Reply to Wuttke: Our reinterpretation of QENS does not violate scattering theory
Not Available
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Frauenfelder, Hans.
Not Available
Significance Quasielastic neutron scattering (QENS) has been used for > 40 y to study complex systems. Fascinating questions remain. The neutron has to be a de Broglie wave packet to obtain dynamics information on biological systems. During its interaction with a proton in a protein, the wave packet puts pressure on the proton and its environment. The protein acts like an ideal spring and by Hooke’s law transiently stores the energy produced by the pressure. On leaving, the wave packet regains essentially the full energy. However, during the passage, fluctuations in the sample change the neutron energy slightly and broaden the energy spectrum. The results call for a reexamination of the theory of quasielastic neutron scattering from complex systems.
Glasses, supercooled liquids, and proteins share common properties, in particular the existence of two different types of fluctuations, {alpha} and {beta}. While the effect of the {alpha} fluctuations on proteins has been known for a few years, the effect of {beta} fluctuations has not been understood. By comparing neutron scattering data on the protein myoglobin with the {beta} fluctuations in the hydration shell measured by dielectric spectroscopy we show that the internal protein motions are slaved to these fluctuations. We also show that there is no 'dynamic transition' in proteins near 200 K. The rapid increase in the mean square displacement with temperature in many neutron scattering experiments is quantitatively predicted by the {beta} fluctuations in the hydration shell.