Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Fensin, M. L.

Publications and source records attributed to Fensin, M. L..

Generating shield response functions using a source independent method - 25587

Generalized questions about shield materials are common and yet difficult to answer analytically. Most forms of quick analysis use simple attenuation. The drawback to such methods is the use of mono-energetic averaged cross sections. Averaging a cross section requires knowledge of the flux a priori. If the flux was known, then some more in-depth calculation was performed negating the need for quick scoping calculations. Source independent methods for assessing the transport medium provide a means of creating response functions that yield general statements about the effectiveness of a shielding material. The following paper uses MCNP 6.2 to generate source independent, energy dependent, response functions for the transport medium that allow for quick scoping of effectiveness of various neutron shields. The source independent method here leveraged FT SCX tally treatment, to assess the performance of various shields such that energy response is preserved. (authors)

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Testing Nesting DXTRAN Spheres for Neutron Transport in Air

The deterministic transport sphere (DXTRAN sphere) is a technology that can be utilized in MCNP for improving sampling in the vicinity of a particular geometry, when the solid angle, between the source and particular geometry, is small. At a collision event, a DXTRAN particle is created and deterministically transported to the DXTRAN sphere, while the colliding particle (NONDXTRAN particle) continues transporting as if no DXTRAN event had occurred. Weight is balanced by killing the NONDXTRAN particle when traversing the DXTRAN sphere. If set up correctly, the DXTRAN particle placed on the DXTRAN sphere has a high probability of interacting with the geometry within the DXTRAN sphere. The Central Limit Theorem (CLT) states that the estimated mean approaches a normal distribution with known variance as the number of random samples grows sufficiently large. In reality the variance is seldom known and therefore must be estimated. In a Monte Carlo calculation, one must determine when the number of random samples is sufficiently large for the CLT to be satisfied. For the CLT to be satisfied, the first two moments (mean and variance) must exist. The second moment, the variance of a normal distribution is estimated. The slope test, which uses the largest 201 history scores of each tally fluctuation chart (TFC) bin fit to a Pareto function, is used to determine if the largest history scores decrease faster than 1/x{sup 3}. If the slope is less than 3, then enough histories have not yet been sampled such to meet the second moment existence requirement of the CLT. Usually, a slope of less than 3 indicates that the effects of high weight scores have not been satisfactorily sampled; such a consequence can also be manifested in examining trends in the 4. moment, the variance of the variance (VOV). For example, when examining the TFC, if the VOV is monotonically decreasing for a few sets of histories and then drastically increases for the next set of histories, chances are a rare high weight score, significantly greater than the average score, was encountered. As a result of the 1/R{sup 2} term, a point detector can achieve an extremely high weight, much greater than the average, as the distance from collision to point detector approaches zero. To remedy this difficulty, a 'radius of exclusion' is applied, where within the radius of exclusion 'the point detector estimate is assumed to be the average flux uniformly distributed'. A DXTRAN sphere can suffer from the same weight fluctuation as collisions in the vicinity of the DXTRAN sphere produce much larger weights than collisions happening far from the DXTRAN sphere. If the rare large weight put on the DXTRAN sphere then scores in a tally, there will be a significant increase in the VOV and the slope may drop below 3. To compliment that analysis, here we utilize an air composition and density that varies as a function of altitude, detailing the trials and tribulations of attempting to pass the 10 statistical checks for a variety of single and nested DXTRAN sphere approaches. The objective here is to illuminate important considerations for radiation transport problems with small solid angles in a scatter medium of few mean free paths (MFPs)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Characterizing Fluence as a Function of Areal Density for 1 and 14 MeV Neutrons Transported Through Air

Computing neutron dosimetry involves transporting neutrons [n] from a source to a sink, determining the neutron heating within the sink and multiplying the neutron heating by a quality factor to compute the dose equivalent. The space and energy dependent neutron fluence is a measure of the amount of neutrons crossing a particular surface area, about a particular energy and is given in units of [n/cm{sup 2}]. Microscopic cross sections are given in units of area and vary by isotope and reaction type as a function of energy. The product of the atom density of a particular atom in a specie and the microscopic cross section of a particular reaction results in the macroscopic cross section of a particular reaction, given in units of per length [1/cm] as a function of energy. Summing the macroscopic cross sections of all isotopes, and all collisions resulting in heating, within a volume, results in a total collision heating macroscopic cross section for that volume. The product of the energy and spatial dependent collision heating macroscopic cross section and the energy and spatial dependent fluence, within an energy group, results in a collision heating reaction density for that particular reaction in that energy group. Weighting each energy group's collision heating reactions, with the corresponding energy dependent particle damage per collision heating event (usually biological damage), and then integrating over energy and volume results in the delivered dose. Therefore understanding dose delivery involves examining the spatial and energy (and time) dependent fluence behavior. Because of the coupled energy and space dependence of the heating weighting and macroscopic cross sections, the fluence is not so easily separable in energy and space; however, the energy integrated fluence can be used as a first order approximation of the relative magnitude of reactions as a function of space. Here we examine the first part in the dosimetry calculation process, transporting neutrons from source to sink, as applied to neutron transport in air, examining characteristics of the fluence. Presented here is analysis regarding the nature of the fluence peak between 10 g/cm{sup 2} and 100 g/cm{sup 2} for a typical air transport calculation. Due to the high concentration of nitrogen and oxygen isotopes of these elements, these isotopes tend to dominate the transport. From the analysis presented here, the fluence peak is the result of scatter back and forth across the peak regime, and (n,2n) has a minimal (<4%) contribution. Further evidence of minimal (n,2n) impact in the 10-100 g/cm{sup 2} span includes the 1 MeV fluence peak being so much larger than the 14 MeV peak; where 1 MeV is not above the (n,2n) threshold. Also presented here is the usefulness of using tally tagging with cell flagging to further dissect the nature of the fluence. These technologies allow us to understand the originating volume that makes a contribution to a scoring regime. (authors)

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Comparing Thick Target Neutron Yield Calculations for Alphas on F-19 using MCNP6 1.1 Beta with TENDL 2012 Libraries

Because of the heritage of MCNPX, the first production release of MCNP6{sup TM} used physics models, instead of ACE (A Compact Evaluated Nuclear Data File) formatted libraries, for simulating the transport of alpha particles at all energies, as MCNPX could not yet read ACE formatted light ion libraries. For non-Coulombic interactions, the physics models have suggested minimums of ∼ 20-200 MeV. The first production release of MCNP6, MCNP6{sup TM} 1.0, was still capable of transporting alphas to low energies; however, the physics models resulted in poor prediction of inelastic reactions at energies below the suggested minimums. This poorer prediction at low energies resulted in orders of magnitude lower neutron yields for events resulting from light ion interactions at low energies. For example, F-19(α,n)Na-22 from U-234 decay in UF{sub 6} produced poor neutron production results. Modeling these types of interactions correctly is vital for signal analysis for nonproliferation safeguards and nuclear security as well as for correctly characterizing source terms for radiation protection and shielding calculations. The TALYS computer code was developed to simulate nuclear reactions involving neutrons, photons, protons, deuterons, tritons, alphas and He-3 particles, in the 1 keV - 200 MeV energy range. TENDL is a nuclear data library, which provides the output of the TALYS nuclear model code system for direct use in applications (i.e. ACE formatted cross sections). Since 2008, TENDL had publicly provided ACE formatted libraries for alpha transport; however, not until the release of MCNP6{sup TM} 1.1 beta, had MCNP6 publicly possessed the capability to read such libraries. At the Radiation Protection and Shielding Division topical meeting in 2014, initial testing of MCNP6 1.1 beta showed that MCNP6 using TENDL 2012 resulted in poor prediction when compared to the compilation of experiment data provided in R. Heaton et al. Further comparisons for PuBe sources, using the MCNP6 1.1 beta spontaneous decay alpha feature coupled with alpha transport, were also given in the winter American Nuclear Society meeting in 2014, where the results showed large discrepancies with measured data. For F-19(α,n)Na-22 interactions, the R. Heaton et al. paper is a conglomeration of several important references; and the data provided by R. Heaton et al. used a numerical fit of the excitation function provided by Norman et al.. Norman et al. has recently published their (α,n) thick target yield data for PbF{sub 2} in tabular form, backing out the thick target yields of F-19(α,n)Na-22 and computing F{sub 2} and UF{sub 6} thick target neutron yields (as supplements to the PbF{sub 2} data). Here we compared measured thick target yields of E. B. Norman et al. to MCNP6 1.1 beta using TENDL 2012 libraries. Deterministically backing out the thick target yield from measured values involves using the stopping power. MCNP uses either the SPAR code or an interpolation of the Spar code and Bethe-Boch formula for computing stopping powers. As a result one may believe that these separate methods will arrive at separate thick target yields independent of the production cross section. In our MCNP calculations, we simulated the alpha until the alpha completely stopped in the medium. The energy loss in the condensed history algorithm is not continuous but discrete and related to the stopping powers. Because the neutron production yield is energy dependent, the energy loss dictates the emission of secondary neutrons; and therefore the difference in stopping powers used may have some slight effect on the yield difference. For this study, we chose to use the default condensed history algorithm setup, while future studies should address tightening steps in the condensed history algorithm to prove whether or not choice of stopping power actually matters. The fact that all 5 evaluated isotopic compositions resulted in different thick target yield percent differences does warrant this type of investigation. A typical user may not be only interested in integral emission, taking 10 s to 100 s of processor hours to simulate, but rather a timely generation of the spectra. Such an application would require biasing the production of secondaries from alpha sources such that millions of secondaries could be produced, emulating a converged energy dependent spectra. Neutron production biasing from alpha sources does not currently exist; however, developing a biasing algorithm for neutron production from alpha sources should be investigated in the future.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Performance upgrades to the MCNP6 burnup capability for large scale depletion calculations

The first MCNP based inline Monte Carlo depletion capability was officially released from the Radiation Safety Information and Computational Center as MCNPX 2.6.0. With the merger of MCNPX and MCNP5, MCNP6 combined the capability of both simulation tools, as well as providing new advanced technology, in a single radiation transport code. The new MCNP6 depletion capability was first showcased at the International Congress for Advancements in Nuclear Power Plants (ICAPP) meeting in 2012. At that conference the new capabilities addressed included the combined distributive and shared memory parallel architecture for the burnup capability, improved memory management, physics enhancements, and new predictability as compared to the H.B Robinson Benchmark. At Los Alamos National Laboratory, a special purpose cluster named “tebow,” was constructed such to maximize available RAM per CPU, as well as leveraging swap space with solid state hard drives, to allow larger scale depletion calculations (allowing for significantly more burnable regions than previously examined). As the MCNP6 burnup capability was scaled to larger numbers of burnable regions, a noticeable slowdown was realized.This paper details two specific computational performance strategies for improving calculation speedup: (1) retrieving cross sections during transport; and (2) tallying mechanisms specific to burnup in MCNP. To combat this slowdown new performance upgrades were developed and integrated into MCNP6 1.2.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Comparing Measured (a,n) Thick Target Yields to MCNP6 using TENDL 2012 Libraries - Paper 31

MCNP6, due to the heritage of MCNPX, has always possessed the capability to transport the light ions, such as alpha particles. Two types of competing physics take place during the particle transport: atomic and nuclear physics. Charged particles lose energy to media due to Coulombic interactions. MCNP6 models Coulombic interactions through the use of the continuous slowing down approximation. Stopping powers are calculated at a variety of energies using the Bethe-Bloch formula with Sternheimer and Peierls density effect correction. For energies less than 1.31 MeV/AMU, a low-energy SPAR model is used. When the energy of the particle is high enough, there is a transition from nuclear interactions to nucleon interactions. MCNP6 possess various physics models to account for these types of intra-nuclear cascades. These models are less accurate at low energies. Even though MCNP6 will transport these light ions to low energies (i.e. less than 20 MeV), most of the available model physics in MCNP6, for nuclear interactions, has a suggested minimum energy of ∼20-200 MeV. The result of the poorer prediction at low energies causes important light ion events, such as F-19(a,n)Na-22 from U-234 decay in UF{sub 6}, to produce orders of magnitude fewer neutrons in MCNP6 than should be emitted. As with neutrons, ACE (A Compact ENDF) formatted light ion libraries have been developed from several different evaluations. These libraries possess better physics at low energies where the physics models break down. The TENDL 2012 evaluations possess alpha transport libraries, in ACE format, such that they can easily be used with codes like MCNP6 that read ACE formatted cross sections. As a result, a capability was developed for MCNP6 to read and implement these library cross sections when the light ion reached energies below the library upper energy cutoff. Perfectly modelling an experiment for benchmark comparisons to a code calculation can be tricky. For complex setups, systematic error is always possible; and usually a hefty uncertainty analysis is required to quantify just the geometry setup and material combination choices. For an (a,n) interaction, a thick target yield is defined as the amount of neutrons emitted given that the alpha ranges out in the material. For alpha transport at low energy <10 MeV, in reasonably dense materials (>1-2 g/cc), with a material dimension length larger than a few hundred microns, alpha particles will tend to completely stop and range out in the material. For Li, Be, B, C, N, O, F, Na, Mg and Al thick target yields exist in 200 keV intervals from 1 to 9.8 MeV (most of the elements do have (a,n) thresholds above 1 MeV). Because modelling a thick target yield in MCNP6 is much easier than attempting to account for the complexity of systematic error from a full out experiment, we present here comparisons of (a,n) thick target yields to those calculated in MCNP6 using the TENDL 2012 alpha library evaluations.

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Testing the Delayed Gamma Capability in MCNP6 - Paper 86

The mission of the Domestic Nuclear Detection Office (DNDO) is to quickly and reliably detect unauthorized attempts to import or transport special nuclear material (SNM) for use against the United States. Developing detection equipment to meet this objective requires accurate simulation of both the detectable signature and detection mechanism. MCNP6 is capable of transporting the various types of radiation encountered in these scenarios; however, the accuracy of MCNP6 must be quantified such that we can be confident in the results of the simulations. Delayed gamma transport is one important component of these detection scenarios. Delayed gamma transport is defined as the combination of gamma emission from radioactive and subsequent transport through matter. MCNP always possessed the ability to emit delayed neutrons from fission; however, these delayed neutron spectra and intensity were functional fits and not directly sampled from the created fission products. Furthermore, there existed no method to emit the decay photons from radioactive fission products (or any radioactive nucleus) A delayed particle capability was initially added to MCNPX 2.6.A in 2005 to sample the radioactive fission product parents and emit decay particles resulting from the decay chain. At the point of capture, a residual nucleus is created and decayed using the CINDER90 depletion code. MCNP only sends CINDER90 a residual radioactive nucleus and not a flux (i.e. capture rate). As a result, the Bateman equations for the solution are coupled first order differential equations with constant coefficients. Theoretically, these equations could be solved analytically; however, CINDER90 employs a numerical Markov linear chain scheme to solve these equations. This paper addresses a more simplified approach to benchmarking in order to best assess: (1) whether or not deficiencies exist in the current methodology for certain types of decay chains; and (2) paths forward for improving the delayed particle emission capability. We utilize closed form analytic solutions to the granddaughter equations for particular sets of isotope systems to compare the accuracy of the delayed gamma capability in MCNP6. (authors)

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

The new MCNP6 depletion capability

The first MCNP based in-line Monte Carlo depletion capability was officially released from the Radiation Safety Information and Computational Center as MCNPX 2.6.0. Both the MCNP5 and MCNPX codes have historically provided a successful combinatorial geometry based, continuous energy, Monte Carlo radiation transport solution for advanced reactor modeling and simulation. However, due to separate development pathways, useful simulation capabilities were dispersed between both codes and not unified in a single technology. MCNP6, the next evolution in the MCNP suite of codes, now combines the capability of both simulation tools, as well as providing new advanced technology, in a single radiation transport code. We describe here the new capabilities of the MCNP6 depletion code dating from the official RSICC release MCNPX 2.6.0, reported previously, to the now current state of MCNP6. NEA/OECD benchmark results are also reported. The MCNP6 depletion capability enhancements beyond MCNPX 2.6.0 reported here include: (1) new performance enhancing parallel architecture that implements both shared and distributed memory constructs; (2) enhanced memory management that maximizes calculation fidelity; and (3) improved burnup physics for better nuclide prediction. MCNP6 depletion enables complete, relatively easy-to-use depletion calculations in a single Monte Carlo code. The enhancements described here help provide a powerful capability as well as dictate a path forward for future development to improve the usefulness of the technology. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Technical Cross-Cutting Issues for the Next Generation Safeguards Initiative's Spent Fuel Nondestructive Assay Project

Ever since there has been spent fuel (SF), researchers have made nondestructive assay (NDA) measurements of that fuel to learn about its content. In general these measurements have focused on the simplest signatures (passive photon and total neutron emission) and the analysis has often focused on diversion detection and on determining properties such as burnup (BU) and cooling time (CT). Because of shortcomings in current analysis methods, inspectorates and policy makers are interested in improving the state-of-the-art in SF NDA. For this reason the U.S. Department of Energy, through the Next Generation Safeguards Initiative (NGSI), targeted the determination of elemental Pu mass in SF as a technical goal. As part of this research effort, 14 nondestructive assay techniques were studied . This wide range of techniques was selected to allow flexibility for the various needs of the safeguards inspectorates and to prepare for the likely integration of one or more techniques having complementary features. In the course of researching this broad range of NDA techniques, several cross-cutting issues were. This paper will describe some common issues and insights. In particular we will describe the following: (1) the role of neutron absorbers with emphasis on how these absorbers vary in SF as a function of initial enrichment, BU and CT; (2) the need to partition the measured signal among different isotopic sources; and (3) the importance of the “first generation” concept which indicates the spatial location from which the signal originates as well as the isotopic origins.

Next Generation Safeguards Initiative↗

Determination of Plutonium Content in Spent Fuel with Nondestructive Assay

There are a variety of reasons for quantifying plutonium (Pu) in spent fuel such as independently verifying the Pu content declared by a regulated facility, making shipper/receiver mass declarations, and quantifying the input mass at a reprocessing facility. As part of the Next Generation Safeguards Initiative, NA-241 has recently funded a multilab/university collaboration to determine the elemental Pu mass in spent fuel assemblies. This research effort is anticipated to be a five year effort: the first part of which is a two years Monte Carlo modeling effort to integrate and down-select among 13 nondestructive assay (NDA) technologies, followed by one year for fabricating instruments and then two years for measuring spent fuel. This paper gives a brief overview of the approach being taken for the Monte Carlo research effort. In addition, preliminary results for the first NDA instrument studied in detail, delayed neutron detection, will be presented. In order to cost effectively and robustly model the performance of several NDA techniques, an"assembly library" was created that contains a diverse range of pressurized water reactor spent fuel assemblies (burnup, enrichment, cooling time) similar to that which exists in spent pools today and in the future, diversion scenarios that capture a range of possible rod removal options, spatial and isotopic detail needed to accurately quantify the capability of all the NDA techniques so as to enable integration. Integration is being designed into this study from the beginning since it is expected that the best performance will be obtained by combining a few NDA techniques. The performance of each instrument will be quantified for the full assembly library in three different media: air, water and borated water. In this paper the preliminary capability of delayed neutron detection will be quantified for the spent fuel library for all three media. The 13 NDA techniques being researched are the following: Delayed Gamma, Delayed Neutrons, Differential Die-Away, Differential Die-Away Self-Interrogation, Lead Slowing Down Spectrometer, Neutron Multiplicity, Nuclear Resonance Fluorescence, Passive Prompt Gamma, Passive Neutron Albedo Reactivity, Self-integration Neutron Resonance Densitometry, Total Neutron (Gross Neutron), X-Ray Fluorescence, 252Cf Interrogation with Prompt Neutron Detection.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗