Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Croft, Stephen

Publications and source records attributed to Croft, Stephen.

At least 91 records · Page 5

Impact of lump characteristics on self-shielding corrections of active neutron interrogation on fissile material in waste - 15405

Non-destructive active neutron assay techniques such as active neutron coincidence counting, differential die away analysis or the californium shuffler method rely on the interrogation of fissile nuclear materials by an external neutron source. Whether it is a spontaneous fission or (α,n) neutron source, like {sup 252}Cf or AmLi; or a fusion neutron generator, all of these techniques rely on induced secondary fission events to provide prompt or delayed neutron signals that serve as the basis for the fissile material quantification. The accuracy of these fissile mass measurements is therefore dependent on the neutron interrogation efficiencies determined for calibration reference standards and whether the measured items are comparable to the calibration condition. In such favorable conditions, it is possible to establish a reliable empirical non-linear relationship between apparent (uncorrected) and real or true fissile mass. However, in waste measurements, this is unlikely to be the case; thus a calibration approach that takes account of the neutron self-shielding effect is required. By incorporating the Self-Shielding Factor (SSF) of the calibration reference standards, a linear mass calibration factor [s{sup -1}. {sup 239}Pu{sub eq} g{sup -1}] can be found; this calibration is accurate for waste in which the fissile material is 'infinitely dilute' i.e. the waste exhibits no self-shielding; this is assumed to be representative of dispersed material. The self-shielding correction and its systematic uncertainty are then left to be treated as part of the Total Measurement Uncertainty (TMU) evaluation associated with the assay result. The derivation of the TMU contribution associated with the self-shielding effect in nuclear waste is a complex problem for which a reliable evaluation has to be performed. This is usually based on assuming 'worst case scenarios' for the distribution of material that can arise in a particular waste stream. Such an approach is conservative, but often very penalizing, especially if one considers larger lumps (those containing grams of fissile material); for such lumps, the self-shielding correction becomes very significant, potentially altering the mass of {sup 239}Pu{sub eq} by over an order of magnitude. A worst case 'nuclear safety value' may not be the most appropriate choice for building a consignment best estimate or repository sentencing value for an item. In the present work the authors describe a numerical approach to study the variability of neutron self-shielding factors associated with distributions of a wide range of lump characteristics in terms of size, shape, chemical composition, density and isotopic composition. The described novel calculation tool is capable of accurately predicting the real impact of random distribution of lumps in a waste material, and allowed to show that given reasonable, defensible, assumptions on the composition of the lumps in waste stream, the systematic error component of the DDA TMU can be significantly reduced. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Model-based approaches to calibration and certification of nondestructive assay systems - 15615

Increasingly, model-based methods founded in physics are employed to calibrate, or extend the calibration of, nondestructive assay (NDA) systems used to characterize materials contaminated with plutonium, uranium, and other radioactive isotopes. In addition, modeling and mathematical methods are used to establish system parameters, correction factors, and measurement uncertainty components in NDA measurements. The methods combine the characteristics of the measurement configuration (detector structure, object shape and dimensions, source-detector distance and orientation, and collimation), generator knowledge of the waste composition, and known physical properties of the system in order to establish these parameters, factors, and components. These methods offer several important benefits over traditional methods used to test, calibrate, operate, and certify radiation measurement systems. First, instruments can be set up and put into service more quickly and correctly using a model-based approach. Second, calibrations can be performed, tested, and modified with reduced use of plutonium and uranium standards when modeling and mathematical methods are employed. Also, modeled approaches avoid calibration error resulting from heterogeneous source distribution. Moreover, the parameters can be installed quickly and simply in an office setting without the need for the safety, security, and safeguards considerations that are present when standards are used. Calibrations can also be tailored to fit unique or nonstandard container configurations (for example, over-packed drums), new container types, or specialized matrices. Finally, when modeling methods are applied, correction factors and measurement uncertainty elements can be developed, tested, and validated relatively quickly and without the need for surrogate matrix materials and a large number of test measurements. A combined gamma and neutron NDA system has recently been moved from Idaho National Laboratory to the TA 55 facility at Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL). The system will be used to assay transuranic waste packaged in drums. After the move, the system was modified to replace degraded components and improve system performance. Afterwards, it was set up to assay different container types and to extend the calibration range. Model-based approaches were used to adapt the system to its new purpose at LANL. This report will describe the setup, calibration, and certification of the combined system at LANL Included in this discussion will be the measurement applications and details of the measurement methods. The steps in these processes that involved the use of modeling and mathematical calculations to replace or supplement more traditional methods will be identified and discussed. Finally, an overarching discussion of the methods and advantages of model-based methods to establish the properties of NDA systems will be presented. We conclude that validated mathematical methods offer a robust, flexible, and mature approach which is technically defensible from first principle physics. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Minimum detectable activity for tomographic gamma scanning system - 15648

For any radiation measurement system, it is useful to explore and establish the detection limits and a minimum detectable activity (MDA) for the radionuclides of interest, even if the system is to be used at far higher values. The MDA serves as an important figure of merit, and often a system is optimized and configured so that it can meet the MDA requirements of a measurement campaign. The non-destructive assay (NDA) systems based on gamma ray analysis are no exception and well established conventions, such the Currie method, exist for estimating the detection limits and the MDA. However, the Tomographic Gamma Scanning (TGS) technique poses some challenges for the estimation of detection limits and MDAs. The TGS combines high resolution gamma ray spectrometry (HRGS) with low spatial resolution image reconstruction techniques. In non-imaging gamma ray based NDA techniques measured counts in a full energy peak can be used to estimate the activity of a radionuclide, independently of other counting trials. However, in the case of the TGS each 'view' is a full spectral grab (each a counting trial), and each scan consists of 150 spectral grabs in the transmission and emission scans per vertical layer of the item. The set of views in a complete scan are then used to solve for the radionuclide activities on a voxel by voxel basis, over 16 layers of a 10x10 voxel grid. Thus, the raw count data are not independent trials any more, but rather constitute input to a matrix solution for the emission image values at the various locations inside the item volume used in the reconstruction. So, the validity of the methods used to estimate MDA for an imaging technique such as TGS warrant a close scrutiny, because the pair-counting concept of Currie is not directly applicable. One can also raise questions as to whether the TGS, along with other image reconstruction techniques which heavily intertwine data, is a suitable method if one expects to measure samples whose activities are at or just above MDA levels. The paper examines methods used to estimate MDAs for a TGS system, and explores possible solutions that can be rigorously defended. (authors)

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Comments on extracting the resonance strength parameter from yield data

The F(α,n) reaction is the focus of on-going research in part because it is an important source of neutrons in the nuclear fuel cycle which can be exploited to assay nuclear materials, especially uranium in the form of UF 6 . At the present time there remains some considerable uncertainty (of the order of ± 20%) in the thick target integrated over angle (α,n) yield from 19 F (100% natural abundance) and its compounds as discussed. An important thin target cross-section measurement is that of Wrean and Kavanagh who explore the region from below threshold (2.36 MeV) to approximately 3.1 MeV with fine energy resolution. Integration of their cross-section data over the slowing down history of a stopping α-particle allows the thick target yield to be calculated for incident energies up to 3.1 MeV. This trend can then be combined with data from other sources to obtain a thick target yield curve over the wider range of interest to the fuel cycle (roughly threshold to 10 MeV to include all relevant α-emitters). To estimate the thickness of the CaF 2 target they used, Wrean and Kavanagh separately measured the integrated yield of the 6.129 MeV γ-rays from the resonance at 340.5 keV (laboratory α-particle kinetic energy) in the 19 F(p,αγ) reaction. To interpret the data they adopted a resonance strength parameter of (22.3 ± 0.8) eV based on a determination by Becker et al. The value and its uncertainty directly affects the thickness estimate and the extracted (α,n) cross-section values. In their citation to Becker et al's work, Wrean and Kavanagh comment that they did not make use of an alternative value of (23.7±1.0) eV reported by Croft because they were unable to reproduce the value from the data given in that paper. The value they calculated for the resonance strength from the thick target yield given by Croft was 21.4 eV. The purpose of this communication is to revisit the paper by Croft published in this journal and specifically to explain the origin of the reported resonance strength. Fortunately the original notes spanning the period 12 January 1988 to 16 January 1990 were available to consult. Finally, in hindsight there is certainly a case of excessive brevity to rectify. In essence the step requiring explanation is how to compute the resonance strength, ω γ , from the reported thick target resonance yield Y.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

The Impact of Gate Width Setting and Gate Utilization Factors on Plutonium Assay in Passive Correlated Neutron Counting

In the field of nuclear safeguards, passive neutron multiplicity counting (PNMC) is a method typically employed in non-destructive assay (NDA) of special nuclear material (SNM) for nonproliferation, verification and accountability purposes. PNMC is generally performed using a well-type thermal neutron counter and relies on the detection of correlated pairs or higher order multiplets of neutrons emitted by an assayed item. To assay SNM, a set of parameters for a given well-counter is required to link the measured multiplicity rates to the assayed item properties. Detection efficiency, die-away time, gate utilization factors (tightly connected to die-away time) as well as optimum gate width setting are among the key parameters. These parameters along with the underlying model assumptions directly affect the accuracy of the SNM assay. In this paper we examine the role of gate utilization factors and the single exponential die-away time assumption and their impact on the measurements for a range of plutonium materials. In addition, we examine the importance of item-optimized coincidence gate width setting as opposed to using a universal gate width value. Finally, the traditional PNMC based on multiplicity shift register electronics is extended to Feynman-type analysis and application of this approach to Pu mass assay is demonstrated.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Point model equations for neutron correlation counting: Extension of Böhnel's equations to any order

Various methods of autocorrelation neutron analysis may be used to extract information about a measurement item containing spontaneously fissioning material. The two predominant approaches being the time correlation analysis (that make use of a coincidence gate) methods of multiplicity shift register logic and Feynman sampling. The common feature is that the correlated nature of the pulse train can be described by a vector of reduced factorial multiplet rates. We call these singlets, doublets, triplets etc. Within the point reactor model the multiplet rates may be related to the properties of the item, the parameters of the detector, and basic nuclear data constants by a series of coupled algebraic equations – the so called point model equations. Solving, or inverting, the point model equations using experimental calibration model parameters is how assays of unknown items is performed. Currently only the first three multiplets are routinely used. In this work we develop the point model equations to higher order multiplets using the probability generating functions approach combined with the general derivative chain rule, the so called Faà di Bruno Formula. Explicit expression up to 5th order are provided, as well the general iterative formula to calculate any order. This study represents the first necessary step towards determining if higher order multiplets can add value to nondestructive measurement practice for nuclear materials control and accountancy.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Cadmium Subtraction Method for the Active Albedo Neutron Interrogation of Uranium

This report describes work performed under the Next Generation Safeguards Initiative (NGSI) Cadmium Subtraction Project. The project objective was to explore the difference between the traditional cadmium (Cd) ratio signature and a proposed alternative Cd subtraction (or Cd difference) approach. The thinking behind the project was that a Cd subtraction method would provide a more direct measure of multiplication than the existing Cd ratio method. At the same time, it would be relatively insensitive to changes in neutron detection efficiency when properly calibrated. This is the first published experimental comparison and evaluation of the Cd ratio and Cd subtraction methods.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Nuclear Material Detection by One-Short-Pulse-Laser-Driven Neutron Source

Covered in the PowerPoint presentation are the following areas: Motivation and requirements for active interrogation of nuclear material; laser-driven neutron source; neutron diagnostics; active interrogation of nuclear material; and, conclusions, remarks, and future works.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Minimum Detectable Activity for Tomographic Gamma Scanning System

For any radiation measurement system, it is useful to explore and establish the detection limits and a minimum detectable activity (MDA) for the radionuclides of interest, even if the system is to be used at far higher values. The MDA serves as an important figure of merit, and often a system is optimized and configured so that it can meet the MDA requirements of a measurement campaign. The non-destructive assay (NDA) systems based on gamma ray analysis are no exception and well established conventions, such the Currie method, exist for estimating the detection limits and the MDA. However, the Tomographic Gamma Scanning (TGS) technique poses some challenges for the estimation of detection limits and MDAs. The TGS combines high resolution gamma ray spectrometry (HRGS) with low spatial resolution image reconstruction techniques. In non-imaging gamma ray based NDA techniques measured counts in a full energy peak can be used to estimate the activity of a radionuclide, independently of other counting trials. However, in the case of the TGS each “view” is a full spectral grab (each a counting trial), and each scan consists of 150 spectral grabs in the transmission and emission scans per vertical layer of the item. The set of views in a complete scan are then used to solve for the radionuclide activities on a voxel by voxel basis, over 16 layers of a 10x10 voxel grid. Thus, the raw count data are not independent trials any more, but rather constitute input to a matrix solution for the emission image values at the various locations inside the item volume used in the reconstruction. So, the validity of the methods used to estimate MDA for an imaging technique such as TGS warrant a close scrutiny, because the pair-counting concept of Currie is not directly applicable. One can also raise questions as to whether the TGS, along with other image reconstruction techniques which heavily intertwine data, is a suitable method if one expects to measure samples whose activities are at or just above MDA levels. The paper examines methods used to estimate MDAs for a TGS system, and explores possible solutions that can be rigorously defended.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗