Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Enders, Alexander L.

Publications and source records attributed to Enders, Alexander L..

Process for Conducting a Cost Benefit Analysis for New Radiation Portal Monitors

The Domestic Nuclear Detection Office (DNDO) has deployed over 1,400 radiation portal monitors (RPMs) around the United States to enhance border security. DNDO is now considering deployment of a newer generation of RPMs, intended to have equal or better sensitivity but a considerably lower nuisance alarm rate due to Naturally Occurring Radioactive Material (NORM) that is common in the stream of commerce. If the nuisance alarm rate is sufficiently reduced at a site, US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) may be able to reduce the staffing necessary to respond to nuisance alarms generated by the RPMs. This document provides an overview of some possible processes for conducting a cost benefit analysis to place a reliable dollar amount on the value of these new systems. While there is no hard and fast guide for conducting a cost benefit analysis, an austere method is provided for quick estimating. Two robust methods are also provided, one taking guidance from an Office of Management and Budget circular and the other from the Government Accountability Office.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

Nuclear Smuggling Detection and Deterrence FY 2016 Data Analysis Annual Report

The National Nuclear Security Administration’s Office of Nuclear Smuggling Detection and Deterrence (NSDD) has facilitated the installation of more than 3,500 radiation portal monitors (RPMs) at 606 sites in 56 countries worldwide. This collection of RPMs represents the world’s largest network of radiation detectors and provides one element in the defense-in-depth approach that supports the Global Nuclear Detection Architecture. These systems support NSDD’s mission to build partner country capability to deter, detect, and interdict the illicit transport of radiological and fissile material through strategic points of entry and exit at seaports, airports, and border crossings. NSDD works collaboratively with partner countries and international organizations to optimize the operation of these RPMs. The large amount of data provided by NSDD partner countries highlights the close cooperation and partnerships NSDD has built with 56 countries around the world. Thirty-seven of these countries shared at least some RPM-related data with NSDD in fiscal year 2016. This significant level of data sharing is a key element that distinguishes the NSDD office as unique among nuclear nonproliferation programs and initiatives: NSDD can provide specific, objective, data-driven decisions and support for sustaining the radiation detection systems it helped deploy. This data analysis report summarizes and aggregates the RPM data provided to the NSDD office for analysis and review in fiscal year 2016. The data can be used to describe RPM performance and characterize the wide diversity of NSDD deployment sites. For example, NSDD deploys detector systems across sites with natural background radiation levels that can vary by a factor of approximately six from site to site. Some lanes have few occupancies, whereas others have approximately 8,000 occupancies per day and the different types of cargo that travel through a site can result in site-wide alarm rates that range from near 0% at some sites to above 3% at others. Based on the data received, the global average uptime for NSDD RPMs was above 96% for fiscal year 2016. NSDD takes all of these factors into account in making recommendations to partner countries on how to most effectively manage and maintain site operations. NSDD utilizes reports and other information products created by data analysts to efficiently allocate the resources needed to detect and ultimately interdict illicit nuclear and radiological material.

98 NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT, SAFEGUARDS, AND PHYSICAL P↗

Detection with Enhanced Energy Windowing Phase I Report

This document reviews the progress of Phase I of the Detection with Enhanced Energy Windowing (DEEW) project. The DEEW project is the implementation of software incorporating an algorithm which reviews data generated by radiation portal monitors and utilizes advanced and novel techniques for detecting radiological and fissile material while not alarming on Naturally Occurring Radioactive Material. Independent testing indicated that the Enhanced Energy Windowing algorithm showed promise at reducing the probability of alarm in the stream of commerce compared to existing algorithms and other developmental algorithms, while still maintaining adequate sensitivity to threats. This document contains a brief description of the project, instructions for setting up and running the applications, and guidance to help make reviewing the output files and source code easier.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

DART 7.0 User Guide

The Desktop Analysis Reporting Tool (DART) is a software package that allows users to easily view and analyze daily files that span long periods. DART gives users the capability to quickly determine the state of health of a radiation portal monitor (RPM), troubleshoot and diagnose problems, and view data in various time frames to perform trend analysis. In short, it converts the data strings written in the daily files into meaningful tables and plots. The standalone version of DART (“soloDART”) utilizes a database engine that is included with the application; no additional installations are necessary. There is also a networked version of DART (“polyDART”) that is designed to maximize the benefit of a centralized data repository while distributing the workload to individual desktop machines. This networked approach requires a more complex database manager Structured Query Language (SQL) Server; however, SQL Server is not currently provided with DART. Regardless of which version is used, DART will import daily files from RPMs, store the relevant data in its database, and it can produce reports for status, trend analysis, and reporting purposes.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Benefits of Daily File Analysis

Data analysis is an integral part of the Second Line of Defense (SLD) program to ensure that radiation monitoring equipment is operating effectively. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) has developed the Desktop Analysis Reporting Tool (DART), which allows SLD users to easily analyze daily file data and to determine the state of health of the monitors. Currently, SLD analysts at ORNL use the DART software to review radiation portal monitor (RPM) data and to generate reports that provide findings to SLD country, project, and sustainability managers.

DART↗

Methodology for Determining Radiation Portal Monitor Availability from Daily Files

The Second Line of Defense (SLD) Program works with partner countries to enhance their capabilities in deterring, detecting, and interdicting the illicit trafficking of nuclear and radiological materials through international borders by providing radiation detection equipment and related training. With agreement from SLD partner countries, the program collects daily file data from installed TSA Systems pedestrian, conveyor, vehicle, and rail radiation portal monitors (RPMs).1 Analysis of the data can provide information related to the state of health and configuration of the radiation monitoring equipment. By analyzing this data from the field over long periods of time, the program is able to determine valuable information such as the general reliability of the deployed equipment. In order to characterize the program’s overall effectiveness, data from daily files is used to determine the availability of RPMs that submit daily files to Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). Availability in this context is the proportion of time the RPM is in a functioning condition. The RPM is available when all the components of the system are functioning properly, thereby allowing the proper functioning of the RPM as a whole. This document explains the methodology and assumptions used to arrive at an availability metric for the RPMs from which ORNL receives data.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗