Engineering topics

Brandon, A. D.

Publications and source records attributed to Brandon, A. D..

At least 19 records

NASA NTRS2019

Distribution of Fe3+ and H in Minerals During Partial Melting and Metasomatism of Spinel Peridotite

Oxygen fugacity and water content are crucial parameters for many chemical and physical properties of the Earth's mantle, for example bearing on fluid type, melting initiation, and deformation. However, the exact behaviour of Fe3+ and H during melting and metasomatism is still under debate. Here, the Fe3+/ΣFe ratio (Mössbauer and EMP) and water content (FTIR) of peridotite minerals are examined in mantle xenoliths from Kilbourne Hole (KH), NM, and Dish Hill (DH), CA (USA). These spinel peridotites have compositions consistent with partial melting with variable degrees of metasomatism (undetectable to cryptic to modal). Pyroxenites also allow to examine melt-rock reactions. Bulk-rock Fe2O3 content of the KH peridotites correlates with indices of melting (positive with bulk-rock Al2O3 and Cpx Yb contents, and negative with spinel Cr#) confirming that Fe3+ behaves as an incompatible element during melting. Correlations of the Fe3+/ΣFe ratio of minerals with these indices, however, indicates that Fe3+ is incompatible in Cpx but compatible in Opx and spinel during melting. Water contents in olivine, Cpx and Opx from most KH peridotites can be explained by partial melting and correlate negatively with the Fe3+/ΣFe ratio of spinel and Opx but positively with that of Cpx. This indicates partial control of Fe3+ on the incorporation of H in pyroxene, but not related to a redox equilibrium in Cpx. The higher Fe3+/ΣFe ratio of spinel in the metasomatized KH and DH peridotites, and in the pyroxenites confirms that oxidation characterizes modal metasomatism. Metasomatism, however, is not necessarily accompanied by water addition.

Peslier, A. H.↗

NASA NTRS2019

Martian Magma Evolution from Olivine-Hosted Melt Inclusions in Shergottites Using MELTS Models

Shergottites, the largest martian meteorite group, come from at least two geochemically different source reservoirs i.e. incompatible trace element (ITE)-depleted and enriched. The depleted shergottites are thought to be derived from an ITE-depleted mantle reservoir, while enriched shergottites are thought to be derived from an ITE-enriched mantle reservoir that represents late stage residual melt from a magma ocean or interaction with martian crust. Moreover, the martian crust is distinct from shergottites, by being highly oxidized, distinctly ITE-enriched, and older. The link between the crust and shergottite compositions is poorly understood. Here we model shergottite differentiation to resolve the origin of enriched shergottites and why the bulk martian crust is compositionally distinct from shergottites. Early formed olivine-hosted melt inclusions can provide primary melt composition from which the parental magma had crystallized and also information at different stages of crystallization during parent magma differentiation that leads to shergottite magma evolution as well as crustal contribution assessment. We analyzed olivine-hosted melt inclusions of two enriched poikilitic shergottites for their major, minor and trace element concentrations using electron microprobe and laser ablation ICP-MS. We corrected the melt inclusion compositions for post-entrapment re-equilibration with their host olivine. To comprehend the crystallization sequence of these rocks and whether the melt entrapment is consistent with the crystallization, we use MELTS models for equilibrium and fractional crystallization. The results of these models suggest that all the melts were trapped in a closed system progressive crystallization at 1150-1210 ⁰C within 1 kbar to 1 bar pressure that is equivalent to <8.5 km, implying melt entrapment without any additional exogenous materials.

Ferdous, J.↗

NASA NTRS2019

Trace Element Abundances of Olivine-Hosted Melt Inclusions in Shergottites Northwest Africa 7397 and Robert Massif 04262

Olivine-hosted melt inclusions (MIs) may retain trapped parent magma compositions as well as record progressive differentiation while magmas crystallize and ascend towards the surface [1,2 and references therein]. Major element compositions of the MIs, especially Fe and Mg, can be affected by post-entrapment re-equilibration with their host olivine [1,2]. Therefore, Fe/Mg ratio correction is required to obtain MI bulk compositions following equilibrium with their host olivine. Partition coefficients of most of the trace elements in olivine are very low (i.e. DOL/melt<0.001). Thus, ratios of trace elements of olivine-hosted MIs are unlikely to be affected by post-entrapment re-equilibration and no correction is necessary [2]. Hence, tracking trace element behavior in MIs may constrain the composition of the parent magma and its evolution yielding insights on magma differentiation of shergottites. However, analyzing MIs for chemical compositions is a challenging task due to their low abundances and small sizes. Using a highly sensitive and precise micro-beam technique is essential to examine olivine-hosted MIs in order to measure trace element abundances. For this purpose, laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) is an excellent tool due to its wide range of laser spot sizes (1-150 μm), ability to obtain raster analysis (several mm2) and lower detection limits (0.1 ppb) [3].

Ferdous, J.↗

NASA NTRS2018

D/H Isotope Fractionation During H Diffusion Loss from Clinopyroxene Evidenced in Martian Nakhlites

Knowing the distribution and origin of water in terrestrial planets is crucial to understand their formation, evolution and the source of their atmospheres and surface water. Mantle D/H ratios may be used to determine what type of material contributed water to the terrestrial planets [1]. However, other processes, magmatic or surface alteration processes, can also modify D/H ratios, and for Mars, we only have samples from the crust, as meteorites. The D/H ratio of igneous phases of Martian meteorites is generally explained in terms of the mixing contributions of two reservoirs: surficial with high D/H (dD > 700 ‰) related to interaction with the martian atmosphere (dD ~ 5000‰), and mantle-derived with lower D/H (dD < 500 ‰ but the exact value is still debated)[2]. However, our present study evidences that H loss in clinopyroxene during degassing can significantly fractionate H isotopes and increase their D/H ratios. In situ analyses of H isotopes, and of water, major and trace element contents were performed on the pyroxenes of 5 nakhlites. Nakhlites are clinopyroxenites that likely originated from the same lava flow or shallow magma chamber. Water contents decrease (380 to <5 ppm H2O) with increasing dD (-268 to 4860 ‰). Significant influence from spallation, exchange with the martian atmosphere, shock, surface alteration, and hydrothermal processes is ruled out. Together with the evidence of less water at the edge of individual pyroxene grains compared to their interior, we interpret this correlation as the result of preferential diffusive loss of H relative to D from the already crystallized pyroxenes during ascent of the partially-crystallized magma. Similar H isotope fractionations have been observed in another nominally anhydrous mineral, garnet, during experimental dehydration [3]. These results emphasize that caution is warranted when interpreting H isotope analyses of igneous, nominally anhydrous minerals in terms of planetary processes.

Peslier, A. H.↗

NASA NTRS2017

Evaluating Crustal Contamination Effects on the Lithophile Trace Element Budget of Shergottites

The origin of the incompatible trace element (ITE) enriched compositions of shergottites has been a point of contention for decades [1-2]. Two scenarios have been proposed, the first is that enriched shergottite compositions reflect an ITE-enriched mantle source, whereas in the second, the ITE enrichment reflects crustal contamination of mantle-derived parent magmas. Evidence supporting the first scenario is that the ITE-enriched shergottite compositions are consistent with the outcomes of magma ocean crystallization [3], and that Os-Nd isotope relationships for shergottites cannot be explained by realistic crustal contamination models [4]. In contrast, Cl and S isotopes are consistent with shergottite magmas interacting with Mars crust [5,6], and ITE-enriched olivine-hosted melt inclusions and interstitial glass are found in depleted shergottite Yamato 980459 [7]. These findings indicate that some level of crustal interaction occurred but the question of whether ITE-enrichments in some bulk shergottites reflect crustal contamination remains open. Recently, a Mars crustal breccia meteorite has been found, NWA 7034 and its paired stones, that is our best analogue to an average of Mars ancient crust [8-10]. This allows for better constraints on crustal contamination of shergottite magmas. We modeled magma-crust mixing and assimilation-fractional crystallization (AFC) using ITE-depleted shergottite compositions and bulk NWA 7034 and its clasts as end-members. The results of these models indicate that crustal contamination can only explain the ITE-enriched compositions of some bulk shergottites under unusual circumstances. It is thus likely that the shergottite range of compositions reflects primarily mantle sources.

Brandon, A. D.↗

NASA NTRS2017

Evaluating Crustal Contamination Effects On The Lithophile Trace Element Budget Of Shergottites, NWA 856 As A Test Case

The issue of whether crustal contamination has affected the lithophile trace element budget of shergottites has been a point of contention for decades. The evaluation has focused on the enriched shergottite compositions as an outcome of crustal contamination of mantle-derived parent magmas or, alternatively, the compositions of these stones reflect an incompatible trace element (ITE) enriched mantle source.

Brandon, A. D.↗

NASA NTRS2016

Petrology and Geochemistry of New Paired Martian Meteorites Larkman Nunatak 12240 and Larkman Nunatak 12095

Two of the latest Martian meteorites found in Antarctica, paired olivine-phyric shergottites LAR 12240 and LAR 12095, are described in order to decipher their petrological context, and place constraints on the geological history of Mars. This project identifies all phases found in LAR 12240 and 12095 and analyzes them for major and trace elements. The textural relationships among these phases are examined in order to develop a crystallization history of the magma(s) that formed these basalts.

Funk, R. C.↗

NASA NTRS2016

Basaltic Shergottite NWA 856: Differentiation of a Martian Magma

NWA 856 or Djel Ibone, is a basaltic shergottite discovered as a single stone of 320 g in South Morocco in April, 2001. This meteorite is fresh, i.e. shows minimal terrestrial weathering for a desert find. No shergottite discovered in North Africa can be paired with NWA 856. The purpose of this study is to constrain its crystallization history using textural observations, crystallization sequence modeling and in-situ trace element analysis in order to understand differentiation in shergottite magmatic systems.

Ferdous, J.↗

NASA NTRS2015

Melt Inclusion Analysis of RBT 04262 with Relationship to Shergottites and Mars Surface Compositions

Martian meteorite RBT 04262 is in the shergottite class. It displays the two lithologies typically found in "lherzolitic shergottites": one with a poikilitic texture of large pyroxene enclosing olivine and another with non-poikilitic texture. In the case of RBT 04262, the latter strongly ressembles an olivine- phyric shergottite which led the initial classification of this meteorite in that class. RBT 04262 has been studied with regards to its petrology, geochemistry and cosmic ray exposure and belongs to the enriched oxidized end-member of the shergottites. Studies on RBT 04262 have primarily focused on the bulk rock composition or each of the lithologies independently. To further elucidate RBT 04262's petrology and use it to better understand Martian geologic history, an in-depth study of its melt inclusions (MI) is being conducted. The MI chosen for this study are found within olivine grains. MI are thought to be trapped melts of the crystallizing magma preserved by the encapsulating olivine and offer snapshots of the composition of the magma as it evolves. Some MI, in the most Mg-rich part of the olivine of olivine-pyric shergottites, may even be representative of the meteorite parent melt.

Potter, S. A.↗

NASA NTRS2015

Peology and Geochemistry of New Paired Martian Meteorites 12095 and LAR 12240

The meteorites LAR 12095 and LAR 12240 are believed to be paired Martian meteorites and were discovered during the Antarctic Search for Meteorites (ANSMET) 2012-2013 Season at Larkman Nunatak. The purpose of this study is to characterize these olivine-phyric shergottites by analyzing all mineral phases for major, minor and trace elements and examining their textural relationships. The goal is to constrain their crystallization history and place these shergottites among other Martian meteorites in order to better understand Martian geological history.

Funk, R. C.↗

NASA NTRS2015

Petrology of Diogenite NWA 5480, A Pristine Olivine-Rich Deformed Harzburgite

Diogenites are achondrites that are part of the HED (howardite, eucrite, diogenite) meteorite group thought to originate from asteroid Vesta. This suite of igneous rocks offers a glimpse of early planetary differentiation and subsequent igneous processes. While eucrites represent asteroidal basaltic crust and howardites the impact brecciated surface, diogenites are samples of the mantle and lower crust. Most of them are orthopyroxene (Opx) dominated cumulates, although harzburgites and rare dunites have also been found. The majority of diogenites are impact breccias. This study describes NWA 5480, a pristine, i.e. hardly altered and minimally shocked, harzburgitic diogenite.

Peslier, A. H.↗

NASA NTRS2013

Constraints on the Composition and Evolution of the Lunar Crust from Meteorite NWA 3163

The lunar meteorite NWA 3163 (paired with NWA 4881, 4483) is a ferroan, feldspathic granulitic breccia characterized by pigeonite, augite, olivine, maskelynite and accessory Tichromite, ilmenite and troilite. Bulk rock geochemical signatures indicate the lack of a KREEP- derived component (Eu/Eu* = 3.47), consistent with previously studied lunar granulites and anorthosites. Bulk rock chondrite-normalized signatures are however distinct from the anorthosites and granulites sampled by Apollo missions and are relatively REE-depleted. In-situ analyses of maskelynite reveal little variation in anorthite content (average An% is 96.9 +/- 1.6, 2 sigma). Olivine is relatively ferroan and exhibits very little variation in forsterite content with mean Fo% of 57.7 +/- 2.0 (2 sigma). The majority of pyroxene is low-Ca pigeonite (En57Fs33Wo10). Augite (En46Fs21Wo33) is less common, comprising approximately 10% of analyzed pyroxene. Two pyroxene thermometry on co-existing orthopyroxene and augite yield an equilibrium temperature of 1070C which is in reasonable agreement with temperatures of 1096C estimated from pigeonite compositions. Rb-Sr isotopic systematics of separated fractions yield an average measured Sr-87/Sr-87 of 0.699282+/-0.000007 (2 sigma). Sr model ages are calculated using a modern day Sr-87/Sr-86 Basaltic Achondrite Best Initial (BABI) value of 0.70475, from an initial BABI value Sr-87/Sr-86 of 0.69891 and a corresponding Rb-87/Sr-97 of 0.08716. The Sr model Thermomechanical analysis (TMA) age, which represents the time of separation of a melt from a source reservoir having chondritic evolution, is 4.56+/-0.1 Ga. A Sr model T(sub RD) age, which is a Rb depletion age and assumes no contribution from Rb in the sample in the calculation, yields 4.34+/-0.1 Ga (i.e. a minimum age). The Ar-Ar dating of paired meteorite NWA 4881 reveals an age of c. 2 Ga, likely representing the last thermal event this meteorite experienced. An older Ar-40/Ar-39 age of c. 3.5 Ga may record the thermal event which produced the granulitic texture. Additional chronological constraints will be provided by Sm-Nd systematics. Ferroan Anorthosites like NWA 3163 have been interpreted to represent direct lunar magma ocean (LMO) crystallization products. If this is the case, trace element concentrations in NWA 3163 primary mineral phases should be in equilibrium with residual LMO liquids present during crystallization of those phases. Results from petrogenetic modeling suggest that the NWA 3163 protolith did not form from crystallization of an initially LREE depleted LMO but rather require an initially chondritic LMO with early garnet crystallization. Furthermore, a two-stage crystallization model where plagioclase crystalized prior to pyroxene (93% vs. 99.5% of LMO crystallization) is implied.

McLeod, C. L.↗

NASA NTRS2013

The Petrology and Geochemistry of Feldspathic Granulitic Breccia NWA 3163: Implications for the Lunar Crust

Lunar meteorites are crucial to understand the Moon s geological history because, being samples of the lunar crust that have been ejected by random impact events, they potentially originate from areas outside the small regions of the lunar surface sampled by the Apollo and Luna missions. The Apollo and Luna sample sites are contained within the Procellarum KREEP Terrain (PKT, Jolliff et al., 2000), where KREEP refers to potassium, rare earth element, and phosphorus-rich lithologies. The KREEP-rich rocks in the PKT are thought to be derived from late-stage residual liquids after approx.95-99% crystallization of a lunar magma ocean (LMO). These are understood to represent late-stage liquids which were enriched in incompatible trace elements (ITE) relative to older rocks (Snyder et al., 1992). As a consequence, the PKT is a significant reservoir for Th and KREEP. However, the majority of the lunar surface is likely to be significantly more depleted in ITE (84%, Jolliff et al., 2000). Lunar meteorites that are low in KREEP and Th may thus sample regions distinct from the PKT and are therefore a valuable source of information regarding the composition of KREEP-poor lunar crust. Northwest Africa (NWA) 3163 is a thermally metamorphosed ferroan, feldspathic, granulitic breccia composed of igneous clasts with a bulk anorthositic, noritic bulk composition. It is relatively mafic (approx.5.8 wt.% FeO; approx.5 wt.% MgO) and has some of the lowest concentrations of ITEs (17ppm Ba) compared to the feldspathic lunar meteorite (FLM) and Apollo sample suites (Hudgins et al., 2011). Localized plagioclase melting and incipient melting of mafic minerals require localized peak shock pressures in excess of 45 GPa (Chen and El Goresy, 2000; Hiesinger and Head, 2006). NWA 3163, and paired samples NWA 4481 and 4883, have previously been interpreted to represent an annealed micro-breccia which was produced by burial metamorphism at depth in the ancient lunar crust (Fernandes et al., 2009). This is in contrast to the interpretation of Hudgins et al. (2009) where NWA 3163 was interpreted to have formed through contact metamorphism. To further constrain its origin, we examine the petrogenesis of NWA 3163 with a particular emphasis on in-situ measurement of trace elements within constituent minerals, Sm-Nd and Rb-Sr isotopic systematics on separated mineral fractions and petrogenetic modeling.

McLeod, C. L.↗

NASA NTRS2012

In Situ Chemical Characterization of Mineral Phases in Lunar Granulite Meteorite Northwest Africa 5744

Northwest Africa (NWA) 5744 meteorite is a granulitic and troctolitic lunar breccia which may represent nearly pristine lunar crust (Fig. 1). NWA 5744 is unusually magnesian compared to other lunar breccias, with bulk [Mg/(Mg+Fe)] ~ 0.79 [1, 2]. Inspection shows impactor content is likely to be very minor, with low Ni content and a lack of metal grains. Some terrestrial contamination is present, evidenced by calcite within cracks. NWA 5744 has notably low concentrations of incompatible trace elements (ITEs) [2]. The goal of this study is to attempt to classify this lunar granulite through analyses of in situ phases.

Kent, J. J.↗

NASA NTRS2010

In Situ Determination of Siderophile Trace Elements in Metals and Sulfides in Enstatite Achondrites

Enstatite meteorites are identified by their extremely reduced mineralogy (1) and similar oxygen isotope composition (2). The enstatite meteorite clan incorporates both EH and EL chondrites, as well as a wide variety of enstatite achondrites, such as aubrites or anomalous enstatite meteorites (e.g. Mt. Egerton, Shallowater, Zaklodzie, NWA 2526). The role of nebular versus planetary processes in the formation of enstatite meteorites is still under debate (e.g. 3-5). Past studies showed a significant influence of metal segregation in the formation of enstatite achondrites. Casanova et al. (6) suggested incomplete metal-silicate segregation during core formation and attributed the unfractionated siderophile element patterns in aubrites metals to a lack of fractional crystallization in a planetary core. Recent studies suggest a significant role of impact melting in the formation of primitive enstatite chondrites (7) and identified NWA 2526 as a partial melt residue of an enstatite chondrite (8). To understand the nature of siderophile element-bearing phases in enstatite achondrites, establish links between enstatite achondrites and enstatite chondrites (9), and constrain planetary differentiation on their respective parent bodies and their petrogenetic histories, we present laser ablation ICP-MS measurements of metal and sulfide phases in Shallowater, Mt. Egerton, and the aubrites Aubres, Cumberland Falls, and Mayo Belwa.

vanAcken, D.↗

NASA NTRS2010

SM-ND Age and REE Systematics of Larkman Nunatek 06319: Closed System Fractional Crystallization of a Shergottite Magma

Sm-Nd isotopic data were collected on mineral separates and bulk rock powders of LAR 06319, yielding an age of 180+/-13 Ma (2(sigma)). This age is concordant with the Lu-Hf age (197+/-29 Ma, [1]) determined in conjunction with these data and the Sm-Nd age (190+/-26 Ma) of Shih et al., 2009 [2]. The Sm-Nd data form at statistically significant isochron (Fig. 1) that is controlled largely by leachate-residue pairs (samples with the R suffix are residues after leaching in cold 2N HCl for 10 minutes).

Shafer, J. T.↗

NASA NTRS2010

A More Reduced Mantle Source for Enriched Shergottites; Insights from the Olivine-Phyric Shergottite Lar 06319

A detailed petrographic study of melt inclusions and Cr-Fe-Ti oxides of LAR 06319 leads to two main conclusions: 1) this enriched oxidized olivine- phyric shergottite represents nearly continuous crystallization of a basaltic shergottite melt, 2) the melt became more oxidized during differentiation. The first crystallized mineral assemblages record the oxygen fugacity which is closest to that of the melt s mantle source, and which is lower than generally attributed to the enriched shergottite group.

Peslier, A. H.↗

NASA NTRS2010

Highly Siderophile Elements as Tracers for the Subcontinental Mantle Evolution Beneath the Southwestern USA: The San Carlos and Kilbourne Hole Peridotite Xenoliths Revisited

Peridotite xenoliths from San Carlos, Arizona, and Kilbourne Hole, New Mexico, have been studied since the 1970 s to give insights into melting and metasomatism in the subcontinental mantle beneath the southwestern USA. More recently, the highly siderophile elements (HSE; Os, Ir, Ru, Rh, Pt, Pd, and Re) and the included Re-Os isotope system have been established as powerful tools for the study of mantle processes because of their range in compatibility during mantle melting and their siderophile and chalcophile geochemical behavior. Model aluminachron Re-Os ages for San Carlos and Kilbourne Hole, as well as for the nearby Dish Hill and Vulcan's Throne sites, give consistent depletion ages of around 2.2 Ga. This age can be interpreted as a single large scale mantle melting event linked to crustal formation and continental growth under the southwestern USA. Highly siderophile elements, however, may be added to depleted peridotites via melt-rock interaction, especially the more incompatible and hence mobile Pt, Pd, and Re. This may result in overprinting of the signature of melt extraction, thus abating the usefulness of Re-Os mantle extraction model ages. A comprehensive characterization of the suite of mantle xenoliths from the SW USA in terms of HSE concentrations is thus necessary to re-assess the Re-Os system for dating purposes. San Carlos peridotites are depleted to moderately fertile, as indicated by their bulk Al2O3 contents between 0.66 wt% and 3.13 wt%. Bulk Os-187/Os-188 in San Carlos peridotites range from 0.1206 to 0.1357. In contrast, Kilbourne Hole peridotites tend to be more fertile with Al2O3 between 2.11 and 3.78 wt%, excluding one extremely depleted sample with 0.30 wt% Al2O3, and have Os-187/Os-188 between 0.1156 and 0.1272, typical for mantle peridotites. No large fractionation between the more compatible HSE Os, Ir, and Ru are observed. The more incompatible HSE Re, Pd, and to a minor extent, Pt, however, are depleted in a number of samples by factors of up to 4 for Pt, 6 for Pd, and 20 for Re, compared to primitive mantle estimates. This is in agreement with previous studies from the same locales, which demonstrated the presence of different populations of mantle xenoliths having undergone various degrees of melt extraction. The depletion of the more incompatible elements (Re, Pd, and Pt) also suggests that the HSE budgets of the SW USA peridotites were primarily established by extraction of basaltic melt, and reflect only minor influence from later episodes of metasomatism. Model Re-Os ages obtained from San Carlos and Kilbourne Hole xenoliths may thus reflect ages of crustal formation and mantle depletion in the SW USA region.

vanAcken, D.↗