models, benchmarking with experiments, not only help us to understand what model differences are and why they occur, but also to identify the state-of-the-art EOS models for ICF target designers to use. For this purpose, the first Equation of- State Workshop, supported by the US Department of Energy's ICF program, was held at the Laboratory for Laser Energetics (LLE), University of Rochester on 31 May - 2nd June, 2017. Finally, this paper presents a detailed review on the findings from this workshop: (1) 5-10% model-model variations exist throughout the relevant parameter space, and can be much larger in regions where ionization and dissociation are occurring, (2) the D 2 EOS is particularly uncertain, with no single model able to match the available experimental data, and this drives similar uncertainties in the CH EOS, and (3) new experimental capabilities such as Hugoniot measurements around 100 Mbar and high-quality temperature measurements are essential to reducing EOS uncertainty.
Extension of the Hugoniot and analytical release model of α -quartz to 0.2–3 TPa
In recent years, α-quartz has been used prolifically as an impedance matching standard in shock wave experiments in the multi-Mbar regime (1 Mbar = 100 GPa = 0.1 TPa). This is due to the fact that above ~90–100 GPa along the principal Hugoniot α-quartz becomes reflective, and thus, shock velocities can be measured to high precision using velocity interferometry. The Hugoniot and release of α-quartz have been studied extensively, enabling the development of an analytical release model for use in impedance matching. However, this analytical release model has only been validated over a range of 300–1200 GPa (0.3–1.2 TPa). Furthermore, we extend this analytical model to 200–3000 GPa (0.2–3 TPa) through additional α-quartz Hugoniot and release measurements, as well as first-principles molecular dynamics calculations.
Shock compression experiments on Lithium Deuteride (LiD) single crystals
Shock compression experiments in the few hundred GPa (multi-Mbar) regime were performed on Lithium Deuteride single crystals. This study utilized the high velocity flyer plate capability of the Sandia Z Machine to perform impact experiments at flyer plate velocities in the range of 17–32 km/s. Measurements included pressure, density, and temperature between ~190 and 570 GPa along the Principal Hugoniot—the locus of end states achievable through compression by large amplitude shock waves—as well as pressure and density of reshock states up to ~920 GPa. As a result, the experimental measurements are compared with density functional theory calculations, tabular equation of state models, and legacy nuclear driven results that have been reanalyzed using modern equations of state for the shock wave standards used in the experiments.
Probing off-Hugoniot states in Ta, Cu, and Al to 1000 GPa compression with magnetically driven liner implosions
We report on a new technique for obtaining off-Hugoniot pressure vs. density data for solid metals compressed to extreme pressure by a magnetically driven liner implosion on the Z-machine (Z) at Sandia National Laboratories. In our experiments, the liner comprises inner and outer metal tubes. The inner tube is composed of a sample material (e.g., Ta and Cu) whose compressed state is to be inferred. The outer tube is composed of Al and serves as the current carrying cathode. Another aluminum liner at much larger radius serves as the anode. A shaped current pulse quasi-isentropically compresses the sample as it implodes. The iterative method used to infer pressure vs. density requires two velocity measurements. Photonic Doppler velocimetry probes measure the implosion velocity of the free (inner) surface of the sample material and the explosion velocity of the anode free (outer) surface. These two velocities are used in conjunction with magnetohydrodynamic simulation and mathematical optimization to obtain the current driving the liner implosion, and to infer pressure and density in the sample through maximum compression. This new equation of state calibration technique is illustrated using a simulated experiment with a Cu sample. Monte Carlo uncertainty quantification of synthetic data establishes convergence criteria for experiments. Results are presented from experiments with Al/Ta, Al/Cu, and Al liners. Symmetric liner implosion with quasi-isentropic compression to peak pressure ∼1000 GPa is achieved in all cases. These experiments exhibit unexpectedly softer behavior above 200 GPa, which we conjecture is related to differences in the actual and modeled properties of aluminum.
Shockless compression and release behavior of beryllium to 110 GPa
A magnetohydrodynamic loading technique was used to shocklessly compress beryllium to peak longitudinal stresses of 19–110 GPa and, subsequently, unload in order to determine both the compressive response and also the shear stress supported upon release. Loading strain rates were on the order of 10{sup 6 }s{sup −1}, while the unloading rates were nearly constant at 3 × 10{sup 5 }s{sup −1}. Velocimetry was used to monitor the ramp and release behavior of a beryllium/lithium fluoride window interface. After applying window corrections to infer in situ beryllium velocities, a Lagrangian analysis was employed to determine the material response. The Lagrangian wavespeed-particle velocity response is integrated to generate the stress-strain path, average change in shear stress over the elastic unloading, and estimates of the shear modulus at peak compression. These data are used to infer the pressure dependence of the flow strength at the unloading rate. Comparisons to several strength models reveal good agreement to 45 GPa, but the data indicate 20%–30% higher strength near 100 GPa.
Determining the refractive index of shocked [100] lithium fluoride to the limit of transmissibility
Lithium fluoride (LiF) is a common window material used in shock- and ramp-compression experiments because it displays a host of positive attributes in these applications. Most commonly, it is used to maintain stress at an interface and velocimetry techniques are used to record the particle velocity at that interface. In this application, LiF remains transparent to stresses up to 200 GPa. In this stress range, LiF has an elastic-plastic response with a very low (<0.5 GPa) elastic precursor and exhibits no known solid-solid phase transformations. However, because the density dependence of the refractive index of LiF does not follow the Gladstone-Dale relation, the measured particle velocity at this interface is not the true particle velocity and must be corrected. For that reason, the measured velocity is often referred to as the apparent velocity in these types of experiments. In this article, we describe a series of shock-compression experiments that have been performed to determine the refractive index of LiF at the two most commonly used wavelengths (532 nm and 1550 nm) between 35 and 200 GPa to high precision. A modified form of the Gladstone-Dale relation was found to work best to fit the determined values of refractive index. In addition, we provide a direct relationship between the apparent and true particle velocity to correct experimentally obtained wave profiles by others using these velocimetry techniques.
Time-dependence of the alpha to epsilon phase transformation in iron
Here, iron was ramp-compressed over timescales of 3 ≤ t(ns) ≤ 300 to study the time-dependence of the α→ε (bcc→hcp) phase transformation. Onset stresses (σ α→ε ) for the transformation ~14.8-38.4 GPa were determined through laser and magnetic ramp-compression techniques where the transition strain-rate was varied between 10 6 ≤ $\dot{μ}$ α→ε (s ₋1 ) ≤ 5×10 8 . We find σ α→ε = 10.8 + 0.55 ln($\dot{μ}$ α→ε ) for $\dot{μ}$ α→ε < 10 6 /s and σ α→ε = 1.15($\dot{μ}$ α→ε ) 0.18 for $\dot{μ}$ α→ε > 10 6 /s. This $\dot{μ}$ response is quite similar to recent results on incipient plasticity in Fe suggesting that under high rate ramp compression the α→ε phase transition and plastic deformation occur through similar mechanisms, e.g., the rate limiting step for $\dot{μ}$ > 10 6 /s is due to phonon scattering from defects moving to relieve strain. We show that over-pressurization of equilibrium phase boundaries is a common feature exhibited under high strain-rate compression of many materials encompassing many orders of magnitude of strain-rate.
Probing the Interiors of the Ice Giants: Shock Compression of Water to 700 GPa and 3.8 g/cm³
Recently, there has been a tremendous increase in the number of identified extrasolar planetary systems. Our understanding of their formation is tied to exoplanet internal structure models, which rely upon equations of state of light elements and compounds such as water. Here, we present shock compression data for water with unprecedented accuracy that show that water equations of state commonly used in planetary modeling significantly overestimate the compressibility at conditions relevant to planetary interiors. Furthermore, we show that its behavior at these conditions, including reflectivity and isentropic response, is well-described by a recent first-principles based equation of state. These findings advocate that this water model be used as the standard for modeling Neptune, Uranus, and “hot Neptune” exoplanets and should improve our understanding of these types of planets.