Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Frank A Leone

Publications and source records attributed to Frank A Leone.

Progressive Damage Failure Analysis of a Multi-Stringer Post-Buckled Panel

Validation of a progressive damage finite element analysis model using the CompDam material model was performed on a large multi-stringer panel subjected to compressive loading. The panel had a Teflon insert embedded between the skin panel and stiffener to cause an ultimate failure mode of stiffener separation. The compressive loading of the panel caused the skin between the stiffeners to locally buckle before any damage began to occur. The post-buckled behavior of the panel was the driving mechanism to the onset of damage and the damage growth that led to skin-stiffener separation. An integrated global-local modeling approach was used to validate several aspects the overall behavior of the panel from start to failure. The global region captured the pre-buckled stiffness of the test panel within 10% and the buckling load of the skin panel at the critical location within 2%. The skin’s five half-wave buckled mode shape was accurately predicted by the model. The integrated local model captured the load corresponding to the onset of damage within 5% of the average test data. Comparisons are made for key aspects of the damage morphology, such as a growth pattern that included a significant matrix split in the first ply of the skin and a migration of the delamination from the skin-stiffener interface to the skin’sply1-ply2 interface. The ultimate failure mode was shown to be an unstable growth of delamination damage under the stiffeners which led to a peak load of the analysis that was approximately 5% above the average peak load of the testing. The validated global-local modeling approach used on the multi-stringer post-buckled panel with a Teflon insert used a methodology and lessons learned using smaller specimens applied to a subcomponent that captured several aspects of a modern aircraft design.

Jason Action↗

Progressive Damage Analysis of Post-Buckled Stiffened Panels under Static Compressive Loading

The validation of progressive damage analysis methods requires experimental data that captures the initiation of damage, its evolution with continued loading, and the morphology of damage throughout its evolution. In support of the NASA Advanced Composites Project, several validation specimens of increasing complexity have been tested and characterized in order to provide the data required to assess the capabilities of several progressive damage analysis methods for fiber-reinforced composite materials. The analytical capabilities of interest for this validation program include networks of interacting matrix cracks and delaminations in post-buckled stiffened structures. A series of single stringer compression specimens was tested and characterized at NASA Langley Research Center. The experimental data from these tests are compared with progressive damage finite element analysis results. Test/analysis comparisons are made in terms of load/displacement histories, damage morphology, and damage size versus load metrics.

Frank A Leone↗

TPSAS-NF1676L-15315-DND

Some advantages over mechanical joints: - Lower structural weight - Lower manufacturing cost - Improve damage tolerance However: - Lack of failure criteria and material/structural validated models - Lack of an accurate and reliable quality control

Donato Girolamo↗

Initiation and Propagation of Skin/Stiffener Separation in Postbuckled Structures Subjected to Cyclic Loads

A methodology is proposed to evaluate experimentally and numerically the initiation and propagation of skin/stiffener separation in postbuckled panels subjected to cyclic loads. The response mechanisms that characterize skin/stiffener separation were investigated using a three point bend (3PB) test specimen, which is a simple specimen consisting of a laminate representing the skin and a doubler representing the stiffener flange. The 3PB tests were performed under quasi-static and cyclic loads. A fatigue cohesive model was used to analyze the initiation and propagation of skin/stiffener separation in the 3PB. The results indicate that the fatigue cohesive model with model parameters obtained from quasi-static fracture tests can provide accurate predictions of initiation from a pristine state, and the rate of fatigue crack propagation for a variety of mode mixities, load levels, and stress ratios.

Carlos G Davila↗

Understanding Variability in Mechanical Behavior of Adhesively Bonded Sandwich Joints due to Stochastic Material Damage

A mesoscale progressive damage analysis was applied to the analysis of recently tested adhesively bonded sandwich panels, in which ten nominally identical tension loaded panels failed in three different failure modes, with peakloads ranging from 13.0 –16.1 kips. A parametric finite element model for progressive damage analysis of an adhesively bonded joint (ABJ) considering matrix and fiber damage, and delamination cracks in unidirectional and fabric composite sections of the joint, as well as core crushing, and adhesive fracture was developed. The model was developed using Abaqus/Explicit and utilized continuum damage mechanics material models for intralaminar damage in the facesheet and doubler plies, cohesive elements for delamination and adhesive debonding, and discretized cells considering plasticity to model crushing of the aluminum honeycomb core. Analysis predictions obtained with a pristine model agreed well with the average experimental peak load, strain in the joint, and post-test damage states. Then, various methods to incorporate stochastic material variability into ABJ model were evaluated. These methods included simulation of pre-existing matrix damage, pre-existing adhesive porosity, and uniform modification of adhesive properties. These material and manufacturing defects changed the damage mode predictions in some cases. The analysis of stochastic strength due to the considered defects revealed unintuitive damage mode interaction in the ABJ, explaining some structure-property relationships observed experimentally.

Richard Larson↗

Investigating Transverse Ply Thickness and Cracking Effects on the Tensile Strain to Failure of Thin-ply, Cross-ply Carbon Composites using X-ray Computed Tomography

The effect of 90°-ply thickness on the fibre direction tensile failure strain of cross-ply laminates was investigated by designing four different cross-ply composite laminate configurations with 90° blocks of varying numbers of plies adjacent to a central block of 0° plies. The range of 90° block thicknesses evaluated included conventional ply thicknesses to allow for comparisons with conventional ply geometries. The central 0° ply block was subjected to primarily longitudinal tension with a small component of transverse tension due to the layup and thermal residual stresses. Advanced instrumentation, including acoustic emission and X-ray computed tomography, was used to detect and visualize damage accumulation in the specimens. It was found that decreasing the thickness of the 90° ply blocks reduced transverse matrix microcracking up to the point where no full-width transverse cracks developed prior to ultimate failure. A small degradation of the fibre direction failure strain in the central 0° plies was found as the 90°-layer thickness increased in the laminates, which corresponded with the development of edge/transverse cracks.

Tamas Rev↗

Scalability of Cohesive Fatigue Analyses Using Explicit Solvers

A cohesive fatigue law has been integrated into a constitutive material model compatible with an explicit finite element solver. The cohesive fatigue model response is based on engineering approximations of the endurance limit and the Goodman diagram. This approach can predict stress-life diagrams for crack initiation, the Paris law regime, and transient effects of crack initiation and stable tearing. Simplified cyclic loading is utilized so that the applied load(or displacement) corresponds to the peak load of a fatigue cycle. Loads are held constant during fatigue while damage develops with increasing solution increments. An automatically-calculated ratio of fatigue cycles per solution increment controls the rate of damage growth, ensuring that damage growth is modeled with a sufficient minimum number of increments and damage growth advances to a minimum desired extent within the explicit analysis step time. The compatibility with an explicit finite element solver enables the analysis of structures that are computationally intractable for implicit finite element solvers. Scalability studies are conducted for geometrically nonlinear problems involving fiber-reinforced composite structures that exhibit fatigue damage growth of interacting matrix cracks and delaminations

Frank A Leone↗

Low-Velocity Impact Analyses of Composite Panels Using Cohesive Zone Modeling and Continuum Damage Mechanics

A parametric study was conducted to gage the sensitivity of simulations of low-velocity impacts on laminated composite panels to various finite element model and material model features. The material model used in this parametric study was previously verified and validated for conducting progressive damage analyses of post-buckled composite structures subjected to quasi-static loading conditions. Based on the results of this parametric study, updates have been made to a progressive damage analysis material model and the best practices for its application. Experimental results are compared to computational results obtained with and without the updates to the models. Both thermoset and thermoplastic fiber-reinforced materials are considered. The resulting enhancements to the material model are presented in detail.

Frank A Leone↗