Engineering PapersSearch

Engineering topics

Kirka, Michael M.

Publications and source records attributed to Kirka, Michael M..

Uncertainty Quantification of Fatigue Behavior of Rough AM Surfaces and Microstructures to Enable Hydrogen Gas Turbine

Modifying fossil-fueled industrial gas turbines to utilize low or zero-carbon fuels, such as hydrogen or hydrogen-natural gas blends, is a complex endeavor. The successful implementation of this technology hinges on three key design criteria: (1) developing new fuel injectors capable of efficiently burning alternative fuels, (2) ensuring manufacturability to meet cost and time-to-market goals, and (3) achieving component durability in the demanding environment of an operating gas turbine. Additive manufacturing (AM) accelerates product development, yet concerns persist regarding the durability of parts with rough AM surfaces. A fully experimental approach to quantify the fatigue performance of rough AM microstructures is both costly and labor-intensive. To address this, ORNL and Solar Turbines Incorporated (Solar) employed a crystal plasticity finite element (CPFE) model to identify the factors influencing AM surface fatigue behavior. These CPFE findings, combined with targeted experimental data, were used to develop a computationally efficient surrogate model suitable for assessing the lifespan of gas turbine engine components.

08 HYDROGEN

Denoising diffusion probabilistic models for generative alloy design

Inverse material design is an extremely challenging optimization task made difficult by, in part, the highly nonlinear relationship linking performance with composition. Quantitative approaches have improved significantly owing to advances in high throughput experimentation and computational thermodynamics. However, existing physics-based tools are mostly forward models; input a chemistry and obtain a prediction. More recently the materials community has leveraged advances in the machine learning community to establish novel inverse design frameworks. Very recently denoising diffusion probabilistic models have been shown to be extremely powerful generators producing synthetic data of various modalities e.g. images, text, audio, tables, etc.. In this work a novel framework for alloy design and optimization is proposed leveraging these class of models. Five key generative tasks are demonstrated (1) unconditional generation (2) composition conditioned generation (3) property conditioned generation (4) multi-feedstock conditioned generation and (5) generative optimization. These methods were tested on three case studies: high entropy alloy design, superalloy binder jet additive manufacturing, and in-situ dual-feedstock wire-arc additive manufacturing. Results indicate that the established models are extremely flexible, expressive, and robust. The architecture’s flexibility and training procedure empower the model to learn complex intra-compositional and composition-property relationships. Furthermore, the probabilistic nature of these models makes them well suited for addressing solution non-uniqueness and tackling uncertainty quantification tasks. While the fidelity and quantity of the underlying training data is paramount, we envision that future alloy design frameworks will make extensive use of these kinds of machine learning models as “search” tools bolstering the utility of experimental and computational approaches.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Using Additive Manufacturing to Repair Gas Turbine Hot Section Components

Ni-based superalloys are used in the hot sections of gas turbine engines due to their excellent high temperature performance. During service the material degrades due to exposure at high temperature and mechanical loads. Hence, utility provides often inspect, service, and repair components in gas turbine engines to ensure safe operation. A major challenge, however, is that the most heat-resistant alloys are generally considered ‘non-weldable’ rendering them difficult to repair via welding operations. In these cases components are often scrapped and then replaced by parts which must be re-manufactured. This burdens utilities with additional cost and supply chain issues can result in long term outages or reduced operating limits. In this work EPRI and ORNL investigated a proposed repair strategy for gas turbine hot section components. Hot section superalloy GTD-111 was selected as a candidate repair material system and AM material ABD-900 the repair material. Sandwich structures were fabricated via electron beam melting additive manufacturing (EBM-AM) producing tensile bars with gage sections consisting of dissimilar ABD-900 / GTD-111 / ABD-900 material. Metallography revealed that the interface exhibited no deleterious phases or processing defeats. Creep rupture experiments on heat treated material demonstrates that the emulated repair coupons exhibit creep resistance between GTD-111 and ABD-900. This study demonstrates that the proposed EBM-AM repair strategy presents a viable opportunity towards enabling AM repair of gas turbine engine components.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Understanding the influence of boron in additively manufactured GammaPrint®-700 CoNi-based superalloy

Boron is commonly added to superalloys in small amounts to enhance creep resistance, but can lead to cracking at high concentrations, especially during the additive manufacturing process. Two variants of CoNi-based GammaPrint®-700 superalloy with different B contents (0.08 at% vs 0.16 at%) were printed via laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) with the same printing parameters, with only the high B alloy exhibiting solidification cracking. Atom probe tomography (APT) revealed stronger segregation behaviors in the high B alloy compared to the low B alloy at both the inter-dendritic regions and grain boundaries (GBs). The segregation behavior at inter-dendritic regions was well captured with Scheil simulation and can correlate with the existing cracking susceptibility index (CSI) on cracking tendencies, although high angle GBs are where cracking occurs according to electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) measurements. Additionally, the extent of GB segregation was compared between the high B and low B alloy. Higher B additions led to significantly more GB B segregation in the high B alloy compared to the low B alloy. Further, for the high B alloy, the cracked region of one GB exhibited higher levels of B compared to the uncracked region of the same GB. However, much higher B contents were also found in two other uncracked GBs in the high B alloy, which demonstrates that higher GB B concentrations are not fully responsible for the cracking. A much larger variance in GB B segregation content was found in the high B alloy compared to the low B alloy. These phenomena were explained with a solidification model with the GB segregation content expressed explicitly by a modified Langmuir-McLean equation. This model linked the GB segregation content with solidification undercooling, which can be used as quantitative cracking criteria for future builds.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

LPBF Processability of NiTiHf Alloys: Systematic Modeling and Single-Track Studies

Research into the processability of NiTiHf high-temperature shape memory alloys (HTSMAs) via laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) is limited; nevertheless, these alloys show promise for applications in extreme environments. This study aims to address this limitation by investigating the printability of four NiTiHf alloys with varying Hf content (1, 2, 15, and 20 at. %) to assess their suitability for LPBF applications. Solidification cracking is one of the main limiting factors in LPBF processes, which occurs during the final stage of solidification. To investigate the effect of alloy composition on printability, this study focuses on this defect via a combination of computational modeling and experimental validation. To this end, solidification cracking susceptibility is calculated as Kou’s index and Scheil–Gulliver model, implemented in Thermo-Calc/2022a software. An innovative powder-free experimental method through laser remelting was conducted on bare NiTiHf ingots to validate the parameter impacts of the LPBF process. The result is the processability window with no cracking likelihood under diverse LPBF conditions, including laser power and scan speed. This comprehensive investigation enhances our understanding of the processability challenges and opportunities for NiTiHf HTSMAs in advanced engineering applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Location-Specific Microstructure and the Effect of Heat Treatment on Electron-Beam Melted Ni-Based Superalloy LSHR

Examine set-to-set variability with 4 build sets with the same layout Establish the effect of solutioning heat treatments (HT) on as-fabricated grain structure and microstructure – (gamma)’-solvus= 1156 ºC (1) As-fabricated (2) 2 hour subsolvus HT(-15 ºC) + conventional 2-step aging (3, 4, 5) 0.5 hour, 2 hours, 4 hours supersolvus HT (+18 ºC) + 2 step aging Gain insight into location-specific microstructure to correlate later to mechanical properties (tensile, creep, LCF behavior)

heat treatment

NASA/ORNL/AFRL Project Work on EBM LSHR: Additive Manufacturing of High-Temperature Gamma-Prime Strengthened Ni-Based Superalloys

Powder-bed fabrication of aerospace alloys may revolutionize production by eliminating the need for extensive machining and expensive tooling. Heated-bed electron-beam melting (EBM) offers advantages over non-heated laser additive manufacturing (AM) methods, including lower residual stress, reduced risk of contamination, slower cooling rates, and faster build times. NASA Glenn Research Center has joint project work with Oak Ridge National Lab and the Air Force Research Laboratory to explore the feasibility of fabricating advanced Ni-based gamma-prime superalloys with EBM AM.

additive manufacturing