Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Huber, Zachary F.

Publications and source records attributed to Huber, Zachary F..

Radiological Characterization of Uranium Decay Products in LEU U-10Mo Before and After Heat Treatment

Fuel for the U.S. high-performance research reactor fleet is undergoing significant development as the United States moves away from using highly enriched uranium dispersion fuels. The proposed fuel is a high-density, low-enriched uranium (LEU, 19.75 wt% U 235) alloyed with ten weight percent molybdenum fuel (known as LEU U 10Mo). The LEU U 10Mo fuel samples studied in this report were made by down-blending highly enriched uranium with a master alloy, which is cast from molybdenum rods and depleted uranium, via vacuum induction melting and then casting.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Chlorine Isotope Separations using Thermal Diffusion

As of the close of 2023 a thermal diffusion isotope separations (TDIS) apparatus was constructed, successful shakedown testing was achieved and enrichments of isotopic concentrations relative to natural abundance 35/37 Cl were collected. Further, the model for these enrichment experiments drove the timing for sampling and other critical, extrapolated functions that are discussed herein. Our decision to move forward in 2024 with the installation of a larger set of separation tubes and associated equipment was based on the successful development of the predictive model. The Chlorine Isotopes Project Team at PNNL is prepared to claim that the installation and hence its separative power is restricted only by the spatial limitations of the laboratory, and this at present appears to be the limiting feature to first pass high enriched 37 Cl.

07 ISOTOPE AND RADIATION SOURCES↗

Casting and Characterization of U-50Zr

Uranium alloyed with 50 wt% zirconium (U-50Zr) is a proposed light water reactor (LWR) nuclear fuel by Lightbridge Corporation (LTBR). The proposed method for making the U-50Zr alloy is to arc-melt master alloys and then remelt in a vacuum induction melter (VIM) to consolidate the material and cast into an intermediate shape. After casting, the material will eventually need to be formed into a desired fuel shape. The work discussed in this report resulted from a joint effort between Ltbr and Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNN) to investigate a 500g – 1kg scale casting process to produce the U-50Zr alloy in the desired δ-UZr 2 phase and characterize the impurities and microstructure that result from the casting process. Master alloys were fabricated in an arc melter, then five castings were carried out in a VIM with multiple inert coating and crucible materials to find an appropriate combination. Both ZrO 2 and graphite crucibles were used and different combinations of Y 2 O 3 , CaZrO 3 , and TiC to identify which would contain the molten metal with the least reaction. On each casting, the C, O, N, H impurities were analyzed as well as the phase by x-ray diffraction and microstructure. Of the five castings, two resulted in majority of δ-UZr 2 phase-pure material and had impurity levels within acceptable ranges. The two most successful castings utilized a graphite crucible with a TiC undercoating and a Y 2 O 3 overcoat. The O and N levels were below 1000 ppm and the C content was variable but did not result in measurable carbide formation. The highest success casting resulted in an average of 282 ppm C, 567 ppm O, 217 ppm N and 79 ppm H. This casting's crucible and inert coating material was repeated with slightly different casting parameters and resulted in higher C numbers but similar phase identification. The differences between each casting are discussed and recommendations are made for future experiments to better decide on a casting process to go forward with.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Electropolishing of a Full-Sized U-10Mo Plate

Electropolishing is used to remove material from the surface of a metal using electric potential and current. U-10Mo fuel is produced from a low enriched uranium plate alloyed with 10% molybdenum (U-10Mo). Electropolishing is being considered in two steps of the process of fabricating this U-10Mo fuel. First, it could be used as a means initially improving the surface finish of the cast plate while removing smut from the casting process from the surface prior to homogenization. Second, it could be used again after homogenization to remove oxidation and continue to improve the surface finish prior to hot rolling. The purpose of this work is to demonstrate the process on full-size ingots and optimize the process. A depleted uranium U-10Mo plate was electropolished three times: the first two times were prior to homogenization and the third after a homogenization step. The first two polishes decreased the overall roughness, as measured by laser confocal microscopy. After each polish, a smoother and shinier blue-gold surface was left on the plate. Upon homogenization, the surface had a more matte appearance and the surface roughness increased back to the pre-homogenization values obtained prior to the initial polish. After electropolishing the homogenized pieces, the changes in surface roughness increased, as measured by laser confocal microscopy. The final polishing step was not long enough to return the surface roughness to pre-homogenization conditions, implying less polishing is needed before the homogenization versus afterwards. Heat generation during the polish was addressed by circulating the electrolyte solution through an external heat exchanger; however, solubility and anodization challenges require further study.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

A Robust Processing Approach for Producing Highly Loaded Dispersion Fuels

A robust fabrication method, resulting in higher yields, to produce highly loaded U3Si2-Al dispersion fuels for converting research reactors from a high enriched to a low enriched uranium fuel needs to be developed. To reliably produce a highly loaded dispersion fuel, process changes need to be implemented where the traditional approach has experienced challenges and poor yields. The present work describes the key changes needed. Parts of the work were done with uranium silicide and parts were completed with a representative silicide surrogate. The major deviations from traditional fabrication methods are associated with a refinement in particle size distribution, method for compacting to achieve complex shapes, and welding of the aluminum picture frame used to encapsulate the fuel compact. Methods for rolling and arc melting are also discussed. By using the methods described within, fabricating a highly loaded dispersion fuel that can meet stringent fuel homogeneity and geometry requirements at higher yields and lower costs may be possible.

U3Si2, HFIR, dispersion fuel, Uranium, Research Re↗

Forming Complex Nuclear Fuel Shapes in High-Loaded Silicide Surrogates

This work provides proof of the concept that high silicide loading nuclear fuel meat surrogates with complicated geometries can be produced with uniform density through an application of cold isostatic pressing (CIP). Dispersion fuels with high volumetric loading of U_3 Si_2 have challenges in fabrication. Fabrication involves a series of processes including powder compaction, rolling pack assembly, and roll forming. PNNL has undertaken extensive experimental work using MoSi2 and WSi2 as surrogates for U3Si2 to explore the feasibility of reducing or eliminating the issues through the application of CIP in the powder pressing step prior to rolling pack assembly. The composites were prepared at >40 vol% silicide loading, which was representative of 4.8 gU/cm^3 and formed via CIP at 50 KSI (Kilopound per Square Inch) pressure. The CIP mold design was taken through a design process which aimed to reduce defects and increase precision. The application of CIP here provides a broad strategy for producing highly loaded dispersion fuels with complex geometries and uniform density.

Clelland, Dustin T.↗

A comparison of carbon impurities in pre- and post-melt uranium Part 1: Scanning electron microscopy analysis

Although C impurities in U have been studied for decades, fundamental questions regarding their incorporation, migration, and overall transformation during metal processing still exist. In two written Parts, we compare the chemical speciation, distribution, crystallography, and morphologies (size, shape, etc.) of carbon-containing impurities in U metal both before and after melting using high resolution analytical electron microscopy (AEM). This first Part demonstrates the variability of carbide inclusions in depleted U (DU) metal with respect to their chemical phases and morphologies as observed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Here, a variety of inclusion types, such as the pill-shaped U monocarbide (UC), previously only hypothesized, are summarized. Additionally, delineation between hopper-shaped U carbonitride U(C,N) and dendritic UC inclusions is discussed in relationship to archived literature.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Hot Forging Options for Thick Castings

Uranium alloyed with 10 wt% molybdenum (U-10Mo) is a monolithic nuclear fuel relevant to the National Nuclear Security Administration’s nonproliferation efforts. Research has been underway to optimize processing techniques for the U-10Mo fuel. This study investigated the use of hot compression or “hot forging” on a thick (~1") cast and homogenized U-10Mo plate before standard hot and cold rolling procedures. After plates were cast and homogenized, six samples were cut and forged at 700°C at a strain rate of either 0.10 s –1 or 0.01 s –1 at six levels of reduction. After forging, all samples underwent hot and cold rolling followed by annealing to achieve a final foil thickness of about 0.0085". Samples were taken at each stage of the casting and thermomechanical processing to assess the microstructural evolution. Chemical composition, microstructure, and uranium carbide morphology are presented and assessed in this study. Upon hot forging, dislocations accumulate along the grain boundaries, which serve as nucleation sites for randomly oriented, strain-free grains during subsequent annealing steps. Hot forging and subsequent annealing produced very heterogeneous grain sizes. However, no molybdenum segregation was observed after forging. No obvious trend was observed between forging conditions (strain rate and reduction percentage) and the microstructure after final thermomechanical processing. Upon hot rolling to 0.04" and annealing (700°C for 45 min), the average grain diameters from OM was 17 ± 2 µm across the six different forged samples. The subsequent cold rolling to 0.0085" and then annealing (700°C for 45 min) resulted in an average of 13 ± 2 µm between the six samples. Thus, the starting, as-forged microstructure did not appear to significantly influence the final microstructure of the cold-rolled foil. These results will help with understanding and expanding hot working capabilities for thicker U-10Mo castings. They also provide useful information on the effects of hot forging and its potential use to minimize defects that can arise during subsequent hot and cold rolling procedures.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Delayed onset of discontinuous precipitation-based phase transformation in U10Mo alloys doped with Silicon

A uranium-10 wt% molybdenum (U-10Mo) alloy is one of the primary candidates for metallic fuels that would use low-enriched uranium in place of highly enriched uranium, to support nuclear nonproliferation efforts. Optimal performance of a U-based metallic nuclear fuel can be achieved by retaining the high-temperature, body-centered cubic (bcc) allotrope (γ-U) at room temperature, which can be accomplished in the U-10Mo alloy. However, presence of minor alloying elements can influence the final constitution of room-temperature phases in the U10Mo alloy, specifically, formation of α-U phase which results in anisotropic behavior of the fuel in reactor. Further, through a detailed transmission electron microscopy analysis, the present study reports the constituent phases that are present in a U10Mo alloy containing ~0.1 wt% Si after it is subjected to homogenization heat treatment and thermomechanical processing. For comparison, results from an undoped U10Mo alloy are also included. The experimental results reveal that γ-UMo solid solution is the major phase in a hot-rolled, Si-doped U10Mo alloy metallic fuel foil, along with U 2 MoSi 2 C, UC, and U 2 Mo, after isothermal annealing at 460 °C for 10h. In contrast, after the same heat treatment, the undoped U10Mo alloy metallic fuel had formed a noticeable amount of α-U along prior γ-UMo grain boundaries through discontinuous precipitation (DP, area fraction: ~27.9%) with characteristic lamellar morphology, together with γ-UMo, UC, and U 2 Mo. This result indicates that doping with Si could mitigate the DP reaction in U10Mo alloy and prevent formation of undesirable α-U. This work sheds light on optimizing Si-doping–dominated microstructure in U10Mo fuels and facilitates designing and tuning of microstructures of U10Mo alloys for tailoring the final designed performance of the fuel under irradiation.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Capability to Process and Characterize Uranium-Zirconium (U-Zr) and Uranium-Zirconium-Plutonium (U-Zr-Pu) Alloys

This work investigated co-reduction of anhydrous compounds of uranium, zirconium, and plutonium to produce uranium rich ternary nuclear fuel alloys. Metallothermic co-reduction is a novel method to produce all-metal nuclear fuels. Metal fuels offer thermal, fissility, compatibility, and security benefits over oxide fuels. Alloys of uranium–10% zirconium with plutonium contents of 0%, 2.5%, 5%, and 10% were produced, with yields of 60–85% of theoretical values in a traditional calciothermic bomb reduction apparatus. Microstructural analysis indicated transformation of uranium phase from gamma to beta and then alpha, in alternating lamellar plates typical of alpha phase uranium and delta phase uranium-zirconium, with zirconium and carbides at prior grain boundaries. Some of the analyses were inconclusive in their results and therefore require additional testing. Successful ternary co-reduction would simplify production of homogeneous feedstock and thereby streamline manufacture of homogeneous ternary metallic fuel.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Alternate Methods for Cleaning Zirconium Plate

The United States High Performance Research Reactor Conversion Program identified the need to transition from highly enriched uranium fuel to lowly enriched uranium fuel for high power research and civil reactors. One of the fuel configurations selected for these reactors was a uranium (U) foil alloyed with 10% molybdenum (Mo). The U-10Mo fuel foil was then covered with a zirconium (Zr) interlayer and pressed into an aluminum cladding. Idaho National Laboratory prescribed a need to remove surface oxidation on the Zr prior to bonding it with U-10Mo fuel foil. To determine the best method of oxidation removal, a variety of polishing methods, including hand polishing with a diamond paste or Scotch-Brite™ pads, mechanically wet-polishing with abrasive belts, and chemical etching with hydrofluoric/nitric acid mixtures, were investigated on pre-polished Zircaloy 702 sheets purchased directly from the manufacturer. No change in surface roughness was detected using any of these methods relative to the as-received material. In fact, scanning electron microscopy detected grit from hand polishing with Amplex Grade 30 waste soluble diamond paste and Scotch-Brite™ pads. Visible staining was found, and fluorine detected via X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy on the flash etching samples. These contaminants were not seen on the as-received material. In addition to the need to remove the oxide layer on the Zr prior to co-rolling, there are concerns that the Neolube debonding agent on the co-rolling can may contaminate the Zr surface after co-rolling. The experimental results found that zirconium in contact with Neolube coated steel plates was easily cleaning with ethanol wiping after heat treated and no carbide inclusions remained on the surface. Overall, all cleaning methods tested did not significantly change the surface roughness of the plates or reduce the oxide layer present on the zirconium. Carbon was found on all the samples, before and after cleaning, except for the flash etch samples which detected fluorine instead. The insignificant changes seen in the cleaned plates relative to the as received plates question the need for cleaning prior to rolling. Further investigation in the requirements for cleaning at this step is recommended. Current methods for cleaning the surface after hot rolling with alcohol appear sufficient. After hot rolling, if Neolube does peel off the can and onto the zirconium coated foil surface, a dry abrasive or diamond paste polish is not recommended due to the chance of abrasive being embedded into the surface. However, the ability of an etchant to lift the lubricant off the zirconium surface indicates that a spot etch method could work to clean specific spots where Neolube is present, if the need arises.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

PNNL FY2021 Sibling Pin Testing Results

The post-irradiation examination, axial tensile, burst, and four-point bend testing results of the first two sibling pins, 6U3/L8 and 5K7/P2 are presented.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Effects of Casting Parameters and Impurity Concentrations on As-Cast U–10Mo

This work investigates the effects of casting parameter changes on as-cast uranium-10 wt% molybdenum alloys on a 1-2kg scale. A commercial tilt-pour vacuum induction melting system was utilized to study the effects of casting atmosphere, total heating time, hold time at maximum temperature, mold temperature, and crucible type on the as-cast microstructure of U-10Mo. Ten thin plates (5.08 mm thick) and four thick plates (25.4 mm and 63.5 mm thick) were cast and analyzed for carbon, oxygen, hydrogen, and nitrogen impurities. Additionally, molybdenum content and primary dendrite length (PDL) of the microstructure was quantified. A statistical evaluation was performed to identify key carbon and oxygen relationships with operating parameters, impurities, and primary dendrite length. Additional factors investigated include: crucible material, time at maximum temperature, total heating time, and pour temperature. Zirconia crucibles reduced carbon content on average by 35%. Additionally, there was a significant statistical association between carbon and oxygen content, between oxygen content and maximum temperature hold time, between mold temperature and PDL, and between PDL, maximum temperature hold time and mold temperature.

Huber, Zachary F.↗

Development of Casting Techniques for d-phase Uranium-Zirconium Alloys: CRADA 524 [Abstract only]

Casting of d-phase HALEU UZr2 alloy is an early milestone in the fabrication process for Lightbridge Fuel™. The Radiochemical Processing Laboratory at PNNL has been identified as having both the capability and expertise to perform the necessary high temperature casting of samples of Lightbridge’s alloy. The necessary equipment, facility licensing, and shipping capabilities for special nuclear material coupled with its expertise in uranium casting techniques makes PNNL uniquely suited to this project.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Enhancing isotope mixing in U-10Mo downblend castings with electromagnetic stirring

Uranium alloyed with 10 wt percent molybdenum (U-10Mo) is the proposed fuel for use in the United States’ high-performance research reactors. The U-10Mo fuel is fabricated by a two-step casting process that downblends highly enriched uranium with depleted uranium (DU) and/or natural uranium (NU) and subsequently alloys the resulting high-assay low-enriched uranium (HALEU) with Mo. Currently, a two-step casting process is needed to meet the ingots’ U-235 enrichment homogeneity specifications. This work demonstrates the ability to provide more homogeneous U-235 distributions during downblend casting by using zirconia for crucibles rather than graphite. When graphite is used as a crucible, the electromagnetic field produced by the induction heater couples directly with the graphite. Zirconia is nonconducting in this study, and therefore does not couple with the field. The induction field couples directly with the metal, and causes electromagnetic stirring (EMS) in the molten metal pool. Eight downblend casting experiments were carried out in this work. Four were performed with zirconia crucibles and four with graphite crucibles. The U-235 enrichment was measured at nine discrete points in each casting using laser ablation multi-collector inductively coupled mass spectrometry (LA-MC-ICP-MS). The enrichment homogeneity was approximately eight times better in zirconia crucible castings than in graphite crucible castings as measured by the plate enrichment range and enrichment coefficient of variation. The results show a single casting step could be used to meet USHPRR enrichment specifications if electromagnetic stirring is present during casting. A related investigation was carried out to determine whether it is appropriate to measure enrichment on as-cast ingots or whether heat treated specimens should be used to accurately characterize enrichment. The results show that the as-cast microstructure plays a significant role in enrichment homogeneity. It is recommended that all enrichment measurements be done after the homogenization heat treatment typical of U-10Mo processing.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Thermomechanical Processing of Uranium Alloys with 10 and 50 Weight Percent Zirconium

This work focuses on casting and thermomechanical processing for moderate sized (500-1000g) 10% by weight and 50% by weight uranium-zirconium alloys. Three castings of uranium – 10wt% zirconium and a fourth casting of uranium – 50wt% zirconium were completed using different castings processes. The first casting process relied on only induction mixing within the VIM system thereby eliminating the need for an arc-melting feedstock preparation step. The second casting process used the arc-melting process prior for feedstock to the same VIM system. In this study, the induction mixing process alone with a graphite crucible appears insufficient for the fabrication of UZr alloys. Graphite is suitable with the use of master alloy UZr feedstock produced by arc-melting. There was a moderate increase of approximately 100 ppm of carbon within the U10Zr alloys. However, there was a near 1000 ppm increase of carbon in the U50Zr alloy. This carbon content is considered too high for forming processes, and therefore, warrants the use of a ceramic crucible for UZr castings near 50wt% zirconium. Zirconia does not appear suitable for UZr castings near 50wt% zirconium. The use of Beryllia or Thoria may be a more suitable option. However, due to the significantly lower liquidus and lower zirconium content, Zirconia crucibles do appear viable for carbon reduction in the U10Zr system. Two thermomechanical processes are also studied in this work - hot extrusion of the U50Zr system and heat treatment in an argon atmosphere. This work demonstrated that extrusion of the U50Zr alloy near 680°C is a viable choice even with +1000 ppm carbon. Extrusion of the U50Zr system near 630°C was unsuccessful and does not appear viable unless significant force and tooling strength is available. There appears to be a moderate increase in extrudate hardness when compared to as-cast. Heat-treatment reduced the hardness of as-cast alloys in the U10Zr castings as well as resolve some variance in the microstructures. However, for the U50Zr billet that did not successfully extrude at 630°C, heat treatment at 900°C for 96 hours did not have a significant impact on hardness or microstructure.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗