Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Greenwald, Martin

Publications and source records attributed to Greenwald, Martin.

High Performance Equilibrium Solvers for Integrated Magnetic Fusion Simulations

With the funding provided by this award, we developed numerical codes for the study of magnetically confined plasmas for fusion applications. Accordingly, our work can be divided into two separate categories: 1) the design and analysis of novel numerical methods providing high accuracy and high efficiency; 2) the study of the equilibrium and stability of magnetically confined plasmas with some of these numerical codes, as well as the study of the nature of the turbulent behavior which may arise in the presence of instabilities. We first developed new numerical schemes based on integral equation methods for the computation of steady-state magnetic configurations in fusion experiments, providing high accuracy for the magnetic field and its derivatives, which are required for stability and turbulence calculations. We employed different integral formulations depending on the application of interest: axisymmetric or non-axisymmetric equilibria, force-free or magnetohydrodynamic equilibria, fixed-boundary equilibria or free-boundary equilibria. While efficient, these methods do not yet apply to plasma boundaries which are not smooth, a situation which is fairly common in magnetic confinement experiments. To address this temporary weakness, we also constructed a new steady-state solver based on the Hybridizable Discontinuous Galerkin (HDG) method, which provides full geometric flexibility. In addition to these numerical tools focused on steady-states, we also contributed to the improvement of the speed and accuracy of codes simulating the plasma dynamics of fusion plasmas, by developing a novel velocity space representation for the efficient solution of kinetic equations, which most accurately describe the time evolution of hot plasmas in fusion experiments. Using the tools discussed above, we studied several questions pertaining to the equilibrium and stability of magnetically confined plasmas. In particular, we derived a new simple model for axisymmetric devices called tokamaks, to predict how elongated a fusion plasma can be before it becomes unstable and collapses. We also looked at the effect of the shape of the outer plasma surface on key properties of the steady-state magnetic configurations, and how these properties impact turbulence in fusion plasmas, and the corresponding transport of momentum. Likewise, we studied the role of large localized flows on the steady-state magnetic configurations, and how they may influence plasma stability and turbulence. Non-axisymmetric steady-state magnetic configurations are inherently more complex than axisymmetric steady-state configurations, and the subject of ongoing controversies regarding the regularity of the equations determining such steady-states, and their solutions. Implementing an existing NYU code in a new geometry, we studied the nature of the singularity of the solutions observed in the code, and methods to eliminate them. Our main conclusion is that by appropriately tailoring the plasma boundary, it is possible to eliminate the singularities otherwise appearing in our simulations, and to obtain steady-states which appear to be smooth. To gain further insights on incompletely understood turbulence phenomena, we proposed a new reduced model capturing most of these phenomena, which is simple enough to not require expensive numerical simulations on massive supercomputers to investigate them. We demonstrated the strong similarity between our simulations and published results obtained from computationally expensive simulations, and plan to rely on our reduced model to identify the key mechanisms determining the evolution and strength turbulent driven transport in fusion plasmas. Finally, we proposed a new framework for tokamak reactor design studies, enabling us to consider the relative merits of steady-state versus pulsed fusion reactors. We found that pulsed fusion reactors may benefit most from recent advances in magnet technology, and the availability of very high field magnets. As such, they may become more desirable than steady-state tokamak reactors for cost efficient electricity generation.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Data Catalog Project - A Browsable, Searchable, Metadata System

Modern experiments are typically conducted by large, extended, where researchers rely on other team members to produce much of the data they use. The experiments record very large numbers of measurements which can be difficult for users to find, access and understand. We are developing a system for users to annotate their data products with structured metadata, providing data consumers with a discoverable, browsable data index. Machine understandable metadata captures the underlying semantics of the recorded data, which can then be consumed by both programs, and interactively by users. Collaborators can use these metadata to select and understand recorded measurements.

96 KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT AND PRESERVATION↗

Experimental energy confinement time scaling with dimensionless parameters in C-Mod I-mode plasmas

The dependence of energy confinement time on gyroradius, β, and normalized collisionality in I-mode plasmas is investigated through dedicated C-Mod experiments scanning dimensionless parameters with constant safety factor. The gyroradius scaling is calculated to be Ω τE ∝ ρ * -3.9±1.5 , which suggests core transport may scale with gyro–Bohm physics, indicating favorable extrapolation of the I-mode regime to future devices at low ρ * . The scaling exponent for ν C is calculated to be small, but positive (Ω τE ∝ ν $^{0.44 ± 0.24}_{C}$), and the exponent for β is deemed inconclusive (Ω τE ∝ β 1.4±3.1 ) due to high correlation with the other two dimensionless variables in the dataset, and therefore requires further investigation. The individual dimensionless parameter scaling is compared to calculations from larger C-Mod I-mode datasets as well as multi-machine scaling laws for ELMy H-mode and L-mode plasmas. Finally, multiple regression techniques and principal component analysis are used to clarify the single parameter scalings and analyze parameter significance within the dataset.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

On Principles, Values, Metrics and Criteria for the Development of Magnetic Fusion Energy

Fusion energy holds the promise of providing abundant, safe, clean and environmentally sustainable power for the foreseeable future. Hence, fusion has enormous potential to benefit society if it can be developed into a commercial energy source in a timely manner. However, the task of developing fusion energy is a challenging endeavor and it is believed that it will take several decades in order to reach the final goal. Hence, it is imperative to develop a strategic plan and to periodically revise and update this plan. In 2017, the Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Fusion Energy Sciences (FES) commissioned the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) to provide a long term strategic plan for magnetic fusion energy (MFE). In turn, the MFE community mobilized to provide input to the NAS panel. This resulted in a series of US Magnetic Fusion Energy Research Strategic Directions (US MFRSD) Workshops.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Funding for the 2ND IAEA technical meeting on fusion data processing, validation and analysis

The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) will organize the second Technical Meeting on Fusion Da Processing, Validation and Analysis from 30 May to 02 June, 2017, in Cambridge, MA USA. The meeting w be hosted by the MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center (PSFC). The objective of the meeting is to provide a platform where a set of topics relevant to fusion data processing, validation and analysis are discussed with the view of extrapolation needs to next step fusion devices such as ITER. The validation and analysis of experimental data obtained from diagnostics used to characterize fusion plasmas are crucial for a knowledge based understanding of the physical processes governing the dynamics of these plasmas. The meeting will aim at fostering, in particular, discussions of research and development results that set out or underline trends observed in the current major fusion confinement devices. General information on the IAEA, including its mission and organization, can be found at the IAEA websit Uncertainty quantification (UQ) Model selection, validation, and verification (V&V) Probability theory and statistical analysis Inverse problems & equilibrium reconstru ction Integrated data analysis Real time data analysis Machine learning Signal/image proc essing & pattern recognition Experimental design and synthetic diagnostics Data management

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Management, Analysis, and Visualization of Experimental and Observational Data – The Convergence of Data and Computing

Scientific user facilities—particle accelerators, telescopes, colliders, supercomputers, light sources, sequencing facilities, and more—operated by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science (SC) generate ever increasing volumes of data at unprecedented rates from experiments, observations, and simulations. At the same time there is a growing community of experimentalists that require real-time data analysis feedback, to enable them to steer their complex experimental instruments to optimized scientific outcomes and new discoveries. Recent efforts in DOE-SC have focused on articulating the data-centric challenges and opportunities facing these science communities. Key challenges include difficulties coping with data size, rate, and complexity in the context of both real-time and post-experiment data analysis and interpretation. Solutions will require algorithmic and mathematical advances, as well as hardware and software infrastructures that adequately support data-intensive scientific workloads. This paper presents the summary findings of a workshop held by DOE-SC in September 2015, convened to identify the major challenges and the research that is needed to meet those challenges.

Bethel, E. Wes↗

Fusion Energy Sciences Exascale Requirements Review. An Office of Science review sponsored jointly by Advanced Scientific Computing Research and Fusion Energy Sciences, January 27-29, 2016, Gaithersburg, Maryland

The additional computing power offered by the planned exascale facilities could be transformational across the spectrum of plasma and fusion research — provided that the new architectures can be efficiently applied to our problem space. The collaboration that will be required to succeed should be viewed as an opportunity to identify and exploit cross-disciplinary synergies. To assess the opportunities and requirements as part of the development of an overall strategy for computing in the exascale era, the Exascale Requirements Review meeting of the Fusion Energy Sciences (FES) community was convened January 27–29, 2016, with participation from a broad range of fusion and plasma scientists, specialists in applied mathematics and computer science, and representatives from the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) and its major computing facilities. This report is a summary of that meeting and the preparatory activities for it and includes a wealth of detail to support the findings. Technical opportunities, requirements, and challenges are detailed in this report (and in the recent report on the Workshop on Integrated Simulation). Science applications are described, along with mathematical and computational enabling technologies. Also see http://exascaleage.org/fes/ for more information.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Automated metadata, provenance cataloging and navigable interfaces: ensuring the usefulness of extreme-scale data

The MPO (Metadata, Provenance, Ontology) Project successfully addressed the goal of improving the usefulness and traceability of scientific data by building a system that could capture and display all steps in the process of creating, analyzing and disseminating that data. Throughout history, scientists have generated handwritten logbooks to keep track of data, their hypotheses, assumptions, experimental setup, and computational processes as well as reflections on observations and issues encountered. Over the last several decades, with the growth of personal computers, handheld devices, and the World Wide Web, the handwritten logbook has begun to be replaced by electronic logbooks. This transition has brought increased capability such as supporting multi-media, hypertext, and fast searching. However, content creation and metadata (a set of data that describes and gives information about other data) capturing has for the most part remained a manual activity just as it was with handwritten logbooks. This has led to a fragmentation of data, processing, and annotation that has only accelerated as scientific workflows continue to increase in complexity. From a scientific perspective, it is very important to be able to understand the lineage of any piece of data: who, what, when, how, and why. This is typically referred to as data provenance. The fragmentation discussed previously often means that data provenance is lost. As scientific workflows move to powerful computers and become more complex, the ability to track all of the steps involved in creating a piece of data become even more difficult. It was the goal of the MPO (Metadata, Provenance, Ontology) Project to create a system (the MPO System) that allows for automatic provenance and metadata capturing in such a way to allow easy searching and browsing. This goal needed to be accomplished in a general way so that it may be used across a broad range of scientific domains, yet allow the addition of vocabulary (Ontology) that is domain specific as is required for intelligent searching and browsing in the scientific context. Through the creation and deployment of the MPO system, the goals of the project were achieved. An enhanced metadata, provenance, and ontology storage system was created. This was combined with innovative methodologies for navigating and exploring these data using a web browser for both experimental and simulation-based scientific research. In addition, a system to allow scientists to instrument their existing workflows for automatic metadata and provenance is part of the MPO system. In that way, a scientist can continue to use their existing methodology yet easily document their work. Workflows and data provenance can be displayed either graphically or in an electronic notebook format and support advanced search features including via ontology. The MPO system was successfully used in both Climate and Magnetic Fusion Energy Research. The software for the MPO system is located at https://github.com/MPO-Group/MPO and is open source distributed under the Revised BSD License. A demonstration site of the MPO system is open to the public and is available at https://mpo.psfc.mit.edu/. A Docker container release of the command line client is available for public download using the command docker pull jcwright/mpo-cli at https://hub.docker.com/r/jcwright/mpo-cli.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Management, Analysis, and Visualization of Experimental and Observational Data -- The Convergence of Data and Computing

Scientific user facilities---particle accelerators, telescopes, colliders, supercomputers, light sources, sequencing facilities, and more---operated by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science (SC) generate ever increasing volumes of data at unprecedented rates from experiments, observations, and simulations. At the same time there is a growing community of experimentalists that require real-time data analysis feedback, to enable them to steer their complex experimental instruments to optimized scientific outcomes and new discoveries. Recent efforts in DOE-SC have focused on articulating the data-centric challenges and opportunities facing these science communities. Key challenges include difficulties coping with data size, rate, and complexity in the context of both real-time and post-experiment data analysis and interpretation. Solutions will require algorithmic and mathematical advances, as well as hardware and software infrastructures that adequately support data-intensive scientific workloads. This paper presents the summary findings of a workshop held by DOE-SC in September 2015, convened to identify the major challenges and the research that is needed to meet those challenges.

Bethel, E. Wes↗

Report of the DOE Workshop on Management, Analysis, and Visualization of Experimental and Observational data – The Convergence of Data and Computing

The Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science (SC) operates dozens of national science user facilities that span many different disciplines. These facilities include accelerators, colliders, supercomputers, light sources and neutron sources, as well as facilities for studying the nanoworld, the environment, and the atmosphere. In Fiscal Year 2014 over 33,000 researchers from academia, industry, and government laboratories, spanning all fifty states and the District of Columbia, utilized these unique facilities to perform new scientific research. Each of these facilities generates vast amounts of scientific data, and the rate, size, and complexity of this data is rapidly increasing, thanks to advances in technology. A growing concern, which motivates this workshop, is the likely significant adverse impact on science programs that will result without significant advances in the capabilities needed to manage and gain knowledge from these collections of data. The purpose of this workshop, held 29 September 2015 through 1 October 2015 in Bethesda, MD, is to help the Advanced Scientific Computing Research (ASCR) and research community better understand needs related to the management, analysis, and visualization of experimental and observational data (EOD) collected and generated by experimental and observational science projects (EOS) at Office of Science user facilities.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Data catalog project—A browsable, searchable, metadata system

Modern experiments are typically conducted by large, extended groups, where researchers rely on other team members to produce much of the data they use. The experiments record very large numbers of measurements that can be difficult for users to find, access and understand. Here. we are developing a system for users to annotate their data products with structured metadata, providing data consumers with a discoverable, browsable data index. Machine understandable metadata captures the underlying semantics of the recorded data, which can then be consumed by both programs, and interactively by users. Collaborators can use these metadata to select and understand recorded measurements. The data catalog project is a data dictionary and index which enables users to record general descriptive metadata, use cases and rendering information as well as providing them a transparent data access mechanism (URI). Users describe their diagnostic including references, text descriptions, units, labels, example data instances, author contact information and data access URIs. The list of possible attribute labels is extensible, but limiting the vocabulary of names increases the utility of the system. The data catalog is focused on the data products and complements process-based systems like the Metadata Ontology Provenance project [Greenwald, 2012; Schissel, 2015]. This system can be coupled with MDSplus to provide a simple platform for data driven display and analysis programs. Sites which use MDSplus can describe tree branches, and if desired create ‘processed data trees’ with homogeneous node structures for measurements. Sites not currently using MDSplus can either use the database to reference local data stores, or construct an MDSplus tree whose leaves reference the local data store. A data catalog system can provide a useful roadmap of data acquired from experiments or simulations making it easier for researchers to find and access important data and understand the meaning of the data and how it was obtained. This is particularly useful in research facilities that study the results of many different experiments or simulations and may not know the intricacies of the data organization in use where the data was generated. It is also possible to store a local copy of key data items in local MDSplus trees and then add processed data to the local catalog.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Preface to the Special Issue: Strategic Opportunities for Fusion Energy

Here, the Journal of Fusion Energy provides a forum for discussion of broader policy and planning issues that play a crucial role in energy fusion programs. In keeping with this purpose and in response to several recent strategic planning efforts worldwide, this Special Issue on Strategic Opportunities was launched with the goal to invite fusion scientists and engineers to record viewpoints of the scientific opportunities and policy issues that can drive continued advancements in fusion energy research.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Plasma Simulation Program

Many others in the fusion energy and advanced scientific computing communities participated in the development of this plan. The core planning team is grateful for their important contributions. This summary is meant as a quick overview the Fusion Simulation Program's (FSP's) purpose and intentions. There are several additional documents referenced within this one and all are supplemental or flow down from this Program Plan. The overall science goal of the DOE Office of Fusion Energy Sciences (FES) Fusion Simulation Program (FSP) is to develop predictive simulation capability for magnetically confined fusion plasmas at an unprecedented level of integration and fidelity. This will directly support and enable effective U.S. participation in International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) research and the overall mission of delivering practical fusion energy. The FSP will address a rich set of scientific issues together with experimental programs, producing validated integrated physics results. This is very well aligned with the mission of the ITER Organization to coordinate with its members the integrated modeling and control of fusion plasmas, including benchmarking and validation activities. [1]. Initial FSP research will focus on two critical Integrated Science Application (ISA) areas: ISA1, the plasma edge; and ISA2, whole device modeling (WDM) including disruption avoidance. The first of these problems involves the narrow plasma boundary layer and its complex interactions with the plasma core and the surrounding material wall. The second requires development of a computationally tractable, but comprehensive model that describes all equilibrium and dynamic processes at a sufficient level of detail to provide useful prediction of the temporal evolution of fusion plasma experiments. The initial driver for the whole device model will be prediction and avoidance of discharge-terminating disruptions, especially at high performance, which are a critical impediment to successful operation of machines like ITER. If disruptions prove unable to be avoided, their associated dynamics and effects will be addressed in the next phase of the FSP.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Verification and validation for magnetic fusion

Dramatic progress in the scope and power of plasma simulations over the past decade has extended our understanding of these complex phenomena. However, as codes embody imperfect models for physical reality, a necessary step toward developing a predictive capability is demonstrating agreement, without bias, between simulations and experimental results. While comparisons between computer calculations and experimental data are common, there is a compelling need to make these comparisons more systematic and more quantitative. Tests of models are divided into two phases, usually called verification and validation. Verification is an essentially mathematical demonstration that a chosen physical model, rendered as a set of equations, has been accurately solved by a computer code. Validation is a physical process which attempts to ascertain the extent to which the model used by a code correctly represents reality within some domain of applicability, to some specified level of accuracy. This paper will cover principles and practices for verification and validation including lessons learned from related fields.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Intrashot motional Stark effect calibration technique for lower hybrid current drive experiments

The spurious drift in pitch angle of order several degrees measured by the motional Stark effect (MSE) diagnostic in the Alcator C-Mod tokamak over the course of an experimental run day has precluded direct utilization of independent absolute calibrations. Recently, the underlying cause of the drift has been identified as thermal stress-induced birefringence in a set of in-vessel lenses. The shot-to-shot drift can be avoided by using MSE to measure only the change in pitch angle between a reference phase and a phase of physical interest within a single plasma discharge. This intrashot calibration technique has been applied to the lower hybrid current drive (LHCD) experiments and the measured current profiles qualitatively demonstrate several predictions of LHCD theory such as an inverse dependence of current drive efficiency on the parallel refractive index and the presence of off-axis current drive.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Intra-shot MSE Calibration Technique For LHCD Experiments

The spurious drift in pitch angle of order several degrees measured by the Motional Stark Effect (MSE) diagnostic in the Alcator C-Mod tokamak1 over the course of an experimental run day has precluded direct utilization of independent absolute calibrations. Recently, the underlying cause of the drift has been identified as thermal stress-induced birefringence in a set of in-vessel lenses. The shot-to-shot drift can be avoided by using MSE to measure only the change in pitch angle between a reference phase and a phase of physical interest within a single plasma discharge. This intra-shot calibration technique has been applied to the Lower Hybrid Current Drive (LHCD) experiments and the measured current profiles qualitatively demonstrate several predictions of LHCD theory such as an inverse dependence of current drive efficiency on the parallel refractive index and the presence of off-axis current drive.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗