Accurate imaging of hydraulic fractures using templated electrical resistivity tomography
Not Available
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Johnson, Timothy C..
Not Available
Although geophysics has been used for identifying subsurface fluid flow and contaminant spatial distributions at the Hanford Site and elsewhere, geophysics has not been generally used for identifying aquifer stratigraphy at environmentally relevant depths (> 70 m). This is because the bulk geophysical measurements of aquifer sediments cannot be directly related to sediment properties due to competing effects (e.g., porosity, pore-fluid conductivity, grain-sizes), thereby restricting the ability of conventional geophysical tools from discriminating their variation. Electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) is a method that can overcome these limitations because time-lapsed imaging, demonstrating changes in these properties over time, can be obtained from field sensors that can be left in place.
Monitoring plays an important role in supporting remedial investigations and selection of remedies for groundwater contamination and for assessing performance during implementation of remedies. When a groundwater plume is near the interface between groundwater and surface water, the dynamics of groundwater flow at this interface needs to be considered in the design and implementation of a remedy. For this and other aquifer situations, groundwater flow dynamics may be difficult to evaluate through groundwater head measurements due to a sparse monitoring-well network, a relatively flat hydraulic gradient, or the presence of induced gradients from pumping operations or groundwater mounds. Geophysical approaches, coupled with other targeted measurements or the use of an ionic tracer, provide temporal data that can quantify groundwater flow dynamics. Recent developments include a flux-monitoring tool that measures fluid conductivity, bulk conductivity, and temperature at the interface between groundwater and surface water. Joint interpretation of these local data with temporal two- or three-dimensional geophysical data improves quantification of groundwater and mass flux at a targeted location. In addition, geophysical design improvements that enable the use of numerical simulations to evaluate implementation configurations and expected data resolution for geophysical methods identify threshold conditions for successful monitoring and identify the most cost-effective configurations to meet monitoring objectives.
Long-term monitoring solutions at contaminated sites are necessary to track plume migration and evaluate the performance of remediation efforts. Electrical resistivity imaging (ERI) can potentially provide information about plume dynamics; however, the feasibility and likelihood of success is seldom evaluated before conducting a field study. Coupling flow and transport models with geoelectrical models provides a powerful way to assess the potential effectiveness of an actual ERI field campaign. in this paper, we present a coupled approach for evaluating the feasibility of monitoring nitrate migration and remediation using 4D time-lapse ERI at a legacy nuclear waste facility. This kilometer-scale study focuses on depths below the water table (~70 m). A flow and transport model is developed to perform simulations of nitrate migration and removal via a hypothetical pump-and-treat system. A tracer injection is also simulated at the leading edge of the nitrate plume to enhance the conductivity contrast between the native subsurface and the groundwater fluids. Images of bulk conductivity provide limited information concerning plume migration while time-lapse difference images, which remove the static effects of geology, provide more useful information concerning plume dynamics over time. A spatial moment analysis performed on flow and transport and ERI models matches well during the tracer injection; however, inversion regularization smoothing otherwise limits the value in terms of locating the center of mass. We find that the addition of a tracer enables ERI to characterize plume dynamics during pump-and-treat operations, and late-time ERI monitoring provides a conservative estimate of nitrate plume boundaries in this synthetic study.
The Hanford Site 300 Area lies adjacent to the Columbia River, approximately 5 km north of Richland, Washington. Past waste disposal practices in the 300 Area resulted in vadose zone uranium contamination beneath former infiltration ponds and trenches. Stage-driven water table fluctuations and river water intrusion facilitate mobilization of uranium from contaminated sediments in regions periodically occupied by the water table (i.e., the periodically rewetted zone or PRZ), thereby raising groundwater uranium concentrations above the maximum allowable contaminant level for uranium. This report documents the ERT imaging operations and interpretation of imaging results in terms of the extent of amendment delivery (including phosphate and/or carrier fluid) within the treatment area. Based on the interpretation, amendment delivery to the LVZ and PRZ was observed to be variable between each of the three imaging clusters, as shown in Figure S.1. Amendment transport in Cluster 1 exhibited significant lateral flow in comparison to Clusters 2 and 3, resulting in a final amendment distribution throughout a large portion of the LVZ and PRZ sediment between the injection wells. Cluster 2 exhibited good amendment delivery in the LVZ only near the injection wells. In the PRZ at Cluster 2, amendment was effectively distributed through the full distance between injection wells. Cluster 3 exhibited the smallest amount of lateral flow and amendment was primarily distributed in the LVZ and PRZ very near the injection wells. Imaging results below the water table suggest that more amendment entered the groundwater in Cluster 2 and Cluster 3 than in Cluster 1.
The United States Department of Energy, Geothermal Technologies Office (GTO) is funding a collaborative investigation of enhanced geothermal systems (EGS) processes at the meso-scale. This study, referred to as the EGS Collab project, is a unique opportunity for scientists and engineers to investigate the creation of fracture networks and circulation of fluids across those networks under in-situ stress conditions. The EGS Collab project is envisioned to comprise three experiments and the site for the first experiment is on the 4850 Level in phyllite of the Precambrian Poorman formation, at the Sanford Underground Research Facility, located at the former Homestake Gold Mine, in Lead, South Dakota. Principal objectives of the project are to develop a number of intermediate-scale field sites and to conduct well-controlled in situ experiments focused on rock fracture behavior and permeability enhancement. Data generated during these experiments will be compared against predictions of a suite of computer codes specifically designed to solve problems involving coupled thermal, hydrological, geomechanical, and geochemical processes. Comparisons between experimental and numerical simulation results will provide code developers with direction for improvements and verification of process models, build confidence in the suite of available numerical tools, and ultimately identify critical future development needs for the geothermal modeling community. Moreover, conducting thorough comparisons of models, modelling approaches, measurement approaches and measured data, via the EGS Collab project, will serve to identify techniques that are most likely to succeed at the Frontier Observatory for Research in Geothermal Energy (FORGE), the GTO’s flagship EGS research effort. As noted, outcomes from the EGS Collab project experiments will serve as benchmarks for computer code verification, but numerical simulation additionally plays an essential role in designing these meso-scale experiments. This paper reviews specific numerical simulations supporting the design of experiments within Test Bed 1, a volume of phyllite rock under in-situ stress conditions off the western side of the West Access Drift on the 4850 Level, near Governor’s Corner. Numerical simulations were executed prior to the start of hydraulic stimulation activities within Test Bed 1 following standard practices, using best estimates of principal stress conditions, thermal conditions, and the rock petrophysical properties, including geomechanical properties. These simulations indicated notching of the borehole would promote the initiation of transverse fractures, seismic magnitudes during the hydraulic stimulation would be below 0.1 magnitude on the Richter scale, a rock thermal conductivity of 5.0 W/m K yielded agreement with kISMET borehole temperature logs, back pressure on the production borehole would increase circulation across the test bed, and the production borehole would serve to halt propagation of the hydraulic fracture to the drift. Pre-existing natural fractures, heterogeneities in the rock properties, monitoring boreholes, and overlooked mine elements have prompted a second look at numerically modeling stimulation, fluid circulation, tracer migration, and thermal breakthrough. Numerical simulation is an invaluable tool for providing insight and understanding to complex physical processes. The success of simulations, however, often depends on including all of the salient features of the system in the founding conceptual model. This paper takes a retrospective look at examples where the conceptual model and simulation was sufficient to provide accurate forecasts and those where elements were missing, necessitating rethinking of the simulation.
An in situ injection of polyphosphate amendment was conducted to address a uranium source zone for a plume near the Columbia River at the U.S. Department of Energy Hanford Site. This treatment was applied as an enhanced attenuation approach, targeting uranium in a periodically wetted zone where groundwater inundates as the water table rises in response to the seasonal high river stage. Uranium within this zone is mobilized into the groundwater at the high river stage, resulting in a persistent groundwater plume. The polyphosphate amendment creates precipitates that decrease uranium mobility so that the amount of uranium flushed into groundwater when the zone is periodically wetted is significantly decreased. With a reduced flux of uranium into the plume, the plume concentrations are expected to decrease over time. During injection, real-time geophysical monitoring was applied to provide hourly images of injected-fluid distribution. The real-time autonomous data collection, processing, and reporting enabled the electrical resistivity tomography images to provide operational feedback during injection. These data were used in conjunction with operational information (e.g., flow rate, pressures) and subsurface data from 24 monitoring wells placed within and downgradient of the treatment area (e.g., water level and specific conductance probes, uranium concentration, phosphate concentration) to assess overall performance of the treatment.
The EGS (Enhanced Geothermal Systems) Collab project is performing stimulation experiments in highly monitored and well-characterized intermediate-scale (~10-20 m) field test beds. The characterization and monitoring system includes an array of electrodes grouted in place within six monitoring wells, with 16 electrodes per well. The electrodes enable characterization of the 3D low-frequency electrical properties of the host rock, and changes in those properties during stimulation and tracer testing using both static and time-lapse Electrical Resistivity Tomography. In this talk we present: 1) ERT array design and installation, 2) baseline (pre-stimulation) imaging results, 3) time-lapse data collected during stimulation operations, and 4) real-time imaging during clean water injections intended to illuminate flow paths as a decrease in bulk electrical conductivity. We will also discuss aspects and lessons learned for conducting ERT imaging operations in the presence of high fluid pressure gradients during stimulation and flow operations. Results to date reveal a highly heterogeneous rock fabric, ranging over four orders of magnitude in bulk electrical conductivity, and high polarization capacity. Baseline imaging results are consistent with borehole logs and core studies. Time-lapse imaging results to identify major flow paths during tracer studies are forthcoming and will be discussed during this presentation. Ultimately the ERT imaging data sets provide useful information for validating and verifying model predictions in preparation for research at DOE’s Frontier Observatory for Research in Geothermal Energy (FORGE).
Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS) offer the potential to extract and use large quantities of clean energy, but questions remain on reservoir creation and sustainability. The EGS Collab project, supported by the US Department of Energy’s Geothermal Technologies Office, is establishing a suite of highly monitored and well-characterized intermediate-scale (~10-20 m) field test beds along with fracture stimulation and interwell flow tests to better understand processes that control formation of effective subsurface heat exchangers. EGS Collab tests will provide a means of testing tools and concepts that could later be employed under geothermal reservoir conditions at DOE’s Frontier Observatory for Research in Geothermal Energy (FORGE) or enhanced geothermal systems. Key to the project is using numerical simulations in the experiment design and interpretation of results. Our first set of experiments is underway at the Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF) in South Dakota. To date, stepwise stimulations have been performed at two locations, with the final stimulation connecting our injection and production wells. Numerous data have been collected and are currently being analyzed.
The objective of the EGS Collab project is to establish a suite of intermediate-scale (~10-20 m) field test beds coupled with stimulation and interwell flow tests to provide a basis to better understand fracture stimulation methods, resulting fracture geometries, and processes that control heat transfer between rock and stimulated fractures. Experiment 1 of the project is being conducted at a depth of ~1.5 km in the Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF) on the 4850 Level (ft. below the ground surface). The stimulation method planned for Experiment 2 of this project is hydroshearing of an existing natural fracture. In siting this experiment, there are several key geologic criteria that need to be met. These include: 1) the fracture should be least 10 m in length so that it could be intersected by two boreholes that are spaced that far apart; 2) it should be optimally oriented relevant to the stress field so that it is critically stressed; 3) the site should have appropriate stress conditions (not too shallow a depth); 4) the fracture should have sufficient permeability to allow for prestimulation flow testing, but not too high a permeability that would preclude permeability enhancement via shear stimulation; 5) the fracture should not intersect other features (permeable fractures, boreholes, adjacent drifts) that could serve as major leak-off zones; 6) the site should not be complicated by geology (a single lithology would be preferred). In addition, there are logistical criteria that will also influence site selection, including: 1) site availability/access, 2) logistical support, e.g., power, internet, water, operating rail system; 3) drift size and orientation compatible with drilling and site operations; 4) appropriate ground support. There are only two deep levels at SURF that can be accessed by the Yates Shaft: the 4100 and the 4850, so we limited our search to these two levels. Currently, three candidate sites are being evaluated: the existing Experiment 1 site and its surroundings on the West Drift on the 4850 level, and two locations on the 4100 level. This paper will evaluate advantages, disadvantages, and risks associated with these three options at SURF.
The vadose zone within the Hanford Central Plateau contains large quantities of mobile contaminants that have not yet reached the groundwater. Deep vadose zone (DVZ) contamination is located below the depth of direct contaminant exposure potential, but may be a current and/or potential future source of groundwater contamination. Monitoring to observe subsurface processes and driving forces related to contaminant transport or to directly observe contaminant movement in the DVZ provides remedy performance information prior to contaminants reaching the groundwater and thereby is an important element of a remedy implementation.
Development of Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS) requires accurate predictions of flow rates and temperatures at production wells over time. The concept of EGS is simple; however, complications from heterogeneity and complexity of fracture pathways may lead to channeling, short-circuiting, and premature thermal breakthrough. In the EGS Collab project, we are establishing a suite of highly monitored and well characterized intermediate-scale (~10-20 m) field test beds along with fracture stimulation and interwell flow tests to better understand processes that control formation of effective subsurface heat exchangers. EGS Collab experiments will provide a means of testing tools and concepts that could later be employed under geothermal reservoir conditions at FORGE or elsewhere. Key to the project is using numerical simulations in the experiment design and interpretation of results. Our tests will be well-controlled, in situ experiments focused on rock fracture behavior and permeability enhancement. Our pre- and post-test modeling results of each field experiment compared with detailed measurements will allow for improved model prediction and validation. We will use comprehensive instrumentation to collect high-quality and high-resolution geophysical and other fracture characterization and fluid flow data. We will analyze these data and compare them with models and field observations to further elucidate the basic relationships between stress, induced seismicity, and permeability enhancement. We will also observe and quantify other key governing parameters that impact permeability, and will attempt to understand how these parameters might change throughout the development and operation of an EGS project with the ultimate goal of enabling commercial viability of EGS. Our first set of experiments will be performed at the Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF) in South Dakota. Our team is well underway with building the first field experiment test bed planned for this project, which is supported by the US Department of Energy’s Geothermal Technologies Office.
Changes in bulk electrical conductivity are governed in large part by two diagnostic parameters concerning the state of vadose zone contamination: saturation and pore fluid conductivity. As a robust, remote, non-invasive, three-dimensional, and scalable imaging tool, time-lapse electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) can provide extensive diagnostic information concerning vadose zone contaminant distribution and migration by imaging changes in bulk electrical conductivity. We demonstrate long-term surface ERT monitoring of a ~70-m-thick contaminated vadose zone to investigate whether rising groundwater nitrate levels are caused by unanticipated vadose zone flux. A three-dimensional time-lapse image spanning 10 years (2007-2017) reveals the impacts of meteoric surface infiltration events, but ultimately supports the adequacy of current conceptual understanding by indicating that rising nitrate levels are not sourced in the vadose zone.
Some of the inorganic and radionuclide contaminants in the deep vadose zone at the Hanford Site are at depths where direct exposure pathways are not of concern, but may need to be remediated to protect groundwater. The Department of Energy developed a treatability test program for technologies to address Tc-99 and uranium in the deep vadose zone. These contaminants are mobile in the subsurface environment, have been detected at high concentrations deep in the vadose zone, and at some locations have reached groundwater. The treatability test of desiccation described herein was conducted as an element of the deep vadose zone treatability test program. Desiccation was shown to be a potentially effective vadose zone remediation technology to protect groundwater when used in conjunction with a surface infiltration barrier.
Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS) development will require an ability to accurately predict the flow rates and temperatures of the production wells. While simple in concept, complex heterogeneous fracture pathways can lead to channeling, short-circuiting, and premature thermal breakthrough complicating EGS. The EGS Collab project will establish a suite of intermediate-scale (~10-20 m) field test beds coupled with stimulation and interwell flow tests to provide a basis to better understand the fracture geometries and processes that control heat transfer between rock and stimulated fractures. These experiments will provide a means of testing tools, codes, and concepts that could later be employed under geothermal reservoir conditions at FORGE and in EGS. We will perform well-controlled, in situ experiments focused on rock fracture behavior and permeability enhancement. Pre- and post-test modeling of each test will allow for model prediction and validation. Comprehensive instrumentation will be used to collect high-quality, high-resolution geophysical and fracture characterization and fluid flow data. ,These data will be analyzed and compared with models and field observations to further elucidate the basic relationships between stress, induced seismicity, and permeability enhancement. To the maximum extent achievable, we will observe and quantify other key governing parameters that impact permeability, and attempt to understand how these parameters might change throughout the development and operation of an EGS project with the goal of enabling commercial viability of EGS. The Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF) in South Dakota was selected as the EGS Collab project experimental site based on the evaluation of information from several sites. Our team has designed and constructed the first field experiment planned for this project, which is supported by the US Department of Energy’s Geothermal Technologies Office.
The first experiment of the Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS) Collab (a.k.a Stimulation Investigations for Geothermal Modeling Analysis and Validation (SIGMA-V)) project is designed to comprehensively monitor a series of hydraulic fracture stimulations and subsequent flow tests. This experiment is planned for the 4850 Level in the Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF), located at the former Homestake Gold Mine, in Lead, South Dakota. The target host rock for these stimulations and flow tests is a phyllite schist known as the Poorman formation. This paper discusses at a high level the engineering design for the stimulation and fracture monitoring system, the considerations for the test bed construction, and the preliminary stimulation modeling. Furthermore, this paper will highlight the intricate ways that predictive modeling can be used for testbed and stimulation design. This project is funded by the United States Department of Energy, Geothermal Technologies Office (GTO).
For sites with vadose zone contamination, the nature and extent of groundwater contaminant plumes are related to the flux into groundwater. In thick vadose zones at arid sites, transport is likely relative slow, complicating direct measurement of contaminant flux. A predictive numerical analysis was applied to estimate contaminant flux to groundwater at the Hanford BY Cribs site. The site received large amounts of waste water in the 1950’s, containing contaminants such as technicium-99 and nitrate. Recently, large increases in groundwater concentrations have been observed in site groundwater wells and, for potential remediation purposes, the assumption that the changes are the result of increased vadose zone fluxes into groundwater needed to be evaluated. The analysis approach uses forward simulations, tracking contaminants during and after disposal, and imposed concentration (IC) simulations, where concentrations, derived from electrical conductivity data obtained in 2007, are imposed on the flow field. A total of three IC methods, relating electrical conductivity to nitrate concentrations, are developed and tested. The numerical analysis shows that the forward simulations predict high fluxes during and directly after disposal, with decreasing trends starting not later than 1970. Although the IC simulations show differences in the nitrate vadose zone mass imposed in 2007 compared to forward simulations, the IC simulations also show declining nitrate fluxes over time. The predicted fluxes of the forward and IC simulations after 2007 are in reasonable agreement. Given the declining nature of the contaminant fluxes, it can be concluded that the observed concentration increases in the groundwater below the BY Cribs site cannot be explained as resulting from an increase in contaminant flux from the vadose zone. An alternative explanation, based on the observed decrease in aquifer thickness below the site, is presented.
The Solfatara volcano is the main degassing area of the Campi Flegrei caldera, characterized by 30 of unrest. Assessing and understanding such renewal activity is a challenging task because hydrothermal interactions with magmatic gases remain poorly understood. In this study, we decipher the complex structure of the shallow Solfatara hydrothermal system by performing the first 3-D, high-resolution, Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) of the volcano. The 3-D resistivity model was obtained from the inversion of 43,432 resistance measurements performed on an area of 0.68 km 2 . The proposed interpretation of the multiphase hydrothermal structures is based on the resistivity model, a high-resolution infrared surface temperature image, and 1,136 soil CO 2 flux measurements. In addition, we realized 27 soil Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC) and pH measurements demonstrating a negligible contribution of surface conductivity to the shallow bulk electrical conductivity. Hence, we demonstrate that the resistivity changes are mainly controlled by fluid content and temperature. The high-resolution tomograms identify for the first time the structure of the gas-dominated reservoir at 50 m depth that feeds the Bocca Grande fumarole through a ~10-m-thick channel. In addition, the resistivity model reveals a channel-like conductive structure where the liquid produced by steam condensation around the main fumaroles flows down to the Fangaia area within a buried fault. The model delineates the emplacement of the main geological structures: Mt Olibano, Solfatara crypto-dome, and tephra deposits. It also reveals the anatomy of the hydrothermal system, especially two liquid-dominated plumes, the Fangaia mud pool and the Pisciarelli fumarole, respectively.