John Prothro | Engineering Papers

NASA NTRS2023

A System to Provide Deterministic Flight Software Operation and Maximize Multicore Processing Performance: The Safe and Precise Landing – Integrated Capabilities Evolution (SPLICE) Datapath

A method and design are described for a system that processes multiple data streams, utilizing a multicore asymmetric processing architecture, that eliminates data interrupts to the application processors. The design supports a deterministic environment for flight software in NASA’s Safe and Precise Landing – Integrated Capabilities Evolution (SPLICE) project. The SPLICE project develops sensor, algorithm, and compute technologies for Precision Landing and Hazard Avoidance (PL&HA) capabilities. The compute technology for SPLICE is the Descent and Landing Computer (DLC). The DLC hosts several SPLICE algorithms with high computational resource requirements that must be executed in a real-time and deterministic manner. The software runs on a custom Single Board Computer (SBC), with a Xilinx Ultrascale+ Multiprocessor System-on-a-Chip (MPSoC). Input data for the flight software is from a variety of sensors, unique with respect to data rate and packet size. A data path between the SPLICE sensors and algorithms is designed to efficiently deliver this data to the flight software using the MPSoC asymmetric processing cores and Field Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) fabric. This is implemented in a manner that isolates the application processors running the flight software from interrupts associated with the input data. By leveraging real-time processors on the MPSoC, and a structure with the appropriate interfaces in the shared memory on the SBC, the flight software can use the full set of application processors. The available utilization for each processor in this set is also maximized for the SPLICE applications, providing a sufficiently deterministic execution environment without the cost and overhead of a real-time operating system.

David K. Rutishauser↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

NASA and Blue Origin Collaborative Assessment of Precision Landing Algorithms and Computing

NASA’s Safe and Precise Landing Integrated Capabilities Evolution (SPLICE) project is developing sensor, algorithm, and compute technologies for precision landing and hazard avoidance. These technologies are being tested as an integrated Precision Landing and Hazard Avoidance (PL&HA) system on Blue Origin’s New Shephard suborbital vehicle. A key goal for the computing element of this technology development is to characterize the performance of the SPLICE software workloads on the project’s Descent and Landing Computer (DLC). The DLC is a multi-core processor designed as a surrogate for NASA’s High-Performance Space Computer (HPSC). Measurements of the SPLICE workload performance on the DLC provides NASA insight on how PL&HA capabilities will perform on the HPSC, and guidance on how the SPLICE algorithms can be implemented to best utilize the DLC platform. This insight can also be used to derive requirements to guide trade studies on candidate computing architectures, for use on platforms like Blue Moon. NASA and Blue Origin are collaborating under an agreement to pursue this mutual benefit. Performance metrics collected are based on measurement of common compute resources such as percentage used of memory bandwidth, I/O utilization, interrupt latency, and kernel vs. user space code residency. Where possible existing performance counters and metrics that are part of the operating system kernel are used. As the design has a significant FPGA component, performance counters are identified and instantiated in the fabric to measure DMA performance and interface metrics. Collection of metrics is performed on the DLC with a representative workload that simulates a full landing cycle of the Blue Origin New Shepard vehicle. Consideration is given to the other compute implementations and whether they can run SPLICE algorithms at the same rate and with the same latency as the DLC. One option being considered is the use of a RISC-V soft core instantiated in a radiation resilient FPGA fabric such as the Xilinx KU60. Select algorithms from the SPLICE code will be run for comparison with the DLC. This paper describes how the DLC is instrumented to collect performance measurements of the SPLICE workloads, preliminary results from these measurements, and their implications on SPLICE algorithm implementation. The results of experimentation to derive candidate requirements for architecture trades on a PL&HA computing system are also presented.

computer performance↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

NASA and Blue Origin’s Flight Assessment of Precision Landing Algorithms Computing Performance

NASA’s Safe and Precise Landing - Integrated Capabilities Evolution (SPLICE) project continues NASA’s work in the development and testing of technologies for Precision Landing and Hazard Avoidance (PL&HA). This paper presents results characterizing how SPLICE flight software utilizes the shared computing resources of the Descent Landing Computer (DLC), one of the PL&HA technologies under development. The SPLICE technologies are being tested as an integrated payload on Blue Origin’s New Shephard suborbital vehicle. The results presented in this paper are measured by applications running in and with the flight software both in flight, and in a high-fidelity Hardware-in-the-Loop (HWIL) simulation environment. Linux utilities to measure performance are also executed from the command line in the HWIL configuration. Performance measurements of the SPLICE workloads executing on the DLC provide insight on how efficiently the software is utilizing the DLC resources. Examples of how these measurements have guided improvements in the flight code are presented. In addition, the DLC uses a commercial processor as a surrogate for NASA’s High Performance Spaceflight Computing (HPSC) processor. This work provides insight on how an HPSC system may perform delivering PL&HA capabilities on a future mission. The measurements also can be used to infer architectural requirements for PL&HA capabilities, informing the HPSC project and other flight computer development efforts. Examples of the measurements collected include processor utilization, I/O bandwidth, cache and branch misses, and application profiles.

Precision Landing and Hazard Avoidance↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

NASA and Blue Origin’s Flight Assessment of Precision Landing Algorithms Computing Performance

NASA’s Safe and Precise Landing - Integrated Capabilities Evolution (SPLICE) project continues NASA’s work in the development and testing of technologies for Precision Landing and Hazard Avoidance (PL&HA). This paper presents results characterizing how SPLICE flight software utilizes the shared computing resources of the Descent Landing Computer (DLC), one of the PL&HA technologies under development. The SPLICE technologies are being tested as an integrated payload on Blue Origin’s New Shepard suborbital vehicle. The results presented in this paper are measured by applications running in and with the flight software both in flight, and in a high-fidelity Hardware-in-the-Loop (HWIL) simulation environment. Linux utilities to measure performance are also executed from the command line in the HWIL configuration. Performance measurements of the SPLICE workloads executing on the DLC provide insight on how efficiently the software is utilizing the DLC resources. Examples of how these measurements have guided improvements in the flight code are presented. In addition, the DLC uses a commercial processor as a surrogate for NASA’s High-Performance Spaceflight Computing (HPSC) processor. This work provides insight on how an HPSC system may perform delivering PL&HA capabilities on a future mission. The measurements also can be used to infer architectural requirements for PL&HA capabilities, informing the HPSC project and other flight computer development efforts. Examples of the measurements collected include processor utilization, I/O bandwidth, cache and branch misses, and application profiles.

Precision Landing↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

A System to Provide Deterministic Flight Software Operation and Maximize Multicore Processing Performance: The Safe and Precise Landing – Integrated Capabilities Evolution (SPLICE) Datapath

A method and design are described for a system that processes multiple data streams, utilizing a multicore asymmetric processing architecture, that eliminates data interrupts to the application processors. The design supports a deterministic environment for flight software in NASA’s Safe and Precise Landing – Integrated Capabilities Evolution (SPLICE) project. The SPLICE project develops sensor, algorithm, and compute technologies for Precision Landing and Hazard Avoidance (PL&HA) capabilities. The compute technology for SPLICE is the Descent and Landing Computer (DLC). The DLC hosts several SPLICE algorithms with high computational resource requirements that must be executed in a real-time and deterministic manner. The software runs on a custom Single Board Computer (SBC), with a Xilinx Ultrascale+ Multiprocessor System-on-a-Chip (MPSoC). Input data for the flight software is from a variety of sensors, unique with respect to data rate and packet size. A data path between the SPLICE sensors and algorithms is designed to efficiently deliver this data to the flight software using the MPSoC asymmetric processing cores and Field Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) fabric. This is implemented in a manner that isolates the application processors running the flight software from interrupts associated with the input data. By leveraging real-time processors on the MPSoC, and a structure with the appropriate interfaces in the shared memory on the SBC, the flight software can use the full set of application processors. The available utilization for each processor in this set is also maximized for the SPLICE applications, providing a sufficiently deterministic execution environment without the cost and overhead of a real-time operating system.

heterogeneous processing system↗