Satellite studies of magnetospheric substorms on August 15, 1968. VIII - Ogo 5 plasma wave observations.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Kennel, C. F..
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Summaries are presented of research in basic plasma physics. Nonlinear waves and shock-like phenomena were studied which are pertinent to space physics applications, and include specific problems of magnetospheric and solar wind plasma physics.
Scaling laws for possible outer planet magnetospheres are derived by extrapolation from terrestrial physics. These laws suggest that convection and its associated auroral effects are likely to be relatively less important than in the earth's case, and that there is a possibility that the outer planets have significant radiation belts of energetic trapped particles.
Wave propagation and refraction of Type 1 irregularities in the equatorial electrojet were investigated. Quantitative calculation of wave refraction in a model electrojet showed that the direction of wave refraction must change sign at one altitude. Waves propagating with the electrons rotate their wave vectors upwards in the upper electrojet and downwards in the lower electrojet during the day, and vice versa at night. Furthermore, the altitude region of largest linear growth rate is also the one with the weakest refraction rate. Consequently, computations of the ray-path integrated wave growth shows that this region would dominate the backscatter spectrum from the electrojet if linear theory were valid, and it is further noted that the maximum amplitude wave should have phase velocities exceeding the ion acoustic speed. It was concluded that propagation alone, without inclusion of nonlinear effects, cannot explain backscatter observations of a constant Doppler frequency shift given by the ion acoustic speed.
A simple analysis is presented which indicates that Type 1 irregularities which have a slight component of propagation along the magnetic field may be more unstable than those which propagate across the field. It was found that significant irregularity amplitudes may occur at the northern or southern extremities of the equatorial electrojet from those modes with large north-south group velocity, and they could significantly change our understanding of nonlinear solutions of the electrojet instability.
Following a southward shift of the interplanetary magnetic field, which implies enhanced reconnection at the nose of the magnetosphere, the magnetopause shrinks from its Chapman-Ferraro equilibrium position. If the convective return of magnetic flux to the magnetopause equalled the reconnection rate, the magnetopause would not shrink. Consequently, there is a delay in the development of magnetospheric convection following the onset of reconnection, which is ascribed to line tying by the polar cusp ionosphere. A simple model relates the dayside magnetopause displacement to the currents feeding the polar cap ionosphere, from which the ionospheric electric field, and consequently, the flux return rate, may be estimated as a function of magnetopause displacement. Flux conservation arguments then permit an estimate of the time scale on which convection increases, which is not inconsistent with that of the substorm growth phase.
Analytical investigation of parametric coupling of a large-amplitude 'pump' wave to a natural plasma mode of the ionospheric E layer. It is shown that the E layer plasma mode can be either stabilized or destabilized by the parametric process. Two necessary conditions for parametric interaction are (1) near frequency matching (i.e., the pump wave frequency should be near the local upper hybrid frequency) and (2) a finite electric field component of the pump wave perpendicular to the background static magnetic field. An investigation of the propagation characteristics of the pump wave in the magnetic equatorial region indicates that an obliquely propagating O mode in the magnetic meridian plane meets the two necessary conditions in an optimal manner. From typical values of ionospheric parameters it is estimated that the required incident energy flux of the pump wave for parametric stabilization or destabilization of the E layer plasma mode (near its natural marginal stability) is much less than 1 mW/sq m. Thus parametric coupling experiments for the ionospheric E layer are technically feasible.
Investigation of various changes in the configuration of the geomagnetic tail that occur during the growth phase of magnetospheric substorms. A flaring-tail model indicates that the observed increases in geomagnetic tail field are explained if the dayside magnetopause shrinks by 1 to 2 earth radii. Increased tail flaring also requires that the tail current sheet approach near the earth during the growth phase. The motion of the inner edge of the plasma sheet, and consequently an equatorward shift of the nightside auroral oval, is consistent with the structural modifications mentioned above.
Study of the formation of the quiet-time electron slot, which divides the radiation belt electrons into an inner and an outer zone. The pitch-angle diffusion of radiation belt electrons resulting from resonant interactions with the observed plasmaspheric whistler-mode wave band is quantitatively investigated. The effects of wave propagation obliquely to the geomagnetic field direction with the resulting diffusion at all cyclotron-harmonic resonances and the Landau resonance are evaluated along with the effects of interactions occuring at all geomagnetic latitudes. The results obtained account for the long-term stability of the inner radiation zone, the location of its outer edge as a function of electron energy, and the removal of electrons to levels near zero throughout the slot. Computed pitch-angle distributions and precipitation decay rates are in good agreement with slot-region observations.
Consideration of an idealized model of electrojet polarization. Precipitation from the inner edge of the electron plasma sheet creates a density maximum in the auroral-oval ionosphere, which in turn leads to Hall and Pedersen conductance maximums. It is then assumed that a uniform westward convection electric field is imposed on the lower ionosphere before polarization. Field-aligned currents must flow into the ionosphere equatorward and out of the ionosphere poleward of the Hall conductance maximum. As the convection field and ionospheric density increase during the substorm growth phase, the field-aligned current densities should eventually reach an instability threshold beyond which anomalous resistance should produce field-aligned electric fields. The partial blockage of the field-aligned currents produces an equatorward electric field and therefore a partial Cowling conductivity in the lower ionosphere. Rough numerical estimates indicate that the expected field-aligned currents can exceed the stability threshold estimated by Kindel and Kennel (1971), that 1- to 5-kV field-aligned potential drops correspond to significant electrojet enhancement, and that the required energy dissipation of field-aligned currents in the topside ionosphere, a few ergs/per sq cm per sec column, suggests significant topside modification following auroral breakup.
Scaling laws for possible outer planet magnetospheres are derived. These suggest that convection and its associated auroral effects will play a relatively smaller role than at earth, and that there is a possibility that they could have significant radiation belts of energetic trapped particles.
Demonstration that magnetosheath electrons precipitating into the dayside auroral oval are a significant source of ionization and consequently will lead to electrical conductivity enhancements within the oval. By assuming that the electrons are maintained isotropic by strong pitch-angle diffusion as they precipitate into the ionosphere, the precipitation heat flux can be simply related to solar-wind energy density and consequently to the level of magnetic activity. For quiet solar-wind conditions, the heat fluxes of 1 to 10 ergs/sq cm/sec expected and observed lead to height-integrated Pedersen conductivity enhancements of 4 to 15 mhos. During magnetic storms the conductivity enhancements could increase by a factor of 3 to 5. Since the precipitating electrons are soft, the Hall conductivity enhancements are smaller than the Pedersen conductivity enhancements. For typical electric fields the computed conductivity enhancements lead to field-aligned currents bounding the enhancements in order-of-magnitude agreement with observation. The topside ionosphere should also have a density enhancement over the auroral oval on the dayside.
Precipitation from the inner edge of the electron plasma sheet creates a density maximum in the auroral oval ionosphere, which in turn leads to Hall and Pedersen conductance maxima. A uniform westward convection electric field is imposed upon the lower ionosphere previous to polarization. Field-aligned currents flow into the ionosphere equatorward, and out poleward, of the Hall conductance maximum. As the convection field and ionospheric density increase during substorm growth phase, the field-aligned current densities eventually reach an instability threshold, beyond which anomalous resistance produces field-aligned electric fields. The partial blockage of the field-aligned currents produces an equatorward electric field and therefore a partial Cowling conductivity in the lower ionosphere.
A proposed model of the substorm growth phase describes a gradual development of internal magnetospheric convection driven by enhanced field-line reconnection at the front-side magnetopause. The observed increased tail magnetic field, inward motion of the tail current system, and inward displacement of the plasma sheet inner edge are shown to follow from a line-tied inward motion of the dayside magnetopause and a slow development of magnetospheric convection. Resulting changes in the nightside auroral oval ionosphere lead to the formation of the auroral electrojet which is the ground signature (magnetically) of substorm breakup.
A general description of cyclotron harmonic resonant pitch-angle scattering is presented. Quasi-linear diffusion coefficients are prescribed in terms of the wave normal distribution of plasma wave energy. Numerical computations are performed for the specific case of relativistic electrons interacting with a band of low frequency whistler-mode turbulence. A parametric treatment of the wave energy distribution permits normalized diffusion coefficients to be presented graphically solely as a function of the electron pitch-angle. The diffusion coefficients generally decrease with increasing cyclotron harmonic number. Higher harmonic diffusion is insignificant at very small electron pitch-angles, but becomes increasingly important as the pitch-angle increases. One thus expected the rate of pitch-angle scattering to decrease with increasing electron energy, since the resonant value of the latter varies proportionately with harmonic number. This indicates that, in mirror-type magnet field geometrics, such as the earth's radiation belts, the diffusion losses of high energy electrons are likely to be appreciably slower than those at low energy.
Relativistic electron precipitation during magnetic storms, showing cyclotron resonances with electromagnetic ion cyclotron waves
Experimental and theoretical studies are reported on ion acoustic and ion cyclotron turbulence and their roles in anomalous resistivity, viscosity, diffusion and heating and in the structure of collisionless electrostatic shocks. Resistance due to ion acoustic turbulence has been observed in experiments with a streaming cesium plasma in which electron current, potential rise due to turbulent resistivity, spectrum of unstable ion acoustic waves, and associated electron heating were all measured directly. Kinetic theory calculations for an expanding, unstable plasma, give results in agreement with the experiment. In a strong magnetic field, with T sub e/T sub i approximately 1 and current densities typical for present Tokomaks, the plasma is stable to ion acoustic but unstable to current driven electrostatic ion cyclotron waves. Relevant characteristics of these waves are calculated and it is shown that for ion, beta greater than m sub e/m sub i, the electromagnetic ion cyclotron wave has a lower instability threshold than the electrostatic one. However, when ion acoustic turbulence is present experiments with double plasma devices show rapid anomalous heating of an ion beam streaming through a plasma.
Topside ionospheric instabilities of electrostatic ion acoustic and ion cyclotron waves to field aligned currents in single and multiion plasmas