Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Forget, Benoit

Publications and source records attributed to Forget, Benoit.

At least 37 records · Page 2

Threadsafe Dynamic Neighbor Lists for Monte Carlo Ray Tracing

Monte Carlo (MC) transport codes offer high-fidelity modeling of particle transport physics, but their high computational cost makes them impractical for many applications. For some applications such as multiphysics and depletion that use finely discretized geometries, a large portion of this computational cost is attributable to ray tracing. Neighbor lists are a well-known method for accelerating ray-tracing calculations in a MC code, but despite their prevalence, little work has been published on the details of their implementation. The fine details can have a significant impact on performance, particularly when using shared-memory parallelism. This paper addresses these details of implementation with a discussion of different neighbor list schemes and their impact on software runtime. Performance tests were run by using OpenMC on a pin-cell problem discretized with up to 200 axial regions. The results demonstrate that switching from surface-based to cell-based neighbor lists leads to a 10 faster calculation rate for the most fine discretization. Finally, using a threadsafe shared-memory data structure results in a 20% faster calculation rate versus simple threadprivate neighbor lists. Results here show that a data structure that is contiguous in memory improves performance by only 1% to 2% over noncontiguous linked lists.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Calculation of multi-group migration areas in deterministic transport simulations

Recent work on the Cumulative Migration Method (CMM) has demonstrated that it is possible to define multi-group transport cross sections directly from Monte Carlo spectral calculations by utilizing edits of the energy-dependent neutron migration areas. However, it is difficult to demonstrate that downstream deterministic transport calculations actually preserve Monte Carlo migration areas. This paper addresses this issue by: 1) demonstrating the relationship of migration area with the concept of mean squared displacement, 2) deriving, and validating vs. Monte Carlo, an analytic expression for computing one-group migration areas for a homogeneous medium with energy-independent cross sections, 3) deriving, and validating vs. Monte Carlo, an analytic expression for computing multi-group migration areas for a homogenized medium with energy-dependent cross sections, and 4) rigorously proving that energy condensation of multi-group transport cross section must be inverse flux weighted in order to preserve Monte Carlo neutron migration areas.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

L3:RTM.MCH.P19.06: Neutronics UQ

This report summarizes some of the work performed in the last year on the nuclear data uncertainty tasks using the multipole representation. This approach was proposed to provide a simple and integrated way of evaluating the nuclear data uncertainty in a Monte Carlo simulation and evaluating their impact on multigroup cross sections. As previously described, the windowed multipole format allows for a resonance based representation of the cross sections with direct Doppler broadening. This representation also lends itself nicely to the evaluation of sensitivities of resonance parameters and the direct perturbation of resonance parameters in the simulation environment. Both of these approaches rely on the need of conversion of the covariance data (File 32 of the ENDF library) into a pole and residues form: i.e. into a multipole covariance. Section 5 details the current pathways that have been used so far to achieve this. In order to verify the conversion process of the covariance data, the sensitivies to the resonance parameters and the sampling from these parameters, an analytical benchmark of the slowing process was developed. The benchmark provides a closed-form solution for the flux in the presence of Hydrogen and multiple resonant nuclides. Section 2 details the analytical benchmark and provides the closed-form solutions for the flux and its sensitivity to resonance parameters. A verification of the proposed methodology is performed and compared with the analytic solution to demonstrate the accuracy of the benchmark and the applicability of our embedded resonance perturbation approach in a small Monte Carlo code. Papers are currently being drafted documenting the benchmark and the generation of sensitivities. As paths to best generate multipole covariance matrices are being compared, we also explored new methods to propagate nuclear data uncertainty across the Monte Carlo neutron transport calculation. Section 4 studies the use of multipole covariance matrices to perform sensitivity analysis. Section 3.2 documents the results of our investigations into a new way of propagating nuclear data uncertainty across Monte Carlo transport simulations by sampling new epistemic cross sections for each new neutron.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Full core 3D simulation of the BEAVRS benchmark with OpenMOC

The Method of Characteristics (MOC) has seen wide interest in reactor physics because of its accuracy and efficiency in computing lattice physics problems. While most of its use has been in solving 2D problems, there has been recent interest in extending MOC to 3D in order to more accurately calculate 3D power distributions in LWRs. While the method is naturally extensible to 3D, it presents significant computational difficulties. OpenMOC, an open source MOC simulator, has been extended from 2D to 3D capabilities. Simulation results are presented in this study for the full core 3D simulation of the BEAVRS benchmark, adequately resolved in space and angle.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Multigroup Cross-Section Generation with the OpenMC Monte Carlo Particle Transport Code

High-fidelity deterministic transport codes require highly accurate multigroup cross sections (MGXS). Monte Carlo is increasingly cited as a reactor-agnostic approach to MGXS generation since it is unconstrained by the engineering-based approximations that limit the applicability of deterministic MGXS generation tools. This paper introduces a new framework that uses the OpenMC Monte Carlo code to generate MGXS for use in multigroup transport codes. The openmc.mgxs module is built atop OpenMC's Python application programming interface to process tally data output by the OpenMC executable. This paper validates the module to generate MGXS that enable the multigroup OpenMOC transport code to compute eigenvalues to within 50 pcm and fission rates to within 1% of reference solutions for two heterogeneous pressurized water reactor benchmarks.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Integral Full Core Multi-Physics PWR Benchmark with Measured Data

In recent years, the importance of modeling and simulation has been highlighted extensively in the DOE research portfolio with concrete examples in nuclear engineering with the CASL and NEAMS programs. These research efforts and similar efforts worldwide aim at the development of high-fidelity multi-physics analysis tools for the simulation of current and next-generation nuclear power reactors. Like all analysis tools, verification and validation is essential to guarantee proper functioning of the software and methods employed. The current approach relies mainly on the validation of single physic phenomena (e.g. critical experiment, flow loops, etc.) and there is a lack of relevant multiphysics benchmark measurements that are necessary to validate high-fidelity methods being developed today. This work introduces a new multi-cycle full-core Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) depletion benchmark based on two operational cycles of a commercial nuclear power plant that provides a detailed description of fuel assemblies, burnable absorbers, in-core fission detectors, core loading and re-loading patterns. This benchmark enables analysts to develop extremely detailed reactor core models that can be used for testing and validation of coupled neutron transport, thermal-hydraulics, and fuel isotopic depletion. The benchmark also provides measured reactor data for Hot Zero Power (HZP) physics tests, boron letdown curves, and three-dimensional in-core flux maps from 58 instrumented assemblies. The benchmark description is now available online and has been used by many groups. However, much work remains to be done on the quantification of uncertainties and modeling sensitivities. This work aims to address these deficiencies and make this benchmark a true non-proprietary international benchmark for the validation of high-fidelity tools. This report details the BEAVRS uncertainty quantification for the first two cycle of operations and serves as the final report of the project.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

A Rejection Sampling Based Method for Determining Thermal Scattering Angle and Energy

This paper proposes a new method for determining the outgoing energy and angle, E' and µ, of a thermal neutron after undergoing a scattering collision with a material. This method involves rejection sampling from the √E' •S (a, ß) kernel. While this new method is less computationally efficient than the old table lookup method, it has far lower data storage requirements, facilitates the treatment of temperature, provides a true continuous energy and angle representation, and enables the possibility of performing sensitivity analysis on fundamental thermal scattering parameters. This paper aims to demonstrate the feasibility of this approach leaving efficiency improvement to future work.

74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS↗

The Random Ray Method for neutral particle transport

A new approach to solving partial differential equations (PDEs) based on the method of characteristics (MOC) is presented. The Random Ray Method (TRRM) uses a stochastic rather than deterministic discretization of characteristic tracks to integrate the phase space of a problem. TRRM is potentially applicable in a number of transport simulation fields where long characteristic methods are used, such as neutron transport and gamma ray transport in reactor physics as well as radiative transfer in astrophysics. In this study, TRRM is developed and then tested on a series of exemplar reactor physics benchmark problems. The results show extreme improvements in memory efficiency compared to deterministic MOC methods, while also reducing algorithmic complexity, allowing for a sparser computational grid to be used while maintaining accuracy.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

On-the-fly Doppler broadening of unresolved resonance region cross sections

In this paper, two methods for computing temperature-dependent unresolved resonance region cross sections on-the-fly within continuous-energy Monte Carlo neutron transport simulations are presented. The first method calculates Doppler broadened cross sections directly from zero-temperature average resonance parameters. In a simulation, at each event that requires cross section values, a realization of unresolved resonance parameters is generated about the desired energy and temperature-dependent single-level Breit-Wigner resonance cross sections are computed directly via the analytical Ψ-x Doppler integrals. The second method relies on the generation of equiprobable cross section magnitude bands on an energy-temperature mesh. Within a simulation, the bands are sampled and interpolated in energy and temperature to obtain cross section values on-the-fly. Both of the methods, as well as their underlying calculation procedures, are verified numerically in extensive code-to-code comparisons. Energy-dependent pointwise cross sections calculated with the newly-implemented procedures are shown to be in excellent agreement with those calculated by a widely-used nuclear data processing code. Relative differences at or below 0.1% are observed. Integral criticality benchmark results computed with the proposed methods are shown to reproduce those computed with a state-of-the-art processed nuclear data library very well. In simulations of fast spectrum systems which are highly-sensitive to the representation of cross section data in the unresolved region, k-eigenvalue and neutron flux spectra differences of <10 pcm and <1.0% are observed, respectively. The direct method is demonstrated to be well-suited to the calculation of reference solutions — against which results obtained with a discretized representation may be assessed — as a result of its treatment of the energy, temperature, and cross section magnitude variables as continuous. Also, because there is no pre-processed data to store (only temperature-independent average resonance parameters) the direct method is very memory-efficient. Typically, only a few kB of memory are needed to store all required unresolved region data for a single nuclide. However, depending on the details of a particular simulation, performing URR cross section calculations on-the-fly can significantly increase simulation times. Alternatively, the method of interpolating equiprobable probability bands is demonstrated to produce results that are as accurate as the direct reference solutions, to within arbitrary precision, with high computational efficiency in terms of memory requirements and simulation time. Analyses of a fast spectrum system show that interpolation on a coarse energy-temperature mesh can be used to reproduce reference k-eigenvalue results obtained with cross sections calculated continuously in energy and directly at an exact temperature to within <10 pcm. Probability band data on a mesh encompassing the range of temperatures relevant to reactor analysis usually require around 100 kB of memory per nuclide. Finally, relative to the case in which probability table data generated at a single, desired temperature are used, minor increases in simulation times are observed when probability band interpolation is employed.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Treatment of Nonuniform Temperature Distribution by Subgroup Method

The subgroup method divides an energy group into several subgroups according to the magnitude of the cross section. The subgroup fixed source equation is formulated on the energy range of a subgroup, the ratio of which to the energy range of an energy group is defined as subgroup probability. Typically the physical probability table or the mathematical probability table is applied. However, both of the tables are not guaranteed to share the same set of subgroup probabilities for a resonant nuclide at different temperatures. This means that the subgroup fixed source equation cannot be formulated and the subgroup method will not work when the temperature distribution is nonuniform. To overcome this defect, the subgroup method based on partial cross section fit scheme (PXSFS) and the simplified partial cross section fit scheme (SPXSFS) are proposed. These methods fit the cross sections at different temperatures as partial cross sections to share a same set of subgroup probabilities. The new methods is compared to the conventional subgroup method (CSM) based on physical probability table and the preexisting methods: the correlation model (CM), the subgroup level adjustment scheme (SLAS) and the number density adjustment scheme (NDAS). The numerical results show that the new methods can better predict the spatial dependent reaction rate than preexisting methods. Within these two methods, the simplified scheme consumes less time.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Kernel reconstruction methods for Doppler broadening — Temperature interpolation by linear combination of reference cross sections at optimally chosen temperatures

This paper establishes a new family of methods to perform temperature interpolation of nuclear interactions cross sections, reaction rates, or cross sections times the energy. One of these quantities at temperature T is approximated as a linear combination of quantities at reference temperatures (T j ). The problem is formalized in a cross section independent fashion by considering the kernels of the different operators that convert cross section related quantities from a temperature T 0 to a higher temperature T — namely the Doppler broadening operation. Doppler broadening interpolation of nuclear cross sections is thus here performed by reconstructing the kernel of the operation at a given temperature T by means of linear combination of kernels at reference temperatures (T j ). The choice of the L 2 metric yields optimal linear interpolation coefficients in the form of the solutions of a linear algebraic system inversion. The optimization of the choice of reference temperatures (T j ) is then undertaken so as to best reconstruct, in the L∞ sense, the kernels over a given temperature range [T min ,T max ]. The performance of these kernel reconstruction methods is then assessed in light of previous temperature interpolation methods by testing them upon isotope 238 U. Temperature-optimized free Doppler kernel reconstruction significantly outperforms all previous interpolation-based methods, achieving 0.1% relative error on temperature interpolation of 238 U total cross section over the temperature range [300 K,3000 K] with only 9 reference temperatures.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Optimal Temperature Grid for Accurate Doppler Kernel Reconstruction

For computational efficiency, both Monte Carlo and deterministic neutron transport codes often rely on pre-tabulated cross section sets and simple interpolation schemes to represent the Doppler broadening of the cross sections at a needed temperature. Accurate accounting of Doppler effects is of paramount importance for reactor analysis since it impacts the power distribution and the reactor response during transients. Temperature interpolation methods for Doppler broadening have traditionally been physically motivated engineering curve-fits, selected upon best-performance criteria on important nuclides.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Quantifying Transient Uncertainty in the BEAVRS Benchmark Using Time Series Analysis Methods

Advances in computation have brought about significant improvements in creating fast-running high-fidelity simulations of nuclear cores. The BEAVRS benchmark is a highly-detailed PWR specification with two cycles of measured operational data used to validate high-fidelity core analysis methods. This PWR depletion benchmark captures the fine details of the LWR fuel assemblies, burnable absorbers, in-core fission detectors, core loading and shuffling patterns. Specifically, 58 of the 193 assemblies contain in-core detectors with measurements taken over 61 axial positions every month. These detectors are U-235 fission chambers with slightly varying mass of U-235. The collected signals are normalized on a given assembly permitting full core comparisons. The fuel layout for cycle 1 and instrument tube locations for the reactor are given in figures 1 and 2 respectively. Through a series of data processing and comparisons, it was shown that axially integrated radial maps of reaction rates were in close agreement between provided detector data and calculated data. More recently, the focus of the BEAVRS project has been on quantifying uncertainty to further assess the validity of aforementioned results. A close investigation of sources of error shows that uncertainties from operational nuclear data arise primarily from data measurements and processing. While the errors in axial realignment and interpolation seem significant, these sources affect only a small subset of data points near grid spacers and do not persist throughout the entire core. Instead, measurement uncertainty from detector count rates and radial integration dominate the uncertainty in measured data are determined as the most significant sources of error. This uncertainty analysis treated each given burnup step as independent of comparable data at neighboring burnup steps. More recent work has been targeted at understanding how reaction rates vary over time, in order to determine whether calculated reaction rates follow any observable trends. This abstract hones in on transient uncertainty quantification, in order to compare observed data against models for transient behavior. The first section of the paper uses linear regression tools to fit operational data, while the latter portion of the paper explores more complex simulation tools to fit operational data. Ultimately, the BEAVRS benchmark aims to serve as a true non-proprietary international benchmark for the validation of high-fidelity tools. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Treatments for Neutron Resonance Elastic Scattering Using the Multipole Formalism in Monte Carlo Codes

The elastic scattering cross sections of resonant nuclides can vary drastically within small energy intervals. In reactor physics simulations, accurate treatment of neutron resonance elastic scattering is vital, as the phenomenon can have a strong effect on scattering kinematics which, in turn, affect macroscopic values, such as the fuel temperature reactivity coefficient. To reduce memory requirements and facilitate coupling with heat transfer, a new representation for cross sections was recently adopted in OpenMC based on the multipole formalism. However, this new approach invalidates the previous implementations of correct resonance treatments, including the Doppler Broadening Rejection Correction (DBRC) method. This work thus developed a modified DBRC algorithm, called DBRC-MP, compatible with the new data representation. This new method is also verified against the previous DBRC method. While slightly more computationally costly than the traditional DBRC approach using ACE format cross sections, the use of the multipole representation in treating resonance scattering enables the reduction of memory requirements by a hundred-fold and facilitates the representation of temperature dependent cross sections. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Optimal Temperature Grid For Accurate Doppler Kernel Reconstruction

For computational efficiency, both Monte Carlo and deterministic neutron transport codes often rely on pre-tabulated cross section sets and simple interpolation schemes to represent the Doppler broadening of the cross sections at a needed temperature. Accurate accounting of Doppler effects is of paramount importance for reactor analysis since it impacts the power distribution and the reactor response during transients. Temperature interpolation methods for Doppler broadening have traditionally been physically motivated engineering curve-fits, selected upon best-performance criteria on important nuclides. Kernel reconstruction methods have recently been introduced to perform fast and efficient Doppler broadening interpolation as the result of an optimization problem,, . Out of all the possible kernels analyzed, the temperature-optimized free Doppler kernel reconstruction method was shown to significantly outperform traditional Doppler broadening interpolation methods. Detailed derivations will be part of an upcoming journal paper. In this article, key formulae and results for performing free Doppler kernel reconstruction are summarized, and a study of the optimal temperature grid (T{sub j}) selection is presented. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Predicting Correlation Coefficients for Monte Carlo Eigenvalue Simulations

Monte Carlo methods are most often considered as a reference for neutron transport simulations since very limited approximations are made about nuclear data and system geometry. To report uncertainty of any tally evaluated as generation averages, the sample variance is divided by the number of active generations, which is based on the assumption that the neutron generations are independent. Correlation effects between neutrons in multiplying systems, particularly when performing power iteration to evaluate eigenvalues have been observed in previous work. Neglecting the correlation effect results in an underestimate of uncertainty reported by Monte Carlo calculations. Previous work has also proposed methods to predict the underestimation ratio. Yamamoto et al expanded the fission source distribution with diffusion equation modes, performed numerical simulation of the AR (autoregressive) process of the expansion coefficients and used the correlation of the AR process to predict that of the Monte Carlo eigenvalue simulation. Sutton applied the discretized phase space (DPS) approach to predict the underestimation ratio but the method cannot predict the ratio when one neutron generates offspring in different phase space regions or generates a random number of offspring. This paper presents a method to predict the correlation effect with the model of multi-type branching processes (MBP). The method requires simulations for one generation of neutrons without knowing the source distribution and can predict the underestimation ratio for the cases where the traditional DPS approach does not work. The generation-to-generation correlation determines the convergence rate of active generations, the bias of variance estimator for each generation and the underestimation ratio of variance estimator for tallies averaged over active generations. The generation-to-generation correlation is characterized by the Auto-Correlation Coefficients (ACC) between tallies from different generations. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Spatially Continuous Depletion Algorithm for Monte Carlo Simulations

To correctly predict reactor behavior during cycle operations, the evolution of nuclide number densities throughout the core must be accurately modeled. The time-varying spatial distribution of nuclide number densities is typically resolved by discretizing the Monte Carlo geometry into smaller cells over which number densities are assumed to be spatially invariant. The nuclide number densities in these smaller cells are integrated through time using reaction rate tallies on the same discretized geometry. However, detailed distributions of nuclide number densities in a full three dimensional simulation can require a prohibitive amount of tallies, and the spatial discretization of the base geometry makes coupling to external multi-physics tools difficult. In this paper a method for solving for spatially continuous number density distributions during depletion calculations will be described. The spatially continuous number densities can be used in the transport method proposed by Brown and Martin which allows for transporting neutrons through a material with continuously varying properties such as temperature and nuclide number densities. Coupled with the ability of Functional Expansion Tallies (FETs) to represent tallied quantities as continuous functions, it is possible to both solve for and make use of spatially continuous nuclide number densities. The need for this capability was alluded to by Brown et. al., but no solution has yet been proposed. With a continuous depletion method, recent work which utilized FETs and continuous material tracking to incorporate multi-physics feedback in Monte Carlo simulations can be extended to simulations that include depletion analysis. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗