Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Heidet, Florent

Publications and source records attributed to Heidet, Florent.

At least 37 records · Page 2

PELICAN Design, Test Planning, and Commissioning Results

To support design efforts for the Versatile Test Reactor (VTR) core assemblies, an experimental facility has been designed and constructed at Argonne National Laboratory to match the hydraulic flow conditions within the VTR’s primary heat transport system (PHTS). This facility, the Pressure drop Experimental Loop for Investigations of Core Assemblies in advanced Nuclear reactors, PELICAN, provides the ability to measure pressure drop across a full-scale fuel assembly containing prototypic axial reflectors, fuel, and plena components. The PELICAN facility was designed and built to offer maximum flexibility, allowing testing from short sub-sections all the way to the full-length core fuel assemblies. The report presents the high-level program objectives, a summary of the facility design, instrumentation, and control systems, and the testing procedure. The outcomes from facility characterization efforts and first test matrix results are then presented and then, finally, the conclusion contains a summary of the future work to be performed. This test facility was designed to match the hydraulic conditions of the flowing sodium in the VTR using water as a surrogate fluid. To do so, the water is elevated to a temperature of 110°C where its viscosity matches that of sodium, and with a 50-HP centrifugal pump, is capable of generating full scale flow rates to achieve prototypic Reynolds and Euler number flow conditions. To prevent boiling, the system is maintained at elevated pressure of at least 2.7-3.0 bar (40-44 psig). A set of 15 tests have been used to perform checkout activities in order to commission the device, survey the capabilities of PELICAN, and generate experimental data at isothermal conditions and over a range of flow rates up to 44 kg/s (700 GPM) to produce datasets used in the verification and validation of VTR design and modeling efforts. Initial testing focused on facility characterization, which assessed the operational capabilities of various control systems. The thermal control system was qualified, including the thermal response of the loop to the heat added by self- and auxiliary heaters, the chiller and heat exchanger systems for removing excess heat, and their coupled ability to maintain steady-state isothermal conditions as desired. Additionally, the pressure control system was verified to ensure necessary operating environments that promote pump health and prevent boiling of loop inventory at high temperatures could be met. With these systems in place, the first set of matrix tests have been carried out using orifice plates with inner diameters of 2.25-inches and 2.5-inches. Orifice plate flow behavior is well covered in scientific literature, and the results find good agreement with the measured pressure drop vs flow rate and those of theoretical predictions. This initial testing not only helps to validate the experiment, but it also produces a high quality data set for a geometry that is easily reproducible for simulations. Finally, the report is concluded with a discussion of the work to come and provides a snapshot of the test articles in the experimental pipeline whose designs are being inspired by the current designs from the VTR.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Progress Report on the Assessment of the Material Performance for TCR Applications

The objective of Argonne’s materials research activities for the Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) program is to improve the understanding of material properties from additive manufacturing with the focus on understanding the creep and fatigue properties of additively manufactured materials. The material work conducted by Argonne provides support in developing and qualifying advanced materials and manufacturing processes to allow for innovative reactor design and licensing for the TCR. In this report, we present the creep data at temperatures of 550, 600 and 650°C and stresses between 175 and 300 MPa for 316L stainless steel produced by a laser powder bed fusion process. We conducted five different post-build heat treatments, namely 650°C/1h, 750°C/1h, 800°C/1h, 900°C/1h and 1050°C/1h. Creep tests of the heat-treated specimens were performed under the same test condition, 550°C/275 MPa to evaluate and understand the effect of post-build heat treatment on the creep behavior of additively-manufactured 316L SS. Creep tests were conducted to ASME NQA-1 or its lab equivalent for quality assurance.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

EVALUATION OF PRESSURE DROP CORRELATIONS FOR THE WIRE-WRAPPED ROD BUNDLES

The accurate prediction of pressure drop in the fuel rod bundle is of importance for the design and thermal-hydraulic analysis of nuclear reactor system. Due to very complex geometry of wire-wrapped fuel rod bundle geometry for the Sodium Fast Reactor (SFR), a simple method using hydraulic (equivalent) diameter is not sufficient to predict the pressure drop of rod bundle accurately. For several decades, many experimental works have been performed to develop an accurate correlation for wire-wrapped fuel bundle friction factor. In these works, the friction factor correlation of wire-wrapped fuel bundle has been developed as a function of Reynolds number of the flow and the design parameters such as fuel pin diameter, wire diameter, rod pitch, and wire lead length. The Cheng and Todreas correlations are well-known and used in many subchannel analysis code, such as CADET, TRIO-U, MATRA-LMW, SE2-ANL, etc. Novendstern model, Rehme model, Baxi and Dalle Donne model are also well-known and widely referred. Computational Fluid Dynamics is another typical approach to predict the pressure drop of wire-wrapped fuel rod bundle, but it requires the model validation because the accuracy of pressure drop prediction by the CFD simulation depends on what turbulence model is employed. The present work aims at evaluating the existing pressure drop correlations for the wire-wrapped fuel rod bundle and evaluating the pressure drop of 217-pin rod bundle by the CFD analysis.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

Assessment of the Material Performance for TCR Applications (Progress Report)

The objective of Argonne’s materials research activities for the Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) program is to improve the understanding of material properties from additive manufacturing with the focus on understanding the creep and fatigue properties of additively manufactured materials. The material work conducted by Argonne provides support in developing and qualifying advanced materials and manufacturing processes to allow for innovative reactor design and licensing for the TCR. In FY 2020, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) provided six ASTM standard sized creep specimens of additively-manufactured 316L stainless steel (AM 316L SS) for evaluation of the effect of post-build heat treatment on the creep property. Two different teat treatments were conducted on the as-built specimens, namely 1050°C/1h and 650°C/1h before creep testing. All specimens were creep tested at 550°C and 275 MPa to understand the effect of heat treatments. We have also received AM 316L SS printed in various forms including rods and sheets, wrought 316 L SS (as a reference material), and AM IN718 for tensile, creep and fatigue testing. Both ASTM standard sized specimens and subsized specimens are being fabricated or tested to contribute to a comprehensive mechanical property database of AM materials and to provide location-specific property data to the TCR digital platform. Mechanical testing at Argonne is conducted to ASME NQA-1 or its lab equivalent for quality assurance. This report presents the results of the creep tests at 550°C and microstructural characterization for the assessment of the effect of the post-build heat treatment on the creep behavior of AM 316L SS. It also discusses ongoing efforts on obtaining location-dependent properties of AM 316L SS.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Scoping Analysis of Sodium Cooled Fast Spectrum Test Reactor Cores

A team from the national laboratories conducted a study that assessed advanced reactor technology options and the irradiation needs of a broad group of stakeholders. This identified a gap in the fast neutron irradiation capability - the need for a test reactor that can deliver high neutron fluxes of fast neutrons. The study compared fast and thermal neutron irradiation technology options based on technology maturity and the ability to meet strategic objectives, along with pathways to deployment and tradeoffs in mission. It also provided a recommendation on specific technology options to address the current gap in fast neutron irradiation capabilities. In this context, a detailed scope of work was prepared that pertains to a trade study focusing on the core of a fast neutron spectrum test reactor. This report presents the main results obtained by a team of Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) and Idaho National Laboratory (INL) scientists. It aims at developing an overall understanding of how the various areas important to the design and successful operation of such a facility interact with one another. Developing a sense of the relevant sensitivities at a systems level creates an understanding of where and how margins may be available to improve performances (e.g., flux level, capacity factor, and thermal hydraulic limits). Emphasis is given to the reactor (core design options and safety) and its fuel cycle (fuel supply and fabrication, as well as spent fuel management).

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Modeling and simulation functional needs for molten salt reactor licensing

The modeling and simulation functional needs to license and design molten salt reactor concepts were assessed and an evaluation methodology was developed using a licensing-focused approach considering the modeling and simulation components that contribute to a molten salt reactor safety analysis report. These functional needs were prioritized by identifying the relationships between functional needs and using a quantitative weighting method to identify the most critical components to build a licensing case. This novel weighting method provided a list of functional needs prioritized relative to key advanced reactor licensing outcomes. In addition, functional need inputs were ranked to reveal those that feed the most modeling and simulation components. The findings from this prioritization effort were used to inform the modeling and simulation goals of the US Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy (DOE-NE) Molten Salt Reactor campaign.Modeling and simulation needs were grouped into three main categories: (1) source term definition, material accountancy, and radiological consequences, (2) safety analysis, and (3) steady-state neutronics and thermal hydraulics. Here, five near-term goals were identified among these focus areas that add value: (1) deploying a systems and safeguards analysis computational tool, (2) defining source terms for molten salt reactor analysis and interfacing with the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission on accident progression analysis, (3) developing point designs for liquid-fueled thermal-spectrum and fast-spectrum molten salt reactors, (4) building safety analysis specifications and reference solutions for Molten Salt Reactor Experiment transients, and (5) interfacing with the thermophysical and thermodynamic salt chemistry databases.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Advanced Manufacturing for Nuclear Core Design

Advanced manufacturing technologies are fundamentally altering the way components are designed and manufactured. The potential application space for these technologies within the nuclear industry is broad, with the most benefit realized from the ability to approach the nuclear core design problem from an advanced manufacturing perspective. One of the objectives of the US Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy (DOE-NE) Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) design and analysis activities is to demonstrate this approach. A mitigation of conventional constraints realized through advanced manufacturing methods opens up the design space, enabling a departure from typical axially uniform pin- and plate-type geometries common to operating nuclear reactors worldwide. The ability to use more heterogenous spatial and material flexibilities increases the demand on the predictability of higher fidelity modeling and simulation tools to be used in the design, analysis, and optimization processes. Leading candidate advanced manufacturing technologies for nuclear applications are additive methods that provide for high dimensional control and incorporation of small design features such as powder bed fusion, laser directed energy deposition, and binder jetting. Potential applications to core design identified during DOE-NE TCR design and analysis activities fall into two categories: those that are uniquely enabled by additive manufacturing technologies and those that are enabled by the characteristics (e.g., repeatability and instrumentation) inherent to these technologies. Identified applications include reducing in-core parasitic materials, improving heat conduction across fuel-cladding gaps, optimizing thermal hydraulic design with flexible coolant flow geometries, reducing uncertainties in manufactured components, optimizing core conditions with design heterogeneities, designing feedback mechanisms using material characteristics, and embedding burnable poisons. These potential applications join a host of nuclear industry advanced manufacturing activities to recapture manufacturing capabilities, reduce manufacturing costs and complexities, reduce deployment time, and enable performance and operational enhancements.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Fuel Loading Optimization and Planning for the Versatile Test Reactor

The Versatile Test Reactor (VTR) mission is to enable accelerated testing of advanced reactor fuels and materials required for advanced reactor technologies. In service of this duty, the goal of the design is to maximize the peak fast flux and the experimental volume exposed to a fast flux above 4.0 × 1015n/cms s. Delivering the desired neutron fluence for each experiment requires the capability to optimize the fuel loading to achieve a specified cycle length and flux, while also satisfying other criteria such as thermal hydraulic design constraints. To achieve the desired conditions and cycle length, several measures may be taken, including optimization of the fuel loading pattern, moving partially-burned assemblies back and forth between the core and the in-vessel storage, and potentially shuffling fuel within the core. Optimizing in a "brute-force" manner by solving a wholecore transport equation for hundreds of configurations would be inefficient. A sufficiently refined DIF3D-VARIANT solution for the whole core requires on the order of 1 hour. Instead, we seek an approximate evaluation of the parameters for many variations on a base core configuration without directly solving a diffusion or transport equation for each.

fuel loading optimization↗

Assessment of Low Enriched Uranium Fueled Core Configurations for the Versatile Test Reactor

The Versatile Test Reactor (VTR) Program was initiated in FY-2017. This multi-laboratory effort supported by the U.S. Department of Energy has the long-term objective of completing a Versatile Test Reactor concept with associated cost and schedule estimate that enables a fully informed DOE decision within 3 years, to have a fully operating VTR by 2026 if acquisition is authorized, and to enable accelerated testing of advanced reactor fuels and materials required for advanced reactor technologies. The VTR concept uses sodium as coolant, features a core power of 300 MWth, and employs reactor-grade plutonium as fissile material in a U-Pu-10Zr fuel alloy. The reference core layout provides 10 assembly locations for high-flux irradiation testing with peak fast flux in excess of 4x1015 n/cm2-s. In order to establish a comparison point with other types of fuel, alternative core configurations were investigated using Low Enriched Uranium (LEU) fuel. The objective of this study was to modify the reference VTR core such as to use LEU fuel and assess the performance tradeoff, while retaining the same core envelope.

Stauff, Nicolas E.↗

Graphite Moderation in Fast Reactors

With the renewed interest in designing and building a fast test reactor in the U.S., several new reactor concepts have been emerging. Although the main mission of a fast test reactor would be to enable high fast flux irradiation capability, there could be added value for such a fast test reactor to also offer thermal neutron irradiation capabilities. As such, several of these concepts considered the use of a moderator material in a Sodium-cooled Fast Reactor (SFR), which is claimed to also offer benefits with respect of mass of fuel required. The work discussed in this paper focuses on exploring and assessing the benefits and challenges resulting from making use of thermalized neutrons to reduce the critical fuel mass. The analyses are performed for a graphite moderating material, using a simple core model to easily identify the phenomena observed. It is found that it is necessary to reduce the fuel enrichment near the moderated regions in order to avoid unacceptable power peaking. In the end, use of moderating materials outside a SFR core does not provide significant benefit in term of fuel volume reduction, but allows for a noticeable reduction of the mass of fissile material needed. However, it also implies a number of additional challenges which are highlighted in this paper.

core optimization↗

Core and Fuel Cycle Performance of a Molten Salt Fast Reactor

This paper discusses the reactor core design and modeling approaches for a specific molten salt fast reactor (MSFR) design that is started up with high-assay low-enriched uranium (HALEU) within a chloride fuel salt and focuses on the technical assumptions and design choices. These include the fuel salt properties, first core and make-up heavy metal requirements, fuel composition evolution, equilibrium fission product concentration, etc. This MSFR concept was developed as part of a wider study that sought to compare the fuel cycle performance tradeoffs between deploying a fleet of sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs) and deploying a fleet of MSFRs. MSFRs that use flowing liquid fuel salt and on-line salt processing are of particular interest because these technology characteristics are significantly different from those of SFRs and can lead to major differences in fuel cycle impacts. The goal of this study was not to draw general conclusions based on a direct comparison of two very specific point designs for an SFR and MSFR, but rather to use this example MSFR design and associated parametric studies to gain insight into the key technology characteristics that impact fuel cycle performance as it relates to resource utilization (i.e., uranium consumption). The MSFR reactor physics, fission product removal, and fuel salt mass flows were modeled using Argonne’s recently-developed molten salt reactor (MSR) analysis tools while the time-dependent fuel cycle performance of this specific reactor was compared to that of a representative SFR design using the fuel cycle system dynamics code DYMOND.

chloride salt↗

Thermal hydraulic model of the molten salt reactor experiment with the NEAMS system analysis module

System analysis codes have a long history of providing best-estimate and conservative safety analysis for both light water and advanced reactor technologies, including molten salt reactors. As interest continues to expand with advanced reactor concepts, system analysis codes will need revisions to accommodate the behavior of these technologies. Legacy system analysis codes will need to be updated to the latest numerical techniques to shorten execution time and increase the accuracy of results. One example of a modern system analysis code that already encompasses these characteristics is the System Analysis Module (SAM). One key objective of this paper was to review available information for system code modeling of the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE) from sources in the open literature and collect the information from these open sources in one place for the first time. This supports the potential objective of developing an open specification for system code analysis for MSRE steady state and transients with and without reactor kinetics. Data from actual MSRE tests will serve as the basis for code-to-code comparison exercises, including the MSRE zero power physics tests, the fuel pump start-up and coast down tests, and the natural circulation transient. The objective is to produce a code-to-code benchmark with a standardized set of comparison problems, recognizing the limitations of the original data. To demonstrate an initial application of this objective and the usefulness of compiling this open data, two Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE)-related models were developed to evaluate SAM for liquid fueled molten salt reactors. One model was the SAM MSRE hydraulic mockup, which provided experimental data for pressure drop measurements. The second model was the complete MSRE primary loop. The MSRE primary loop model incorporated a fluoride salt fuel/coolant with heat transfer in both the core and heat exchanger. For both the hydraulic mockup and MSRE primary loop models, a holistic 1-D system description was built using open documentation, an open description that can be readily modified and applied for any system analysis code. SAM results for the pressure drop of the hydraulic mockup model were within 6% with measurements. Coolant temperatures for the primary loop model matched the expected axial change in temperature from historical calculations. Using alternative coolant properties obtained from the literature, corresponding to salts with different actinide contents, returned similar trends in core temperature profiles. A thermal hydraulic demonstration of a loss-of-flow transient showed the importance of coupling SAM thermal hydraulic analysis to neutronics. Here, this coupling is essential for simulating MSR transients with system analysis codes.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Molten Salt Reactor Campaign Modeling and Simulation Program Plan

The modeling and simulation activities within the Molten Salt Reactor Research and Development Campaign of the US Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy Advanced Reactor Technologies Program facilitate the development and application of analysis tools for the licensing and design of molten salt reactors.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗