Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Kim, Soon

Publications and source records attributed to Kim, Soon.

Update of the Nuclear Criticality Slide Rule: Review of the Estimation of the Number of Fissions

IRSN (France), LLNL (USA) and ORNL (USA) began a long-term collaboration effort in 2015 to update the nuclear criticality Slide Rule (https://ncsp.llnl.gov/analytical-methods/criticality-sliderule) for the emergency response to a nuclear criticality accident. The Slide Rule permits the estimation of neutron and gamma dose rates and integrated doses based upon estimated fission yields, as a function of distance from the fission source, and time after criticality accidents for different critical systems. This paper presents the review of the section “estimation of the number of fissions”, named “fission yield” in the Slide Rule document. This estimation is important because the other information provided by the Slide Rule is directly proportional to the number of fissions. The previous models, based on Hansen and Barbry formulae, will be presented with their associated assumptions and limitations. Then, new proposals will be presented with a comparison to past criticality accidents and experimental data. The new formulae, based on the heat energy equation, cover many types of criticality accidents (solution, dry or low-moderated powder, rods/assemblies in water and dry metal) and require limited information in an emergency situation.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Update of the Nuclear Criticality Slide Rule Calculations: Plutonium systems – Delayed Fission Gamma

IRSN (France), LLNL (USA) and ORNL (USA) began a long-term collaboration effort in 2015 to update the nuclear criticality Slide Rule for the emergency response to a nuclear criticality accident. The Slide Rule permits the estimation of neutron and gamma dose rates and integrated doses based upon estimated fission yields, as a function of distance from the fission source, and time after criticality accidents for different critical systems. This paper presents results from the fourth phase of the current update of the Slide Rule project, in which delayed fission-product gamma (DFG) dose rates of unreflected plutonium critical systems were compared by several modern 3D radiation transport codes (MCNP, COG, SCALE), using updated flux-to-dose conversion factors. Dose rates are calculated for fissile material at five moderation ratios (H/Pu), at 1 m above the ground as a function of distance (between 30 cm and 1,200 m) from the external surface of the source to the center of the detector, and for periods between 1 s and 1,000 min after the critical instantaneous event. Further efforts have been devoted to the determination of the delayed gamma source, by comparing the time-dependent energy spectra obtained from several methods. Overall, DFG dose rates calculated by each participant led to consistent results. Extra effort is under way to identify the cause of the remaining differences, by comparing precisely the gamma source, and particularly nuclides inventories.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Data Testing with Zero Power Reactor (ZPR), Zero Power Physics Reactor (ZPPR), and New Thermal Epithermal eXperiments (TEX) Plutonium Benchmarks [Slides]

This presentation states that new TSLs in ENDF/B-VIII.0 will reduce the overprediction of the library for the most moderated cases. The differences between VII.1 and VIII.0 are driven by the 239 Pu changes and are consistently higher for all configurations. The VIII.0 239 Pu thermal cross sections were specifically adjusted lower to better predict plutonium thermal solutions criticality benchmarks, yet they overpredict the TEX thermal configurations, moderated by PE. Other, smaller differences have been seen for 240 Pu and 56 Fe. PMM-002 has shown utility in testing cross sections over a wide range of neutron energies.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Simulation of the Post-Shot Radiation Environment in the National Ignition Facility

The National Ignition Facility at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory is the world’s biggest and most energetic laser system for inertial confinement fusion. The NIF is designed to perform shots with varying fusion yield (up to 20 MJ or 7.1 × 10 18 neutrons per shot). A great number of diagnostic instruments are present inside the target chamber (TC) and target bay (TB) during shots. The gamma dose rates due to neutron activation are estimated at various decay times following the high-yield (20-MJ) shots. Several components, like the snout assemblies of the diagnostic instrument manipulators and target positioners are inserted inside the TC, close to the target during the shot. These components represent major sources of gamma decay after retraction outside the TC. Five days after a 20-MJ shot, dose rates near the highly activated (retracted) parts are on the order of 1 mSv/h and dose rates within the TB outside the TC but at distance from the retracted components drop to about 50 to 70 μSv/h. The dose is dominated by decay of 24 Na (T 1/2 = 14.95 h) and waiting for two additional days drops the dose rates significantly. Seven days following a 20-MJ shot, dose rates in the immediate vicinity of the retracted components drop to <0.2 mSv/h and the general ambient dose rates within the TB (away from retracted components) near the TC drop to <10 μSv/h. Dose rates at much larger distances from the TC (near TB wall) are an order of magnitude lower. Detailed radiation transport simulations are performed to create detailed dose rate maps for all floors inside the TB. The maps are used to measure worker stay-out times following shots before entry is permitted into the TB.

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Analysis Capability and Data Needs Identified During the Evaluation of the SILENE CAAS Benchmarks

In October 2010, a series of benchmark experiments was conducted at the Commissariat à l’Énergie Atomique et aux Énergies Alternatives (CEA) Valduc SILENE facility. These experiments were a joint effort between the US Department of Energy (DOE) and the French CEA to create three benchmarks for verification and validation of radiation transport codes, as well as evaluated nuclear data, used to analyze criticality accident alarm systems (CAASs). Many preliminary details of these experiments and their evaluation have been discussed in previous publications. The first benchmark evaluation was published in 2015, and the second and third evaluations will be published at the end of 2016.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Final design for thermal epithermal experiments (TEX) with ZPPR plutonium/aluminium plates with polyethylene and tantalum - 13592

Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory has completed the final design for the first phase of the Thermal Epithermal experiments (TEX), which focused on critical configurations composed of plutonium/aluminum Zero Power Physics Reactor (ZPPR) plates moderated by polyethylene with and without a tantalum diluent. {sup 239}Pu and {sup 240}Pu were identified as being the number one and two nuclear data need by the nuclear criticality safety and nuclear data communities, with special emphasis placed on performance issues of the Pu cross sections in the intermediate energy region. Preliminary TEX design recommended tantalum as the first diluent to pursue for final design, as it represented a high priority data need, showed the highest sensitivity and largest contribution to uncertainty with the Pu ZPPR system, and a large number of high quality Ta plates from the ZPPR inventory in Idaho was readily available. The goals of the new critical experiments are 1) to create assemblies that span a wide range of fission energy spectra, from thermal (below 0.625 eV), through the intermediate (0.65 eV to 100 keV), and to fast energies (above 100 keV), and 2) to easily modify the assemblies to include high priority materials like tantalum. A total of ten critical configurations were designed as part of CED-2. Five TEX experiments (Experiments 1-5) were designed to establish baseline configurations with the Pu ZPPR plates covering the thermal, intermediate, and fast fission energy regimes. For all five experiments, the ZPPR plates will be arranged in layers of 24 plates (6 plates by 4 plates), resulting in approximately a 12 inch by 12 inch footprint. Multiple layers will be stacked together with varying thicknesses of interspersed polyethylene placed between the layers to fine tune the neutron spectrum of the assembly. The other five experiments (Experiments 6-10) will be similar to the five baseline experiments, except that a tantalum layer will be placed next to each plutonium plate layer, thus diluting the stack and allowing for tests of the neutron cross section for tantalum. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Evaluation of the concrete shield compositions from the 2010 criticality accident alarm system benchmark experiments at the CEA Valduc SILENE facility

In October 2010, a series of benchmark experiments were conducted at the French Commissariat a l'Energie Atomique et aux Energies Alternatives (CEA) Valduc SILENE facility. These experiments were a joint effort between the United States Department of Energy Nuclear Criticality Safety Program and the CEA. The purpose of these experiments was to create three benchmarks for the verification and validation of radiation transport codes and evaluated nuclear data used in the analysis of criticality accident alarm systems. This series of experiments consisted of three single-pulsed experiments with the SILENE reactor. For the first experiment, the reactor was bare (unshielded), whereas in the second and third experiments, it was shielded by lead and polyethylene, respectively. The polyethylene shield of the third experiment had a cadmium liner on its internal and external surfaces, which vertically was located near the fuel region of SILENE. During each experiment, several neutron activation foils and thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLDs) were placed around the reactor. Nearly half of the foils and TLDs had additional high-density magnetite concrete, high-density barite concrete, standard concrete, and/or BoroBond shields. CEA Saclay provided all the concrete, and the US Y-12 National Security Complex provided the BoroBond. Measurement data from the experiments were published at the 2011 International Conference on Nuclear Criticality (ICNC 2011) and the 2013 Nuclear Criticality Safety Division (NCSD 2013) topical meeting. Preliminary computational results for the first experiment were presented in the ICNC 2011 paper, which showed poor agreement between the computational results and the measured values of the foils shielded by concrete. Recently the hydrogen content, boron content, and density of these concrete shields were further investigated within the constraints of the previously available data. New computational results for the first experiment are now available that show much better agreement with the measured values.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Functional Bounding Content Envelope for Gamma and Neutron Emitting Isotopes in the Model 9977 Packaging

The contents approved for shipment in a Type B radioactive material transportation package have historically been descriptions of discrete items, or groupings of well-defined similar items, in the package safety basis documentation. The need for a comprehensive functional content envelope of both gamma and neutron emitting nuclides compliant with regulatory limits has become necessary as the DOE complex requires shipments of unique mixtures of radionuclides and impurities. Recent publications have presented a calculational model and a corresponding content envelope intended to be compliant with federal regulatory external radiation limits as well as design decay heat limits based on the Model 9977 Packaging. The methodology used to develop this content envelope consisted of determining the external radiation dose rates based on one gram of a given isotope combined, in the case of actinides, with various levels of light element impurities and determining the allowable mass to the regulatory limits based on these dose rates. The method of ratioing from these calculations to the masses that meet the regulatory limits fails in the case of some combinations of actinides and light element impurities because of the effect of subcritical multiplication, resulting in non-conservative and non-compliant dose rates in some cases. This is particularly true for many actinides combined with beryllium, boron, fluorine, lithium, and sodium. In this study, the source was modeled as a sphere with the appropriate dimensions based on the actinide or gamma source density and placed at the bottom of the containment vessel for maximum conservatism. The results presented in this report rectify the above-noted deficiencies by adjusting the previously determined mass limits so that the resulting dose rates are compliant with regulatory limits. Some amount of iteration was required in some instances to adjust the masses for dose compliance. In some instances the masses were increased since they were too conservative. In addition, the method of ratioing the masses when applied to several gamma emitting isotopes also resulted in either non-conservative or overly conservative data. The mass imits presented here are for bare sources and are complaint with the design decay heat limit of 19W. The masses are based on package surface dose rates (the limiting dose rate) that fall in the range 185-195 mrem/h, thus giving an additional margin of between 7.5% and 2.5% to the regulatory limit of 200 mrem/h. This report presents a revised set of mass limits (i.e., content envelope) for several neutron emitting actinides with varying levels of light element impurities compliant with both external radiation and design decay heat limits. In addition, revised limits for gamma sources are also presented. The neutron emitter mass limits are in Tables 1 through 9 and the gamma emitter mass limits are in Table 10. The revised content envelope covering a wide range of materials present in the DOE complex, was developed for the Model 9977 Packaging, providing conservative limits for other commonly-used Type B Packagings such as the Models 9975 and 9978. It should be noted that for the Model 9977 package, shipment is also possible with three shielded containers – lead or tungsten for gamma sources and polyethylene for neutron emitters. The design decay heat limits for these are as follows: 19W for tungsten, 6W for lead and 3W for polyethylene. The limits presented in this report would need to be checked against the lower decay heat limits for the lead and polyethylene and adjusted as required for compliance. Criticality safety is not factored into these limits and should be evaluated on a case by case basis.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

2010 Criticality Accident Alarm System Benchmark Experiment at the CEA Valduc SILENE Facility

Several experiments were performed at the CEA Valduc SILENE reactor facility, which are intended to be published as evaluated benchmark experiments in the ICSBEP Handbook. These evaluated benchmarks will be useful for the verification and validation of radiation transport codes and evaluated nuclear data, particularly those that are used in the analysis of CAASs. During these experiments SILENE was operated in pulsed mode in order to be representative of a criticality accident, which is rare among shielding benchmarks. Measurements of the neutron flux were made with neutron activation foils and measurements of photon doses were made with TLDs. Also unique to these experiments was the presence of several detectors used in actual CAASs, which allowed for the observation of their behavior during an actual critical pulse. This paper presents the preliminary measurement data currently available from these experiments. Also presented are comparisons of preliminary computational results with Scale and TRIPOLI-4 to the preliminary measurement data.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗