Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

DeWolf, Scott

Publications and source records attributed to DeWolf, Scott.

33 records · Page 2

Using Strain in the Vadose Zone During Sinusoidal-Rate Well Tests to Characterize an Aquifer

Well tests with sinusoidal variation in pumping rate are appealing because of the ability to filter competing signals and they also can be set up with no net removal of water, which is an advantage at contaminated sites. Current methods of interpreting sinusoidal-rate well tests analyze the phase lag and amplitude of pressure signals in the aquifer. This approach is restricted by the availability of monitoring wells. An alternative approach could be to measure the stain in the vadose zone instead of pressure in the aquifer. The goal of this research is to evaluate the feasibility of using signals from in-situ sensors in the vadose zone to characterize sinusoidal-rate well tests. Well tests with a variety of periods and amplitudes were performed using a well completed in an unconfined saprolite aquifer with a water table at 9m depth at our test site near Clemson, South Carolina. Vertical strain was measured every meter between 1 to 7 m using a distributed optical fiber sensing technique called coherence length gated microwave photonics interferometry (CMPI). A novel packaging system was designed to couple the optical fiber to the saprolite. The results show that strain measured in the vadose zone during sinusoidal-rate pumping varies periodically with amplitudes from 0.1 to 3 microstrain, depending on the amplitude of the sinusoidal pumping rate. Hydraulic heads at similar radial distances were also periodic with changing amplitudes ranging up to ±0.2 meters. The strain in the vadose zone responds to pressure in the underlying aquifer—the strain is tensile when the pressure is falling, and compressive when the pressure is rising. The phase lag between the pumping rate and the strain was 3 min with a pumping period of 15 minutes, and this gives a hydraulic diffusivity of 0.06 m2/s. This is the same diffusivity obtained by analyzing a constant rate pumping test, and it is slightly larger than the diffusivity (0.044 m2/s) obtained by analyzing the phase lag of the pressure in a nearby monitoring well. Strain measurements in the vadose zone could be made with much less cost and effort than installing a deep monitoring well. These results suggest that strain measurements in the vadose zone could be used to supplement monitoring wells, thereby increasing the resolution, and reducing costs of analyzing well tests.

well test, sinusoidal, periodic pumping, strain↗

Feasibility of using in situ deformation to monitor CO 2 storage

Deformation during CO 2 injection can lead to problems, like seismicity or fluid leaks, but small strains have the potential to be a useful signal for monitoring. The objective of this paper is to evaluate the possible evolution of the strain field during injection, and then assess existing and emerging techniques for measuring the strain field. Poroelastic analyses show that normal strains caused by injection into a reservoir are tensile in the vicinity of the well, but everywhere else at least one strain component is compressive. The vertical strain is compressive in the confining unit, and the radial strain decreases and changes sign from tensile to compressive with distance from the well. Tilting is away from the injection well at the ground surface, but it is towards the well overlying the reservoir. Methods for measuring in-situ strain include instruments that are grouted in the annulus between casing and wall rock (~ 0.1 microstrain resolution), portable strain sensors that are temporarily clamped to the borehole wall (~0.01 microstrain resolution), and strainmeters that are grouted in place (~0.001 microstrain resolution). Instruments for measuring in-situ normal strains at the magnitudes and rates expected during injection are emerging, but they have yet to be fully evaluated in applications related to CO 2 storage. Finally, in-situ strain data measured with emerging instruments promises to fill an important gap between the episodes of fast strain rates measured by seismic data, and the slow strains measured over relatively long periods of time by InSAR and GPS.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Framework for Characterizing Strain in the Vicinity of Leaky Reservoirs

The identification of leaks in the vicinity of reservoirs is critical to determining the feasibility of long-term geologic storage of CO2, methane, wastewater and other fluids. We have established a series of basic reservoir leakage scenarios and performed numerical analysis to characterize the associated pressure and strain fields created from injection into these leaky reservoir settings, as well from ambient loads, such as barometric pressure and earth tides. The end-member conceptual models evaluated include injection and ambient loads applied to: 1) a thin, horizontal layer with no leakage pathways (baseline), 2) a thin layer with a vertical conduit to the surface (e.g., a leaky fault or abandoned well) and 3) a thin layer with a conduit to an overlying aquifer. The pressure and strain fields are sensitive to the reservoir and confining unit geometry, material properties, the distribution, composition and compressibility of the pore fluid and the type of applied load (e.g., constant vs. cyclical injection, barometric pressure fluctuations, earth tides, etc.). Initial results from the numerical analyses indicate that an induced pressure change of 1 MPa in a formation at 1 km depth with a Young’s modulus of 10 GPa is sufficient to create vertical and horizontal strain signals as high as 2 με at a depth of 100 m. The signals predicted from leaky conditions compared to an intact reservoir differ by as much as 0.2 με in magnitude and evolve at different rates. We have developed instruments capable of measuring vertical and horizontal strain at a resolution of better than 5 nε and have recorded repeatable strain signals at 30 m depth in response to wastewater injection into the Avant field in Oklahoma. Based on these findings, strain signals predicted in the shallow subsurface (< 100 m) with numerical analysis are expected to be measurable, and this signal may be inverted to characterize the location and magnitude of leaks, as well as to characterize the geometry and hydromechanical properties of the formation and overlying confining units. This suggests that shallow strain measurements could be a cost effective method for characterizing and monitoring gas storage projects.

Robert, Moak↗

Designs and Results from Three New Borehole Optical Fiber Tensor Strainmeters

The time evolving strain field contains a wealth of information that can be used to interpret subsurface behavior. For example, injecting or removing fluids from reservoirs or aquifers causes deformation that can be used as a diagnostic signal in some cases, while it can interfere with geodetic interpretations in other cases. We've recently completed a field study that demonstrated the feasibility of measuring the strain tensor at a depth of 30 m caused by injection into a reservoir at 530 m depth. The observed strain signals were interpreted using four independent analytic and numerical methods that resulted in estimates of the poroelastic properties and geometry of the reservoir that was consistent with data from well logs. However, studies like these are only possible if these deformations can be reliably measured

DeWolf, Scott↗

Interpreting the Strain Tensor During Injection into a Reservoir

A suite of well tests was conducted to evaluate the feasibility of measuring and interpreting the strain tensor during injection. Water was injected at 1 liter/s for a few days to a few weeks into a well completed at a depth of 530 m in the Bartlesville sandstone in the North Avant Field in Oklahoma. The strain tensor was measured using strainmeters at a depth of 30m and a distance of 220m from the well. We used a Gladwin strainmeter, a state-of-the-art geodetic strainmeter, as well as novel borehole strainmeters developed for the project. After processing, the horizontal strains were tensile and the vertical strain was compressive during injection. The radial strain was less than the circumferential strain. Strain magnitudes increased during injection and recovered afterward. The strain rate was as fast as 100 nanostrain/d at the start of injection, and decreased to 10 nanostrain/d after a few days. The normal strain signals were approximately proportional to the log of time during the first few days of injection, and the semi-log slope was 50 to 75 nanostrain. Data from the Gladwin strainmeter were essentially identical to data from a strainmeter we developed using optical fiber sensors. Tilt was measured using two tiltmeters, but the tilts were erratic compared to the normal strain and were of limited value. Strain data were analyzed using a strain type-curve method, an analytical solution to a poroelastic inhomogeneity, and a stochastic inversion method. Poroelastic simulations explain the data well. Results from the interpretation methods are consistent with each other, and with independent information characterizing the area. The hydraulic diffusivity is approximately 0.5 m2/s and the permeability is between 100 and 500 mD, according to analysis of the strain signals. This is consistent with measurements of permeability from cores, and with analyses of pressure transients. The analyses indicate that Young’s modulus of the reservoir is between 2 and 6 GPa. Strain interpretations indicate the well intersects a permeable lens with a maximum dimension of 500 to 1,000 m. An isopach map of coarse-grained sand confirms a feature roughly 1,000 m in lateral extent. The results demonstrate that the strain signal measured at shallow (30m) depth can be used to infer properties and heterogeneities in an underlying reservoir or aquifer.

Murdoch, Larry↗

A cloud computing approach to massively-parallel distributed stochastic optimization with application to geomechanical reservoir characterization

Many search strategies used to optimize parameters during hydrologic model calibration are inherently limited in that simulations must be performed sequentially in order for the algorithm to converge. As a result, the overall time required to reach a solution increases linearly with the number of steps necessary. In contrast, sampling strategies that attempt to approximate the posterior distribution of the parameters do not require the model simulations to be run in sequence and therefore invite the use of a massively parallel approach across heterogeneous computing environments. We apply a cloud computing methodology to this problem where a head node running on Amazon Web Services continuously produces candidate models that are distributed to arbitrary compute environments to run the simulation, in our case Clemson’s Palmetto cluster computer. Thus the time required to obtain a sufficient number of samples to produce an adequate approximation of the posterior distribution of the parameters is limited by the number of available compute sites. Monte Carlo sampling of the posterior space would be duplicative and inefficient, thus we combine Latin hypercube methods with genetic algorithms to ensure that no large regions of the parameter space are left unexplored, and that high probability regions are investigated thoroughly. We independently assess the fit to different types of data sets without the need to construct a single objective function. Sets of Pareto optimal models are particularly valuable when the quality and information content of data is poorly known or conceptual model errors exist in our simulation. We illustrate our approach for a problem where in situ strain data are used to calibrate the parameters of an oil reservoir in the Avant oil field in Oklahoma. We use well injection and shut-in to stress a deep (500m) confined formation, and observe the geomechanical response using borehole strainmeters installed in the shallow subsurface (30m). These data were then used to calibrate the poroelastic properties of the reservoir and caprock along with the geometry of an elliptic channel associated with the formation. Using our approach we are able to identify issues with model error as well as substantial tradeoffs that occur within the parameters.

inversion, stochastic, geomechanics, poroelastic, ↗

Characterizing and Interpreting the In Situ Strain Tensor During CO 2 Injection

Injecting fluid into a well creates an evolving strain tensor field in the rocks enveloping the well. Understanding the strain field has the potential to improve the effectiveness of CO 2 storage, but the strain tensor had never been measured during injection. The objective of this project was to evaluate how the strain tensor can be measured and interpreted to improve the assessment of geomechanical properties and advance an understanding of geomechanical processes that may present risks to CO 2 storage. The project consisted of three primary tasks related to 1) developing instruments for measuring the strain tensor with high precision; 2) developing methods for analyzing strain signals; and 3) demonstrating the approach at a CO 2 storage analog site.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

9A Injection: October 11 thru October 17, 2017

Processed Gladwin Tensor Strainmeter, Eddy current vertical strain and tilt, and well pressure data from the well 9A injection on October 11 thru October 17, 2017, at the North Avant Field, OK

Geologic Carbon Storage↗

9A Injection: November 28 thru December 1, 2017

Processed Gladwin Tensor Strainmeter, eddy current vertical strain and tilt, optical fiber areal strainmeter, and well pressure and injection rate data from the well 9A injection on November 28 thru December 1, 2017, at the North Avant Field, OK

Geologic Carbon Storage↗

9A Injection: June 28 thru July 23, 2018

Processed Gladwin Tensor Strainmeter, eddy current vertical strain and tilt, optical fiber areal strainmeter, and well pressure and injection rate data from the well 9A injection on June 28 thru July 23, 2017, at the North Avant Field, OK

Geologic Carbon Storage↗

Characterizing the Subsurface Using Deformation from Pumping and Surface Loading Tests

Changes in pore pressure or applied load cause deformation that can be used to characterize the subsurface. A series of field tests were conducted by measuring the deformation and pressure response from a variety of stresses at our test site in South Carolina. The site is underlain by saprolite to a depth of 30 m, and the water table in the unconfined aquifer occurs at a depth of 9 m. The types of tests performed included constant-rate pumping tests and surface point loading tests using the weight of a person or vehicle. Vertical displacement of the saprolite in response to these stresses was measured at depths of 3, 6, 9 and 11 meters in both saturated and unsaturated conditions using an extensometer with a resolution of +/- 10 nm. Results from 2.5-hr-long constant-rate pumping tests indicate a repeatable, compressive vertical strain of roughly 0.1 microstrain in the vadose zone and 1-10 microstrain in the saturated zone. Drawdown was 5 m in the pumping well and 0.1 m in a nearby (r = 9m) observation well. Under saturated conditions, the strain rate gradually decreased throughout the test in a pattern that resembles the drawdown curve in the monitoring well. In contrast, the strain in the vadose zone increased quickly early in the test, but the strain rate diminished and was negligible after approximately 30 minutes of pumping. Interestingly, drawdown in the pumping well also increased quickly over 30 minutes and remained roughly constant after that. Additional tests were conducted by applying a load (weight of a person or vehicle) at the ground surface above the extensometer and allowing the signal to stabilize before removing the load. In the vadose zone, the soil compressed rapidly and then stabilized. In the saturated zone, sudden compression was followed by additional compression at a much slower rate. A similar response was observed upon removal of the load. This transient signal in the saturated zone is interpreted to be a poroelastic effect. When a load is applied, the solid skeleton compresses and pressurizes the pore fluid, causing flow. The strain rate is then a function of pressure diffusion. Simulation of the deformation from both pumping and loading tests using an unsaturated, poroelastic finite-element model indicates that strains are sensitive to the Young’s modulus and hydraulic conductivity as functions of saturation.

well tests, strain, surface loading, hydromechanic↗

Measuring and interpreting borehole strainmeter data to improve CO2 storage

Injecting fluids into a well deforms the enveloping rocks in a complex pattern that increases in magnitude and expands outward with time, and measurements of this strain field may be useful for monitoring the injection process. A pair of instruments capable of measuring four components of strain and two components of tilt has been developed. One instrument is designed to be removeable, whereas the other one is grouted in place. The removeable strainmeter provides versatility and lower cost because it can be relocated, whereas the grout-in instrument provides better coupling to the formation, which should improve the strain signal. The new strainmeters have been deployed along with a Gladwin strainmeter at the Avant Field, an oil field north of Tulsa, Oklahoma. Oil and water are being pumped out, and water is being injected in multiple boreholes that intersect the Bartlesville formation at a depth of approximately 500 m at the Avant Field. The strainmeters have been deployed at a depth of 30 m near well 9A, an injection well near the edge of the field. Results from a brief, 4-hr-long injection test into well 9A show that the radial and circumferential strain increase (become tensile) with time during injection, reaching a maximum of several 10s of nanostrain. In another example, data from the Gladwin strainmeter showed the strain field changing with time when an injection well 1 km away was shut-in. This caused the strain along a radial direction to become tensile, while the circumferential strain became compressive. This trend reversed a week later when injection into the well resumed. The major axis of the principle strain aligned with the shut-in well. The observed strain signals are similar to results from poroelastic analyses, and preliminary inverse analyses sugest that strain signals can be used to estimate reservoir characteristics at the Avant Field.

Murdoch, Larry↗

New Strainmeters used to Monitor Deformation During Injection and Withdrawal

Injecting or removing fluids from reservoirs or aquifers causes deformation that can be used as a diagnostic signal in some cases, while it can interfere with geodetic interpretations in other cases. This has motivated us to develop instrumentation and methods to characterize the strain field resulting from injection and pumping. Three new instruments have been deployed at our field stations near Clemson University and at the Avant Field north of Tulsa, OK. Two use non-contact eddy current transducers configured to measure four components of strain and two tilts to 1 part-per-billion. One system is designed for permanent installation, the other is removable for short term deployments. Another system is a low cost volumetric strainmeter consisting of an embedded optical fiber that is interrogated using laser interferometry. This strainmeter is designed to be a permanently installed and has a resolution of several parts-per-trillion. The field sites are designed to characterize strains during pumping or injection over different scales and in different geologic settings. The Clemson field station is underlain by biotite gneiss, a low permeability crystalline rock overlain by moderate permeability, soft saprolite above 30m depth. The water table is at approximately 9m depth. The strainmeters are in the crystalline rock at approximately 40m depth, and pumping occurs in the overlying saprolite. In contrast, wells at the Avant Field site are much deeper. They are approximately 500m deep and completed in a 25-m-thick oil-bearing sandstone. Strainmeters at the Avant Field are at ~30m depth. These two sites provide contrasting approaches to characterizing strain at 30-40m depth. Water is pumped from an overlying formation at the Clemson site, whereas it is pumped from a much deeper underlying formation at the Avant Field. Preliminary results are available from a brief injection test, and from a longer shut-in test at the Avant Field. Injection is characterized by an increase in tensile strains in both the radial and circumferential directions approximately 220m from the well. The shut-in was characterized by radial tension and circumferential compression in response to a well approximately 1km from the strainmeter. These are the expected signals caused by injection and shut-in according to poroelastic simulations.

DeWolf, Scott↗