Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Caughman, John B. O.

Publications and source records attributed to Caughman, John B. O..

Research and Development to Reduce Impurity Production and Transport of the Impurities to the Target in Linear Plasma Devices Using Helicon Plasma Sources

Linear plasma devices used to test plasma facing materials (PFMs) and components for fusion reactors are often suffering under the production of intrinsic impurities from the plasma source system. Most linear plasma devices use internal electrodes (hollow cathodes, reflex arc, or cascading arc), which typically are the source of the main impurities. The next-generation plasma generators use radio frequency (RF) plasma sources like helicons to avoid internal electrodes. However, high power operation of helicons has proven to result in impurity production due to the high rectified sheath voltages created. Depending on the plasma parameters and magnetic configuration, these impurities can be transported to the target and deposited there to unacceptable high levels. Here, in this contribution, the experimental results from Proto-MPEX are summarized, and the conclusions of the impurity source physics are given. Methods to reduce the impurity production, the impurity transport, and the net deposition on the target are presented. These methods to reduce the impurity production include Faraday screens to reduce the sheath voltage drop, high-Z refractory coatings to reduce the erosion yield, and wall conditioning methods. Methods to reduce the impurity transport include changes in the magnetic configuration as well as electron heating to change axial and radial temperature profiles. Preliminary results on the effectiveness of some of these methods are presented.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Final Design of the Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment

The Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (MPEX) has completed its design phase. MPEX will be a unique facility to investigate plasma material interactions (PMIs) under fusion prototypic divertor conditions in steady state. This includes plasma exposure conditions expected in a fusion reactor divertor. Materials to be investigated will include solids, liquids, and neutron pre-irradiated materials. Electron and ion heating will allow for a large operational domain ranging from erosion-dominated PMI conditions to deposition-dominated PMI conditions. An overview of the final design for all MPEX systems is given. Here, in particular, it is shown how mission-driven project requirements have led to detailed design choices with innovative solutions. Examples are the water-cooled helicon window, the electron cyclotron heating launcher, the target holder and manipulator, and the autonomous decouplers.

Fusion reactor↗

Heat Flux Analysis From IR Imaging on Proto-MPEX

The Prototype Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (Proto-MPEX) is a linear device used to develop the source and heating concept for MPEX, an experiment to study plasma–material interactions for future fusion reactors. This paper highlights recent analysis and results on Proto-MPEX using an infrared (IR) camera, a key tool for imaging heat fluxes measured at the material target. The target heat fluxes are crucial to understanding the source and heating concepts. The recent analysis includes the application of homography and 3-D finite-element methods to provide between-shot measurements of the 2-D target heat flux profile. The IR camera inferred heat flux is shown to correlate with Langmuir probe inferred heat fluxes for a range of parameters in helicon only and helicon + electron cyclotron heated discharges. Results show both desirable central and undesirable edge heat flux for helicon source and electron heating on the target. These heat flux measurements are shown to be important for better understanding of the source and heating physics.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Effect of magnetic field ripple on parallel electron transport during microwave plasma heating in the Proto-MPEX linear plasma device

The Prototype Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (Proto-MPEX) is a linear plasma device located at Oak Ridge National Laboratory to develop the plasma source concept for the Materials Plasma Exposure eXperiment (MPEX). Recent experiments have demonstrated the heating of electrons in a high-density deuterium plasma (n e ~ 5 × 10 19 m -3 ) via electron Bernstein waves and source plasma production via helicon waves in this linear configuration. Moreover, experimental observations suggest that the magnetic ripple adversely affects the parallel transport of the heated electrons toward the target where material samples are to be exposed to the plasma. In order to understand the transport process during microwave application, a test-particle Monte-Carlo (MC) code has been developed that incorporates the effects of Coulomb collisions, magnetic mirror adiabatic trapping and electron cyclotron interaction via a quasilinear RF heating operator. MC calculations indicate that the absence of 2nd turning points along the trajectory of cyclotron heated electrons significantly reduces adiabatic trapping and maximizes power transport to the Target surface. Thermalization of cyclotron heating electrons is analyzed with the MC code and it is found that for conditions relevant to ProtoMPEX, a significant fraction of the absorbed heating power is coupled to the Target surface via ballistic fast electrons; however, under certain conditions, up to 60% of the absorbed RF power can be dissipated via thermalization of the fast electrons on the background plasma. Results are compared with experimental measurements. Finally, the implications of the results are discussed in the context of the upcoming MPEX device.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Latest Results from Proto-MPEX and the Future Plans for MPEX

The Prototype Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (Proto-MPEX) is being used to qualify the plasma source and heating systems for the Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (MPEX). The MPEX will address important and urgent research needs on plasma material interactions for future fusion reactors. In MPEX, plasma-facing components (nonirradiated and a priori neutron irradiated) will be exposed to plasma conditions as they are expected in future fusion reactors. The MPEX, a steady-state device enabled by superconducting magnets, will be able to break into new ground by assessing plasma-facing materials and components at an ion fluence level in the range of 10 30 to 10 31 m -2 . To achieve the relevant plasma conditions, high-density plasmas (>4 × 10 19 m -3 ) are produced with a high-power helicon source. The so-produced low-temperature helicon plasma is then additionally heated with waves in the ion cyclotron resonance frequency and electron cyclotron resonance frequency domains. Proto-MPEX has achieved all key parameters (source n e , source T e , source T i , target T e , target T i , target ion flux, and target heat flux) within a factor of 2 of the design requirements of MPEX, albeit not simultaneously. These parameters were achieved with a total installed heating power of 330 kW, which is less than half of the planned heating power in the MPEX (800 kW). An overview of the latest results from Proto-MPEX is given. These results are shown in relationship to the MPEX system goals. Remaining necessary research and development tasks are discussed. The MPEX is currently in the conceptual design phase. Lastly, the status of the design and an overview of the system requirements are presented.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Computational investigation of ion cyclotron heating on Proto-MPEX

Ion cyclotron heating (ICH) on the Prototype Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (Proto-MPEX) is to be accomplished using the “beach-heating” technique. Beach heating has not been previously demonstrated to efficiently heat core ions at the high electron density values present in Proto-MPEX. This work numerically investigates the wave propagation characteristics of the ICH region on Proto-MPEX to explore avenues for efficient core ion heating. The analysis reveals that finite electron temperature effects are required to predict core ion heating. Cold plasma dispersion analysis and full-wave simulations show that the inertial Alfvén wave (IAW) is restricted from coupling power into the core plasma because (1) the group velocity is too shallow for its energy to penetrate into the core before damping in the periphery and (2) when operating in a magnetic field where ω/ω ci ≳ 0.7, the IAW is cut off from the core plasma by the Alfvén resonance. However, including kinetic effects shows that the kinetic Alfvén wave (KAW) can propagate in the electron temperature regime in Proto-MPEX. Full-wave simulations show that when the electron temperature is increased to T e > 2 eV and the edge electron density is sufficiently high n e edge > 1 × 10 17 m -3 , ion power absorption in the core increases substantially (≈25% of total power). Here, the increase in ion power absorption in the core is attributed to the propagation of the KAW. Calculations of electron and ion power absorption show that the electron heating is localized around the Alfvén resonance, while the ion heating is localized at the fundamental ion cyclotron resonance.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Evidence of electron heating at different radial locations on Proto-MPEX

This paper reports on the observation of controlled underdense electron heating for high heat flux applications in the Prototype Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment. The goal of this experiment is to demonstrate the source and heating concepts to create a high intensity plasma at material targets to study plasma-material interactions in similar plasma conditions to magnetic fusion divertors. A 80 kW helicon source at 13.56 MHz is used for the plasma density production and a 15 kW microwave source at 28 GHz is used for electron heating. Moreover, for electron densities ~5 × 10 18 m -3 , the electron temperature at the target location increases from 2 eV to 5 eV and the core heat flux increases by a factor of 5. It is shown that the radial profile of the heat flux delivered at the target can be controlled by either the background plasma density or the magnetic field. In conclustion, analysis suggests that the electron heating is due to heating near the upper-hybrid resonance layer and that this heating scenario may scale up to divertor-relevant electron densities ~5 × 10 19 m -3 by increasing the microwave driving frequency to 105 GHz.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Characterization of the helicon plasma flux to the target of Proto-MPEX

The ITER divertor will have to handle the boundary plasma power exhaust in the form of high heat and particle flux. The Prototype Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (Proto-MPEX) is a plasma source development device for the proposed Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (MPEX), which is intended to create fusion reactor divertor-like plasma conditions for studying plasma material interactions. Here, ion fluxes to various targets within Proto-MPEX are found to be 5 ± 2.5 × 10 23 m –2 s -1 when using only a helicon plasma source. The fluxes along the flux tube are compared for both 30 cm in front of the target and a few cm in front of the target. The emission intensity fall-off distance in front of the target is studied via Balmer series from a visible camera looking at the target. As a result, this fall-off distance of ~2–4 cm and the dissociation and ionization mean free path of D 2 being over 0.5 m leads to a conclusion that Proto-MPEX is not in a high recycling regime with helicon only plasmas.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Differential pumping requirements for the light-ion helicon source and heating systems of Proto-MPEX

The physics of electron and ion heating of high-density deuterium helicon plasmas (>3 × 10 19 m –3 ) in the Proto-Material Plasma Exposure Experiment linear device are under investigation. Theoretical estimates indicate that for efficient heating, discharges with very low neutral gas content ( &laquo; 0.1 Pa) in the heating sections are required to minimize collisional losses and charge exchange interactions with neutrals. However, this requirement is typically not compatible with the neutral gas pressures (1–2 Pa) commonly used in high-density, light-ion helicon sources. To satisfy these competing requirements, differential pumping techniques are needed. Here, results are presented that demonstrate the production of high-density discharges (2–6 × 10 19 m –3 ) with very low neutral gas content (<0.01 Pa) and high degree of ionization (>75%) in the heating sections. Results indicate that the best fueling location is upstream of the plasma source. We elaborate on the key aspects that must be considered to produce these discharges: (1) fueling location, radio-frequency pulse length, and magnetic field configuration, (2) flow rate and timing of the gas injection, and (3) use of conductance-limiting elements.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Summary of RF Technology Program Activities, October 2013 - September 2017

The goals of the National RF Research and Development Program (NRRDP) are to advance the basic understanding of high-power radio frequency (RF) in a plasma environment, and to maintain the high-power transmitters and cooling water systems required to support the ITER Ion Cylcotron Range of Frequencies (ICRF) transmission line high power component testing and operation of the Proto-Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (MPEX) device. The work includes the study of the RF sheath, and development of RF-related diagnostics. These include active and passive spectroscopic diagnostics that can provide local and line integrated measurements of RF and Direct Current (DC) electric fields in the edge plasma of fusion devices, as well as measurements of other parameters. One of these, the Doppler Free Saturation Spectroscopy (DFSS) diagnostic, utilizes a laser beam split into two intersecting, counter-propagating pump and probe beams, whose intersection defines the measurement region. DFSS has demonstrated measurements of atomic spectra with 500 times greater resolution than passive Optical Emission Spectroscopy (OES). This allows Stark effect based electric field measurements to be made with two orders of magnitude high sensitivity than with OES. Measurements have been made using an ORNL electron-cyclotron resonant (ECR) plasma source producing densities up to 10 19 m -3 , in the vicinity of an RF-biased planar electrode.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

Plasma flow measurements in the Prototype-Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (Proto-MPEX) and comparison with B2.5-Eirene modeling

The Prototype Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (Proto-MPEX) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory is a linear plasma device that combines a helicon plasma source with additional microwave and radio frequency heating to deliver high plasma heat and particle fluxes to a target. Double Langmuir probes and Thomson scattering are being used to measure local electron temperature and density at various radial and axial locations. A recently constructed Mach-double probe provides the added capability of simultaneously measuring electron temperatures (T e ), electron densities (n e ), and Mach numbers (M). With this diagnostic, it is possible to infer the plasma flow, particle flux, and heat flux at different locations along the plasma column in Proto-MPEX. Preliminary results show Mach numbers of 0.5 (towards the dump plate) and 1.0 (towards the target plate) downstream from the helicon source, and a stagnation point (no flow) near the source for the case where the peak magnetic field was 1.3 T. Measurements of particle flow and n e and T e profiles are discussed. Finally, the extensive coverage provided by these diagnostics permits data-constrained B2.5-Eirene modeling of the entire plasma column, and comparison with results of modeling in the high-density helicon plasmas will be presented.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Helicon normal modes in Proto-MPEX

Here, the Proto-MPEX helicon source has been operating in a high electron density 'helicon-mode'. Establishing plasma densities and magnetic field strengths under the antenna that allow for the formation of normal modes of the fast-wave are believed to be responsible for the 'helicon-mode'. A 2D finite-element full-wave model of the helicon antenna on Proto-MPEX is used to identify the fast-wave normal modes responsible for the steady-state electron density profile produced by the source. We also show through the simulation that in the regions of operation in which core power deposition is maximum the slow-wave does not deposit significant power besides directly under the antenna. In the case of a simulation where a normal mode is not excited significant edge power is deposited in the mirror region.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Direct measurement of the transition from edge to core power coupling in a light-ion helicon source

Here, we present time-resolved measurements of an edge-to-core power transition in a light-ion (deuterium) helicon discharge in the form of infra-red camera imaging of a thin stainless steel target plate on the Proto-Material Exposure eXperiment device. The time-resolved images measure the two-dimensional distribution of power deposition in the helicon discharge. The discharge displays a mode transition characterized by a significant increase in the on-axis electron density and core power coupling, suppression of edge power coupling, and the formation of a fast-wave radial eigenmode. Although the self-consistent mechanism that drives this transition is not yet understood, the edge-to-core power transition displays characteristics that are consistent with the discharge entering a slow-wave anti-resonant regime. RF magnetic field measurements made across the plasma column, together with the power deposition results, provide direct evidence to support the suppression of the slow-wave in favor of core plasma production by the fast-wave in a light-ion helicon source.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Plasma source development for fusion-relevant material testing

Plasma facing materials in the divertor of a magnetic fusion reactor will have to tolerate steady-state plasma heat fluxes in the range of 10 MW/m2 for ~107 sec, in addition to fusion neutron fluences, which can damage the plasma facing materials to high displacements per atom (dpa) of ~50 dpa . Material solutions needed for the plasma facing components are yet to be developed and tested. The Materials Plasma Exposure eXperiment (MPEX) is a newly proposed steady state linear plasma device that is designed to deliver the necessary plasma heat flux to a target for this material testing, including the capability to expose a-priori neutron damaged material samples to those plasmas. The requirements of the plasma source needed to deliver this plasma heat flux are being developed on the Proto-MPEX device, which is a linear high-intensity radio frequency (RF) plasma source that combines a high-density helicon plasma generator with electron and ion heating sections. It is being used to study the physics of heating over-dense plasmas in a linear configuration. The helicon plasma is operated at 13.56 MHz with RF power levels up to 120 kW. Microwaves at 28 GHz (~30 kW) are coupled to the electrons in the over-dense helicon plasma via Electron Bernstein Waves (EBW), and ion cyclotron heating at 7-9 MHz (~30 kW) is via a magnetic beach approach. High plasma densities >6x1019/m3 have been produced in deuterium, with electron temperatures that can range from 2 to >10 eV. Operation with on-axis magnetic field strengths between 0.6 and 1.4 T is typical. The plasma heat flux delivered to a target can be > 10 MW/m2, depending on the operating conditions.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗