Design Optimization of Additively Manufactured HFIR Control Elements
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Chandler, David.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) operates the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) for the US Department of Energy Office of Science to perform neutron scattering experiments, produce isotopes, and conduct materials irradiation research. ORNL is funded by the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) Office of Materials Management and Minimization to evaluate the conversion of HFIR’s fuel from high-enriched uranium (HEU) to low-enriched (LEU). Due to potential fabrication issues with the complex UMo fuel design required to convert HFIR, NNSA requested ORNL to evaluate an alternate LEU fuel form – U3Si2-Al dispersion fuel. Neutronic and thermal-hydraulic feasibility analyses were performed with Shift and HSSHTC, respectively, to predict reactor performance and thermal safety margins. A number of designs were proposed and evaluated using an iterative approach in an effort to show that reactor performance could match that obtained using HEU fuel and that thermal safety margins were adequate. This study concludes that conversion of HFIR with U3Si2-Al LEU (19.75 wt.%) fuel with 4.8 gU/cm3 is feasible if, among other requirements, the fuel meat region is centered and symmetric about the fuel plate thickness centerline, the active fuel zone length is increased 5.08 cm to 55.88 cm, the proposed fabrication tolerances can be met, and the fuel can be qualified for HFIR conditions.
Additive manufacturing is under investigation as a novel method of fabricating the control elements (CEs) of the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory with greater simplicity, eliminating numerous highly complex fabrication steps and thereby offering potential for significant savings in cost, time, and effort. This process yields a unique CE design with lumped absorbers, a departure from traditionally manufactured CEs with uniformly distributed absorbing material. Here, this study undertakes a neutronics analysis of the impact of additively manufactured CEs on the HFIR core physics, seeking preliminary assessment of the feasibility of their practical use. The results of the MCNP transport simulations reveal changes in the HFIR reactor physics arising from geometric and nuclear effects. Absorber lumping in the discrete CEs yields a large volume of unpoisoned material that is not present in the homogeneous design, in turn yielding increases in free thermal flux in the CE absorbing regions and their immediate vicinity. The availability of additional free thermal neutrons in the core yields an increase in fission rate density in the fuel closest to the CEs and a corresponding increase in neutron multiplication on the order of 100 pcm. The absorption behavior exhibited by the discrete CEs is markedly different from the homogeneous CEs due to several competing effects. Self-shielding arising from absorber lumping acts to reduce the effective absorption cross section of the discrete CEs, but this effect is offset by geometric and spectral effects. The operational performance of the discrete CEs is found to be comparable to the homogeneous CEs, with only limited deficiencies in reactivity worth that are expected to be operationally recoverable via limited adjustment of the CE positions and withdrawal rate. On the whole, these results indicate that the discrete CEs perform reasonably similarly to the homogeneous CEs and appear feasible for application in HFIR. In conclusion, the physical phenomena identified in this study provide valuable background for follow-up design studies.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The High Flux Isotope Reactor at Oak Ridge National Laboratory is an 85 MW th pressurized light-water-cooled and -moderated flux-trap type research reactor. The reactor is used to conduct numerous experiments, advancing various scientific and engineering disciplines. As part of an ongoing program sponsored by the US Department of Energy National Nuclear Security Administration Office of Material Management and Minimization, studies are being performed to assess the feasibility of converting the reactor’s highly enriched uranium fuel to low-enriched uranium fuel. To support this conversion project, reference models with representative experiment target loading and explicit fuel plate representation were developed and benchmarked for both fuels to (1) allow for consistent comparison between designs for both fuel types and (2) assess the potential impact of low-enriched uranium conversion. These high-fidelity models were used to conduct heat deposition analyses at the beginning and end of the reactor cycle and are presented herein. This article (1) discusses the High Flux Isotope Reactor models developed to facilitate detailed heat deposition analyses of the reactor’s highly enriched and low-enriched uranium cores, (2) examines the computational approach for performing heat deposition analysis, which includes a discussion on the methodology for calculating the amount of energy released per fission, heating rates, power and volumetric heating rates, and (3) provides results calculated throughout various regions of the highly enriched and low-enriched uranium core at the beginning and end of the reactor cycle. These are the first detailed high-fidelity heat deposition analyses for the High Flux Isotope Reactor’s highly enriched and low-enriched core models with explicit fuel plate representation. Lastly, these analyses are used to compare heat distributions obtained for both fuel designs at the beginning and end of the reactor cycle, and they are essential for enabling comprehensive thermal hydraulics and safety analyses that require detailed estimates of the heat source within all of the reactor’s fuel element regions.
A high-fidelity model of the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) with a low-enriched uranium (LEU) fuel design and a representative experiment loading has been developed to serve as a new reference model for LEU conversion studies. With the exception of the fuel elements, this HFIR LEU model is completely consistent with the current highly enriched uranium HFIR model. Results obtained with the new LEU model provide a baseline for analysis of alternate LEU fuel designs and further optimization studies. The newly developed HFIR LEU model has an explicit representation of the HFIR-specific involute fuel plate geometry, including the within-plate fuel meat contouring, and a detailed geometry model of the fuel element side plates. Such high-fidelity models are necessary to accurately account for the self-shielding from 238 U and the depletion of absorber materials present in the side plates. In addition, a method was developed to account for fuel swelling in the high-density LEU fuel plates during the depletion simulation. In conclusion, calculated time-dependent metrics for the HFIR LEU model include fission rate and cumulative fission density distributions, flux and reaction rates for relevant experiment locations, point kinetics data, and reactivity coefficients.
This report compares key metrics for two fuel design models of the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). The first model represents the highly enriched uranium (HEU) fuel currently in use at HFIR, and the second model considers a low-enriched uranium (LEU) interim design fuel. Except for the fuel region, the two models are consistent, and both include an experiment loading that is representative of HFIR's current operation. The considered key metrics are the neutron flux at the cold source moderator vessel, the mass of 252 Cf produced in the flux trap target region as function of cycle time, the fast neutron flux at locations of interest for material irradiation experiments, and the reactor cycle length. These key metrics are a small subset of the overall HFIR performance and safety metrics. They were defined as a means of capturing data essential for HFIR's primary missions, for use in optimization studies assessing the impact of HFIR's conversion from HEU fuel to different types of LEU fuel designs.
Not Available
The purpose of this report is to document a high-fidelity VESTA/MCNP High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) core model that features a new, representative experiment loading. This model, which represents the current, high-enriched uranium fuel core, will serve as a reference for low-enriched uranium conversion studies, safety-basis calculations, and other research activities. A new experiment loading model was developed to better represent current, typical experiment loadings, in comparison to the experiment loading included in the model for Cycle 400 (operated in 2004). The new experiment loading model for the flux trap target region includes full length 252 Cf production targets, 75 Se production capsules, 63 Ni production capsules, a 188 W production capsule, and various materials irradiation targets. Fully loaded 238 Pu production targets are modeled in eleven vertical experiment facilities located in the beryllium reflector. Other changes compared to the Cycle 400 model are the high-fidelity modeling of the fuel element side plates and the material composition of the control elements. Results obtained from the depletion simulations with the new model are presented, with a focus on time-dependent isotopic composition of irradiated fuel and single cycle isotope production metrics.
At present, most 99 Mo is produced in research, test, or isotope production reactors by irradiation of highly enriched uranium targets. To achieve the denser form of uranium needed for switching from high to low enriched uranium (LEU), targets in the form of a metal foil (~125-150 µm thick) are being developed. The LEU High Density Target Project successfully demonstrated several iterations of an LEU-fission-based Mo-99 technology that has the potential to provide the world’s supply of Mo-99, should major producers choose to utilize the technology. Over 50 annular high density targets have been successfully tested, and the assembly and disassembly of targets have been improved and optimized. Two target front-end processes (acidic and electrochemical) have been scaled up and demonstrated to allow for the high-density target technology to mate up to the existing producer technology for target processing. In the event that a new target processing line is started, the chemical processing of the targets is greatly simplified. Extensive modeling and safety analysis has been conducted, and the target has been qualified to be inserted into the High Flux Isotope Reactor, which is considered above and beyond the requirements for the typical use of this target due to high fluence and irradiation duration.
Additive manufacturing techniques have made major strides in recent years and are now capable of creating complex components in near-final form. The nuclear industry has many applications with complicated and even unique components that are time consuming, expensive, and more difficult to make using traditional fabrication routes. Modern fabrication techniques possess the potential to reduce fabrication lead-time and costs while increasing quality and efficiency. However, these methods have not been adopted due to the need for strict validation for nuclear applications. Unlike structural components that largely consist of a uniform material, for nuclear reactor core components incorporation of fissile or neutron poison materials inside a cladding becomes necessary. This in turn requires a more complex and flexible manufacturing method to produce these hybrid components. In this study, demonstration of ultrasonic additive manufacturing (UAM) process to produce components resembling research reactor control elements was carried out]. Specifically, the control elements for ORNL's High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) were targeted. These control elements (consisting of an inner cylinder and four outer plates) are placed on the periphery of the circular HFIR core. The control elements consist of Al6061-T6 alloy with a 13-cm-long grey and a 56-cm-long black region, corresponding to 40 wt% of Ta and 30 wt% Eu{sub 2}O{sub 3} (europia) are incorporated along their length. In this study various fabrication parameters for production of aluminum blocks with and without embedded Eu{sub 2}O{sub 3} and Ta bearing compacts were explored. Select optimized specimens we then irradiated inside HFIR for one reactor cycle. The UAM process exploits ultrasonic energy to facilitate solid-state welding of metal foils in contact under pressure. This additive process is carried out in successive layers to build up the material and when coupled with CNC milling, it yields complex 3D components. The milling and subsequent additive steps may be used to embed foreign material into the material undergoing buildup. In this manner fissile or neutron poison elements may be incorporated into the complex structure, though in an inhomogeneous fashion. Multiple Al-6061 blocks were produced by UAM using 25 mm wide by 0.15 mm thick Al-6061-H18 tapes. The mechanical properties of these blocks in the as-fabricated condition was characterized in detail and it was shown that a great degree of anisotropy in the mechanical behavior exists between the direction in the tape plane and the direction perpendicular to the tapes (buildup direction) The latter exhibited reduced modulus and significantly smaller strength. Post production heat treatment appeared to greatly enhance the strength in the buildup direction. Multiple tensile specimens machined per SS-J3 geometry were prepared for irradiation testing. The tensile specimen matrix was set up to enable post irradiation examination of mechanical properties in various directions as well as after heat treatment. A small block with embedded Ta- and Eu{sub 2}O{sub 3}-bearing compacts, three of each kind, was also produced, as demonstrated previously. These compacts were 5.7 mm in diameter and 1.6 mm in height and contained 60 vol Ta or Eu{sub 2}O{sub 3}. The poison-bearing Al-6061 block alongside the tensile bars was loaded into a perforated rabbit (irradiation capsule) for irradiation in HFTK. The perforated rabbit allows penetration of HFIR water coolant into the Interior of the capsule in direct contact with the test specimens. The rabbit was loaded into the flux trap region at the uppermost position in the core. Irradiation temperature was 68 deg. C and fast neutron (E>0.1 MeV) fluence was 10{sup 25} neutrons/m{sup 2}. Currently PIE activities are ongoing that are focused on mechanical testing of irradiated tensile bars and metallographic examination of neutron poison bearing block.
A concerted effort over the past few years has focused on enhancing the core depletion models for the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) as part of a comprehensive study for designing a HFIR core that would use low-enriched uranium (LEU) fuel. A HFIR core depletion model that is based on current state-of-the-art methods and nuclear data was needed for use as a reference for the design of an LEU fuel for HFIR and to improve the basis for analyses that support HFIR’s current operation with high-enriched uranium (HEU) fuel. This paper summarizes the recent improvements in modeling and simulation for HFIR core analyses, with a focus on core depletion models.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
We present a mechanism for a generic, powerful force of assembly and mobility for transmembrane proteins in lipid bilayers. This force is a pre-transition (or pre-melting) effect for the first-order transition between ordered and disordered phases in the membrane. Using large-scale molecular simulation, we show that a protein with hydrophobic thickness equal to that of the disordered phase embedded in an ordered bilayer stabilizes a microscopic order–disorder interface. The stiffness of that interface is finite. When two such proteins approach each other, they assemble because assembly reduces the net interfacial energy. Analogous to the hydrophobic effect, we refer to this phenomenon as the 'orderphobic effect'. The effect is mediated by proximity to the order–disorder phase transition and the size and hydrophobic mismatch of the protein. The strength and range of forces arising from this effect are significantly larger than those that could arise from membrane elasticity for the membranes considered.
We present a mechanism for a generic, powerful force of assembly and mobility for transmembrane proteins in lipid bilayers. This force is a pre-transition (or pre-melting) effect for the first-order transition between ordered and disordered phases in the membrane. Using large-scale molecular simulation, we show that a protein with hydrophobic thickness equal to that of the disordered phase embedded in an ordered bilayer stabilizes a microscopic order-disorder interface. The stiffness of that interface is finite. When two such proteins approach each other, they assemble because assembly reduces the net interfacial energy. Analogous to the hydrophobic effect, we refer to this phenomenon as the ‘orderphobic effect’. The effect is mediated by proximity to the order-disorder phase transition and the size and hydrophobic mismatch of the protein. Furthermore, the strength and range of forces arising from this effect are significantly larger than those that could arise from membrane elasticity for the membranes considered.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.