Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Forman, William

Publications and source records attributed to Forman, William.

Technology Requirements For a Square-Meter, Arcsecond-Resolution Telescope for X-Rays: The SMART-X Mission

Addressing the astrophysical problems of the 2020's requires sub-arcsecond x-ray imaging with square meter effective area. Such requirements can be derived, for example, by considering deep x-ray surveys to find the young black holes in the early universe (large redshifts) which will grow into the first supermassive black holes. We have envisioned a mission based on adjustable x-ray optics technology, in order to achieve the required reduction of mass to collecting area for the mirrors. We are pursuing technology which effects this adjustment via thin film piezoelectric "cells" deposited directly on the non-reflecting sides of thin, slumped glass. While SMARTX will also incorporate state-of-the-art x-ray cameras, the remaining spacecraft systems have no more stringent requirements than those which are well understood and proven on the current Chandra X-ray Observatory.

Schwartz, Daniel A.↗

A1367: A Cluster in Formation

A1367 is a puzzling cluster with a large elongation, suggesting a major merger but with an anti-correlation between the luminosity and temperature of the two components of the cluster (NE and SW). The less luminous subconcentration appears hotter and the more luminous portion of the cluster appears cooler in contradiction to the well-established positive correlation of temperature and luminosity for clusters and groups. A1367 lies at the intersection of two large scale filaments in our local Universe - one in the direction of the Coma cluster and a second in the direction of the Virgo cluster. The elongation of the main X-ray structure lies along the Virgo-A1367 filament. With the XMM-Newton observation we have developed a model involving multiple mergers from two directions to explain the observed features of A1367.

Mushotzky, Richard↗

Over-Luminous Elliptical Galaxies

The first paper from our work has been completed and accepted for publication. Another paper presents a study of the ESO 30601 70 galaxy group, combining Chandra, XMM-Newton, and optical observations. We find that the system is a true fossil galaxy group - a group whose optical light is dominated by a single galaxy. The group X-ray emission is composed of a central, dense, cool core (10 kpc in radius) and an isothermal medium beyond the central 10 kpc. The region between 10 and 50 kpc (the cooling radius) has the same temperature as the gas from 50 to 400 kpc, although the gas cooling time between 10 and 50 kpc (2-6 Gyr) is shorter than the Hubble time. Thus, the ESO 3060170 group does not have a group-sized cooling core. We suggest that the group cooling core may have been heated by a central active galactic nucleus (AGN) outburst in the past and that the small, dense, cool core is the truncated relic of a previous cooling core. The Chandra observations also reveal a variety of X-ray features in the central region, including a finger, an edge-like feature, and a small tail, all aligned along a north-south axis, as are the galaxy light and group galaxy distribution. The proposed AGN outburst may cause gas to slosh around the center and produce these asymmetric features. The observed flat temperature profile to 1/3rvir is not consistent with the predicted temperature profile in recent numerical simulations. We compare the entropy profile of the ESO 3060170 group with those of three other groups and find a flatter relation than that predicted by simulations involving only shock heating, S approximately r approximately 0.85. This is direct evidence of the importance of non-gravitational processes in group centers. We derive the mass profiles within 1/3rvir and find that the ESO 3060170 group is the most massive fossil group known.

Forman, William↗

Mass and Dynamical Structures of the Lensing Clusters CL0024+17 and CL2244+02

We present a detailed gravitational mass measurement based on the XMM-Newton imaging spectroscopy analysis of the lensing cluster of galaxies CL0024+17 at $z = 0.395$. The emission appears approximately symmetric. However, on the scale of $r\sim3.3'$, some indication of elongation is visible in the northwest-southeast direction from the hardness ratio map. Within $3'$, we measure a global gas temperature of $3.52\pm0.17$ keV, metallicity of $0.22\pm0.07$, and a bolometric luminosity of $2.9\pm0. l\times10(exp 44)$ erg/s. We derive a temperature distribution with an isothermal temperature of 3.9 keV up to a radius of $1.5'$ and a strong temperature gradient in the outskirts ($1.3' less than r less than 3.3'$). Under the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium, we measure the gravitational mass and gas mass fraction to be $M-{200} = 2.0\pm0.3\times 10(exp 14)$ solar masses and $f-{gas} = 0.20\pm0.03$ at $r-{200} = 1.05$ Mpc (all for a Hubble constant of 70 km/sec/Mpc) using the observed gas temperature profile. The complex core structure is the key to explaining the discrepancy between the gravitational mass determined from the XMM-Newton observations and HST optical lensing measurements.

Forman, William↗

XII Recontres De Blois

In the initial awarding of the grant, we had difficulty phasing our proposed support of graduate students, postdoctoral fellows and young US scientists with the meeting schedule and the grant cycle. Initially, the grant arrived too late to support the meeting. The following year, a combination of the renewal process and the meeting announcement prevented us from announcing the support opportunity sufficiently in advance to allow us to make awards and provide support. As described in the initial proposal, the Moriond and Blois meetings are a unique opportunity for younger researchers to make oral presentations of their work at an international venue. As noted above, the phasing of meetings combined with the difficulty of arranging foreign travel for scientists at other institutions precluded the possibility of supporting the proposed meetings and providing young US scientists and post-doctoral fellows support to attend these meetings.

Kaluzienski, Louis↗

Over-Luminous Elliptical Galaxies

We have completed a first draft of a paper on the galaxy group ES03060170, the hottest known fossil group. We have submitted a first draft of the paper but the final completion is delayed due to several issues mentioned by the referee that we wish to revisit and discuss in more detail. The XMM data was combined with Chandra data which allowed a rich set of projects. The paper discusses the north-south elongation which is similar to that of the central dominant galaxy as well as the galaxy distribution. We detect an X-ray "finger" or small tail emanating from the central galaxy to the north, suggesting motion of the galaxy within the elongated gravitational potential. The overall agreement between XMM and Chandra data are excellent (although the XMM data extend to larger radii). Both data sets show a cool core centered on the dominant galaxy. Surprisingly, the temperature maps and detailed spectra indicate that the finger of gas is NOT cool, but has the same temperature as the ambient gas. We extracted surface brightness profiles, deprojected gas density profiles, cooling time profiles, and entropy profiles. There is a sharp discontinuity in gas temperature where the surface brightness profile starts to rise rapidly at 10 kpc. This produces a decrease in the cooling time and the gas entropy within 10 kpc. The central cooling time (within 10 kpc) is less than l0(exp 9) years and falls to almost half that value in the inner 5 kpc. Despite the very short cooling time, we find no evidence (even with the excellent statistics from XMM-Newton) for multi-phased gas, i.e., a cooling flow. We find two "edges" associated with the gas distribution (common in peaked X-ray groups and galaxies). On large scales, the temperature profile is flat and disagrees with the profile predicted by Loken et al. (2003) from detailed numerical simulations. We studied the galaxy distribution within one virial radius. The galaxy concentration associated with the group is detectable only within 0.3 of the virial radius (450 kpc) given the available depth of the optical galaxy catalogs at present. We have derived total mass and gas mass distributions (from the X- ray data) and find the gas fraction approaches a constant 8% (for Ho = 70).

Mushotzky, Richard↗

Over-Luminous Elliptical Galaxies

We have completed a first draft of a paper on the galaxy group ESO3060170, the hottest known fossil group. We have submitted a first draft of the paper but the final completion is delayed due to several issues mentioned by the referee that we wish to revisit and discuss in more detail. The XMM data was combined with Chandra data which allowed a rich set of projects. The paper discusses the north-south elongation which is similar to that of the central dominant galaxy as well as the galaxy distribution. We detect an X-ray 'finger' or small tail emanating from the central galaxy to the north, suggesting motion of the galaxy within the elongated gravitational potential. The overall agreement between XMM and Chandra data are excellent (although the XMM data extend to larger radii). Both data sets show a cool core centered on the dominant galaxy. Surprisingly, - the temperature maps and detailed spectra indicate that the finger of gas is NOT cool, but has the same temperature as the ambient gas. We extracted surface brightness profiles, deprojected gas density profiles, cooling time profiles, and entropy profiles. There is a sharp discontinuity in gas temperature where the surface brightness profile starts to rise rapidly at 10 kpc. This produces a decrease in the cooling time and the gas entropy within 10 kpc. The central cooling time (within 10 kpc) is less than 109 years and falls to almost half that value in the inner 5 kpc. Despite the very short cooling time, we find no evidence (even with the excellent statistics from XMM-Newton) for multi-phased gas, i.e., a cooling flow. We find two 'edges' associated with the gas distribution (common in peaked X-ray groups and galaxies). On large scales, the temperature profile is flat and disagrees with the profile predicted by Loken et al. (2003) from detailed numerical simulations. We studied the galaxy distribution within one virial radius. The galaxy concentration associated with the group is detectable only within 0.3 of the virial radius (450 kpc) given the available depth of the optical galaxy catalogs at present. We have derived total mass and gas mass distributions (from the X-ray data) and find the gas fraction approaches a constant 8% (for H0 = 70).

Mushotsky, Richard↗

A 4 MPC X-Ray Filament Falling into the Cluster A85

We have completed a first paper confirming the ROSAT observation of a merging filamentary structure associated with the rich cluster A85. We detected a portion of the extended 4 Mpc filament first seen by the ROSAT PSPC. We confirm that there is an extended feature, aligned at the same position angle as the major axis of the central cD, the bright cluster galaxies, and nearby groups and clusters. We find that the X-ray emission from the filament is best described by thermal emission with a temperature of approx. 2 keV, which is significantly lower than the ambient cluster medium, but is significantly higher than anticipated for a gas in a weakly bound extended filament. It is not clear whether this is a filament of diffuse emission, a chain of several groups of galaxies, or stripped gas from the infalling south blob. In conclusion, the XMM-Newton observations confirmed that there really is a highly elongated filamentary like structure extending from the the merging south clump to the south east of Abell-85 along the direction defined by all the structures pointed out by Durret et al. (1998b). The fact that the spatial structure of the X-ray filament detected by XMM-Newton cannot be exactly superimposed to that obtained from ROSAT data shows that it is still difficult to determine exactly its nature. However, the X-ray spectrum from this structure is most likely thermal and its temperature is about 2.0 keV, consistent with that of groups. This value is notably cooler than that of the main cluster: the temperature map by Markevitch et al. (1998) shows the presence of gas at about 3-4 keV in the region at a distance from the cluster center at least as far as the northern part of the ellipse. So, we appear to be seeing cool gas as it enters the cluster core. Another possibility is that the filament is associated with the wake of cool stripped gas left behind by the south blob as it falls onto the cluster. In this case, the 'filament', whether it is diffuse or made of groups, would not really be a filament in the large scale structure formation sense. Besides X-ray observations with a much better signal to noise ratio, which probably will have to wait for the next generation of X-ray satellites, optical data can shed light on this question. With this purpose, we intend to perform wide field imaging in various bands to estimate galaxy photometric redshifts and determine how galaxies are distributed in the 'filament' area.

Forman, William↗

X-Ray Measured Masses for Clusters of Galaxies

Results of the analysis of Chandra observations fo the gas density and temperature profiles for several clusters f galaxies will be used to determine the amount and distribution of the total mass in clusters. These results will be compared with past results from ASCA. with theoretically predicted mass profiles and with mass profiles determined from gravitational lensing.

Forman, William↗

Cosmological implications of ROSAT observations of groups and clusters of galaxies

We have combined ROSAT Position Sensitive Proportional Counter (PSPC) and optical observations of a sample of groups and clusters of galaxies to determine the fundamental parameters of these systems (e.g., the dark matter distribution, gas mass fraction, baryon mass fraction, mass-to-light ratio, and the ratio of total-to-luminous mass). Imaging X-ray spectroscopy of groups and clusters show that the gas is essentially isothermal beyond the central region, indicating that the total mass density (mostly dark matter) scales as rho(sub dark) varies as 1/r squared. The density profile of the hot X-ray emitting gas is fairly flat in groups with rho(sub gas) varies as 1/r and becomes progressively steeper in hotter richer systems, with rho(sub gas) varies as 1/r squared in the richest clusters. These results show, that in general, the hot X-ray-emitting gas is the most extended mass component in groups and clusters, the galaxies are the most centrally concentrated component, and the dark matter is intermediate between the two. The flatter density rofile of the hot gas compared to the dark matter produces a gas mass fraction that increases with radius within each object. There is also a clear trend of increasing gas mass fraction (from 2% to 30%) between elliptical galaxies and rich clusters due to the greater detectable extent of the X-ray emission in richer systems. For the few systems in which the X-ray emission can be traced to the virial radius (where the overdensity delta is approximately equal 200), the gas mass fraction (essentially the baryon mass fraction) approaches a roughly constant value of 30%, suggesting that this is the true primordial value. Based on standard big bang nucleosynthesis, the large baryon mass fraction implies that Omega = 0.1 - 0.2. The antibiased gas distribution suggests that feedback from galaxy formation and hydrodynamics play important roles in the formation of structure on the scale of galaxies to rich clusters. All the groups and clusters in our sample have mass-to-light ratios of M/L(sub V) approximately 100 - 150 solar mass/solar luminosity, which strongly contrasts with the traditional view that the mass-to-light ratio of rich clusters is significantly greater than individual galaxies or groups with M/L(sub V) approximately 250 - 300 solar mass/solar luminosity. We also show that M/L(sub V is essentially constant within the virial radius of clusters (where delta is greater than or approximately 200), which is consistent with the peaks formalism of biased galaxy formation. While the mass-to-light ratios of groups and clusters are comparable (indicating a constant mass fraction of optically luminous material), the ratio of the total mass-to-luminous mass (gas plus stars) monotonically decreases between galaxies and clusters. The decrease in M(sub total)/M(sub lum) arises from two factors: (1) the composition of baryonic matter varies from a predominance of optically luminous material (stars) on the scale of galaxies (approximately 10 kpc) to a predominance of X-ray luminous material (hot gas) on the scale of rich clusters (approximately 1 Mpc), and (2) the hot gas has a more extended spatial distribution than the gravitating matter. The observed decrease M(sub total)/M(sub lum) between galaxies and clusters indicates that the universe actually becomes `brighter' on mass scales between 10(exp 12) and 10(exp 15) solar mass, in the sense that a greater fraction of the gravitating mass is observable.

David, Laurence P.↗

Mapping the dark matter in the NGC 5044 group with ROSAT: Evidence for a nearly homogeneous cooling flow with a cooling wake

The NGC 5044 group of galaxies was observed by the ROSAT Position Sensitive Proportional Counter (PSPC) for 30 ks during its reduced pointed phase (1991 July). Due to the relatively cool gas temperature in the group (kT = 0.98 +/- 0.02 keV) and the excellent photon statistics (65,000 net counts), we are able to determine precisely a number of fundamental properties of the group within 250 kpc of the central galaxy. In particular, we present model-independent measurements of the total gravitating mass, the temperature and abundance profiles of the gas, and the mass accretion rate. Between 60 and 250 kpc, the gas is nearly isothermal with T varies as r(exp (-0.13 +/- 0.03)). The total gravitating mass of the group can be unambiguously determined from the observed density and temperature profiles of the gas using the equation of hydrostatic equilibrium. Within 250 kpc, the gravitating mass is 1.6 x 10(exp 13) solar mass, yielding a mass-to-light ratio of 130 solar mass/solar luminosity. The baryons (gas and stars) comprise 12% of the total mass within this radius. At small radii, the temperature clearly increases outward and attains a maximum value at 60 kpc. The positive temperature gradient in the center of the group confirms the existence of a cooling flow. The cooling flow region extends well beyond the temperature maximum with a cooling radius between 100 and 150 kpc. There are two distinct regions in the cooling flow separated by the temperature maximum. In the outer region, the gas is nearly isothermal with a unifor m Fe abundance of approximately 80% solar, the flow is nearly homogeneous with dot-M= 20 to 25 solar mass/year, the X-ray contours are spherically symmetric, and rho(sub gas) varies as r(exp -1.6). In the inner region, the temperature profile has a positive gradient, the mass accretion rate decreases rapidly inward, the gas density profile is steeper, and the X-ray image shows some substrucutre. NGC 5044 is offset from the centroid of the outer X-ray contours indicating that the central galaxy may have a residual velocity with respect to the center of the group potential. There is also a linear X-ray feature with an extent of approximately 30 kpc with one end coincident with NGC 5044. The X-ray emission from this feature is softer than the ambient gas. We interpret this feature as a 'cooling wake' formed by the accreting gas as it is gravitationally focused into the wake of NGC 5044. One of the most surprising results of our PSPC observation is the discovery of a nearly homogeneous cooling flow. Prior results concerning the mass accretion profile in cooling flows indicate that dot-M varies as r. This relation implies that significant mass deposition occurs at large radii which generates an inhomogeneous flow. The mass accretion rate in the NGC 5044 group is essentially a constant beyond 40 kpc (well within the cooling radius). Significant mass deposition (a declining dot-M) does not commence until the gas accretes to within 40 kpc of the group center where the radiative cooling time is approximately equals 10(exp 9) year. Th is radius also corresponds to the temperature maximum, the break in gas density profile, and the onset of structure in the X-ray image. A Hubble constant of H(sub 0) = 50 km/sec/Mpc is used throughout the paper.

David, Laurence P.↗

Einstein x ray observations of the core of the Shapley Supercluster in northern Centaurus

We present Einstein x ray observations of the core of the Shapley Supercluster, one of the richest and densest known mass concentrations in the local (z less than 0.1) universe. We used Imaging Proportional Counter (IPC) observations supplemented with data from the Einstein Slew Survey to determine the locations and structure of mass concentrations in the region. An x ray map composed of IPC observations of the central (10 deg x 10 deg) region of the Shapley Supercluster is presented. We present evidence that the X-ray clusters observed within 5 deg of the core of the supercluster are on average brighter than those of corresponding richness class distributed throughout the sky. However, we measure no significant difference in the galaxy formation efficiency of these cluster of galaxies compared to other, more isolated clusters. We also find one previously uncataloged cluster-sized mass concentration in the core of the Shapley Supercluster. This new cluster, 'SC 1327-312', is relatively x ray bright (F(sub x) = 1.1 + or - 0.2 x 10(exp -11) erg sec(exp -1) cm(exp -2)) and L(sub x) = 1.1 + or - 0.2 x 10(exp 44) erg sec(exp -1) within 10 minutes, assuming z = 0.0477, H(sub 0) = 50, q(sub 0) = 0). As SC 1327-312 lies well within an Abell radius of the richness R = 4 cluster Shapley 8 (A3558), we suggest it may contribute to an artificially high galaxy count and richness classification for shapley 8. From slew data, we estimate an x ray luminosity for Shapley 8 which is just half the mean luminosity of the four other R = 4 clusters observed by the IPC, further suggesting the richness classification to be an overestimate.

Breen, Jeffrey↗

A spatial, kinematical, and dynamical analysis of Abell 400

The paper presents a detailed spatial, kinematical, and dynamical analysis for the cluster A400, based on a nearly complete redshift survey of bright galaxies within 1 Mpc of the cluster center. A dispersed component with a high fraction of spiral galaxies at a velocity of 8200 km/s, and a background group with a mean velocity of 13,400 km/s are identified. It is proposed that the main body of A400 is composed of at least two individual subclusters. If subclustering is ignored, the derived dispersion of the 88 galaxies with measured velocities within 4000 km/s of the bright dumbbell galaxy near the cluster center is 702 km/s. When kinematic information is used to split A400 into likely subclusters, the velocity dispersions of the individual units which make up this cluster are on the order of 200-300 km/s. If A400 is considered a single entity, the inferred blue mass-to-light ratio is 1210 solar masses/solar luminosities. It is argued that A400 is an example of a presently occurring merger, and that the individual components of the dumbbell galaxy were once individual D galaxies within the premerger subclusters.

Beers, Timothy C.↗

The pattern of gas deficiency in cluster spirals - The correlation of H I and X-ray properties

The neutral hydrogen content of spiral galaxies is investigated as a function of their location with six nearby rich clusters. Previous findings that H I deficiency varies with projected radius from the cluster center are confirmed, but no correlation between H I depletion and velocity relative to the cluster is seen. The dependence of H I deficiency on radius is monotonic; the most H I-poor objects are located close to the cluster center. The current data, however, cannot be used to distinguish between inbred and evolutionary gas deficiency mechanisms or among different environmental processes. Indications are found that environmental effects on spirals, if present at all, only modify the imprint left at the time of cluster formation. Obstacles and possible remedies to the current limitations are discussed.

Magri, Christopher↗