Diagnostic measurements in harsh inertial fusion energy environments
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Kline, John L.↗
Engineering topics
Kline, John L.
Publications and source records attributed to Kline, John L..
Outer shell symmetry for double shell capsules with aluminum ablators
Double shell targets are a promising potential avenue to obtain robust neutron yield at current laser facilities. Similar to single shell designs, double shells require the symmetric implosion of an ablator in order to uniformly compress and heat a fuel volume, with the goal of achieving thermonuclear burn. Significant differences between double and single shells include the usage of an aluminum ablator as well as a reverse ramp laser pulse. In addition, double shells require a different convergence than single shells for fuel ignition. Numerical implosion studies at various energies with comparisons to experimental outcomes are required to gain confidence that simulations can capture the ablator shape from subscale to full scale. The current work builds on previous implosion experiments conducted at 1-MJ laser energy to con firm achieved ablator symmetry at 1.25 and 1.5 MJ. Average ablator P2 and P4 shapes measured in these experiments are within 5% of the simulated shape, which merits the platforms for further experimental studies.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Perspectives on the status of fusion energy research and near term directions [Slides]
Over the past few years, nearly five billion dollars of private investments from private industry sparked excitement for accelerating the development of fusion energy technologies. Driving these investments are various technical advances in research such as those at facilities such as JET, EAST, NIF, etc. At the same time, the Office of the President, in the spring of 2022, announced a commitment to fusion energy development as part of its strategy to combat climate change. With the goal of a pilot power plant by the 2040s, the research strategy shifted to public private partnerships as a means for the government to support the lofty goal of shorten the deployment time of fusion energy technologies. The rapid change in strategy created a quickly changing research landscape with many potential opportunities. In this presentation, I will attempt to paint a picture of the current state of fusion energy, highlight major challenges, and provide insights into some near-term opportunities for LANL.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Post-Shot Report for OMEGA Double Cylinders (CylDRT 22B)
The direct-drive double cylinder experimental platform is a high-energy-density (HED) science platform designed to image an imploding cylindrical target. The target consists of a directly-driven outer cylinder and a shock-and-collision driven inner cylinder. The purpose of this platform is to study hydrodynamic instability growth on the inner cylinder, the outer surface of which is classically Rayleigh-Taylor unstable during the acceleration phase. We present results from recent experiments at the OMEGA laser facility. These experiments were designed as a proof-of-principle for the platform, using the same cylinder exterior dimensions and direct-drive beam configuration as previous single cylinder experiments. In these experiments, three sets of targets were fielded: no machined perturbations (smooth), a sinusoidal mode-10 perturbation on the outer surface of the inner cylinder, and a mode-20 perturbation on the outer surface of the inner cylinder. The primary diagnostic was a gated x-ray framing camera which imaged the backlit inner cylinder on-axis for sixteen frames over a time window of 1 ns for each shot. A second side-lit radiograph captured one image per shot, diagnosing axial uniformity. In this report we include an overview of the results from both the backlighter and the sidelighter diagnostics. We discuss at length the experimental analysis process. Finally, we present the results of the smooth target implosion trajectory and compare them to post-shot simulations. We see favorable agreement between simulation and experiment.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Influence of mass ablation on ignition and burn propagation in layered fusion capsules
After decades of research, recent laser-driven inertial fusion experiments have demonstrated rapid progress toward achieving thermonuclear ignition using capsule designs with cryogenic fuel layers. The ignition physics for these layered capsules involves a complex interplay between the dynamically forming hot spot and the dense surrounding fuel. Using analytic theory and numerical simulations, we demonstrate that the mass ablation rate into the hot spot depends sensitively upon the temperature of the dense fuel, resulting in ablative inflows up to [Formula: see text] faster than previous estimates. This produces an enthalpy flux into the hot spot that plays a critical role in controlling the hot spot temperature, the ignition threshold, and the subsequent burn propagation. The net influence of mass ablation on the ignition threshold is regulated by a dimensionless parameter that depends upon the temperature of the dense fuel. As a consequence, the ignition threshold is sensitive to any mechanism that heats the dense fuel, such as neutrons or radiation emitted from the hot spot. These predictions are confirmed using radiation-hydrodynamic simulations for a series of capsules near ignition conditions. This analysis may have relevance for understanding the variable performance of recent experiments and for guiding new capsule designs toward higher fusion yields.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Density measurements for the National Ignition Facility (NIF) opacity platform
The Opacity Platform on the National Ignition Facility (NIF) has been developed to measure opacities at varying densities and temperatures relevant to the solar interior and thermal cooling rates in white dwarf stars. The typical temperatures reached at NIF range between 150 and 210 eV, which allow these measurements to be performed experimentally. The captured opacities are crucial to validating radiation-hydrodynamic models that are used in astrophysics. The NIF opacity platform has a unique new capability that allows in situ measurement of the sample expansion. The sample expansion data are used to better understand the plasma conditions in our experiments by inferring the sample density throughout the duration of the laser drive. Here, we present the details of the density measurement technique, data analysis, and recent results for Fe and MgO.
47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗
Preshot Report for OMEGA Double Cylinders (CylDRT 22B)
The primary goals for the May 2022 shot day at OMEGA are to: image an imploding inner cylinder as proof-of-principle for double cylinder experiments, measure the growth of pre-seeded perturbations on the inner cylinder, and measure the axial non-uniformity of the implosion with a sidelighter that provides a transverse view of the target. We will compare these experimental results to xRAGE (2D-only) and FLASH (2D and 3D) radiation-hydrodynamics calculations.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Fast ignition inertial fusion energy using laser-driven ion beams
Ion fast ignition (IFI), or fusion fast ignition initiated by a laser-driven ion beam, is a promising path to high-gain inertial fusion energy (IFE). In IFI, cold, dense deuterium-tritium (DT) fuel is first assembled using lasers or pulsed power drivers. Then, a high-power ion beam is focused onto a small volume within the fuel (the hot spot), heating the fuel rapidly to conditions where fusion ignition takes place. Fusion burn in this hot spot propagates to the fuel surrounding the hot spot, leading to burnup of a significant fraction of this fuel and the possibility of high gain (G~100), as needed for inertial fusion energy. IFI uses separate drivers for the two basic elements, fuel compression and ignition, allowing maximum control and optimization of each. On the other hand, conventional laser fusion uses multiple beams of the same driver to compress the fuel and shock-heat its very center to ignite a burn wave. Despite impressive progress in conventional laser fusion, the precise spatial symmetry, temporal pulse shaping and timing required for high gain and IFE remain a serious unmet challenge.
73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗
Fusion Power Program at LANL
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Kline, John L.↗
Evidence for Trapping-Induced Nonlinear Frequency Shifts in Langmuir Waves Driven via Stimulated Raman Scattering
Thomson scattering is used to detect the spectra of Langmuir waves driven through the backward stimulated Raman scattering process in a diffraction limited laser focal spot. Measured Langmuir wave spectral frequencies are found to vary in time and have broadened spectral power, consistent with a nonlinear frequency shift of the driven Langmuir wave due to electron-trapping. Broadening of the Langmuir wave spectral power is observed to decrease in time, consistent with measured variations in the frequency shift of the driven Langmuir waves. Furthermore, the observed spectral broadening is consistent with the temporally short (ps), bursty nature of backward stimulated Raman scattered light observed in simulations that cannot be resolved by the Thomson scattering diagnostic. Comparison of the broadened spectrum with time integrated spectra from two-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations shows favorable comparison in the broadened spectral widths, supporting the supposition of electron-trapping induced, nonlinear shifting of daughter Langmuir wave frequencies.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
A decadal view of the LANL HED/ICF Program [Slides]
The vast majority of nuclear weapon yield is generated in a regime of extreme temperature, pressure, and density. Without explosive nuclear testing, HED experiments on ICF facilities are the only way to approach and probe these extreme conditions that affect nuclear weapon performance.
45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗
Identifying Entangled Physics Relationships Through Sparse Matrix Decomposition to Inform Plasma Fusion Design
We report a sustainable burn platform through inertial confinement fusion (ICF) has been an ongoing challenge for over 50 years. Mitigating engineering limitations and improving the current design involves an understanding of the complex coupling of physical processes. While sophisticated simulation codes are used to model ICF implosions, these tools contain necessary numerical approximation but miss physical processes that limit predictive capability. Identification of relationships between controllable design inputs to ICF experiments and measurable outcomes (e.g., neutron yield, neutron velocity, areal density) from performed experiments can help guide the future design of experiments and development of simulation codes, to potentially improve the accuracy of the computational models used to simulate ICF experiments. We use sparse matrix decomposition methods to identify clusters of a few related design variables. Sparse principal component analysis (SPCA) identifies groupings that are related to the physical origin of the variables (laser, hohlraum, and capsule). A variable importance analysis finds that in addition to variables highly correlated with neutron yield, such as picket power and laser energy, variables that represent a dramatic change of the ICF design, such as number of pulse steps, are also very important. The obtained sparse components are then used to train a random forest (RF) regression surrogate for predicting total yield. The RF performance on the training and testing data compares with the performance of the RF trained using all the design variables considered. This work is intended to inform design changes in future ICF experiments by augmenting the expert intuition and simulation results.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Exploring Sensitivity of ICF Outputs to Design Parameters in Experiments Using Machine Learning
We report building a sustainable burn platform in inertial confinement fusion (ICF) requires an understanding of the complex coupling of physical processes and the effects that key experimental design changes have on implosion performance. While simulation codes are used to model ICF implosions, incomplete physics and the need for approximations deteriorate their predictive capability. Identification of relationships between controllable design inputs and measurable outcomes can help guide the future design of experiments and development of simulation codes, which can potentially improve the accuracy of the computational models used to simulate ICF implosions. In this article, we leverage developments in machine learning (ML) and methods for ML feature importance/sensitivity analysis to identify complex relationships in ways that are difficult to process using expert judgment alone. We present work using random forest (RF) regression for prediction of yield, velocity, and other experimental outcomes given a suite of design parameters, along with an assessment of important relationships and uncertainties in the prediction model. We show that RF models are capable of learning and predicting on ICF experimental data with high accuracy, and we extract feature importance metrics that provide insight into the physical significance of different controllable design inputs for various ICF design configurations. These results can be used to augment expert intuition and simulation results for optimal design of future ICF experiments.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Symmetry requirements for double shell capsules with aluminum ablators
Double shell targets present a promising avenue to obtain robust neutron yield on current laser facilities. The nature of the target, like current single shell designs, requires a symmetric implosion of an outer ablator to obtain a symmetric fuel volume that will lead to alpha heating and thermonuclear burn. Due to using aluminum as an ablator material and requiring different convergence than single shell symmetry studies at various energies are required. This paper moves forward from previous experiments conducted at 1MJ to show implosion symmetry at 1.25 and 1.5MJ. Symmetry in these experiments is sufficient to merit experiments using double shells to study the platform further. Additional studies are carried out on the outer shell symmetry impacts, showing that mitigating mode growth on the outer ablator is of great importance.
73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗
A temperature profile diagnostic for radiation waves on OMEGA-60
Predicting and matching radiation wave propagation with computational models has proven difficult. Information provided by experiments studying radiation flow has been limited when only radiation breakout is measured. We have developed the COAX (co-axial) diagnostic platform to provide spatial temperature profiles of a radiation wave through low density foams as a more detailed constraint for simulations. COAX uses a standard, laser-driven OMEGA-60 halfraum to drive radiation down a titanium-laden silicon oxide foam. Point-projection X-ray absorption spectroscopy perpendicular to the radiation flow measures the spatial profile of titanium ionization. The spectroscopic measurement utilizes a broadband capsule backlighter. Imaging and streak spectroscopy are used to characterize the size and spectrum of this source. Radiography provides an additional constraint by capturing the developing shock as the radiation flow becomes subsonic. The DANTE diagnostic is used to measure the halfraum temperature. Here, we provide a spectroscopic analysis of COAX data to determine temperature, and we describe experimental sources of uncertainty. The temperature is obtained by comparison to multi-temperature synthetic spectra post-processed from radiation-hydrodynamics simulations. Quantitative comparison between data and synthetic spectra generated from temperature profiles at relevant simulation times enable determination of a peak temperature of 114 ± 8 eV at 265 ± 22.4 μm from the halfraum. This represents an improvement over the temperature uncertainties of previous radiation flow experiments. Further refinements to the spectroscopic analysis could achieve ±4 eV. The combination between space-resolved spectroscopy and radiography enables us to determine the distance from the halfraum of both the radiation front and the shock front at the time of measurement. For the example shown in this paper the radiation front position is 600–630 μm at 3.43 ± 0.16 ns and the shock front position is 633 μm at 3.3 ± 0.24 ns.
72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗