Engineering topics
Holcomb, Andrew
Publications and source records attributed to Holcomb, Andrew.
Improvement of SCALE-XSPROC Multigroup Cross Section Processing Based on the CENTRM Pointwise Slowing Down Calculation
The SCALE-XSProc multigroup (MG) cross section processing procedure based on the CENTRM pointwise slowing down calculation is the primary procedure to process problem-dependent self-shielded MG cross sections and scattering matrices for neutron transport calculations.This procedure supports various cell-based geometries including slab, 1-D cylindrical, 1-D spherical and 2-D rectangular configurations and doubly heterogeneous particulate fuels. Recently, this procedure has been significantly improved to be applied to any advanced reactor analysis covering thermal and fast reactor systems, and to be comparable to continuous energy (CE) Monte Carlo calculations. Some reactivity bias and reaction rate differences have been observed compared with CE Monte Carlo calculations, and several areas for improvement have been identified in the SCALE-XSProc MG cross section processing: (1) resonance self-shielding calculations within the unresolved resonance range, (2) 10 eV thermal cut-off energy for the free gas model, (3) on-the-fly adjustments to the thermal scattering matrix, (4) normalization of the pointwise neutron flux, and (5) fine MG energy structure. This procedure ensures very accurate MG cross section processing for high-fidelity deterministic reactor physics analysis for various advanced reactor systems.
ENDF/B-VIII.0 Augmented Covariance Data The first iteration [Slides]
Nuclear data are necessary for reliable modeling and simulation of the next generation of nuclear reactors. However, the variation in the ratio of the computed to experimental values (C/E) for certain types of nuclear systems is much less than predicted by evaluated nuclear data file (ENDF)/B covariances. Figure 1 provides an example of a set of metal-plutonium-fueled, fast-spectrum (PU-MET-FAST) integral experiments from the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project (ICSBEP) in the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) VALID database. The variation in the C/E values, shown with one standard deviation error bars, is 100% covered by both the SCALE and ENDB/VIII.0 covariance data. This is due to the comparisons to integral data that are essential during the evaluation process. However, the ENDF evaluations represent uncertainties and correlations in differential data only; they do not reflect the impact of the comparison to integral data in the covariance evaluations.
Current Status of SAMMY [Slides]
SAMMY is used to analyze experimental data mainly in the resolved range to generate evaluated data files for use in transport codes. The code base in SAMMY is still mostly F77, i.e., fixed line length and almost no use of modules. SAMMY is used in production environments, so during the modernization its functionality cannot be lost. That means we cannot simply rewrite it from scratch. Modernization is needed to allow us to add new features (for example new and improved algorithms in the resolved range). SAMMY has a large suite of regression tests that can be run and whose outputs can be checked automatically. During the modernization process, we will not change the results of these regression tests, except if errors in the original coding are found and corrected. Future plans for SAMMY include converting all container array access to Fortran allocate (or use C++ storage) and finishing the conversion to use C++ storage for all resonance parameters. We have an initial C++ implementation of the cross section reconstruction from R-Matrix parameters, used in AMPX. We will update this code, add reconstruction of angular data and derivatives and will use it in AMPX and SAMMY. Once this is done, we can start to add new features to the R-Matrix algorithm, like complex channel radii or relativistic effects. We also intend to modularize SAMMY to separate cross section reconstruction, experimental effect etc. from the Bayes fitting routines.
Current Status of AMPX [Slides]
This presentation discussed the added additional GNDS functionality to AMPX which we intend to share with SAMMY. Additionally, this presentation discusses how new ENDF/B-VIII.0 libraries were generated for SCALE. The presentation also discusses the AMPX training that was prepared and presented in Oak Ridge and at NRC headquarters.
Bayesian Monte-Carlo Evaluation Framework of Differential and Integral Data [Slides]
This presentation discusses the Bayesian Monte Carlo evaluation framework of differential and integral data, specifically in relation to two methods that are based on Bayes theorem, which assumes that all PDFs are normal (Gaussian) and that they use a linear approximation for IBEs. The presentation states that basic components of the MC evaluation framework include the computation of random MC ensemble from ENDF File 32, the simulation of IBEs and R-matrix cross section compared to experimental data, and the computation of weighted averages. It also states that the application to U-233 indicates deviation from the conventional linear approximation. In conclusion, evaluation framework will require MCMC method e.g., Metropolis-Hastings (M.-H.).
Impact of the ENDF/B-VIII.0 Library on Advanced Reactor Simulations
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
NCSP Analytical Methods Subtask 3, AMPX Development and Maintenance, and NCSP Nuclear Data Subtask 6, SAMMY Modernization
SAMMY 1 is a production code that still contains a lot of old-style FORTRAN (F77) code. While the code is widely used and performs well, the legacy code base makes it difficult to maintain and to add new features. However, because it is a production code, it cannot lose any functionality while being modernized. In addition, new features need to be added to support the changing needs of the evaluators to analyze data obtained with new equipment and at higher resolution. In addition, as the data are analyzed with higher fidelity and new models within SAMMY, the processing codes and formats must keep pace. This will ensure that any new SAMMY evaluation can be processed by AMPX and can be tested and used in transport codes like SCALE 2 for maximum benefit of the Nuclear Criticality Safety Program (NCSP) mission.
Summary: Verification of the ENDF/B-VII.1 and VIII.0 AMPX 1597-group Libraries for Advanced Reactor Analysis
The SCALE/AMPX multigroup (MG) cross section processing procedure has been updated to minimize reactivity differences for various advanced thermal and fast reactor designs, as observed for the current MG libraries, resulting in excellent agreement between the calculations with the new MG libraries and the continuous-energy reference calculations. The SCALE MG calculations are widely applied to thermal spectrum light-water reactor systems, as well as fast spectrum metallic systems. Due to growing interest from industry and regulators in applying SCALE for the design of fast spectrum reactors—both sodium and molten salt—it was desirable to review and improve the SCALE/AMPX procedure for unresolved resonance self-shielded data and high-energy neutron spectra. The data were improved by generating MG unresolved resonance data based on the analytic probability table method with the narrow resonance approximation and by using very fine and intermediate group structures that are typical for fast system analysis. This study focused on verifying the improved SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing procedure and the new AMPX 1597-group library with the ENDF/B-VII.1 and VIII.0 evaluated nuclear data. The verification was made by performing reaction rate analysis and benchmark calculations for various thermal and fast reactor systems. Results indicate that the improved SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing and libraries provide excellent results for advanced reactor analysis.
VALIDATION OF KENO V.A AND KENO-VI IN SCALE 6.3 BETA 3 USING ENDF/B-VII.1 AND ENDF/B-VIII LIBRARIES
In early 2019, internal beta releases of SCALE 6.3 were identified for internal users, as well as a limited number of external users, to apply when testing key features. Recently developed AMPX-formatted libraries based on ENDF/B-VIII have also been generated for use in internal testing. In this effort, a criticality safety validation was performed using nuclear data libraries based on the ENDF/B-VII.1 and ENDF/B-VIII releases to quantify the changes caused by code development and to identify differences caused by the new nuclear data. As with past validations, the primary suite of experiments used is the Verified, Archived Library of Inputs and Data (VALID) maintained in the Reactor and Nuclear Systems Division at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. The VALID suite contains a total of 618 individual configurations, including systems with fast, thermal, mixed, and intermediate neutron spectra. Fissile species include a range of uranium enrichments, plutonium, mixtures of uranium and plutonium, and 233U. Metal, solution, and compound, mostly in pin array fissile forms, are included in the suite. The results presented here include the 252-group general purpose multigroup library based on ENDF/B-VII.1 and the continuous-energy libraries based on ENDF/B-VII.1 and ENDF/B-VIII.
Verification of the ENDF/B-VII.1 and VIII.0 AMPX 1597-Group Libraries for Advanced Reactor Analysis
The SCALE/AMPX multigroup (MG) cross section processing procedure has been updated to minimize reactivity differences for various advanced thermal and fast reactor designs, as observed for the current MG libraries, resulting in excellent agreement between the calculations with the new MG libraries and the continuous-energy reference calculations. The SCALE MG calculations are widely applied to thermal spectrum light-water reactor systems, as well as fast spectrum metallic systems. Due to growing interest from industry and regulators in applying SCALE for the design of fast spectrum reactors—both sodium and molten salt—it was desirable to review and improve the SCALE/AMPX procedure for unresolved resonance self-shielded data and high-energy neutron spectra. The data were improved by generating MG unresolved resonance data based on the analytic probability table method with the narrow resonance approximation and by using very fine and intermediate group structures that are typical for fast system analysis. This study focused on verifying the improved SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing procedure and the new AMPX 1597-group library with the ENDF/B-VII.1 and VIII.0 evaluated nuclear data. The verification was made by performing reaction rate analysis and benchmark calculations for various thermal and fast reactor systems. Results indicate that the improved SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing and libraries provide excellent results for advanced reactor analysis.
Initial Investigations of the Criticality Safety Validation Basis for HA-LEU Transportation
Many proposed advanced nuclear energy systems require so called high-assay low enriched uranium (HALEU), which has a 235U enrichment >5 wt% and <20 wt%, where the current fleet of light water reactors (LWRs) utilize enrichments of 5 wt% or less. With few benchmark experiments in HA-LEU enrichment range, the interplay of the cross sections for multiple nuclei become important, especially for LEU experiments where 1H, 16O, 235U, 238U and others are applied simultaneously in the calculation of the integral keff response. With continuing evidence that nuclear data are tuned to reproduce expected keff values for selected criticality experiments, which likely do not include those with 20 wt% 235U, particular attention must be given to validation.This paper describes the impact of recent nuclear data changes on HA-LEU and provides a preliminary sensitivity/uncertainty-based assessment of the applicability of available of criticality experiments for the validation of licensing calculations for the transportation of small quantities of 20 wt% UF6.
Overview of Nuclear Data Needs for Nuclear Energy Applications
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The SCALE/AMPX multigroup cross section processing for fast reactor analysis
The SCALE/AMPX multigroup (MG) cross section processing procedure has been updated to minimize reactivity differences for fast reactor designs and boiling water reactors (BWRs) with very high void fractions to provide excellent agreement with continuous-energy reference calculations. SCALE MG calculations are widely applied to thermal spectrum light-water reactor (LWR) systems as well as fast spectrum metallic systems of interest to National Nuclear Security Administration. With growing interest from industry and regulators in applying SCALE for the design of fast spectrum reactors, both sodium and molten salt, and in the licensing of power up rates for BWRs, it is desirable to review the SCALE/AMPX procedure for unresolved resonance self-shielded data and high energy neutron spectra. The data were improved by generating MG unresolved resonance data based on the analytic probability table method with the narrow resonance approximation as well as the use of a very fine group structure typically used in fast system analysis. This study focused on verifying the probability table and the SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing procedure by performing reaction rate analysis and benchmark calculations for various fast reactor and high void BWR systems. Here, results indicate that the improved SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing provides excellent results for the fast reactor analysis.
Bayesian optimization of generalized data
Direct application of Bayes' theorem to generalized data yields a posterior probability distribution function (PDF) that is a product of a prior PDF of generalized data and a likelihood function, where generalized data consists of model parameters, measured data, and model defect data. The prior PDF of generalized data is defined by prior expectation values and a prior covariance matrix of generalized data that naturally includes covariance between any two components of generalized data. A set of constraints imposed on the posterior expectation values and covariances of generalized data via a given model is formally solved by the method of Lagrange multipliers. Posterior expectation values of the constraints and their covariance matrix are conventionally set to zero, leading to a likelihood function that is a Dirac delta function of the constraining equation. It is shown that setting constraints to values other than zero is analogous to introducing a model defect. Since posterior expectation values of any function of generalized data are integrals of that function over all generalized data weighted by the posterior PDF, all elements of generalized data may be viewed as nuisance parameters marginalized by this integration. One simple form of posterior PDF is obtained when the prior PDF and the likelihood function are normal PDFs. For linear models without a defect this PDF becomes equivalent to constrained least squares (CLS) method, that is, the χ2 minimization method.
A Testing Trifecta: Data, Codes, and Evaluations
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SCALE Resonance Parameter Sensitivity Coefficient Calculations
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
ENDF/B-VIII.0 Testing With AMPX and SCALE
As the new ENDF/B-VIII.0 data has continued development from its initial beta release into the final release version, it has subsequently undergone processing and testing at Oak Ridge National Laboratory with AMPX and SCALE. Each of the beta releases has been processed with AMPX to create both multigroup (MG) and continuous-energy (CE) libraries. The MG libraries were all processed using the SCALE 252-group structure. These libraries were then used with the VALID suite for benchmarking the new data library’s performance against the currently distributed ENDF/B-VII.1 (VII.1)-based SCALE libraries. Here, we compare the MG and CE VALID results for the two current ENDF releases, versions VII.1 and the most recent beta release of ENDF/B-VIII.0 as of this writing (VIII.0.β4). Generally, both the MG and CE VALID aggregate results for VIII.0.β4 compare reasonably well with their VII.1-derived counterparts. As can be expected of any new ENDF release, some of the individual cases have substantially different computed neutron multiplicity (k eff ) values between the two releases, although typically the differences are less than 100 percent-milli (pcm). However, changes to the plutonium cross sections have induced much larger changes in the ratio of the computed k eff to the experimental value (C/E) for thermal spectrum plutonium solution critical systems. This paper details the comparative performance of the VII.1 and VIII.0.β4 data for the broad range of test cases covered by the VALID suite. A companion paper at this conference provides details of the baseline validation of SCALE 6.2, including the first release of the VII.1 data.