Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Boron, Ed

Publications and source records attributed to Boron, Ed.

Surveillance Test Articles Development

Material degradation in Advance Test Reactors (ATR) is governed by irradiation, corrosion, elevated temperature exposure and cyclic mechanical creep-fatigue loads. This degradation information during reactor operation condition is limited. Hence, material damage monitoring is a key aspect of the design, analysis and licensing of ATR components. The idea is to monitor material component operation conditions of component by using a surveillance test article. This test article is fabricated with bi-metal configuration with two different thermal expansion coefficients, and design is motivated by Simplified Model Test (SMT) specimen which can capture structure-like mechanical response. Upon raising temperature of the bi-metal test article configuration, expansion mismatch results tensile load on specimen. Thus, temperature dependent passively actuated loading is achieved. The idea is to place this surveillance test article in reactor at location ‘x’ to surveil the mechanical response at critical location ‘y’. By calibrating the test article design, material degradation at critical location can be surveilled through assessing the degradation in surveillance test article. This study presents test article development with different material combinations and follow-up experimental testing work through passively loading test article with temperature history. The test article geometry and observed test results are presented in presentation slides.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Report on Thermal Cycling Testing and Bimaterial Weld Development for a Passively Actuated Materials Surveillance Test Article

This report describes the continuation and conclusion of a thermal cycling test program designed to evaluate a family of passively actuated material surveillance test articles. Additionally, the report details a preliminary study of bimetallic welding between 316 stainless steel and TZM (tungsten-zirconium-molybdenum) alloy. The test program was ultimately successful in demonstrating the basic viability of the passively actuated test article concept as well as specifically validating the procedures developed to size specimens to mimic the mechanical response of operating components. The report discusses and summarizes the results of the complete test program which tested samples for more than 1,000 controlled thermal cycles. The weld development program included both stir friction and electron beam joining. The stir friction welding was ultimately successful, while the electron beam welding would require additional development. Ultimately, these test programs pave the way for implementing a materials surveillance program in future molten salt reactors (MSRs). The report conclusions outline a plan for transforming the research and developed described here into a definite set of practices and procedures for a surveillance program at a future operating reactor.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Fabrication and Testing of Two Passively Actuated Creep-Fatigue Surveillance Test Articles

This report describes the fabrication, testing, and analysis of two families of passively-actuated creep-fatigue test articles. These test articles induce cyclic mechanical load in a test section actuated solely through a mismatch in the thermal expansion coefficient of two materials and driven by a change in the specimen temperature. Test articles of this type could provide material degradation data for a materials surveillance program in future operating molten salt reactors, where variations in the reactor temperature caused by normal or upset cycles would provide the temperature change in the sample. The purpose of the current experimental campaign is to demonstrate the feasibility of fabricating realistically-sized test articles, test the articles under repeated thermal cycling to assess their robustness, particularly the reliability of the bimetallic welds, and collect strain data from instrumented samples to validate the methods used to size the test articles to match key features of the mechanical response of operating reactor components. The thermal cycling tests are ongoing but the test data to date suggests the current test article design is viable, robust, and can be successfully designed to match a target mechanical response. Finally, the report describes preliminary work on welding refractory alloys to 316H stainless steel. Replacing the test article driver material, currently Alloy 617, with a refractory would increase the coefficient of thermal expansion mismatch and support further miniaturization of the test articles.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Initial development of an in-situ, passive material surveillance test article for monitoring high temperature reactor structural components

This report describes the development of a family of passively-actuated surveillance test articles, suitable for use in an in-situ reactor test program monitoring the degradation in structural material properties caused by the reactor environment. The test articles apply creep-fatigue-type cyclic load to a test section driven by changes in the reactor coolant temperature converted to mechanical force by differential thermal expansion. The report describes three types of test articles, all of which apply the load to a 316H test section using Alloy 617 as the driver material. The three types of specimens each serve a unique purpose: (1) initial proof-of-concept, (2) validation of the models used to size the specimens to achieve a given strain range, and (3) demonstration that the articles can be miniaturized for use in an actual operating reactor. In addition to the specimen design, fabrication, and testing, this report describes the outline of two types of in-situ monitoring programs, using the test article. Monitoring programs such as these could be a critical component in gaining regulator acceptance for Molten Salt Reactor (MSR) designs using structural materials for which there is little long-term experimental environmental testing or operating experience available for calibrating the component structural design.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Initial Argonne Sodium Draining Tests: Analysis of Test Results and Comparison with Water Draining Behavior

Three initial sodium draining experiments have been carried out in which sodium was drained from a 0.46 m high 4.6 mm inner diameter vertical stainless steel tube wetted by the sodium representative of a sodium channel in a compact diffusion-bonded sodium-to-CO 2 heat exchanger. Prior to the startup of sodium testing, shakedown tests were conducted with water. In all three sodium experiments, the sodium drained efficiently from the channel. Sodium and water both drain efficiently from a 4.6 mm inner diameter vertical stainless steel tube. This is an important and good result for the design of compact diffusion-bonded heat exchanger sodium channels. Sodium drains more efficiently than water. This is also an important and good result for the design of compact diffusion-bonded heat exchanger sodium channels. The draining phenomena observed with sodium and water are significantly different. The draining of water involves an initial rapid slug draining phase followed by a linear rate draining phase followed by a slow draining phase involving draining of rivulets and drops. This behavior has previously been reported in the literature for viscous fluids. The draining of sodium involves an initial rapid slug draining phase but no discernable linear rate draining phase. There is a subsequent slow draining phase. However, unlike the slow draining phase with water that involves a number of rivulets and drops, the slow draining phase with sodium in two out of three sodium tests mainly involves a single discrete event in which a mass of sodium drains from the tube. This single discrete draining event encompasses most of the sodium mass remaining inside of the tube following the rapid slug draining phase. The existence of a single discrete draining event during the slow draining phase with sodium versus several rivulet and drop draining events with water is thought to simply reflect the fact that significantly lower mass fractions of liquid are left behind inside of the tube following the rapid slug draining phase with sodium relative to water. For the sodium tests, the progress of wetting of the stainless steel by sodium was monitored by means of the voltage drop across the tube outer diameter measured by pairs of opposing electrodes welded to the tube outer surface at three different elevations. The electrode data remarkably reveals phenomena during the sodium draining. The downward passage of the sodium slug trailing edge past each electrode was observed from which a mean slug trailing edge velocity could be determined. The subsequent slower increase in voltage drop suggests draining and thinning of a sodium film left behind upon the tube inner surface; wiggles in the voltage drop data are suggestive of the descent of waves on the film. It is thought that the draining sodium film collects as a mass likely near the lower end of the tube and detaches corresponding to the single discrete draining event observed in the load cell data. The minimum circular channel inner diameter for the draining of water and sodium without the formation of lenses that bridge the channel and may remain inside of the tube without draining is predicted with a correlation to be 2.2 mm. The highest priority for future sodium draining testing is to investigate other channel geometries such as a rectilinear channel or a semicircular channel.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

FY 2017 Progress Report on the Argonne Sodium Draining and Refilling Experiments

The main incentive for utilization of compact diffusion-bonded sodium-to-CO 2 heat exchangers for a Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactor (SFR) with a supercritical carbon dioxide ( s CO 2 ) Brayton cycle power converter is the potential for reduction in heat exchanger size and cost relative to traditional shell-and-tube technology. There is an incentive for the designer to reduce the width of the sodium and CO 2 channels as much as possible to realize the greatest size and cost reductions. However, there are practical limits on minimum channel size due to fundamental phenomena particular to sodium and CO 2 . One is that the channel size must be large enough to enable the rapid draining of sodium from the heat exchanger sodium channels in the event that a sodium leak is detected in an intermediate sodium heat transport system loop, in order to rapidly drain the sodium into the loop sodium storage vessel/tank and thereby limit the sodium mass released that could potentially burn if exposed to air. Information about the minimum sodium channel size can only be obtained by actually draining sodium from representative wetted stainless steel sodium channels under prototypical conditions. It is not possible to obtain such information through modeling and simulation or through simulant experiments. The ANL Sodium Draining and Refilling experiment facility has been designed and is being assembled to obtain data on the draining of sodium from compact diffusion-bonded sodium-to-carbon dioxide heat exchanger sodium channels including the mass of sodium drained versus time, the mass of sodium retained inside of the channels, and the potential for sodium to bridge the channel, freeze, and form a plug inside the channel versus the channel size. This information is needed to determine the minimum sodium channel size required to meet the requirements for sodium draining without bridges being left inside of the channels. Initial shakedown testing has been initiated using water and glass and plastic tubes before transitioning to sodium and stainless steel test sections. For the latter, the test sections will be heated to high temperature to promote rapid sodium wetting of the stainless steel prior to draining. Testing with sodium will be initiated in FY 2018.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗